Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Am I expecting too much of my mother?

93 replies

AIBunfair · 08/11/2026 16:37

I am pregnant, with a toddler, and newly single. I work FT. My ex is all shades of unreliable and hasn’t seen us for months. I don’t know when or if he will be involved in the future.

My mother is in her early 60s, single and works FT. She was an awful, selfish mother when I was a child, but we have got on well since I’ve been an adult. I have no siblings and no other family within 3hrs’ drive. She lives 2hrs’ drive away, and my elderly, though independent, grandparents live near her.

After my split she asked me to move closer, said she’d drop a day at work and help with nursery runs on another day. I was all set to move when she took a full-time job in the opposite direction and said she might be able to help in a few years’ time. I have decided not to move.

She’s said she’ll take a week off when I give birth, but not longer, as she wants to take ten days off at Christmas. I have invited her to stay at Christmas, and she said no because she’d rather be with my grandparents.

She’s offered to come up for weekends but frankly when she does, it’s just another person to feed and look after.

She’s said she will move nearer me in about ten years when my grandparents aren’t around, so “we can help each other out.” At that point, I won’t need childcare and she’ll be in her mid 70s and almost certainly in need of a lot of support due to her lifestyle and existing issues.

I am increasingly frustrated with her. AIBU?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Bitsostuff · 09/11/2026 09:27

@pandarific fair point well made.

pandarific · 09/11/2026 09:24

@Bitsostuff to be fair, it is very very difficult to be so clear minded about it when it is YOUR mum. Also, when the charm turns on and the love starts flowing it makes you a) temporarily forget and b) assume that you’re a terrible person for criticising your poor mother - that’s what the abuse does. Headfuck, thy name is mother.

Bitsostuff · 09/11/2026 09:19

AIBunfair · 08/11/2026 17:01

I think what I’m struggling with is that she relies a lot on me for emotional support. She has no friends and no hobbies. Every year she wants to holiday with me, for me to organise a birthday celebration for her, to invite her to anything I’m doing - yet now, when I need support, little is forthcoming.

And this is the person you think should be willing and able to help you with childcare? The mind boggles.

Forget what you want from a mother, or what you think a mother should be, or the sacrifices you think you'd be willing to make in her place (tbh talk is cheap). Look at the person she is. Then adjust your expectations accordingly.

pandarific · 09/11/2026 09:12

@AIBunfair I am also a childhood trauma survivor and wanted to share the single most useful thing I have found in the last five years:
https://www.patrickteahan.com
this chap is a psychotherapist of many years, also a childhood trauma survivor and is on YouTube and has excellent, deep content free, as well as really specialised advice and a specialist childhood abuse / trauma framework which is SO important. It’s not therapy of course, but is intended to be used as an adjunct or support to therapy or for those working on their issues due to childhood abuse/trauma.

I’m assuming you’re not rolling in it right now to afford private private therapy and personally the NHS provided CBT was utterly unsuitable for me, but he’s got great, targeted advice, and you CAN if you wish join a community he has - I haven’t yet, but I’m eyeing it up.

all the best to you and all good wishes for you and your babies - my advice is to self refer to social services and ask for whatever help they can give you given you are the only reliable adult in your children’s lives and that you are about to have another baby, and focus on finding a solid “mother’s help” (various kinds available) who can be another pair of hands.

Patrick Teahan | Childhood Trauma Recovery Resources

Free resources, courses, assessments, and a healing membership for adults recovering from childhood trauma and dysfunctional family systems.

https://www.patrickteahan.com

Beamur · 09/11/2026 08:38

She's not going to change. Drinking or not.
Sorry you don't have her support. Sounds like she sort of says the right things, but doesn't actually do them.

LancsMa · 09/11/2026 08:19

I'm sorry you've been let down so badly and so often OP. I think it's best if you recognise that your mother is simply not the person you wish she was. Lower your expectations and don't rely on her - for whatever reason, she just can't or won't be there for you in the way you want. If (big if!) she does move closer to you in ten years, given her age, you can bet it won't be so that SHE can give YOU more support! Much more likely the other way around.

Vallmo47 · 09/11/2026 07:42

I’m sorry OP but she’s the same person she always was. She doesn’t owe you childcare and I wouldn’t accept it based on your childhood experiences - you don’t want your children to have the same bad memories of her. Parenting alone must be incredibly daunting and exceptionally hard work, but you can hold your head high that you’ve always done right by your children and given them the childhood you did not have.
In terms of what she asks of you still, I would distance myself and not be as available. Keep it civil if you so wish, but stop catering to her needs. Her plan to move closer in future is because she knows her parents won’t be around forever and you’re the next best option to look after her when she’s elderly.
I have a family member like this so understand how much it hurts but I’m proud to say I’ve done the above and I feel better for it.

CountrySmiling · 09/11/2026 07:27

AIBunfair · 08/11/2026 17:01

I think what I’m struggling with is that she relies a lot on me for emotional support. She has no friends and no hobbies. Every year she wants to holiday with me, for me to organise a birthday celebration for her, to invite her to anything I’m doing - yet now, when I need support, little is forthcoming.

Stop doing it. Don’t move near her and don’t agree to be her carer.
if she goes on about helping each other in 10 years time, state the age you will be then and what you hope to be doing with your life and that doesn’t include her.
You need to start protecting yourself emotionally and not be used.

Autumnalhibernationisthedream · 09/11/2026 07:21

Op she’s offered to come at weekends which is fair as she’s far away and working ft and you’ve said actually no so I don’t understand how you can say if my daughter was giving birth I’d move heaven and earth, you’re literally saying you don’t want her there while saying she should be there!!!!!!!!!!

And you saying she was selfish when you were a child, was she? Or did you see it that way? As mums we are called selfish when we choose ourselves at all even though we do a million things for our kids. I know it’s tough but I think you’re being crazy unreasonable unless there’s countless job opportunities for her near you

Greenmouldycheese · 09/11/2026 07:11

She has no intention of ever helping you. She's thinking of moving closer in her 7ps so can care for her. Yanbu.

Iocanepowder · 09/11/2026 06:56

Sorry for your situation op.

It’s good at least that she intends to help you for a week during the birth.

If you take away all the stuff from the past, anyone is allowed to reflect and revisit a big decision to give up a day off work, so while it’s annoying, I would say let it go.

I agree maybe contact a HV and also maybe get referred to HomeStart.

SuddenDaredJelly · 09/11/2026 06:45

She was an awful, selfish mother when I was a child, but we have got on well since I’ve been an adult.

You got on well when you were a childless adult who didnt need her support, and im guessing your lifestyle meant you suited her as a companion for shopping trips, holidays etc

She's selfish and likely always will be.

Sleepster · 09/11/2026 06:26

AIBunfair · 08/11/2026 18:12

She’s been sober for over a decade, I wouldn’t have her around my child otherwise.

You are someone who was abused as a child by your own mother. In this particular area, I don’t think I would trust your own judgement on your abuser. Please don’t leave your child with her alone.

ThisMauveTurtle · 09/11/2026 01:57

She obviously doesn't like looking after people so just leave her to it.
If she wasn't a good mother I wouldn't expect her to care very much for grandchildren

nomas · 09/11/2026 00:21

seahorsessky · 08/11/2026 23:15

In ten years you will still need childcare, probably not as much unless your child has additional needs, but she's not wrong to say she could help a bit (most ten year olds would only need her to be in the house, not doing a lot, but it would mean you could work/go out or whatever). Whether you think she will help, given what you've put, is a different matter, but you will still need some help then.

There is no way this flakey woman is going to help OP. She just wants OP there so she can use her for socialising.

seahorsessky · 08/11/2026 23:15

In ten years you will still need childcare, probably not as much unless your child has additional needs, but she's not wrong to say she could help a bit (most ten year olds would only need her to be in the house, not doing a lot, but it would mean you could work/go out or whatever). Whether you think she will help, given what you've put, is a different matter, but you will still need some help then.

AcrossthePond55 · 08/11/2026 23:06

CalledIt · 08/11/2026 18:13

But no one has you at gunpoint to be her support worker. Take a step back. There’s absolutely no point in expending far too much emotional energy on someone and then expecting her to changer her life significantly to support you as a single parent. Reserve your resources for yourself.

@AIBunfair

What @CalledIt says. Right now you need your emotional strength for YOU. You have none extra for your mum. And there's nothing wrong with that AND nothing wrong with telling her so.

Your tale of your ex and his drinking struck a chord with me. Our situations are very different (I'm old, retired, and children grown) but my DH of 38 years' drinking spun out of control in a period of 5 months after a serious injury. I was supportive, then bewildered, then sad, and finally angry. I left and have been on my own for over a year now. I have carved myself a new life and I am happy.

I want you to know that you will cope. And you will be happy. But you must as @CalledIt says "Reserve your resources for yourself". There is nothing selfish in putting yourself first. In doing so you are putting your children first.

I had outside support, yes. I was very lucky in that. But to truly heal I had to turn inward. What did I want? What did I need? And above all, what could I do for myself to get the things I wanted and needed. And I found a strength I didn't know I had. Yours is there too.

Dontevenlookatme · 08/11/2026 20:53

I’m so sorry to read your updates OP. I think you would be better finding a network of support that doesn’t include either your mother or your ex - easier said than done, I know.

It’s a while since I had babies, do you have a health visitor you could talk to about your situation who could point you in the direction of actual help, rather than vague promises?

BetweenTheThoughts · 08/11/2026 20:02

You are not being unreasonable; it is understandable to feel disappointed when promised support repeatedly turns into uncertainty. Your priority now should be building a stable environment for yourself and your children, rather than making life decisions around promises that may never materialise.

Luckyingame · 08/11/2026 19:54

bingoringos · 08/11/2026 16:41

Don’t move near her & do not let her move near you when she is older.

Edited

Good point.
I have a similar "mother" and moved to another country.
25 years on, works well. 😜

Chilly80 · 08/11/2026 19:09

As a child you were a burden to her.
As an adult you can be of use to her.
That's not love.

outerspacepotato · 08/11/2026 19:01

You made the right choice not to move. She talks a good game, but no follow through when it comes to you. From what you say, she's never been a helpful or supportive mom and it's unlikely she'll be a support now or in the future. I suspect she would like you nearby so you and your kids could do for her as she ages. She's already using you for support but it doesn't run both ways with her. I would let her know that won't be happening and it's time to drop the rope with her. You have a family to raise on your own. That's where you energy needs to go.

That said, she's working full time in her 60s. She's not going to be providing childcare for you while still working and she is maybe also doing some tasks for her parents. That's a full load. She may say so but it's not happening.

I hope you have some local friends for support.

OMGitsnotgood · 08/11/2026 18:53

You are absolutley being unreasonable. I can appreciate that your life is tough and having your Mum around to help more would make your life easier - but then you’d have to feed her which seems too much of an ask for you. You are young and unless you’ve missed out details fit, whereas your grandparents aren’t likely to be as fit as you.
Your Mum works, looks after her parents and is expected to help you (as long as she doesn’t need feeding). I don’t know what you expect her to do.

Allthevarious · 08/11/2026 18:46

AIBunfair · 08/11/2026 18:12

She’s been sober for over a decade, I wouldn’t have her around my child otherwise.

But she was cruel and selfish to a child. You.

You know what she’s capable of

LostittoBostik · 08/11/2026 18:41

bingoringos · 08/11/2026 16:43

@AIBunfair you said she was an awful selfish mother, she won’t have changed it’s just you stopped needing her.

This nails it I think OP.