Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Am I expecting too much of my mother?

93 replies

AIBunfair · 08/11/2026 16:37

I am pregnant, with a toddler, and newly single. I work FT. My ex is all shades of unreliable and hasn’t seen us for months. I don’t know when or if he will be involved in the future.

My mother is in her early 60s, single and works FT. She was an awful, selfish mother when I was a child, but we have got on well since I’ve been an adult. I have no siblings and no other family within 3hrs’ drive. She lives 2hrs’ drive away, and my elderly, though independent, grandparents live near her.

After my split she asked me to move closer, said she’d drop a day at work and help with nursery runs on another day. I was all set to move when she took a full-time job in the opposite direction and said she might be able to help in a few years’ time. I have decided not to move.

She’s said she’ll take a week off when I give birth, but not longer, as she wants to take ten days off at Christmas. I have invited her to stay at Christmas, and she said no because she’d rather be with my grandparents.

She’s offered to come up for weekends but frankly when she does, it’s just another person to feed and look after.

She’s said she will move nearer me in about ten years when my grandparents aren’t around, so “we can help each other out.” At that point, I won’t need childcare and she’ll be in her mid 70s and almost certainly in need of a lot of support due to her lifestyle and existing issues.

I am increasingly frustrated with her. AIBU?

OP posts:
5128gap · 08/11/2026 17:42

I'm sorry to read your update about your ex. As far as your mother's concerned, I think its a case of half a cake being better than none. She's offering you a week of support when you most need it, so don't cut your nose off to spite your face because you think the offer isn't enough. Same with visits. Another adult in the house, even if they're not the best, gives you a little breathing space, even if it's holding the baby for a while or reading to the toddler. Unfortunately with no other support options you're best to accept what there is rather than fall out and lose it all.

HisNibs · 08/11/2026 17:43

"She was an awful, selfish mother when I was a child, but we have got on well since I’ve been an adult"
Others have said but I'll say it again here... she will not have changed OP. As an adult though, your dependency on her dropped... a lot. She's early 60s, coming up to retirement, no friends, no other family once GPs are gone... she's lining you up to be her carer/support/dogsbody make no mistake. All take, no give, empty promises to make it worse. Drop the rope.

ThisMachineWillNotCommunicate · 08/11/2026 17:43

Why would you want somebody you describe as awful and selfish when you were a child to be providing childcare for your own children?

SirenScream · 08/11/2026 17:44

Regarding your ex @AIBunfair: I think that when we have parents who aren't up to much as parents we often (without realising) are drawn to partners who have similar behaviour patterns.
My understanding is that the unconscious mind steers us into situations in which we have an opportunity to understand the dynamics of our family of origin.
We all have blind spots, sometime it can take decades to properly see things, sometimes people remain in denial.

SirenScream · 08/11/2026 17:47

AIBunfair · 08/11/2026 17:30

I agree with everyone saying I should be relying on my ex. Unfortunately it’s not possible now as he’s in the depths of an alcohol-fuelled mental health breakdown, and social services and the police have recommended no contact. Until the summer, our relationship was good. I’m half-expecting a call to say he’s dead, to be honest.

I have an ex who drank himself to death. I'm your mum's age, looking back it may have been better for my children if he had died when they were very little.

WhatHappenedToYourFurnitureCuz · 08/11/2026 17:54

AIBunfair · 08/11/2026 16:51

I was planning to move closer precisely because she said she’d provide regular childcare - she absolutely doesn’t now.

Maybe it’s just me, but if my daughter was preparing to give birth alone, I’d want to be there to support her as long as I could. I wouldn’t be prioritising a ten day Christmas break of sitting at home instead.

Your question was whether you're expecting too much. If your question was whether she was unreasonable to promise something and then rescind it, I'd have responded to that instead.

How long would you consider acceptable for her to stay with you? Two weeks, three, four?

TheOwlShootAtNight · 08/11/2026 17:58

AIBunfair · 08/11/2026 17:30

I agree with everyone saying I should be relying on my ex. Unfortunately it’s not possible now as he’s in the depths of an alcohol-fuelled mental health breakdown, and social services and the police have recommended no contact. Until the summer, our relationship was good. I’m half-expecting a call to say he’s dead, to be honest.

Why have kids with an alcoholic? I really doubt he started drinking after you got pregnant with your second.

Whacker · 08/11/2026 17:59

Your mother is not responsible for your childcare, that said it would be great if she was supportive during this really difficult time. Be glad she told you before you moved that she won’t be available as originally discussed if your moved closer. Believe her that she won’t be there, outside of the full week she’s agreed to, and make alternative plans. A few months down the road I would be as clear with her as she was with you that in 10 years time you most likely will not be available to ‘help each other out’.

Allthevarious · 08/11/2026 18:06

If she can be cruel and selfish to her own daughter as a child, she can be cruel and selfish to her grandchild @AIBunfair

Cheeseplantalltheway · 08/11/2026 18:08

She has offered something and then withdrawn the offer. That's got to feel disappointing, OP.

Are you expecting too much of your mother? I think that some mothers have it in them to give the kind of support you'd like to have. But it sounds like your mother isn't one of them.

I'm sorry Flowers

notmoredirtywashing · 08/11/2026 18:08

@TheOwlShootAtNight
another nasty and unnecessary comment. What’s wrong with people on here?

AIBunfair · 08/11/2026 18:10

SirenScream · 08/11/2026 17:44

Regarding your ex @AIBunfair: I think that when we have parents who aren't up to much as parents we often (without realising) are drawn to partners who have similar behaviour patterns.
My understanding is that the unconscious mind steers us into situations in which we have an opportunity to understand the dynamics of our family of origin.
We all have blind spots, sometime it can take decades to properly see things, sometimes people remain in denial.

Yes, I agree.

My mother was a drug addict into my 20s and my ex’s parents died young partly because of their alcohol addictions. We always said we wanted to break the cycle.

At the beginning of last year, we were. Ex and I were social drinkers only. He had a stressful period from May (I got pregnant then he lost a job, started another and didn’t like it, and his mum died, and he started drinking heavily in secret) and it all fell apart.

I still hope to hold life together for our children. It’s a thoroughly shit situation but they deserve a stable parent at least.

OP posts:
AIBunfair · 08/11/2026 18:12

Allthevarious · 08/11/2026 18:06

If she can be cruel and selfish to her own daughter as a child, she can be cruel and selfish to her grandchild @AIBunfair

She’s been sober for over a decade, I wouldn’t have her around my child otherwise.

OP posts:
CalledIt · 08/11/2026 18:13

AIBunfair · 08/11/2026 17:01

I think what I’m struggling with is that she relies a lot on me for emotional support. She has no friends and no hobbies. Every year she wants to holiday with me, for me to organise a birthday celebration for her, to invite her to anything I’m doing - yet now, when I need support, little is forthcoming.

But no one has you at gunpoint to be her support worker. Take a step back. There’s absolutely no point in expending far too much emotional energy on someone and then expecting her to changer her life significantly to support you as a single parent. Reserve your resources for yourself.

Havingaswimmoose · 08/11/2026 18:14

Is the mother abandoning her own parents if she moves near OP?
Mother may be free to move only when her own parents die. Hence the ten year suggestion.

Or is the mother neglecting her own daughter who is now in great need of a safety net?

An easy solution would seem to be OP moves. Family living closer is purely easier logistically.
In theory everyone could help each other in various life stages.

In theory.
Sounds a bit too emotionally charged to ever work.

BetterWithPockets · 08/11/2026 18:18

Just wanted to say that you sound like an amazing mum, @AIBunfair(it was your comment about how you’re trying to hold it all together for your kids even though your ex has gone off the rails and your DM is never there for you that made me think that).

DuckbilledSplatterPuff · 08/11/2026 18:33

BetterWithPockets · 08/11/2026 18:18

Just wanted to say that you sound like an amazing mum, @AIBunfair(it was your comment about how you’re trying to hold it all together for your kids even though your ex has gone off the rails and your DM is never there for you that made me think that).

i agree with @BetterWithPockets .
I don't think you can rely her. BUT,
You've still got time to organise a bit of help for yourself aorund the birth and early months. so you are not left in the lurch.
Get a cleaner even if temp.
Gardener or local neighbour or teen
Ask your Health visitor/GP for local suggestions. etc. there might be some home help organisations.
Your toddler will soon be able to go to nursery, or may not be that far off school.. so it's not forever.

We had no one around when i went into sudden labour with one of mine.. Our neighbour unexpectedly and kindly offered to have the other ones for the evening/night. Let your neighbours know.

Housework is not that important when you are dealing with two at once and everything feels better (esp with toddlers) in the open air. (something an aunt told me once, and she was right)
It doesn't have to be perfect, you just have to get through it. and things will settle down.

You said you organise holidays and birthdays etc etc... how often is any of this reciprocated. Match the energy as they say on MN
You will get through this... and then things will be more straightforward. Wishing you the very best @AIBunfair

diddl · 08/11/2026 18:38

If you moved closer is it likely that she'd be any help at all?

Pop in after work & be good company, help with bath time, bedtime for example, be there in an emergency?

LostittoBostik · 08/11/2026 18:41

bingoringos · 08/11/2026 16:43

@AIBunfair you said she was an awful selfish mother, she won’t have changed it’s just you stopped needing her.

This nails it I think OP.

Allthevarious · 08/11/2026 18:46

AIBunfair · 08/11/2026 18:12

She’s been sober for over a decade, I wouldn’t have her around my child otherwise.

But she was cruel and selfish to a child. You.

You know what she’s capable of

OMGitsnotgood · 08/11/2026 18:53

You are absolutley being unreasonable. I can appreciate that your life is tough and having your Mum around to help more would make your life easier - but then you’d have to feed her which seems too much of an ask for you. You are young and unless you’ve missed out details fit, whereas your grandparents aren’t likely to be as fit as you.
Your Mum works, looks after her parents and is expected to help you (as long as she doesn’t need feeding). I don’t know what you expect her to do.

outerspacepotato · 08/11/2026 19:01

You made the right choice not to move. She talks a good game, but no follow through when it comes to you. From what you say, she's never been a helpful or supportive mom and it's unlikely she'll be a support now or in the future. I suspect she would like you nearby so you and your kids could do for her as she ages. She's already using you for support but it doesn't run both ways with her. I would let her know that won't be happening and it's time to drop the rope with her. You have a family to raise on your own. That's where you energy needs to go.

That said, she's working full time in her 60s. She's not going to be providing childcare for you while still working and she is maybe also doing some tasks for her parents. That's a full load. She may say so but it's not happening.

I hope you have some local friends for support.

Chilly80 · 08/11/2026 19:09

As a child you were a burden to her.
As an adult you can be of use to her.
That's not love.

Luckyingame · 08/11/2026 19:54

bingoringos · 08/11/2026 16:41

Don’t move near her & do not let her move near you when she is older.

Edited

Good point.
I have a similar "mother" and moved to another country.
25 years on, works well. 😜

BetweenTheThoughts · 08/11/2026 20:02

You are not being unreasonable; it is understandable to feel disappointed when promised support repeatedly turns into uncertainty. Your priority now should be building a stable environment for yourself and your children, rather than making life decisions around promises that may never materialise.