Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be absolutely furious at Brand's barrister?

315 replies

Bollihobs · 09/11/2026 14:03

Just reading the live sentencing of Russell Brand and this is what his defence barrister, Ian Wilson KC has come out with, presumably in a hand-wringing attempt to lessen the sentence.

Ian Winter KC told Southwark Crown Court that Russell Brand's rape and sexual assault convictions have caused 'total devastation' to his wife Laura Gallacher – but she is 'standing by him'. He said "they have been 'wrestling with how to explain' to their ten-year-old child what has happened to their father. 🤔

Mr Winter said: 'I'm afraid words are completely inadequate to truly try to convey to your Lordship the total devastation she's experiencing.

'Currently (they) are wrestling with how to exactly explain to a child who's just turned ten what has happened here. It brings home the consequences of this conduct to totally innocent people who have been caught up in it.'

WTF??? Surely the only non-innocent person is Brand. The "innocent people caught up in this" are his victims first and foremost. And as for "what has happened to their father" ???? Well, justice came knocking that's what happened!

I have no idea how to complain about a barrister's conduct but I really want to. This is just appalling.

OP posts:
Grammarnut · 09/11/2026 17:22

You are not being unreasonable in your opinion of what Brand's barrister says, but it is his job to defend Brand. That's how our legal system works. Everyone, from the vilest paedophile-murderer to the tacky professional shoplifter, must have representation and defence. Otherwise it is not justice.

OffTheMap · 09/11/2026 17:27

ROTTERTRON · 09/11/2026 17:13

That is not true. It is not the judge's job to convey or express an opinion on the outcome produced by the jurors. He or she is following a framework or guideline and would've followed the SAME guidelines had Brand pleaded guilty and avoided a trial, but with the applied discount respecting the guilty plea.

If you had listened to the judge's summarization (or now read if available a transcript) you will be able to identify all the concessions made to both reduce the overall sentence, and the elements which raised it again. I recommend you do this as it will make absolute sense.

The judge did say, though, with some emphasis and looking him straight in the eye "These were accomplished women who took a reasonable decision to go to a party, to have a few drinks, or to go to your house for one type of consensual sex. I stress that the fact they did so in no way shape or form diminishes your culpability for sexually assaulting one and raping the other. Whatever women wear, wherever they go, indeed whatever they drink, they retain the right to say no and to demand justice from the criminal courts when sexual predators like you , Russell Brand, act without their consent "

I'd say that indicates that the judge was sure the conviction was correct!

Themaghag · 09/11/2026 17:40

Bollihobs · 09/11/2026 14:06

Wow. Just me then. Hey ho.

I agree with you OP - Ian Winter has been a total cunt throughout this trial particularly with regard to his cross examination of witnesses and his bad tempered outburst to Times journo Rosamund Urwin. He's already reported himself to the Bar Council, but it wouldn't hurt if the rest of us called his conduct into question too!

LiuBei · 09/11/2026 17:44

Bollihobs · 09/11/2026 14:06

Wow. Just me then. Hey ho.

But what do you actually want the system to be? That if a barrister decides they think you did it, halfway through the case they can just say "throw away the key, he is awful?"

I think RB is awful, but I think the legal system would be worse if lawyers just stopped trying when they were defending awful people.

19Since7 · 09/11/2026 17:44

Themaghag · 09/11/2026 17:40

I agree with you OP - Ian Winter has been a total cunt throughout this trial particularly with regard to his cross examination of witnesses and his bad tempered outburst to Times journo Rosamund Urwin. He's already reported himself to the Bar Council, but it wouldn't hurt if the rest of us called his conduct into question too!

He has self-reported his outburst, as you say.

As for his conduct in court - if it crossed the line, do you not think the judge would have intervened?

However much you may personally deplore his methods, you will get nowhere raising a complaint just because you disagree with a barrister.

hihelenhi · 09/11/2026 17:45

StrawberryMatchaLatte · 09/11/2026 17:12

Everyone has a legal right to a defence. You are allowed to not like the defence but that is the man's job. If Russell Brand did not have a defence, later down the line it could be said that it was not a fair trial, he could appeal and walk free. Having a prosecution and defence is the only way you can be sure you have a safe conviction.

Of course everyone deserves a fair, objective and robust defence. But many defence lawyers in this area do NOT in fact rely on those outdated rape myths and yet still manage to be objective and robust. Winter's line of questioning stood out to a lot of people, largely because, as someone whose specialism is not sex assault and rape cases, because they consisted mostly of long debunked stereotypes and victim-blaming most of us thought died out decades ago. And it didn't seem at all objective from his behaviour; quite the opposite.

Would a "robust defence" of a white defendant versus a black accuser allow the defence barrister to use false racist stereotypes about black people from decades ago, for example, or would that rightly be avoided? I don't think robust defence necessarily means "anything goes".

Lifeomars · 09/11/2026 17:45

While I fully undersand the concept of mitigation this approach seems more likely to aggravate the judge than to convince him to be more lenient. Brand has shown no regret, no contrition, no undestanding of the impact his actions have had on his victims, he could have done the " i am sorrry my actions have caused distress but at the time I thought it was all consensual" but no, he has demonstrated not one scintialla of regret other than being called to account. When my attacker was senteced it was incontrivertable that his barrister actually said there was nothing to offer in mitigation other than he was sorry which cut no ice with the judge, Then when he got 5 years and an absolute tongue-lashing from the judge he began yelling abuse at the judge. I even managed to feel a bit sorry for his defence, it must be tough to try and put forward a case for an utter wrong un

hihelenhi · 09/11/2026 17:45

19Since7 · 09/11/2026 17:44

He has self-reported his outburst, as you say.

As for his conduct in court - if it crossed the line, do you not think the judge would have intervened?

However much you may personally deplore his methods, you will get nowhere raising a complaint just because you disagree with a barrister.

He did intervene at some points.

Flymyprettiesflies · 09/11/2026 17:46

Bollihobs · 09/11/2026 14:03

Just reading the live sentencing of Russell Brand and this is what his defence barrister, Ian Wilson KC has come out with, presumably in a hand-wringing attempt to lessen the sentence.

Ian Winter KC told Southwark Crown Court that Russell Brand's rape and sexual assault convictions have caused 'total devastation' to his wife Laura Gallacher – but she is 'standing by him'. He said "they have been 'wrestling with how to explain' to their ten-year-old child what has happened to their father. 🤔

Mr Winter said: 'I'm afraid words are completely inadequate to truly try to convey to your Lordship the total devastation she's experiencing.

'Currently (they) are wrestling with how to exactly explain to a child who's just turned ten what has happened here. It brings home the consequences of this conduct to totally innocent people who have been caught up in it.'

WTF??? Surely the only non-innocent person is Brand. The "innocent people caught up in this" are his victims first and foremost. And as for "what has happened to their father" ???? Well, justice came knocking that's what happened!

I have no idea how to complain about a barrister's conduct but I really want to. This is just appalling.

It’s his job to get someone off or a lesser sentence even if that someone is a lying, raping, weasel.

Flipperthepriest · 09/11/2026 17:51

Dontlletmedownbruce · 09/11/2026 17:09

I agree the barrister is just doing his job and has to be creative to find ways to mitigate damage etc. However I think as a member of the public I can also make my own judgments on the morality of a person who chooses to take on this case, because it is a choice. I'd go one step further and say that I have generally very low respect for solicitors and barristers who specialise in criminal law defence.

Obviously the flipside to that is that other people may have even lower respect for you as someone who not only holds that view but vocalises it.

hihelenhi · 09/11/2026 17:51

Lucytheloose · 09/11/2026 16:48

Exactly this. Obviously not everyone is going to be familiar with the exact role of a defence barrister, but it's rather worrying that so many people don't understand the principle of professional objectivity.

Sorry, but this is't about not understanding professional objectivity. I think most of us understand that (and that wrong uns absolutely do need a robust defence and that's the way it is)

I'm not sure Ian Winter KC entirely does understand professional objectivity, however. That was part of the criticism of him specifically.

Flipperthepriest · 09/11/2026 17:52

MadameSosotris · 09/11/2026 16:59

I agree with most of your post, but given Winter's comments to journalists after the trial, it seems to have been a bit personal, although god knows why. Maybe he just can't cope with losing a case.

Yeah that was quite odd. Glad the BSB will be having a look.

MadameSosotris · 09/11/2026 17:53

A robust defence is not the same as lying in order to get your client off. Rape myths have been disproved over and over again- Winter will be fully aware of that, he chose to rely on them anyway. Dishonest and reprehensible behaviour from a KC.

19Since7 · 09/11/2026 17:53

hihelenhi · 09/11/2026 17:45

Of course everyone deserves a fair, objective and robust defence. But many defence lawyers in this area do NOT in fact rely on those outdated rape myths and yet still manage to be objective and robust. Winter's line of questioning stood out to a lot of people, largely because, as someone whose specialism is not sex assault and rape cases, because they consisted mostly of long debunked stereotypes and victim-blaming most of us thought died out decades ago. And it didn't seem at all objective from his behaviour; quite the opposite.

Would a "robust defence" of a white defendant versus a black accuser allow the defence barrister to use false racist stereotypes about black people from decades ago, for example, or would that rightly be avoided? I don't think robust defence necessarily means "anything goes".

Out of interest, what line of questioning/argument would you have used to defend Brand - if you had to do it and do it wholeheartedly, as a barrister would?

hihelenhi · 09/11/2026 17:55

19Since7 · 09/11/2026 17:50

I've just looked at the bar standards board and they will not look into cases of barristers using arguments you disagree with.

https://www.barstandardsboard.org.uk/for-the-public/problems-with-a-barrister/reporting-a-concern.html

It's not just "arguments I disagree with". Not sure why you're directing this at me personally either.

It's objectively false information I'm concerned about, as others have said.

And as I stated, the judge did intervene on occasion, for example, when Winter asked Laura Brand for her opinion. He said "no, no, no" and stopped it. There were, iirc, a few other occasions.

AbsoluteHoot · 09/11/2026 17:57

I don’t see anything he said worthy of complaint, quite the opposite. He was making a legitimate point about the human consequences of the case, particularly the impact on people who have been caught up in the events - ie his innocent family.

Brand’s barrister isn't there to express moral approval or disapproval of their client. He is there to ensure his client receives proper representation within the law.

His wife and children deserve compassion, regardless of who their father is.

PrincessofWills · 09/11/2026 18:00

CaptBirdsEar · 09/11/2026 15:52

OP I get what you’re saying, and yes as some people have said it’s his job, but bugger his wife/kids/family, it’s the victims who I’m sympathetic to 100% - any assault, no matter how long ago.never leaves you.

The two are not mutually exclusive- you can have immense sympathy for the victims and his children.

19Since7 · 09/11/2026 18:01

hihelenhi · 09/11/2026 17:55

It's not just "arguments I disagree with". Not sure why you're directing this at me personally either.

It's objectively false information I'm concerned about, as others have said.

And as I stated, the judge did intervene on occasion, for example, when Winter asked Laura Brand for her opinion. He said "no, no, no" and stopped it. There were, iirc, a few other occasions.

The barrister did not present objectively false information.

A theory that is outdated is still only a theory.

BeSharpGreenReader · 09/11/2026 18:06

Horrible though this is, it is not up the the barrister to decide on guilt/innocence or the sentence. They are required to do their best for their client and let the system work through the process.

The ire should be directed at the people who allowed Brand and other (mostly) men to get away with it for so long.

Flipperthepriest · 09/11/2026 18:07

The system allows for that sort of bullshitting, cod psychology and the like. A real victim would do X, an innocent person would do Y. I find it pretty concerning but as long as it's permitted, clients are allowed to instruct their barristers to make those arguments. Realistically the better way to stop that kind of thing would be at the structural level.

Wadsworthy · 09/11/2026 18:07

The barrister is doing his job. It's a nasty job sometimes, but EVERYONE deserves a defence.

Even scumbags.

PyongyangKipperbang · 09/11/2026 18:09

PrincessofWills · 09/11/2026 18:00

The two are not mutually exclusive- you can have immense sympathy for the victims and his children.

Exactly.

He committed the crimes but his children will suffer the consequences for the rest of their lives. They will always be the kids of "convicted rapist Russell Brand", thats a hell of a burden to carry. School for them will be awful now. If I was their mother I would probably change their surname. His wife has a choice, she can divorce him and not be his wife any more, but they have no choice at all.

GeorgeMichaelsCat · 09/11/2026 18:09

It is literally his job to do and say these arguments.