Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is it ever ok to send one to private and one to state?

239 replies

Notmycircusnotmyotter · 10/11/2026 09:03

Just that really. I would have always said you can never give children such unequal opportunities within a family but I'm looking at my two and they're such different children I'm sort of considering it. I have two primary aged children. My boy (older) is very sweet, impressionable and cautious. He's also insanely bright. He could read well from early 4, was doing Lego for 11+ at 3, he asks me to throw maths questions at him while in the bath. I think he would really thrive in an academic private whereas I worry he won't be stretched enough as he gets older in state and potentially would start coasting and lose interest. This rings true because exactly the same happened to his dad (who was then moved to private), whereas I was private all the way through and left with 5 A levels, top university degree, postgrad quals and now a great career. For these reasons I'm trying to work out finances to allow him to go to a great prep from 8.

The problem is, I can't afford it for two. My daughter (5) is a wholly different character. She's utterly brilliant, so confident, sporty (unlike her brother), she does dance and drama, gymnastics already and loves it all. Academically she's fine, she's thriving at their lovely village primary and she knows her own mind enough to not get distracted. I have no doubt she will thrive anywhere and suspect that she will throw her weight into sports and other extra curriculars rather than being exceptionally academic. I could afford to send DS to private for academic rigour while supporting DD's interests outside of school (and getting tuition for the one girls grammar nearby). But I couldn't afford two in private at the stage and obviously costs go up in secondary.

Am I unreasonable to even consider this? I've gone back and forth so many times my head is now mush.

Thank you for reading!

OP posts:
Muchtoomuchtodo · 10/11/2026 10:20

I’m not a fan of private education but I cannot pretend that it’s the same as a state education. I think you’re kidding yourself if you really think that your dd wouldn’t benefit from private school too. It might be in different ways than exam grades but that doesn’t mean it’s not important.

We didn’t privately educate ours. The oldest came out with 6 As 3 Bs and a C at GCSE and is thriving as an apprentice (we’re in Wales, hence the letter grades)

The youngest got 12 A⭐️ at GCSE and 4 A⭐️ at A level

State schools can and do challenge the most able kids.

If you can’t offer both dc private education, then don’t give one the opportunity and not the other. Use that money for enriching both of their childhoods and early adulthoods in other ways.

jaguar67 · 10/11/2026 10:20

I'm sure you've thought of this, but - if you're considering transferring to Prep school for Grammar school entrance at 11 - check the Prep school's track record. Some focus solely on independent sector - the entrance exams/ process are not the same. I've known parents to fork-out on Prep schools who've ended up hiring private tutors for Grammar School/ Selective Comprehensive exams - and not always with the result they wanted.

angstridden2 · 10/11/2026 10:20

Off the subject, but when did ‘not a great salary’ mean under £100K which to me infers in the £80s/90s? I obviously move in very different circles to MN, my dc earns £100K + but none of my friends do or did. There are a lot of teachers, nurses and managers amongst them so perhaps I know the wrong people! Unless you’re in London and not a government worker, £70,000+ is surely still a good salary?

Snorlaxo · 10/11/2026 10:21

Based on your description yabu.

I think that there are cases where it’s justified eg SEN but private schools usually schedule much more sport and performing arts which your dd would benefit from and enjoy.

Peonies12 · 10/11/2026 10:21

No, absolutely not ok. You are setting up for a lifetime of resentment from your daughter.

Traveltart · 10/11/2026 10:21

Are you somewhere near London where private schools including preps are highly selective and academic? If not, you’re wasting your money particularly on prep and particularly on an already capable child.

I came on here to say that it sounds like your son would thrive in a grammar school which is something I see you are considering.

We found state great for the early years but it really did begin to drop off and aim all resources at those who were struggling as the DC progressed through the next key stage.

It is early days but just be careful if your DD is not as academic as the non grammar schools in grammar areas tend to be worse than average.

It sounds to me like it’s DD who would thrive in private due to the sports and drama (which barely any state school will be able to match).

If your DPs can help indefinitely and there are no strings attached, then great. But you’re looking at £60k of after tax income for two each year. If you’re lucky, fees will only rise 5% a year. That means by the end of year 13, you’re looking at around £425k per child for the whole of their education from year 3. Including trips and uniforms you may well end up spending close to £1m.

Laurmolonlabe · 10/11/2026 10:21

I wouldn't be comfortable doing it, but I know lots of cases where this has happened.

Tablesandchairs23 · 10/11/2026 10:21

No its not fair. If you can't afford both you don't send them. If you did it could cause huge resentment in the future.

Blades2 · 10/11/2026 10:23

Expect when they get older to be either asked some hard questions or don’t be surprised when there’s feelings of inadequacy
you just have to look through some of the adult sibling threads.

Justploddingonandon · 10/11/2026 10:24

In your case I think your DD would end up resenting you. We did consider it for DD as she has quite considerably SEN and there is no way she will manage in a mainstream state high school, but it quickly became apparent that mainstream private wouldn't work for her either (though I'm sure it does for some SEN kids). If we had gone down that route I think DS would've been ok with it as he's older and is happy and settled where he is.

Pollyanna87 · 10/11/2026 10:25

It might seem like a sensible idea now, but could cause huge issues further down the line. Imagine if your DD ends up in a low-paid job, and your DS in a high-paid job. Your DD will surely feel hard done by and it could potentially ruin their relationship.

Fleurchamp · 10/11/2026 10:25

I struggle with this question too.

My son is autistic and academically very able but would struggle in a big school. He is in yr7 and just started at a small independent (40 children per year) and is happy. The state comprehensive option we were given was almost 2,000 pupils. He has slow processing and struggles with concentration- we didn't put him in for the 11+ for grammar as he melted down at a mock test we put him in for. The grammars are also massive schools as no new ones can be built.

My daughter is one of those kids where everything comes easy to her, she sails through life. Academically she is just as bright as my son but doesn't struggle with sitting in a classroom and just gets on with her work without distraction, she would be fine in a large school.

She is in year 5, prepping for the 11+ (with a tutor, the same as her brother) and is keen to go to grammar. Not sure if this is peer led or she genuinely wants to go. She would also massively benefit from a private education as she would throw herself into all the extra curriculars.

I would struggle sending her to grammar with her brother at private school, albeit I wouldn't necessarily send her to his school as she would find it too small. His school has reasonable (in relative terms!) fees but the schools she would be interested in would be 30% more expensive and have amazing facilities (my son's school is fairly basic due to its size) so either way it wouldn't be fair on one of them.

Fortunately, we can just about afford it.

monkeysox · 10/11/2026 10:25

2chocolateoranges · 10/11/2026 09:10

If you can’t afford it for both then they both go to state school.

This.

Shuffletoesxtreme · 10/11/2026 10:27

He doesn’t need to go at 8. Send them both at 11 instead.

Traveltart · 10/11/2026 10:30

OP you’re being needlessly tough on yourself. The important thing is you came to canvas opinion - which you don’t need to abide by! Your children, your money. But you sound open minded which is far better than many who come on here to ask questions and then attack those who offer advice!

I too contemplated sending just DS private as our only co-ed schools are in county lines areas whereas there is a nice girls’ state secondary that we are in zone for! We too got lots of feedback not to send just one so we ended up sending both. DH is 55 now and we have just pulled out some of his pension lump sum to fund the fees going forward. He is on (for now, as he’s old and experienced) a much higher salary than your DH. He knows it won’t last more than a few more years if he’s lucky. But yes it has involved staying in a more dilapidated house than we would like.

CaveMum · 10/11/2026 10:30

Would you consider keeping both in Primary until the natural end then moving them to Private?

It spreads the cost more (you say DD is 5 but not how much older DS is) and allows you time to put money away. This is what we’ve done - we started saving when DD was 6 and in the local village primary, with the intention of looking at private secondary.

This gave us 5 years of savings to help spread the load. She’s in her second year at secondary now and loving it. We can just afford her fees from income at the moment, so our savings are invested in S&S ISAs and are growing quietly in the background. In 2 years her brother will join her and whilst it will be hideously expensive for the following 2 years while they overlap, the savings will cushion it.

Mumtoabillion · 10/11/2026 10:32

I can't bring myself to vote one way or the other. We were in a similar position. But for our youngest, with whom there is a big gap up to the middle child, and the finances only allowed it quite late, so I think it was less of an issue. Listen to your heart, OP, You know how your daughter will see it. If you think their treatment will be hugely different, then don't do it. Mine coped ok but I do still sometimes wonder.

pollcat · 10/11/2026 10:33

One other thing: age 5 is far too early to be sure how academic your DD is. Some kids take longer to bloom!

queenceleste · 10/11/2026 10:35

you can only do what’s best at the time. Clearly your ds would thrive better in a smaller setting. Your dd can thrive in a state setting. Presumably they will both understand this difference?

of course brilliant resilient daughters can suddenly struggle later and unexpectedly and then you have to face that you can’t rescue her from the state system.

Classroom support is being reduced all the time and the state system is always under attack by politicians.

These decisions are tough. But most people can’t afford to even consider private options.

Make your decisions based on now because you can’t predict what will happen later.

We moved house to get close to ‘better’ state schools, which is fairly similar ethically to paying for private education.

Just make sure your daughter has deep resilience as success itself doesn’t make girls strong, it’s how they manage friendships and failure which will build the strength they need to manage their setting. Plenty of young women are miserable in private and state settings!

Bluffinwithmymuffin · 10/11/2026 10:36

OhHobnobs · 10/11/2026 09:24

The children are 2 individuals, not one same entity.

OP, you know your children. Put them where they'll thrive. If that means one private and one state, fine, or any other permutation.

This is also how I see it. People talk about “fairness” but what applies in theory doesn’t necessarily work in practice, so treating kids the same can mean one doesn’t get what’s exactly right for them.

One of mine went to a private secondary on an academic bursary, another was allowed to leave his state school at 15 to pursue a sport, then went back to college at 18 to pick his education up under his own steam.

My choices were very limited due to lack of funds and living in a very undesirable part of London, but in an ideal situation, OP, I’d have sent them all to a state primary, and whichever secondary best suited them, be it private, grammar or comprehensive.

TeensNoMore · 10/11/2026 10:37

You also seem to be assuming/believing that if you go state then it needs to be a grammar school.

A good comp can push the high ability kids as well as supporting lower ability.
A good comp plus top up tutoring for both where needed could work well.

Kadiofakit · 10/11/2026 10:39

I think it's stupid to believe that your bright child won't do as well in state. Spend the money on moving to an area with good schools

dizzydizzydizzy · 10/11/2026 10:39

Notmycircusnotmyotter · 10/11/2026 09:26

I think one in grammar and one in private would be acceptable. I don't know at this point if grammar would be right for DD. I suspect it would suit DS right to the ground. I wonder if private prep to get him ready for 11+ would be too disruptive.

The trouble is you don’t know whether your DCs will pass the 11+. DC1 is exceptionally bright (mostly 9s at GCSE, 4 x Astar at A-Level, 1st from a top university) but did not manage to even come close to passing the 11+ despite going to an 11+ practice class run by a teacher at school and doing practice at home.

If you have a good comprehensive, you have no need for a grammar, if DC1 is anything to go by.

I would spent the money you would have spent on
private school on extra tutoring for both and other enriching experiences such as clubs, outings and holidays.

TheBrambleDormouse · 10/11/2026 10:40

NoWireHangersEver · 10/11/2026 09:09

No it's not fair, and 5 is way too young to assess future academic potential. You're basically imposing your own experiences and stereotypes on her

I tend to agree with this. One of my relatives reasoned that one of her children wasn't as academically bright as the other when they were young and started encouraging her to more vocational careers, owning a small business and things such as that. Said child then began to excel as they aged and illustrated that they were nothing but non-academic! Has a degree and a great job now, whereas the other child who showed academic abilities earlier on hasn't really applied themselves and is certainly not the brighter of the two. They were both privately educated.

My half-sibling had a rich parent and was privately educated. Hasn't ever been very bothered about anything academic, just wanted a decent enough job and to marry and have children. Worked a couple of days a week, married well enough to do so, fair enough.

My parents couldn't afford private school for me. I am academic and really do believe I would've greatly benefited from private school. I don't begrudge my half-sibling, It's not their fault, but I do recognise that I was thought of as 'thick' in my early years, but it was mainly down to being overwhelmed by school overall.
It's important to know that we all bring our own frames of reference when answering this type of question.

Keepgettingolder81 · 10/11/2026 10:40

AgualusasL0ver · 10/11/2026 10:06

@Keepgettingolder81 would you mind if I PM you about the Navy?

Of course, no problem. X.