Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be absolutely furious at Brand's barrister?

315 replies

Bollihobs · 09/11/2026 14:03

Just reading the live sentencing of Russell Brand and this is what his defence barrister, Ian Wilson KC has come out with, presumably in a hand-wringing attempt to lessen the sentence.

Ian Winter KC told Southwark Crown Court that Russell Brand's rape and sexual assault convictions have caused 'total devastation' to his wife Laura Gallacher – but she is 'standing by him'. He said "they have been 'wrestling with how to explain' to their ten-year-old child what has happened to their father. 🤔

Mr Winter said: 'I'm afraid words are completely inadequate to truly try to convey to your Lordship the total devastation she's experiencing.

'Currently (they) are wrestling with how to exactly explain to a child who's just turned ten what has happened here. It brings home the consequences of this conduct to totally innocent people who have been caught up in it.'

WTF??? Surely the only non-innocent person is Brand. The "innocent people caught up in this" are his victims first and foremost. And as for "what has happened to their father" ???? Well, justice came knocking that's what happened!

I have no idea how to complain about a barrister's conduct but I really want to. This is just appalling.

OP posts:
TotaleclipseinFrance · 09/11/2026 16:38

The man is his defence barrister. What part of the word defence are you not understanding?
The only one who should be 'furious' with him is Brand because in my opinion he did a piss poor job of defending him.

TotaleclipseinFrance · 09/11/2026 16:40

blondeseaside · 09/11/2026 15:34

Well yes, he's doing his job, but I have no idea how defence lawyers sleep at night, when all they do all day is try to get murderers and rapists to walk free.

Let's hope you don't get accused of something you're innocent of then because I can assure you that you'll want one of those 'nasty' defence barristers then!

LastChristmasI · 09/11/2026 16:42

MadameSosotris · 09/11/2026 16:27

Ian Winter's behaviour throughout the trial has been unprofessional imo, tbh this is the only part of the trial I have thought his actions relatively normal for a KC, it seems fairly standard for pre-sentencing statements in a case with little to go on for positive remarks about the defendant.

Ironically, his aggressive questioning of victims and reliance on using rape myths for his arguments may get his name in future legal textbooks as the reason for the law changing and it being made compulsory for the judge to explain rape myths to the jury before they start deliberations. Not a legacy many lawyers would want!

Agree. It's the perpetuation of rape myths that hugely concern me. In a way it's good that this case is so high profile, as misogyny and rape myths in the courts aren't a new problem but at least people are paying attention now. I had a judge tell me my exH abuse (which left me suicidal) could not be that bad as my husband was a "well spoken professional man".

Wanging on about the pain to RBs family is neither here nor there, it's just part of the sentencing game. And the judge rightly gave it little weight.

OffTheMap · 09/11/2026 16:43

LittleRobins · 09/11/2026 15:10

Quote from the BBC live updates page:

‘The defence barrister now argues the woman who Brand anally raped was "not particularly vulnerable - she must have felt sufficiently confident [going to his house], considering the sort of persona, and the sort of sex he would engage in".’

Apologies if I’ve misunderstood this as I’ve had very little sleep, but is he saying we have to accept we may be anally raped if we decide to go into the house of a promiscuous man?

Yes, that's what he was saying, pretty much.

The Judge v much disagreed though and said :

"These were accomplished women who took a reasonable decision to go to a party, to have a few drinks, or to go to your house for one type of consensual sex. I stress that the fact they did so in no way shape or form diminishes your culpability for sexually assaulting one and raping the other. Whatever women wear, wherever they go, indeed whatever they drink, they retain the right to say NO and to demand justice from the criminal courts when sexual predators like you , Russell Brand, act without their consent "

Which was a good rebuttal of stuff that Winter had come out with in the trial - that one women was 'tipsy', asked another what she was wearing, victim blamed them for going to his house, asked them, in a way that sounded like an accusation, why they didn't scream, and more.

ROTTERTRON · 09/11/2026 16:44

This isn't completely true. A barrister has explicit knowledge of the law, and what it takes to convince a jury of guilt or innocence. An appelant's voice as you have put it, is NOT reproduced verbatim by the acting barrister. The defendants voice is heard under cross examination.

Barristers deal in cold hard and very clean facts. There may well be something a defendant may wish to convey, but if that muddles the messaging being offered by the very qualified barrister it will not be considered. They have the facts and they know what is relevant and what carries weight. To suggest that a barrister will not speak any words of his own formulation and rely on any of his training and skills is absurd.

TotaleclipseinFrance · 09/11/2026 16:47

ROTTERTRON · 09/11/2026 16:44

This isn't completely true. A barrister has explicit knowledge of the law, and what it takes to convince a jury of guilt or innocence. An appelant's voice as you have put it, is NOT reproduced verbatim by the acting barrister. The defendants voice is heard under cross examination.

Barristers deal in cold hard and very clean facts. There may well be something a defendant may wish to convey, but if that muddles the messaging being offered by the very qualified barrister it will not be considered. They have the facts and they know what is relevant and what carries weight. To suggest that a barrister will not speak any words of his own formulation and rely on any of his training and skills is absurd.

Agree. If this were not the case, the accused might as well get up and speak for himself! Or herself.

Lucytheloose · 09/11/2026 16:48

19Since7 · 09/11/2026 15:06

The barrister has to present anything possible, short of untruth, that could -

a. Show Brand's crimes in a less serious light, e.g. his argument that it's not as bad to rape a woman following on from consensual sex, as it is to rape an unknown woman out of the blue.
b. Offer extenuating circumstances in terms of Brand's state of mind, situation at the time of the crime.
c. Invoke sympathy for Brand's loved ones and dependents who will be affected by his prison term
d. Demonstrate as best he can that Brand has taken steps since the crime to 'be a better person' - charity work, rehab and so on.

That is the barrister's job - if he didn't do that to the best of his ability, he would be in breach of his oaths, in contempt of court and at risk of being disbarred.

It might be a load of old baloney, he might completely disagree in private that circumstances can affect the gravity of a rape, he might, in non-barrister mode, not even want Brand's sentence to be reduced - but he's taken on the role of a barrister, so he has to do his job.

It's like a doctor would have to treat or resuscitate a known serial killer if he turned up on their operating table - they can't allow their personal feelings to affect the job they do and the oaths they have taken in order to be registered to practise.

Exactly this. Obviously not everyone is going to be familiar with the exact role of a defence barrister, but it's rather worrying that so many people don't understand the principle of professional objectivity.

TherapyName · 09/11/2026 16:51

I applaud this judge.

ZoeCM · 09/11/2026 16:54

Apotofrealcoffee · 09/11/2026 14:32

I hate to say it but probably a less damaging message than 18 years being raised in the care system.

Anne Sacoolas's children wouldn't have been in the care system at all. They would have been cared for by their father. People still belated about how she needed to flee for her children's sake.

ROTTERTRON · 09/11/2026 16:57

TotaleclipseinFrance · 09/11/2026 16:40

Let's hope you don't get accused of something you're innocent of then because I can assure you that you'll want one of those 'nasty' defence barristers then!

Forgive me, I don't know how to reply ro the person you replied to.

There is no such thing as a defence lawyer/barrister. There is no such thing as a prosecuting barrister.

If the CPS approaches a barrister for the prosecution- then that barrister must take the assignment. The only bar to not taking the case, is if they have already been approached for the defence.

That is how they 'sleep at night'. It is not personal, it is a job, an assignment. The factor that would prevent them sleeping, would be the concern that they had not performed to the best of their abilities for their client on whatever side of the case they were on.

ukgone2pot · 09/11/2026 16:58

As a survivor at the hands of a top legal professional in his area and who has also defended rape cases and worked at the CPS, I can honestly say a lot of these male barristers are incredibly unhinged. Boys' club mentality and freemasonry is live and well let me just say that.

Sexual assault and sexual violence is also rife at the Bar. It wasn't so long ago that there was an investigation into male predatory behaviour, and Jo Sidhu was disbarred. Winter's actions don't surprise me one bit and although " he was only doing his job" rings out among many, we must now look at the way rape trials are conducted. I know women who have personally died because they couldn't live with how they were victimised and treated during their trial. It is disgusting. And the response from legals on X is " both defendents and complainants die and it's both terrible" can well and truly fuck right off.

mybiggreenfrog · 09/11/2026 16:59

His barrister clearly believes he is innocent, that's why he had a run in with journalists outside court of the day of the court's findings. Also it's his job to get his sentenced minimised.

MadameSosotris · 09/11/2026 16:59

ROTTERTRON · 09/11/2026 16:38

Its nothing personal when it comes to barristers either prosecuting or defending. They are doing the job they have been assigned, and they do not have the right to refuse. If they are asked to prosecute they must prosecute and the same for the defence.

A barrister HAS to make these efforts, otherwise it could be argued that they have not made the best attempt at defending or prosecuting an individual, which then creates another potential legal problem.

I agree with most of your post, but given Winter's comments to journalists after the trial, it seems to have been a bit personal, although god knows why. Maybe he just can't cope with losing a case.

forgivingfiggy · 09/11/2026 17:03

I think your father going to prison for 10 years is likely to cause a huge amount of upset and lifelong trauma. His kids are innocent. I didn’t read the barrister’s comment as ‘please won’t you think of poor Russell’ rather than ‘this has the potential to create even more upset and trauma to innocent victims’. Which is true - no?

LastChristmasI · 09/11/2026 17:04

mybiggreenfrog · 09/11/2026 16:59

His barrister clearly believes he is innocent, that's why he had a run in with journalists outside court of the day of the court's findings. Also it's his job to get his sentenced minimised.

Judging by the sentence the judge clearly believes RB was guilty

Apotofrealcoffee · 09/11/2026 17:04

forgivingfiggy · 09/11/2026 17:03

I think your father going to prison for 10 years is likely to cause a huge amount of upset and lifelong trauma. His kids are innocent. I didn’t read the barrister’s comment as ‘please won’t you think of poor Russell’ rather than ‘this has the potential to create even more upset and trauma to innocent victims’. Which is true - no?

Yes I think you have to be careful not to weaponise his kids’ distress against him. It isn’t their fault.

scalt · 09/11/2026 17:07

Should Lord Pannick have lost sleep from defending the arrogant shit Boris “there were no parties” Johnson?

Not Pannick, no, he was doing his job. As for Johnson: perhaps he should have felt a twinge of conscience that he was not paying a penny towards the cost of this, even though he could easily afford it. And if he had a soul, he might have felt some remorse about many other things as well. But he has no brain to feel anything.

Disturbia81 · 09/11/2026 17:08

It is his job. He has to say something. But a good judge will ignore it.

BasiliskStare · 09/11/2026 17:09

Brand could afford a KC. I read recently a book by Clive Stafford Smith who defended death row inmates. Some of the stories are heartbreaking. If Winter buggered up , so be it. Most KCs wouldn't and I suspect Brand has had the best defence he could afford. I thought the Judge was very thoughtful and addressed things in a way in which would mitigate the chances of an appeal. I think his barrister referred himself , rightly so. It is , IMHO the judges who may not sleep easily because they are the ones passing the sentence , but in this case I reckon Mr Justice Bennathan got it right ( I paraphrase ) whatever women choose to wear or drink etc they have the right to say no.

Dontlletmedownbruce · 09/11/2026 17:09

I agree the barrister is just doing his job and has to be creative to find ways to mitigate damage etc. However I think as a member of the public I can also make my own judgments on the morality of a person who chooses to take on this case, because it is a choice. I'd go one step further and say that I have generally very low respect for solicitors and barristers who specialise in criminal law defence.

Ihopeithinkiknow · 09/11/2026 17:11

Ialwaysthoughtitwasadojo · 09/11/2026 14:59

I couldn't be a defence barrister, it might be his job, but it's immoral.

I used to think this too but then I watched an interview where a defence barrister said that he does his job because he wants to make sure the worst criminals are locked up with nowhere to go with appeals and stuff. It made me look at it differently tbh

StrawberryMatchaLatte · 09/11/2026 17:12

Bollihobs · 09/11/2026 14:06

Wow. Just me then. Hey ho.

Everyone has a legal right to a defence. You are allowed to not like the defence but that is the man's job. If Russell Brand did not have a defence, later down the line it could be said that it was not a fair trial, he could appeal and walk free. Having a prosecution and defence is the only way you can be sure you have a safe conviction.

ROTTERTRON · 09/11/2026 17:13

LastChristmasI · 09/11/2026 17:04

Judging by the sentence the judge clearly believes RB was guilty

That is not true. It is not the judge's job to convey or express an opinion on the outcome produced by the jurors. He or she is following a framework or guideline and would've followed the SAME guidelines had Brand pleaded guilty and avoided a trial, but with the applied discount respecting the guilty plea.

If you had listened to the judge's summarization (or now read if available a transcript) you will be able to identify all the concessions made to both reduce the overall sentence, and the elements which raised it again. I recommend you do this as it will make absolute sense.

Minasama · 09/11/2026 17:16

He has single-handedly brought his profession into disrepute in the past few days. He would do better to shut up.

Perhaps Russell Brand should have considered how his ambition to have sex with 5000 women would look to any future daughters before embarking on that quest.

More the point, how will it look to this poor 10 year old that her mother stayed with such a disgusting man, even when he was convicted?

hihelenhi · 09/11/2026 17:21

ExtraOnions · 09/11/2026 15:57

Ian Winter trotted out all the outdated and discredited Rape Theories, that we all hoped had been left in the past.

Questioning the Anal Rape victim over why she didn’t roll over, kick him off and protest (very difficult when a grown man has penetrated her with his penis).

He’s a disgrace.

You can get a fair trial without stooping to worn out old tropes.

Yes, my understanding is that many defence barristers do indeed avoid rolling out those old tropes these days at accusers in sexual assault cases - precisely because they ARE rape myths and don't make their case look good. They take other tacks instead. Personally, I agree with others who say Winter did a piss poor job. His lack of expertise in this particular area was glaring. And it did seem "personal" rather than professional. I think a few lines were crossed.

I don't actually think actively retraumatising those who have every chance of being genuine rape victims by using non factual, outdated misogynist tropes and blaming them for their own rapes IS just "robust defence". If genuinely traumatised women won't come forward in the first place because of the terror of it (which as we know, they don't), then I'm not sure we can really argue that it is "justice in action". It is't for victims. Very few ever see justice, and sometimes the whole court process makes it a lot worse. But perhaps them being "only women" justice for them doesn't matter?

There is already guidance though that should be given to the jury about rape myths and to ignore them. Whether all judges do it in all cases perhaps remains to be seen. Those myths certainly seem prevalent in the public domain, as we've seen to frankly depressing levels of ignorance this last few days.

Swipe left for the next trending thread