Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Sis said no to plus one at Xmas?

443 replies

Menopausalinsommniac · 09/11/2026 07:33

This Xmas we having lunch at a family members house then they will come to my house for the evening. Food etc at both events and workload are shared between us. They are a family of five (mum, dad & kids). My side there’s me & my kids (I’m single). I had mentioned to a friend who is on alone that they may be able to join us for the day but my family members have said that they can’t come to their house for lunch but it’s ok if I want them at mine in the evening. I feel that I should be able to bring a plus one, even if it’s not a partner? I know I should have asked first but isn’t that a bit unreasonable of them?

OP posts:
SpookySeaWitch · 09/11/2026 10:42

Anarchy99 · 09/11/2026 10:37

Not sure it’s fair that he has to ‘suck it up’ - that sounds like he is reluctant about it and it’s his Christmas too.

Don't worry about him. He'll have a great time. He just grumbles for a few minutes but that's his personality. He loves it really. And likes everyone coming. It's one day.

We're off lots before and after Christmas so plenty of time to chill.

BoredZelda · 09/11/2026 10:42

AitkenDrum1970 · 09/11/2026 07:43

The whole point of Christmas is about being KIND! I could never leave someone (who didn’t want to be) on their own on Christmas Day whether I knew them or they were a friend of a friend. Over the years we’ve had all sorts of people with us for Christmas, they have added interest and often joy to the occasion.

Yeah, I don’t get the “it’s a family day” and “no strangers”. Isn’t the whole point of Christmas that when someone turns up unannounced, and needs some kindness, you give them shelter? Have people forgotten Mary, Joseph and the baby Gee? Surely it’s a “what would Jesus do” situation.

The more the merrier as far as I’m concerned. I trust the judgement of my family and if someone is good enough for them, they are good enough for me. I can imagine being so mean, I left someone sitting alone on Christmas. In this situation, I’d be declining the big family Christmas and hosting the guest at my house.

Anarchy99 · 09/11/2026 10:41

SexyFrenchDepression · 09/11/2026 10:38

There is no chance any of my family would say no to this, we have had various extras join us over the years but I know my family are those sorts of people.

Some people aren't, surely you would know what your family are like with stuff like this? .

I think its miserable but that's just because I can't imagine saying no to someone who otherwise would be alone.

Would you want to be somewhere where they are just tolerating you because you are a friend of a relative? I wouldn’t.

SexyFrenchDepression · 09/11/2026 10:41

SP2024 · 09/11/2026 10:28

Jeez, it’s Christmas. Are people really so mean they would see a friend of their sibling alone for the day? Really?? In my family anyone is welcome, we’d never see people alone if they didn’t want to be. Where are people’s Christmas spirit?

Yeah on MN you're lucky if your welcome if your immediate family, and definitely extremely lucky to be invited if you're a step child, and if you are then expect to be treated very differently to all the other DC 🙄

We have often had last minute guests too, my next door neighbour went overdue with her baby so couldnt host or travel to family so they came over to join us. We have often had SILs or BILs family come also (as in our siblings partners families)

Anyone is welcome!

Anarchy99 · 09/11/2026 10:41

Newmeagain · 09/11/2026 10:35

You sound lovely OP and I am a bit surprised and saddened by some of the responses on this thread.

i am single, with one young adult DC. I don’t have a large family and quite possibly in the future I will be one of those people who is reliant on the kindness of friends and strangers. Except that there does not seem to be much kindness or friendship on offer, judging by this thread !

Kindness to strangers is good but people feel pressurised to spend time with others just because we are sold the image of tables groaning with food and hundreds of people sat round.

I think being alone at Christmas will increasingly become the norm (smaller families etc) and people will adapt.

Brightonkebab · 09/11/2026 10:38

funny how generous people are with other people's time, resource and comfort. It's not kind and in the spirit of christmas to make more work for her sister.

SexyFrenchDepression · 09/11/2026 10:38

There is no chance any of my family would say no to this, we have had various extras join us over the years but I know my family are those sorts of people.

Some people aren't, surely you would know what your family are like with stuff like this? .

I think its miserable but that's just because I can't imagine saying no to someone who otherwise would be alone.

Anarchy99 · 09/11/2026 10:37

SpookySeaWitch · 09/11/2026 10:35

Nah they're being mean.

Think I've got an extra 2 for a late Christmas day meal? I'm working until 2. I might invite exdh too. Our table isn't big enough but I can get the pasting table out too 🤣. Dh will suck it up. Adult dcs be here.

I used to go to Church in my old home town. A couple used to open their home to people for a christmas buffet for christmas day. Usually people her dh had met in the pub who had no one. How lovely is that ❤️

Not sure it’s fair that he has to ‘suck it up’ - that sounds like he is reluctant about it and it’s his Christmas too.

Newmeagain · 09/11/2026 10:35

Menopausalinsommniac · 09/11/2026 08:02

Sorry to drip feed. They have met them, the person isn’t anyone Im dating, they are a friend. The conversation/invitation was spur of the moment and the friend understands that I needed to ask my sister and that it might not happen so no awkwardness there.

You sound lovely OP and I am a bit surprised and saddened by some of the responses on this thread.

i am single, with one young adult DC. I don’t have a large family and quite possibly in the future I will be one of those people who is reliant on the kindness of friends and strangers. Except that there does not seem to be much kindness or friendship on offer, judging by this thread !

Anarchy99 · 09/11/2026 10:35

SP2024 · 09/11/2026 10:28

Jeez, it’s Christmas. Are people really so mean they would see a friend of their sibling alone for the day? Really?? In my family anyone is welcome, we’d never see people alone if they didn’t want to be. Where are people’s Christmas spirit?

‘Christmas spirit’ isn’t a thing for most people outside of movies. The friend presumably hoped for a pity invite (you don’t tell people you are on your own for Christmas unless you are hoping for an invite). Why would you want to be invited to something out of some kind of obligation because it’s Christmas?

SpookySeaWitch · 09/11/2026 10:35

Nah they're being mean.

Think I've got an extra 2 for a late Christmas day meal? I'm working until 2. I might invite exdh too. Our table isn't big enough but I can get the pasting table out too 🤣. Dh will suck it up. Adult dcs be here.

I used to go to Church in my old home town. A couple used to open their home to people for a christmas buffet for christmas day. Usually people her dh had met in the pub who had no one. How lovely is that ❤️

housethatbuiltme · 09/11/2026 10:33

Where on earth does this '+1' entitlement come from?

No invites do not naturally include a '+1' on them, a partner is extended family and should automatically be invited to most appropriate things but its not just a 'If they get to bring their partner and I don't have a partner then I should get to just get to bring any random'.

Aluna · 09/11/2026 10:33

I mean, if you were my sister, of course you could bring your mate. If I were you, I would just spend it with your friend and your adult kids. You don’t really need more than that. You can see the others on Boxing Day.

caringcarer · 09/11/2026 10:31

Of cours you should have asked the host first if you could bring your friend. Now you have dug yourself into a hole if you've already invited this friend. You could explain the hosts don't have room for them but you'd like them to come to your house on Boxing day and Xmas evening.

ItsMeee00 · 09/11/2026 10:29

I wouldn’t be happy if someone just invited someone to my house on Christmas Day, especially if they hadn’t checked first.

SP2024 · 09/11/2026 10:28

Jeez, it’s Christmas. Are people really so mean they would see a friend of their sibling alone for the day? Really?? In my family anyone is welcome, we’d never see people alone if they didn’t want to be. Where are people’s Christmas spirit?

honeylulu · 09/11/2026 10:27

I'm a bit torn. I don't think it's the done thing to invite someone to a home/ event someone else is hosting. But on the other hand it's kind to your friend and they know her so not a new stranger.

I would also feel very annoyed about sister graciously telling me I was allowed to invite my friend to my own house.

I think if I really wanted to spend the day with my friend I would say ok I'll spend the day at home with my kids and friends instead. Family can come over in the evening if they still want to, let me know, or we could do Boxing Day instead. It's still early November so enough notice to change things around.

Hummingbird233 · 09/11/2026 10:22

mamaof4losingmymind · 09/11/2026 10:20

We have a new person for Christmas most years as someone in the family as started a new relationship. The more the merrier its Christmas. We always have enough food to feed a small village. I tell people where the drinks are and to help themselves. So I'm not serving people all day. Its never been an issue Christmas is basically just a party and 99% of parties I don't know everyone there.

Edited

Perhaps it’s the difference between introverts and extroverts. The latter tending to enjoy meeting new people and the more the merrier. The former tending to prefer smaller and more known guests.

Hummingbird233 · 09/11/2026 10:20

I want to feel 100% comfortable at my Christmas table. I want to feel at ease and enjoy quality family time.

I don’t want to spend it hosting someone I barely know.

I think your sister is very fair to suggest the evening is absolutely fine but the daytime is a no. You were reasonable to ask and now need to respect her answer.

mamaof4losingmymind · 09/11/2026 10:20

We have a new person for Christmas most years as someone in the family as started a new relationship. The more the merrier its Christmas. We always have enough food to feed a small village. I tell people where the drinks are and to help themselves. So I'm not serving people all day. Its never been an issue Christmas is basically just a party and 99% of parties I don't know everyone there.

AnneLovesGilbert · 09/11/2026 10:19

Most people would respond better to being asked rather than told.

What are you going to do? Stay at home with your friend and have your family over later as planned or go to your sister’s and have your friend to yours later?

dontaskmeanythinginthemorning · 09/11/2026 10:19

AitkenDrum1970 · 09/11/2026 07:43

The whole point of Christmas is about being KIND! I could never leave someone (who didn’t want to be) on their own on Christmas Day whether I knew them or they were a friend of a friend. Over the years we’ve had all sorts of people with us for Christmas, they have added interest and often joy to the occasion.

Same. Not every year but we’ve had a few different people join us for Christmas dinner - one was a cousin, though not one I know well, but the others were friends/colleagues that we knew would otherwise be alone on Christmas Day and in most cases we’ve only found out they’d be alone on Christmas Eve, but we’ve still welcomed them in last minute. I love it but we’re otherwise a fairly small group of the same people we see daily/weekly anyway, so I find it makes it a bit more of an occasion somehow! I think it shows how insular we’ve all become, and how separated from our ‘neighbours’, that this is such a big deal to so many people.

Having said all that, you can’t invite someone round to someone else’s house, regardless of the event, without checking with them first. Even my husband checked with me first before inviting his colleague to join us, though he knew what the answer would be!

Datafan55 · 09/11/2026 10:18

Talkingtomyhouseplants · 09/11/2026 09:56

Oh stop it don’t be ridiculous. Yes some people don’t have a lot of money, of course that’s true. No that doesn’t mean they have itemised their shopping to make one portion for one meal - Christmas always comes with tons of leftovers and a turkey will feed 7 just as well as it will feed 6. You’re just looking for reasons why it’s not doable.

Those people scraping by will have quite literally have itemised their shopping to make one portion for one meal.

RitaFires · 09/11/2026 10:17

Some people have more the merrier Christmases where anyone can pop along and pull up an ottoman to a coffee table and some people have ones that are more about relaxing in the company of their close family. I think what's gone wrong here is as you all contribute you OP consider this to be a joint enterprise where all the family are equal stakeholders whereas your sister sees it as you inviting someone she doesn't know well to a meal at her house.

Itsthewoluff · 09/11/2026 10:16

It does change the dynamic. You shouldn’t have said anything before you asked your sister. Now it will be awkward for them to come in the evening, knowing they weren’t welcome at your sisters earlier. It would have been better to just invite them to yours for the evening do, then checked with sister about lunch and extended the invite if she was amenable.

I can see why dsis doesn’t want to change the dynamic for the main part of the day. You can’t relax properly, which in your own home is quite important.