Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is it ever ok to send one to private and one to state?

239 replies

Notmycircusnotmyotter · 10/11/2026 09:03

Just that really. I would have always said you can never give children such unequal opportunities within a family but I'm looking at my two and they're such different children I'm sort of considering it. I have two primary aged children. My boy (older) is very sweet, impressionable and cautious. He's also insanely bright. He could read well from early 4, was doing Lego for 11+ at 3, he asks me to throw maths questions at him while in the bath. I think he would really thrive in an academic private whereas I worry he won't be stretched enough as he gets older in state and potentially would start coasting and lose interest. This rings true because exactly the same happened to his dad (who was then moved to private), whereas I was private all the way through and left with 5 A levels, top university degree, postgrad quals and now a great career. For these reasons I'm trying to work out finances to allow him to go to a great prep from 8.

The problem is, I can't afford it for two. My daughter (5) is a wholly different character. She's utterly brilliant, so confident, sporty (unlike her brother), she does dance and drama, gymnastics already and loves it all. Academically she's fine, she's thriving at their lovely village primary and she knows her own mind enough to not get distracted. I have no doubt she will thrive anywhere and suspect that she will throw her weight into sports and other extra curriculars rather than being exceptionally academic. I could afford to send DS to private for academic rigour while supporting DD's interests outside of school (and getting tuition for the one girls grammar nearby). But I couldn't afford two in private at the stage and obviously costs go up in secondary.

Am I unreasonable to even consider this? I've gone back and forth so many times my head is now mush.

Thank you for reading!

OP posts:
Everdecreasingcircumferences · 10/11/2026 12:24

What is the quality of your local state schools like? My eldest went to private for Alevels due to last minute change in subjects available at the intended 6th form college. He is every bit as able and confident as his prep schooled / fully privately educated peers, hasnt missed out at all by being state from Reception to yr11 (has had plenty of sport and music opportunities through extra curriculars) and the cost would have been a complete waste (not that we had ever considered private before Alevel).

If your local schools are decent I would keep both DC in state until yr9 and then move them to private - I honestly think prep schools are a complete waste of money if your local primary and extracurricular offer is good and your children are bright and able.

theprincessthepea · 10/11/2026 12:25

I’m in the exact same mind as you. Although mine have a large age gap, my youngest is very bright, knew the alphabet and recognised words and number sequences from the age of 2, and is wired academically. Whereas my eldest is super social, so sporty but also very smart. I know she would thrive in private too, but I think a public school is perfect for her as she’s smart but not necessarily wired to be academic in the same way my son is. He hyperfocus, loves sequences etc. She’s not competitive when it comes to academia, but self motivated.

So I do hope to consider private or a grammar school when he starts secondary and I have put much more effort into finding a school that’s right for him because he already knows a lot of what an average child his age is learning.

If I didn’t have 2 children that were polar opposites academically I would have said - bad idea. But being in the situation myself, I get it. However I’ll add that I am equally invested in my daughters public education and I’m looking out for sporting opportunities for her, scholarships etc as I don’t want her to think that I’ve poured so much into her brother and left her as she “will be alright regardless”.

Badgerandfox227 · 10/11/2026 12:29

I’m the sibling that went to state, yes I’ve done very well for myself, but I resented it at the time and still now as an adult that my parents spent such a vast amount on one sibling, whilst we struggled at state.

Do not send one unless you are able to send the other. She may be too young to understand the choice you have made now, but she’ll remember as an adult.

Funny how the choice is often about sending the son to private…

bobbycock79 · 10/11/2026 12:35

I agree that your kids , especially your daughter, are too young to be mapped out in their potential already. However I see and get where you're coming from. Our eldest is also very sensitive, socially awkward, lacking confidence . Pretty sure is autistic but masks well at school. We decided to send her to the independent we work at (hefty discount makes it possible) it was the right decision as we have been able to support her and keep an eye on her and she is doing well.

We had hoped we would be in the position to send her younger sibling (7 year difference ) too. However combinations of a pay freeze , cost of living rocketing and some instability in the independent sector made it seem unwise and almost impossible. It's gutting and we do feel guilt but circumstances change beyond our control. Like yours our youngest is a completely different proposition; very academic, sporty, confident, popular socially and just seems to breeze through life. I know they will (and are) doing well in our local good state. It is what it is. I would like to think that with maturity, my youngest will recognise the struggles my eldest had. Life has not been easy for them and they wouldn't want to swap places and understand that we did what we felt was best at the time. Those who say they know siblings who were treated differently in this way and now 'hate' their parents make me feel sad but that there must be a lot of other stuff going on.

Timeforanewname2014 · 10/11/2026 12:39

My answer now is the opposite of what it would have been 5 years ago. At that point we were considering private for DD1 who has SEN but wouldn’t have been able to also send DD2. DD2 we were confident would thrive in state. Eventually ruled out private for various reasons. What actually transpired was that DD1 had lots of support and coped fine in a state secondary school. DD2 struggled far more and would absolutely have benefited from a smaller/ private school. What I’m saying is that what we know to be the case now may not be the reality in a few months or years

Bloozie · 10/11/2026 12:40

On paper, fine. Different children, different needs. Equitable, not equal.

In practice, the sheer abundance of additional opportunities this would grant your son would be untenable to me. Especially as your other child is female. I would feel very uncomfortable layering more privilege on my son. And if your daughter is sporty and into dance and drama, she would REALLY benefit from the facilities of a private school in order to reach her full potential.

I was very bright as a child. Off the charts bright. School didn't know what to do with me, bright. My parents discussed private education at secondary level and I was violently opposed - I didn't want to go. I could not have got better exam results than I did, anywhere else. I was put on the Oxbridge pathway in sixth form, though didn't apply. It was a perfectly ordinary, unexceptional secondary school with a massive catchment - kids from every and all backgrounds, all levels of ability and disability, it was the 90s so neurodivergent children and children with learning difficulties were sadly too often treated as disruptive rather than needing additional support... and I consider that I had a great education.

HoppingPavlova · 10/11/2026 12:40

Yep, utterly unreasonable if you can’t afford both. We sent ours to a mix but that’s because some chose State and didn’t want to go private, however they were all told they could switch both ways at any point, and some did from State to private, so we needed to have the money ready in case. The only hold up some experienced was available places in private but that’s was out of our control and was explained to them as a risk when they didn’t want to go originally.

Janus · 10/11/2026 12:45

We have 3 girls and 1 boy, he is the youngest. Our son dld not get into the same state school as his siblings because they changed the sibling rule. We were faced with private or a state we didn’t know. He went to the state we didn’t know. One of our main reasons is because I never wanted our girls to think a boy was worth more investment. Just so you know, all 3 girls are either at uni or finished uni and have amazing lives, dd1 got a first and dd2 a 2:1 and dd3 is currently studying Law. Our local state school last year had something like 8 go off to Oxford/Cambridge. If they’re bright and supported at home as well as school they honestly can and do thrive. I honestly think it’s either both or none with your dynamic. I have a close friend who sent one of hers to private as she has SEN and couldn’t go to state school realistically, this, for me, would be the only reason to consider it.

ijusthavetoNCforthis · 10/11/2026 12:46

@Notmycircusnotmyotter
Don't do it, please don't. I was sent to a state secondary school whilst my twin brother went to prep school at age 8, then one of the best private schools, boarding from age 13. We used to be so so close before this and it was honestly like he had been brought up in a different family to me! He ended up at Cambridge, I left school few exams to my name and left home at 17.
I have never resented him for it, it wasn't his fault, but our lives were so so different because of this so it was hard to relate to each other when we became adults.
No one should ever split their children in such a way.

Ohcrap082024 · 10/11/2026 12:47

OneoftheWeddingPeople · 10/11/2026 09:11

I know several families who’ve done this but not from the outset. The usual
scenario is the more vulnerable one is struggling at secondary and is moved in extremis. In both cases the older child was fine with this as they were happy where they were in state and didn’t want to move anyway. And could clearly see the other child’s issues so there wasn’t jealousy.

This is very much our situation. Oldest did very well in state grammar school. Was very happy, made lots of friends and thrived.

Youngest was miserable in her state comp. Bullied, anxious, desperately unhappy. So we took the plunge and moved her to a small, nurturing independent school at the end of Year 7.

I do get pangs of guilt that I sent one to an indie and not the other. But it was a “desperate needs calls for desperate measures” situation.

Could I have done it for both - no. Thank goodness I didn’t need to. But even so, I do feel guilty for spending all this money on one and not the other.

Would I have made the decision willingly at such a young age? Absolutely not.

Fidgety31 · 10/11/2026 12:47

How to say you favour one of your kids over the other - without actually saying it !!

PicklePicklePicklePickle · 10/11/2026 12:59

I know a several families who’ve sent one child private. Including a close family member and all but one have had a degree of resentment between the siblings as adults.
The one who didn’t was where the child had autism and severe learning difficulties.

Iceandfire92 · 10/11/2026 13:00

This would be incomprehensible to many people who may not be able to recognise the nuance in this situation. Outwardly it would appear that you are perpetuating chronic resentment and a golden child/scapegoat dynamic between your two children. This could even be perceived as misogyny as the eldest boy would be receiving the private education and the youngest daughter would not receive the same benefits. Academia isn't the only benefit of a private education; your daughter would be missing out on so much extra-curricular sporting opportunities.

SquirrelNemesis · 10/11/2026 13:03

I have nothing against doing different things for different children (one child has had home ed, state mainstream primary and private (LA-funded) special school while the other is EOTAS). But putting vastly more money into the education of one than the other is the issue. It’s one thing if it can really be justified but I’m not sure it can (yet, anyway) based on the situation described.

Full blood siblings are usually similar in intelligence although how it presents may be quite different. You seem to have decided a 5yo is less bright based on being less obviously academic very early. This may later prove to be completely wrong. Also, I honestly think that the gap between state and private is far bigger in sports, music, drama etc than it is in academics so deciding that a traditionally academic child would benefit more from private seems flawed to me. And the academic gaps are acknowledged and mitigated by the system. Plenty of state school kids go to Oxbridge but a lot of sports, classical music etc are still very heavily dominated by people who went to private school.

You also don’t know if your 5yo may face difficulties in future and want to move to private school. I know someone who is funding private school for an older grandchild because they were struggling in state school, but now their younger sibling. is struggling in a similar way and they can’t afford to do the same for the younger one, and are now in a really difficult situation

YenSon · 10/11/2026 13:04

Slightyamusedandsilly · 10/11/2026 09:20

Why is it always the boy that 'needs' private though?

I have (older) friends. DS went to private. He is successful in what he does. DD went to state. She is now a lead medical consultant.

I was horrified when they admitted little Johnny would be private and little Emma would be private. So sexist.

It's either both or neither. Way to set up your children for a life of sibling rivalry, favouritism and fractured sibling relationships.

I worked in a high performing state primary school in an affluent area. What sometimes happened for those inclined, was at some point in KS2 their child would leave to go to a prep school, or they’d go after Y6. One family had 4 children. All 3 sons went to prep in Y3 or Y4. Not the daughter though. She had to stay in state school. She told me that only the boys in her family went to private school. She was the brightest button out of the lot of them.

Muchtoomuchtodo · 10/11/2026 13:19

Notmycircusnotmyotter · 10/11/2026 11:08

I've spent the morning researching and have made a 5 year plan to support them both.

Not far from where we live is a grammar area with outstanding state schools as a fall back. It's also beautiful with large houses that can be done up.

It seems the obvious choice to save hard over the next couple of years for the new house while really focussing on both children's strengths (reading and wide vocab a priority for both), introducing verbal and non-verbal reasoning from year 3/4, tutoring for grammar and moving house to the grammar area when DS is around 9.

If DS gets into grammar and DD doesn't I'll reopen the private option for her. If neither get in, it will either be the great states or less prestigious private for both.

Thanks for everyone's input.

Gosh, a couple of hours this morning to come up with a 5 year plan that has massive implications for you, your dp and dc! That’s extremely fast to do a u-turn!

Retiring at 55 isn’t the norm, and living in small houses is pretty typical too, so the adjustments that you might end up making aren’t too radical!

Please just enjoy your dc and stop microanalysing them.

MajorProcrastination · 10/11/2026 13:23

Notmycircusnotmyotter · 10/11/2026 11:54

Writing off the state sector in modern days, with huge class sizes and not enough SEN support, with teachers leaving in droves.. is categorically not writing off the 93% of children who aren't at private.

But you are comfortable with "writing off" one of your children and not the other? My children are teenagers or 20 and of them and their peers, there's no notable advantage to those who went to either a local private school or went away to a private 6th form. They had good exeperiences but they've not had better A levels or got into better univeristy courses than their friends who are the same age in state school.

The major difference to the outcomes of most young people is how engaged their families are, how supportive their parents are. Your kids have got that.

You can choose what you want for your own children, I just saw a glaring assumption in your post about the state school experience NOW, not just in the 90s and 00s.

HeyThereDelila · 10/11/2026 13:26

They both sound bright; I really don’t understand why you’re choosing your DS for private over your DD. Move to a better secondary school catchment or aim to get both in to grammars with tutoring - they’ll do very well.

Sounds like your DS wouldn’t benefit from the sport etc at private anyway, but your DD would. Private does not mean better academically nowadays.

You can’t treat them differently.

Notmycircusnotmyotter · 10/11/2026 13:27

Tintarella · 10/11/2026 12:05

Desperately unfair to label your daughter sporty but academically unexceptional - and make a decision of this magnitude about her future- at the ripe old age of 5. I think in your position I would move to a place where they both could have a shot at a good grammar.

You're probably right and I've taken this on board.

It wasn't a criticism of my daughter - she's bloody brilliant. Her emotional intelligence is impressive, she's a total powerhouse who could swim well by 3. She's fast and strong with an epic over arm. Ideally she would get into women's cricket but I know I mustn't micromanage too much 😂. She may well be more than capable academically and I will make sure she absolutely has the same in terms of resources for tutors etc.

OP posts:
MyballsareSandy2015 · 10/11/2026 13:30

My brother moved from state to private when he was about 7 … he was disruptive and a bit wild at school and my parents wanted a stricter environment for him. It worked! He thrived.

I’ve never had a problem with being left in state education … I have a completely different personality to him and thrived in my own way there.

Notmycircusnotmyotter · 10/11/2026 13:34

I've taken on board risks of resentment and difficult family relationships. I've also taken on board the risk of perceived misogyny. I would be interested if people would be so opposed if it was the other way round. I imagine some would, some wouldn't.

I've responded further up that it will be either or both, unless one gets into grammar and the other doesn't, at which point it will be a very open family conversation where all views are considered.

A few have said I obviously favour my son. Completely untrue. If anything, I lean towards my easy, chilled, hilarious daughter, despite loving them equally.

I will do all I can to get them the best educations possible - ideally selective and independent.

Thanks everyone for views. You've confirmed the place I started but after going down prep school rabbit holes last night I needed the kick today. Very much appreciated.

OP posts:
SpunkyLimePlayer · 10/11/2026 13:36

This is so strange - you seem to be viewing very young children, their potential and their character as fixed entities and self-fulfilling prophecies. There are arguments and scenarios where it can work and be ok to do one thing for one and one for another. Your arguments are certainly not that.

Biggles27 · 10/11/2026 13:53

I did state from 11 (ie year 7) my brother did public boarding school from private prep so all the way through. I survived.

But would I do it if I’d had two children? probably not as the extras that private schools offer are difficult to see and not be receiving.

I’m on the fence as I’ve been in that same situation and am not traumatised in any way but I wouldn’t do that if I’d had two children 🤷‍♂️

HewasH2O · 10/11/2026 14:02

Scrap the prep school. Set aside equal amounts for both children. Don't assume that they will both get into a grammar school.

PumpkinsForLife · 10/11/2026 14:13

Unless one has SEN requirements that make it "necessary", I don't think this is acceptable. You can make just as valid a case that a less academic child needs private school as you can the more academic one.

I think it's very convenient that everyone who admits to doing this conveniently knows that their other child would "thrive anywhere". Especially when it's people like OP making that claim about a 5 year old! It's a lie they tell themselves to make them feel better.

Swipe left for the next trending thread