Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To say no to son’s girlfriend coming for Christmas.

558 replies

5littleducksallinarow · 10/11/2026 10:42

We don’t have the biggest house and our very small dining table is in an alcove in the lounge, we pull it out for meals but there is 6 of us squeezed around this 4 seater table with 2 extra chairs.
Last year we decided to do a cold meat buffet instead and just have our plates on the sofa and it worked so we’ve decided to do the same again.
This year ds has a girlfriend and has asked if she can come for Christmas and I explained it will only be buffet but he’s unimpressed and says she’s from a posh family and would expect a traditional roast dinner.

Aibu to say we can’t cater for anyone else? We don’t mind if she wants to come for a while or even for some of the buffet but I will not be cooking a Christmas dinner.
Ds is concerned about her reaction to a non traditional roast.
We have met her once and I did put on a similar cold meats buffet back in the summer but she didn’t eat anything.

OP posts:
Cherrytree86 · 10/11/2026 20:39

Funandnames · 10/11/2026 20:19

I’m not saying it’s ’right’ but my honest opinion after dealing with 15 years of family strife….

Just do what he wants. Ask him and others to contribute a hot spread to keep the peace. If she ends up being ‘the one’ it’s not worth the fall out. Once again, I’m not saying it’s right for you to bend over backwards. It’s just that the longterm fallout from these things may not be worth standing by your principles. If meeting him beyond halfway will make everyone happy just do it.

@Funandnames

Not everyone wants to be a doormat though

Unexpectedlysinglemum · 10/11/2026 20:39

I agree he should cook the roast himself

TeethAreImportant · 10/11/2026 20:39

5littleducksallinarow · 10/11/2026 10:42

We don’t have the biggest house and our very small dining table is in an alcove in the lounge, we pull it out for meals but there is 6 of us squeezed around this 4 seater table with 2 extra chairs.
Last year we decided to do a cold meat buffet instead and just have our plates on the sofa and it worked so we’ve decided to do the same again.
This year ds has a girlfriend and has asked if she can come for Christmas and I explained it will only be buffet but he’s unimpressed and says she’s from a posh family and would expect a traditional roast dinner.

Aibu to say we can’t cater for anyone else? We don’t mind if she wants to come for a while or even for some of the buffet but I will not be cooking a Christmas dinner.
Ds is concerned about her reaction to a non traditional roast.
We have met her once and I did put on a similar cold meats buffet back in the summer but she didn’t eat anything.

If he wants a roast, why not go to her posh traditional family for Xmas and have one then?

5littleducksallinarow · 10/11/2026 20:39

anditmakesmesmile · 10/11/2026 20:04

I think I’m on your son’s side. Not much of a Christmas.

I don’t think I’m much of a Christmas person.

I loved it at my own parents all sitting together eating in the dining room with Christmas crackers set out and food in the middle to help yourselves but they had the room and a huge table all nicely decorated and inviting with wine glasses set out, of course I would love a Christmas dinner in those circumstances.

It’s not the same when there’s no space and it’s all stress and make do, nobody can move once seated without everyone else getting up first because some people are trapped against the wall, others can’t move their chair back because of the sofa and nobody can get to the kitchen for anything once we’re seated because the kitchen door is blocked by table and chairs and nobody can put their plate down until everybody has finished dishing up because there’s no space on the table until the serving plates are removed meaning second helpings are a pain and it’s just an obstacle course.

At least if I set the food out on the table I can leave it in the alcove and people can pull a chair out and sit comfortably on a dining chair or the sofa or wander into the kitchen and grab another drink.
I’m just trying to make the best of what we’ve got, we can’t even fit a Christmas tree but I’m glad we’ve got a table at all as some people don’t.

When it’s just Dh and I we don’t need to pull the table out and can eat fine.
Christmas is meant to be fun, a time to get together and celebrate and enjoy the day, if the roast dinner is the cause of all stress then I’d rather have a buffet and done with.
As long as I get some pigs in blankets and some wine.

OP posts:
Cherrytree86 · 10/11/2026 20:39

Goldenbear · 10/11/2026 20:38

I thought he had moved out and only visits?

@Goldenbear

good.

trikonasanallama · 10/11/2026 20:41

5littleducksallinarow · 10/11/2026 15:50

I don’t think he thinks he needs an invitation so if I ask him on Saturday if he wants to come for dinner on Sunday, he will say “I might do” and leave it at that.
If he decides not to we won’t hear a thing and if he decides to turn up he will.

It is annoying as we don’t know what we’re doing and can’t make any plans because we’ve invited him and don’t know if he’ll come or not, so if I suggest would he like to come for a roast tomorrow I have to keep tomorrow free and I’m then obliged to cook it because I invited him when really if he wasn’t coming we’d probably have eaten out or had something else.

You know you can just... stop doing this? Tell him he needs to respond, if he doesn't, the invitation is rescinded.

5littleducksallinarow · 10/11/2026 20:42

Cherrytree86 · 10/11/2026 20:36

@anditmakesmesmile

the son can cook a roast himself if it means that much to him. He’s plenty old enough. He can move out while it’s at it as well, he’s plenty old enough for that too.

He has his own place.

OP posts:
ADragonFlyCharm · 10/11/2026 20:44

BadSkiingMum · 10/11/2026 10:51

I am not sure that this is a hill to die on. She may end up being your son’s wife and sometimes these early interactions set the tone for a long time to come…

Could you buy an extending table before Christmas? There’s still a bit of time.

This.

It would be no trouble at all.

If you did want to show that you had gone to a bit of effort for the sake of your future relationship with your future daughter-in-law, would you consider building an extension or a lovely conservatory that will solve this problem, enhance your home and make it more valuable. Win, win, win.

I know that may not be easy and there isn't masses of time, so it might not be possible and if that proves to be the case, how about a summer house.

Our lovely local garden centre can erect one of these pretty quickly at reasonable cost and it would look absolutely gorgeous and welcoming, twinkling with Christmas Fairy Lights.

We love ours and it has the added advantage that anyone who has over indulged in the plum pudding can just walk out of the door straight into the garden for a quick breath of fresh air before the cheese.

Do consider it at least! x

trikonasanallama · 10/11/2026 20:46

LondonLass2026 · 10/11/2026 17:18

Who do they both think they are? Is she the queen?

Jesus, no way would I be bending over backwards for this pair of ungrateful brats. They take what they're given and they bloody well better do it graciously.

Yes it might not be traditional but it works for you, and you've been open about that. Who the heck is she to make demands? I wouldn't have dared behaved so badly when I met my partner!

Do you have any evidence that she is a brat or the one making demands? From what OP has written it's all coming from the son.

5littleducksallinarow · 10/11/2026 20:47

QuietChristmas2026 · 10/11/2026 20:35

Oh honestly. All these ridiculous suggestions about renting holiday homes, or buying a larger house. Ignore these crazy responses.

But MY idea is worth considering - have you considered going back in time and having fewer children?

🤣😂🤣

We only have 2 children.
We also have 2 living parents left and now ds girlfriend will be 7.

Edit to add ds girlfriend is not 7 there will be 7 people if she comes too.

OP posts:
Fancynancie · 10/11/2026 20:48

5littleducksallinarow · 10/11/2026 17:06

I appreciate the thought but we really don’t have space to even temporarily put a 6 foot table in a 12 foot lounge with a corner sofa and tv along with a 4 foot dinner table that’s already blocking the walkway to the kitchen when pulled out of the alcove to get everyone around.
We already have two extra chairs for when there is 6 but cannot accommodate 7 for a sit down meal as much as we’d like to.

This is fine but just be aware that you are ruling yourself out of hosting any family gatherings in the future, unless summer in the garden.

Most people like to sit around a table and eat christmas or other feast day meals.

Fancynancie · 10/11/2026 20:51

trikonasanallama · 10/11/2026 20:46

Do you have any evidence that she is a brat or the one making demands? From what OP has written it's all coming from the son.

I don’t think it’s ungrateful to expect christmas dinner sitting around a table - it’s fairly basic.

I come from quite a poor background and we always had christmas around the table - in small council houses with people sitting at smaller side tables etc. But it was a special day and it was treated as such. I genuinely don’t think it’s spoilt to want that, I think it’s normal

Bramble26 · 10/11/2026 20:54

5littleducksallinarow · 10/11/2026 10:42

We don’t have the biggest house and our very small dining table is in an alcove in the lounge, we pull it out for meals but there is 6 of us squeezed around this 4 seater table with 2 extra chairs.
Last year we decided to do a cold meat buffet instead and just have our plates on the sofa and it worked so we’ve decided to do the same again.
This year ds has a girlfriend and has asked if she can come for Christmas and I explained it will only be buffet but he’s unimpressed and says she’s from a posh family and would expect a traditional roast dinner.

Aibu to say we can’t cater for anyone else? We don’t mind if she wants to come for a while or even for some of the buffet but I will not be cooking a Christmas dinner.
Ds is concerned about her reaction to a non traditional roast.
We have met her once and I did put on a similar cold meats buffet back in the summer but she didn’t eat anything.

Absolutely include her, she may end up being your daughter in law one day and trust me, she will remember how she was treated by you in the early days.

Ask if there’s anything she’d like to eat / favourite buffet foods, but there’s no need to change your plans or your menu for the day to accommodate / impress her.

Rainbow1901 · 10/11/2026 20:55

As a guest - any guest (for that matter) should accept their hosts' hospitality as it is offered! What a cheek?! Plenty of people don't do a Christmas Roast on Christmas Day and have whatever they fancy - be it pizza, beige food, takeaway or a pub!! None of it is wrong - it's just what people fancy during the season of goodwill. Like or lump it sunshine!!

QuietChristmas2026 · 10/11/2026 20:55

Fancynancie · 10/11/2026 20:51

I don’t think it’s ungrateful to expect christmas dinner sitting around a table - it’s fairly basic.

I come from quite a poor background and we always had christmas around the table - in small council houses with people sitting at smaller side tables etc. But it was a special day and it was treated as such. I genuinely don’t think it’s spoilt to want that, I think it’s normal

Well in OPs house there’s no room.

I don’t understand why people can’t accept that if OP says there’s no room, that means there’s no room? She has described the space and plate/kitchen situation.

Why does a dinner table mean you enjoy Christmas properly? I have a dining table. We all walk right past it with our trays and plates to sit on the sofa.

Surely every person/family enjoys Christmas differently, in their own way, and guests fit in as appropriate?

trikonasanallama · 10/11/2026 20:56

Fancynancie · 10/11/2026 20:51

I don’t think it’s ungrateful to expect christmas dinner sitting around a table - it’s fairly basic.

I come from quite a poor background and we always had christmas around the table - in small council houses with people sitting at smaller side tables etc. But it was a special day and it was treated as such. I genuinely don’t think it’s spoilt to want that, I think it’s normal

Did you mean to quote me?

My post was in response to another poster calling the gf a brat, I was pointing out that we haven't actually heard anything from her at all, just the son.

BruFord · 10/11/2026 21:00

Rainbow1901 · 10/11/2026 20:55

As a guest - any guest (for that matter) should accept their hosts' hospitality as it is offered! What a cheek?! Plenty of people don't do a Christmas Roast on Christmas Day and have whatever they fancy - be it pizza, beige food, takeaway or a pub!! None of it is wrong - it's just what people fancy during the season of goodwill. Like or lump it sunshine!!

Yep @Rainbow1901, if you accept an invitation for Christmas, you accept what you're given - or you can bring some food of your choice, preferably enough to share. If his gf doesn't like buffets, fair enough, she can have Christmas with her own family as she normally does.

Your DS sounds rather bratty @5littleducksallinarow, I couldn't believe it when I read that he's in his late 20's. He could contribute to the dinner himself if he wishes.

MsAmerica · 10/11/2026 21:00

5littleducksallinarow · 10/11/2026 10:42

We don’t have the biggest house and our very small dining table is in an alcove in the lounge, we pull it out for meals but there is 6 of us squeezed around this 4 seater table with 2 extra chairs.
Last year we decided to do a cold meat buffet instead and just have our plates on the sofa and it worked so we’ve decided to do the same again.
This year ds has a girlfriend and has asked if she can come for Christmas and I explained it will only be buffet but he’s unimpressed and says she’s from a posh family and would expect a traditional roast dinner.

Aibu to say we can’t cater for anyone else? We don’t mind if she wants to come for a while or even for some of the buffet but I will not be cooking a Christmas dinner.
Ds is concerned about her reaction to a non traditional roast.
We have met her once and I did put on a similar cold meats buffet back in the summer but she didn’t eat anything.

Are you really in a tizzy over whether to up-end your family plans to cater to a momentary snooty girlfriend?
Seems to me the real problem is your son. Perhaps you can suggest to them that they are welcome to bring any posh food they prefer, to add it to the buffet.

CherryKerry · 10/11/2026 21:08

Your DS ahould book and pay for Christmas dinner at a restaurant for you all if that would be less embarrassing for him?

Agapornis · 10/11/2026 21:08

When he hosts himself is when he gets to decide what is served.

Don't bother catering for a bit of a twat who might not even show up. She probably doesn't even know that he's thinking of inviting her!

Thecomedyclub · 10/11/2026 21:17

5littleducksallinarow · 10/11/2026 20:47

We only have 2 children.
We also have 2 living parents left and now ds girlfriend will be 7.

Edit to add ds girlfriend is not 7 there will be 7 people if she comes too.

Edited

I love your humour! Honestly some pp have been very dense.
I also love the way you cut your cloth…. Your Christmas sounds lovely, and full of joy. Your two parents obviously love it too. It suits you all and your son sounds quite rude. My NY resolution if I were you would be to tell him that enough is enough, and next time he doesn’t commit to an invitation, you won’t be home if he turns up without telling you in advance (at least a day). And mean it!

AskAggie · 10/11/2026 21:19

There’s something really sad and depressing about this post… I’m not sure why but the whole thing sounds awful.

Ally886 · 10/11/2026 21:24

ADragonFlyCharm · 10/11/2026 20:44

This.

It would be no trouble at all.

If you did want to show that you had gone to a bit of effort for the sake of your future relationship with your future daughter-in-law, would you consider building an extension or a lovely conservatory that will solve this problem, enhance your home and make it more valuable. Win, win, win.

I know that may not be easy and there isn't masses of time, so it might not be possible and if that proves to be the case, how about a summer house.

Our lovely local garden centre can erect one of these pretty quickly at reasonable cost and it would look absolutely gorgeous and welcoming, twinkling with Christmas Fairy Lights.

We love ours and it has the added advantage that anyone who has over indulged in the plum pudding can just walk out of the door straight into the garden for a quick breath of fresh air before the cheese.

Do consider it at least! x

Edited

Ah yes because we all have £40k for an extension kicking about.

75% of the UK have less than £5k in savings me old fruit 🙄

Here's you expecting someone who can barely afford a decent table to shell out for a conservatory!

timeforachangeagainagainagain · 10/11/2026 21:24

Goodness some of these posts!! Some people will have you extending the whole house for a roast!! 🤣

OP do as you please. The buffet sounds delicious!! Super chilled too and I think all that matters is that you’re together.

I think this thread shows that some people are very inflexible and have to have a trad Christmas roast. Fair enough. But if someone is hosting, you either go and enjoy what they’re offering, or politely decline.

QuietChristmas2026 · 10/11/2026 21:27

Ally886 · 10/11/2026 21:24

Ah yes because we all have £40k for an extension kicking about.

75% of the UK have less than £5k in savings me old fruit 🙄

Here's you expecting someone who can barely afford a decent table to shell out for a conservatory!

That poster is being sarcastic, along with the rent a holiday home, buy a bigger house, and my suggestion of ‘have fewer children’.

I’m liking the funny suggestions tbh.

Swipe left for the next trending thread