Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To say no to son’s girlfriend coming for Christmas.

558 replies

5littleducksallinarow · 10/11/2026 10:42

We don’t have the biggest house and our very small dining table is in an alcove in the lounge, we pull it out for meals but there is 6 of us squeezed around this 4 seater table with 2 extra chairs.
Last year we decided to do a cold meat buffet instead and just have our plates on the sofa and it worked so we’ve decided to do the same again.
This year ds has a girlfriend and has asked if she can come for Christmas and I explained it will only be buffet but he’s unimpressed and says she’s from a posh family and would expect a traditional roast dinner.

Aibu to say we can’t cater for anyone else? We don’t mind if she wants to come for a while or even for some of the buffet but I will not be cooking a Christmas dinner.
Ds is concerned about her reaction to a non traditional roast.
We have met her once and I did put on a similar cold meats buffet back in the summer but she didn’t eat anything.

OP posts:
5littleducksallinarow · 10/11/2026 19:29

I can’t find the exact table we have as we’ve had it a while now but it’s something like this.
It fits in a small alcove when not in use and we pull it out and it extends slightly.
just trying to give an idea of how 7 people look around it versus a few charcuterie board and some plates.

https://www.argos.co.uk/product/7893605

OP posts:
MagpiePi · 10/11/2026 19:30

5littleducksallinarow · 10/11/2026 17:06

I appreciate the thought but we really don’t have space to even temporarily put a 6 foot table in a 12 foot lounge with a corner sofa and tv along with a 4 foot dinner table that’s already blocking the walkway to the kitchen when pulled out of the alcove to get everyone around.
We already have two extra chairs for when there is 6 but cannot accommodate 7 for a sit down meal as much as we’d like to.

I’m surprised someone hasn’t suggested you just move to a bigger house before Christmas?

It’s the obvious solution and very odd of you not to have considered it already!

🤣🤣

Rustfinch · 10/11/2026 19:34

5littleducksallinarow · 10/11/2026 15:31

I don’t suppose I’ll know either way until the eleventh hour as he never knows what his plans are even when he doesn’t have a girlfriend and we are left with “I dont know what I’m doing yet” right up until the end so there’s every chance she might come or he might come on his own or he might go there in the end or just come for a while.

He usually does come but he’s used to coming and going as he pleases and doesn’t get that I’d like to know who I’m catering for.
His attitude to ordinary family plans is that I invite him and he says I might do, then he has an invitation but we have no idea if he will or not.

You can stop this, you know. "I don't know what I'm doing yet" means he's wanting to keep his options open to see if a better offer comes along/if he feels like he CBA socialising. You don't have to accept it. You can tell him you need to know for sure either way so you know how much food to get in and expect him to make a decision about it. No decision equals a no, so don't buy food for him, then if he shows up explain you did ask him to let you know if he's coming and he didn't. It's quite rude to treat someone as if they're an option instead of committing to plans.

MashCere · 10/11/2026 19:37

YANBU to not want to cook a roast. The buffet sounds great and way less stressful than a traditional roast.

Your son may be feeling a tad inferior compared to his girlfriend’s “posh” family, and it’s not her that’s wanting a roast, but rather your son wanting to prove that he and his family is ‘good enough’ for her.

However, you would be unreasonable to say she can’t come. It’s only 1 extra person, and would you still exclude her if she became his fiancé or wife?

AnotherAnnie · 10/11/2026 19:40

You are saying yes to hosting, which is not saying no at all. It is touching that son wants his girlfriend to have an idealised christmas, but with the space that is simply not an option.

After last time if they opt to come for the buffet I would cheerfully explain that if they do not show in time you will have to eat on time, but happily put some stuff for them in the fridge for them.when they do arrive.

PS Can the husband with the work thing say as early as possible that he has to stay with wife she has plans he hadnt realised.

ScribblingPixie · 10/11/2026 19:40

Nothing to stress about. You're having a bufftet, he can either come or not come. Given he messed up the last time he brought her without apology, don't take any notice of him.

MeridianB · 10/11/2026 19:44

I would have guessed your DS was 17 from your OP. In his late 20s he needs to show a LOT more respect to you and your home.

BreezyLurker · 10/11/2026 19:54

5littleducksallinarow · 10/11/2026 15:50

I don’t think he thinks he needs an invitation so if I ask him on Saturday if he wants to come for dinner on Sunday, he will say “I might do” and leave it at that.
If he decides not to we won’t hear a thing and if he decides to turn up he will.

It is annoying as we don’t know what we’re doing and can’t make any plans because we’ve invited him and don’t know if he’ll come or not, so if I suggest would he like to come for a roast tomorrow I have to keep tomorrow free and I’m then obliged to cook it because I invited him when really if he wasn’t coming we’d probably have eaten out or had something else.

I’ve always been baffled by this sort of behaviour… I know everyone has a different way of communicating but I don’t understand why you wouldn’t just say outright that you want a firm yes or no because it’s annoying having to wait around not doing anything & waiting to see if he turns up. But then I’m very straight down the line & like having things clearly set out with timescales etc. I’m not a rough plans girly & I definitely wouldn’t feel rude about saying I’m going to make something low key or shove something extra in the oven if they can’t commit & just turn up.

Foodwench66 · 10/11/2026 19:56

Just tell him she can come but your menu is not changing.

anditmakesmesmile · 10/11/2026 20:04

I think I’m on your son’s side. Not much of a Christmas.

LydiaTheTattooedLardarse · 10/11/2026 20:09

Sotiredimightreallydie · 10/11/2026 11:49

You've made a huge assumption here:

The OP has decided they will be having a plates on laps buffet, everyone is happy with that, except the son.

The OP had never said what the rest of the family thought of it, including the son. It's just as likely that everyone wants a normal Christmas dinner but feels like they can't say anything.

I also don't get why it has to be cold meats on laps if table space is limited. It could just as easily be a roast on laps (or find another table to stick on the end - be creative).

If you mean they feel like they can’t say anything about the hosts choice of menu, they’re right - they can’t. But there is one very simple thing they could say. “Thank you so much for the offer, but we have plans”. Or “Thank you so much for the offer, but we‘re very keen to have a traditional Christmas dinner. You’re more than welcome to join us”.

If nobody has said that, it implies they are either happy with the OP’s menu, or are not unhappy enough with it to cook their own dinner instead.

LydiaTheTattooedLardarse · 10/11/2026 20:10

anditmakesmesmile · 10/11/2026 20:04

I think I’m on your son’s side. Not much of a Christmas.

He is more than welcome to host an alternative Christmas in his own home.

user1471600850 · 10/11/2026 20:10

anditmakesmesmile · 10/11/2026 20:04

I think I’m on your son’s side. Not much of a Christmas.

Rubbish - is your Christmas defined by a roast dinner! What do you think they do in hot countries - Australians tend to BBQ on the beach - how dreadful! This whole thread makes me depressed - it should be about spending a great day with your family!!!

Funandnames · 10/11/2026 20:19

I’m not saying it’s ’right’ but my honest opinion after dealing with 15 years of family strife….

Just do what he wants. Ask him and others to contribute a hot spread to keep the peace. If she ends up being ‘the one’ it’s not worth the fall out. Once again, I’m not saying it’s right for you to bend over backwards. It’s just that the longterm fallout from these things may not be worth standing by your principles. If meeting him beyond halfway will make everyone happy just do it.

Thegirlwhowent · 10/11/2026 20:19

You say you ask DS if he's coming for dinner and he says he might do - so then you don't know whether he's coming or not. Just tell him that if he isn't definitely coming, there won't be food for him. Then stick to that. He needs to know that he can't always turn up and be fed if he hasn't made a commitment.

WhatWouldTheDoctorDo · 10/11/2026 20:20

YANBU. I’d remind your son that you simply don’t have the space to do a full on roast. The girlfriend is very welcome to come, but that’s what’s on offer, and you’d like to know by xx date if they’re coming.

i was more taken aback that you invite your son for dinner or Sunday lunch etc., he doesn’t let you know one way or another, and you’d keep the day free just in case he comes. That’s just rude. I get the not needing an invitation to the family home, but that’s a bit much. You say it’s annoying, and that he doesn’t get that you want to know etc. so I’m not sure why you put up with it.

Preg1989 · 10/11/2026 20:21

MadMAGA · 10/11/2026 12:29

Have you considered renting a nice holiday cottage so you have enough room for a sit-down dinner and don't embarrass your son in front of his posh girlfriend? Ideally somewhere you can buy in the future so you can keep up the ruse if the relationship stays the course.

Best thing I’ve read this week! 👏🏻

LydiaTheTattooedLardarse · 10/11/2026 20:21

Funandnames · 10/11/2026 20:19

I’m not saying it’s ’right’ but my honest opinion after dealing with 15 years of family strife….

Just do what he wants. Ask him and others to contribute a hot spread to keep the peace. If she ends up being ‘the one’ it’s not worth the fall out. Once again, I’m not saying it’s right for you to bend over backwards. It’s just that the longterm fallout from these things may not be worth standing by your principles. If meeting him beyond halfway will make everyone happy just do it.

Not so much cold meat as wet lettuce…

Goldenbear · 10/11/2026 20:28

5littleducksallinarow · 10/11/2026 11:30

It’s not his long term partner, they met in the spring, she’s been here once and they don’t live together, they see each other about once a week.

If it's not that serious why is she wanting to attend?

CloveRinse · 10/11/2026 20:28

BadSkiingMum · 10/11/2026 10:51

I am not sure that this is a hill to die on. She may end up being your son’s wife and sometimes these early interactions set the tone for a long time to come…

Could you buy an extending table before Christmas? There’s still a bit of time.

@BadSkiingMum

"She may end up being your son’s wife and sometimes these early interactions set the tone for a long time to come…"

Relationships work both ways. She is not making the best impression either, is she?

These are the ones who will be nitpicking and moaning when they don't get free childcare from the MIL in a few years.

I would never dream of being so entitled / demanding about an invitation that someone has extended to me when I a girlfriend. The son is also very cheeky.
Does he not have a home? If it is that important - HE can cook her the posh Christmas dinner of her posh dreams. So so cheeky.

@5littleducksallinarow would you like a full, formal Christmas dinner? If you do, many people will be able to suggest work arounds for small spaces.

If you don't want to do it / cook it then just repeat that the invite is extended for a buffet and leave them to decide what they want to do.

Goldenbear · 10/11/2026 20:32

user1471600850 · 10/11/2026 20:10

Rubbish - is your Christmas defined by a roast dinner! What do you think they do in hot countries - Australians tend to BBQ on the beach - how dreadful! This whole thread makes me depressed - it should be about spending a great day with your family!!!

Well my DH and his family think 99% of family life is about food so he would definitely disagree with you!

Cherrytree86 · 10/11/2026 20:33

suki1964 · 10/11/2026 18:24

You son sounds just like my step- son, as we would have said - ideas above their station :)

Im very proud that hes gone on from nothing and now flies around the world, has a Sydney Harbour apartment , thinks nothing of eating in Michelin starred restaurants , has a beautiful wife who is a KC . But he does forget that we are from pretty humble backgrounds, he dad is a brickie and Im a cook

Hes flying to London for a conference this week and has said hes tagging on a few days to come visit - but has he told us the dates? Has he hell. But he will expect a car available yet not be able to tell us how many nights hes staying with us or when he is with us what meals he will be here for.

When he first met his wife and brought her home to meet the family I was stressed to the hilt making sure everything was perfect, and it still wasnt good enough, he let us know. Last time I hosted them both and her parents and brother, and served up a marks lasagne and gave them a good fry in the morning. If they didnt like it - they were free to find board and lodging elsewhere

You do you. They can go elsewhere if its not "good enough" for them

@suki1964

your son sounds insufferable

QuietChristmas2026 · 10/11/2026 20:35

Oh honestly. All these ridiculous suggestions about renting holiday homes, or buying a larger house. Ignore these crazy responses.

But MY idea is worth considering - have you considered going back in time and having fewer children?

🤣😂🤣

Cherrytree86 · 10/11/2026 20:36

Goldenbear · 10/11/2026 20:32

Well my DH and his family think 99% of family life is about food so he would definitely disagree with you!

@anditmakesmesmile

the son can cook a roast himself if it means that much to him. He’s plenty old enough. He can move out while it’s at it as well, he’s plenty old enough for that too.

Goldenbear · 10/11/2026 20:38

Cherrytree86 · 10/11/2026 20:36

@anditmakesmesmile

the son can cook a roast himself if it means that much to him. He’s plenty old enough. He can move out while it’s at it as well, he’s plenty old enough for that too.

I thought he had moved out and only visits?