Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is it ever ok to send one to private and one to state?

239 replies

Notmycircusnotmyotter · 10/11/2026 09:03

Just that really. I would have always said you can never give children such unequal opportunities within a family but I'm looking at my two and they're such different children I'm sort of considering it. I have two primary aged children. My boy (older) is very sweet, impressionable and cautious. He's also insanely bright. He could read well from early 4, was doing Lego for 11+ at 3, he asks me to throw maths questions at him while in the bath. I think he would really thrive in an academic private whereas I worry he won't be stretched enough as he gets older in state and potentially would start coasting and lose interest. This rings true because exactly the same happened to his dad (who was then moved to private), whereas I was private all the way through and left with 5 A levels, top university degree, postgrad quals and now a great career. For these reasons I'm trying to work out finances to allow him to go to a great prep from 8.

The problem is, I can't afford it for two. My daughter (5) is a wholly different character. She's utterly brilliant, so confident, sporty (unlike her brother), she does dance and drama, gymnastics already and loves it all. Academically she's fine, she's thriving at their lovely village primary and she knows her own mind enough to not get distracted. I have no doubt she will thrive anywhere and suspect that she will throw her weight into sports and other extra curriculars rather than being exceptionally academic. I could afford to send DS to private for academic rigour while supporting DD's interests outside of school (and getting tuition for the one girls grammar nearby). But I couldn't afford two in private at the stage and obviously costs go up in secondary.

Am I unreasonable to even consider this? I've gone back and forth so many times my head is now mush.

Thank you for reading!

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Circu1957 · Yesterday 08:38

Grimda · 10/11/2026 11:27

My friend did this. Scottish state schools are horrendously violent, and one child flatly refused to go any longer. Their anxiety was through the roof. My friend was looking at either giving up work and home educating or private. Private was the cheaper option. The other two are in state and are less anxious children overall so coping so far. The in laws are wealthy so private could be a possibility if they have no other option but they intend to stick in state for now.

If only state schools in Scotland could provide a calm, safe environment to learn in I can see many of the private schools going bust as I know of a number of kids that are in private due to the unaddressed violence.

Can we please rephrase this so we don’t terrify or guilt trip Scottish parents sending their children to state school if they cannot afford private. I am in Scotland, and I went to a state school. My school was not ‘horrendously violent’. Some, some are, just like some in England and Wales are. The majority are absolutely not….so please don’t generalise!

SpunkyLimePlayer · 15/11/2026 07:40

Notmycircusnotmyotter · 10/11/2026 14:50

@Janusnot all grammars a single sex. I was at all girls and I think that was positive. I wouldn't want to see my boy at an all boys. I think boys need the influence of girls while growing up, in a way girls can benefit from being free from distraction.

You're rage baiting with this surely? Hey one of them might be gay - maybe they both are. Your attitude is so backwards and narrow minded. Perhaps they'd both be better off at a state school to escape your very narrow views as they're clearly not going to get an expansive view of the world from their home life.

beyondyuck · 14/11/2026 23:35

OP - I did that and so far 18 and 20 - no resentment.

1 very academic breezed through grammar school, focussed confident a natural all rounder

Other started in same school and it was awful. Bullied, on the verge of school refusal not particiapting in anything as did not like the environment or people. Toom them out and went to local private school. Utter transformation - my child returned to us. Happy confident.

Interstingly they got the same grades.

I have asked hwo they felt and both recognised the grammar school - mainly to do with the year one was in - was bloody awful and that child was better out. No doubt facilities and support was better at the private school but we made sur they both had the same sporting/ club activities as each other.

No regrets - both in Russell Group universities and very well adjusted children.

turquoisedragon1 · 14/11/2026 21:00

turquoisedragon1 · 14/11/2026 19:29

Im not a parent but thought I’d share my experience. I’m 19 and went to the local school which just coincidentally happened to be a coed state grammar. My brother is 2 school years below me. We are both autistic. He didn’t pass the 11+ and the council allocated him to a school that was well known for academics but over an hour away on the bus. My parents considered a private grammar for him instead but decided not to so he went to that school. He was miserable for year 7 so my parents considered private again but decided they would go on the waitlist for the local comp instead where he knew people from primary but was less known for good academics and if he didn’t get a place by the end of year 8 then private it would be. He got a place at the comp and was so much happier there and my mum swears he did better than he would have if he went to the first school purely because he was a lot happier and actually wanted to be in school. I did better academically at GCSE but I think he had a much happier overall school experience. I stayed at my schools sixth form and he went to a very big college in a nearby town which is widely regarded as the best in the north and consistently gets highest Oxbridge offers of state colleges in the north (50+ each year). Our schools were on the same road and we had lots of friendly rivalry. I was a bit sour when my parents were considering the private grammar as it is well known for being very good for my sport and overall has excellent sports facilities whereas my school was very much ‘netball, rugby or running’ and the private looked like hogwarts and that was an important factor for 13 year old me. Grandparents wanted us both to go to a private primary to prep for the 11+. When looking around schools I wanted to go to a different grammar school that was 40 mins on the bus as I just liked the vibe better but parents thought that amount of time on a bus was silly when there was an equally good school walking distance. I’m not sure how I would have grown to feel if he went to the private and I didn’t.

Oh also to add to this, my dad sort of had the idea that if you are clever you will do well anywhere. He had a scholarship to a private school for 1 term and hated it so moved back.

phlebasconsidered · 14/11/2026 20:43

Well, development isn't always straightforward. As a teacher, you can teach kids who are brilliant at year 2 and have flatlined by year 6. Or super at year 7 and have made no progress by year 10. My own son was reading at 4 and would have seemed gifted, but then went practical rather than academic by year 5. My daughter was way behind but overtook by year 7 and whizzed A levels. If you put money behind one and not the other, it's not necessarily a sure bet and yes, it's unfair.

PassTheHemlock · 14/11/2026 20:10

My parents sent my brother to a private school and my sister and l to a state comprehensive. They used the same sort of reasoning as you are using - he was a bit of a special snowflake, and we were tougher and would thrive anywhere. He got far better results than we did and has out-earned us both considerably. He got the lion's share of the inheritance too, on the same basis. I'd be lying if l said l didn't resent it.
I wouldn't do the same to my two kids.

Bigpuffycushions · 14/11/2026 19:44

My sister has three daughters.

The two older girls passed the entrance exam for a top state grammar school.

The youngest didn't pass the exam, so my sister and her husband sent her to a private school.

The alternative was to send her to one of the very poor comprehensive schools in the area. That would have been deeply unfair to the youngest girl.

The older sisters are thriving in an excellent academic school that's perfect for their educational needs. They are not disadvantaged in any way because their parents are paying for their sister's education.

turquoisedragon1 · 14/11/2026 19:29

Im not a parent but thought I’d share my experience. I’m 19 and went to the local school which just coincidentally happened to be a coed state grammar. My brother is 2 school years below me. We are both autistic. He didn’t pass the 11+ and the council allocated him to a school that was well known for academics but over an hour away on the bus. My parents considered a private grammar for him instead but decided not to so he went to that school. He was miserable for year 7 so my parents considered private again but decided they would go on the waitlist for the local comp instead where he knew people from primary but was less known for good academics and if he didn’t get a place by the end of year 8 then private it would be. He got a place at the comp and was so much happier there and my mum swears he did better than he would have if he went to the first school purely because he was a lot happier and actually wanted to be in school. I did better academically at GCSE but I think he had a much happier overall school experience. I stayed at my schools sixth form and he went to a very big college in a nearby town which is widely regarded as the best in the north and consistently gets highest Oxbridge offers of state colleges in the north (50+ each year). Our schools were on the same road and we had lots of friendly rivalry. I was a bit sour when my parents were considering the private grammar as it is well known for being very good for my sport and overall has excellent sports facilities whereas my school was very much ‘netball, rugby or running’ and the private looked like hogwarts and that was an important factor for 13 year old me. Grandparents wanted us both to go to a private primary to prep for the 11+. When looking around schools I wanted to go to a different grammar school that was 40 mins on the bus as I just liked the vibe better but parents thought that amount of time on a bus was silly when there was an equally good school walking distance. I’m not sure how I would have grown to feel if he went to the private and I didn’t.

Elsieandme · 13/11/2026 08:37

It’s ultimately your choice as a parent, but please bear in mind your children may not see the reasoning behind it as fair. Private education could be just as beneficial for your daughter, nurturing her unique talents and interests, so why should her future be any less important even if her path looks different?

They will end up with entirely separate friendship groups and life experiences that they may struggle to relate to, which could slowly push them apart. Your son will have a school experience his sister will never get to share. Take time to really consider the message this sends about how you value each of their education, and who bears the financial sacrifice. I know that may not be your intention at all, but that is very likely how your daughter could interpret it.

SALaw · 12/11/2026 08:26

Why not send both from secondary rather than one from aged 8? (I mean I’d send neither but if you’re dead set on it).

TunnocksOrDeath · 12/11/2026 08:07

When your daughter is old enough to ask why you are spending so much on her brother, and not her. Will you tell her straight out "Because you aren't as brainy as him." or will you have had time to invent a story that she'll find plausible that won't make her feel like a failure?

Sorry to put it so harshly, but I knew a couple of families, back in the '90s, where the grandparents paid to put the boys through private and not their sisters. It was really rough on all the kids. The girls felt quite bitter because in their eyes the grandparents didn't love them as much, and I know at least one of the boys felt a huge amount of personal guilt about it all, which he shouldn't have because it wasn't his decision.

Thejackrussellsrule · 12/11/2026 07:28

My PIL did this, sent BIL to private (boarding) couldn't afford to send DH.

DH has been no contact with his family for years now.

Mythoughtsalone · 12/11/2026 01:01

I would not recommend that you make a difference in your 2 children. As parents we all want what is best for them but I think this would be a very divisive decision. Great for your son but I would worry this would have consequences for your daughter and family in the future. Your daughter is aged 5. A little young to predict her academic ability. I would give them both the same opportunity educationally, in keeping with what you can afford.

ifonlytheydlisten · 12/11/2026 00:00

No

Tinkalinkalink · 11/11/2026 23:14

Absolutely do not do this.

Also I think you should really think hard about your bias towards your daughter which I thought was evident in every post

Stepsisterfromhell · 11/11/2026 23:02

I sent DS1 to private and DS2 to state but this decision was made at a much later date when it was clear that DS1 needed the extra challenge that private school could offer. He was also able to secure a full scholarship. We did put DS2 into the entrance exam when he reached 11 but he was not offered a place or funding. He ended up at a decent state school and is now at a RG uni. They still have a great relationship with each other and there is no resentment. They know we love them both equally.

You should not be embarrassed saying that children have different schooling needs. But I do think it is too early to tell.

Arabelllllllla · 11/11/2026 21:39

My parents did this. I went to state (albeit a good grammar) and sibling went to private. I was the sort of kid who would thrive in either environment, whereas my sibling struggled. They actually did it for the opposite reason to you, that I didn't need support academically because I was bright.

I had no issue with it at the time, nor do I now. We arent miles apart in terms of our lives now, if anything it probably levelled the playing field a bit.

Do what is best for your family. Inevitably any talk of private education riles up mumsnetters. People on here don't know your kids, only you do.

I'm just telling you I'm the product of the situation you more or less describe and I'm fine, no resentment there at all.

Bananacrepewithnuts · 11/11/2026 21:27

Notmycircusnotmyotter · 10/11/2026 09:24

It's really not sexist. If anything here it's "first child-ist". My son has the classic cautious, little bit nervous profile of the first born whereas my daughter is absolutely bomb proof. They're both wonderful in very different ways. I think I see more of myself in DS (quiet, academic, would've disappeared in a huge class), whereas DD is what I would have loved to be (confident, comfortable in her own skin, tall and strong)

You're presuming they will pass the 11+
Big call at age 5.

Lilythepink99 · 11/11/2026 21:10

We did this. DC1 ADHD, nightmare journey through sch and was pretty much expelled from mainstream. Went private for yr 10 and 11, they are now 21. It was the saviour they needed. DC2 went to a good state school, now in 6th form. DC1 would not have got the GSCE’s grades, 6/7/8 they got and the life they have now (has a great job and found their calling). DC2 sometimes mentions it but is not resentful (I hope) but we really didn’t have a choice and I would do it again every time. They will go to uni and we will fund it. Do what’s good for your children. You won’t get any approval here I am afraid.

MargotGobby · 11/11/2026 18:11

You asked if people would change their minds if it was a girl going to the private because she was more academic and a son going comp.

My answer would still be no. How would you even explain it to them without pigeonholing them at a young age and pissing them off when they are old enough to realise.

“Your sibling went private because they are more academic (you’re not that academic). You’re more sporty (the other is not sporty).”

An an aside though, does anyone know of a case where a daughter that’s been sent to private because they were academic (not sen or bullying) while a son’s been left in a comp? Interested to hear

Allowingthebreeze · 10/11/2026 21:54

No.

laurajayneinkent · 10/11/2026 21:38

P.S. I can see that you're now saying probably grammar for both, which seems like a good idea.
If you decide on private, I would suggest a) not starting private school at age 9 - wait til age 11 and save on 2 years' fees; b) looking at scholarships (not just academic ones); and c) asking parents for financial help - in order to send both kids if possible.

laurajayneinkent · 10/11/2026 21:19

Different children need different things. But they are too young to take that decision now!
I (eldest child, very academic) went to private school on a scholarship and did well there - I would have done well at grammar too, but small class sizes are definitely beneficial!
My sister (1 year younger) went to the local comp as she wanted to go there with her friends and my parents let her choose. Looking back many years later, my mum said that that was a bad decision and she wished she had pushed my sister to go to gramnar, as she was/is bright but never got pushed at school, fell in with the wrong crowd and did fairly badly at school.
My younger brother refused to do the 11+, went to a "good" comp 1 hour away and did well.
Do you have good grammar schools locally? My 2 daughters are in an excellent grammar school locally, they (and I) love it there. The school gets great results, but also offers a ton of free extra curriculars including Duke of Edinburgh, army cadets, Young Enterprise, robotics, etc.

stichguru · 10/11/2026 20:49

I think it's acceptable if one child's needs are NOT being met by state (maybe SEN or some kind of particular problem like being badly bullied) and the other is not experiencing these issues at all and is happy and thriving in state.

For your children though it sounds like the older one is doing fine and might do a bit better in private and your younger one is doing fine and might do a bit better in private. You cannot compare the experiences of an 11 year old to those of a 5 year old. Your 5 year old might be in the same situation when she's 11 as your 11 year old is now and then you'd have to move her to private if you'd moved your now 11 year old.

Zanatdy · 10/11/2026 20:21

You don’t know that your DD won’t change and you find in 3yrs she would benefit from private. In your situation, no I wouldn’t do it. I had 2 bright kids, state educated and left with all 9’s. Private wasn’t an option and they did fine.

I know someone who paid private for her son, and her DD went to the local (walkable) secondary, which had an outstanding ofsted. She did take her to see some private schools, but she was not interested and wanted to go to state with her friends. I do think there was some ‘the boy should go private as dad did’ going on which didn’t approve of. But they were relieved DD didn’t want to go too, as would have been a huge stretch. They spent a fortune on tuition for grammar but so competitive here and he didn’t get in.