Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Anybody else fuming about Russell Brand and rape myths.

46 replies

ToastAndCoffee8 · 08/11/2026 15:53

I’m furious, so so furious.
My rapist stood trial 2 years ago and was found not guilty. The rape myths chucked at Russell Brands victims by his defense were also used on me. What I was wearing, that I gave in and didn’t attempt to run, didn’t scream loud enough, went back to work and behaved‘normally’ 2 days later etc etc.
There’s all of this talk now of this sort of defense not being allowed in a court room anymore and juries being educated on fight and flight response which is brilliant, it really is, but what about the rest of us??
Am I being selfish, does anyone feel the Same, where’s our justice or apology, is there anything that can be done?
Just to be clear, I’m over the moon that some of the women in this trial got justice and fuck Russell Brand, throw away the key in my opinion but I can’t help but feel a bit disappointed for myself.

OP posts:
Wildfairy · 08/11/2026 15:55

“Am I being selfish, does anyone feel the Same, where’s our justice or apology, is there anything that can be done”

gently who do you wish an apology from,? Do you mean an apology for the defence behaviour? At this point in time, as unpalatable as it is it’s a legal form of defence to attempt to discredit the accuser,

Brand has been found guilty, so he will go to jail. Did Your rapist not ?

ToastAndCoffee8 · 08/11/2026 15:57

Wildfairy · 08/11/2026 15:55

“Am I being selfish, does anyone feel the Same, where’s our justice or apology, is there anything that can be done”

gently who do you wish an apology from,? Do you mean an apology for the defence behaviour? At this point in time, as unpalatable as it is it’s a legal form of defence to attempt to discredit the accuser,

Brand has been found guilty, so he will go to jail. Did Your rapist not ?

No he was found not guilty.

OP posts:
Sirzy · 08/11/2026 15:59

I can see where you are coming from because of your experinces. Have you received proper support to help you deal with everything?

BUT can you try to reframe it in your mind as this change of narrative may help stop others going through what you did in terms of victim blaming?

gibletsarerank · 08/11/2026 16:06

This type of defence has been criticised for years & yet it still happens. I often say on the threads where people are discussing women fashions that it’s not true a woman can wear what she likes without judgement because of the fact it can be used against her. I always get lambasted for it but acknowledging it exists doesn’t mean you agree with it.
Im sorry you didn’t get justice.

Ksjwks · 08/11/2026 16:07

I was dismayed and angry that RB defence was allowed by the judge to press with questions about whether the women had tried to fight back or leave.
Totally not acceptable in this day and age, when trauma responses of freeze, flop and appease are well recognised legitimate responses to being in a frightening situation, particularly when the perpetrator is bigger than you (as in male, victim female) or in a position of power.
The judge should have shut down that line of questioning immediately.
This needs urgent addressing

ExtraOnions · 08/11/2026 16:09

Some of the langague used by Ian Winter was archaic, offensive, damaging, and in no way truthful.

That someone so educated could get up in court, and repeat such myths, is a disgrace.

He had rightly been called out by victim advocacy groups, and has reported himself to the standards committee.

PanteraRosa · 08/11/2026 16:14

I agree, and I wonder whether this gets addressed during a trial, for example, are they able to have an expert for the prosecution explaining why women might take time to report a rape, or in one of the instances in this trial they were questioning a woman about why she would get into a car with him afterwards.

To me, it’s completely understandable why women do all of these things, but apart from being incredibly traumatic for the victims being questioned in this way, I always wonder whether the jury will understand without explanation. You only have to look at threads on here to see how many people do not…

Also, in this trial, there was the scenario where he was texting them afterwards. This sounds quite common to me, again. I’ve quite often seen even here where people talk about their rapist texting, apparently normally afterwards. I wonder if they try to explain this to the jury.

The thing that always gets me, is the one about why victims take so long to report, often being asked by the defence, who are treating the victim appallingly. They literally are a large part of the reason why women don’t report for a long time.

seahorsessky · 08/11/2026 16:15

We have a nasty culture of victim blaming, whether the crime is serious or minor. In cases of people saying someone stole their car/identity theft, it's disgusting how many people question or blame the victim-you should have been more careful about your password, did you lock up properly? The victim blaming is often for more minor crimes, but you still hear people questioning what people are wearing, as if that makes you responsible for someone's actions.

PanteraRosa · 08/11/2026 16:16

ExtraOnions · 08/11/2026 16:09

Some of the langague used by Ian Winter was archaic, offensive, damaging, and in no way truthful.

That someone so educated could get up in court, and repeat such myths, is a disgrace.

He had rightly been called out by victim advocacy groups, and has reported himself to the standards committee.

I may be wrong, but I think the reason he reported himself to the standards committee was because of the conversation with the journalist afterward?

gibletsarerank · 08/11/2026 16:16

yes I thought it was for the journalist row

ExtraOnions · 08/11/2026 16:17

PanteraRosa · 08/11/2026 16:16

I may be wrong, but I think the reason he reported himself to the standards committee was because of the conversation with the journalist afterward?

I think you are right, and I hope they look at the entirety of his behaviour. His misogyny (including verbally attacking the female journalist) was palpable.

DecafCoffeeIsPointless · 08/11/2026 16:19

I'm so this happened to you OP.

Let's hope change is afoot for future women strong enough to report SA and rape

5128gap · 08/11/2026 16:20

I'm sorry OP, but I don't think there's anything that can be done for women who have suffered historically.
The PM has spoken but there has been no change in law or regulation of defence barristers conduct as yet, and if there were it wouldn't be retrospective.
I'm sorry that you had this experience and it must feel so upsetting to have this wrong acknowledged too late for you to have recieved the justice you deserved.

Sartre · 08/11/2026 16:22

It’s understandable why RB’s barrister went down this route. He was a well known womaniser, he never hid from this and plenty of people have corroborated the fact many women did indeed queue up to sleep with him. He didn’t assault or rape all of the women in other words so the barrister used this to try and claim these women had also been among the many who practically threw themselves at him.

Barristers are there to sell a story basically, even if they know they’re lying. In this case, RB still maintains he was innocent so the barrister has to take him at his word, it’s his job. He was obviously hugely unprofessional following the verdict and I believe has reported himself to the regulator.

Wildfairy · 08/11/2026 17:09

The thing is it’s the defenses job to get the accused off, and they will attempt to do so by discrediting the accuser and casting as much doubt as possible in their story,
it’s very difficult to not do this and win, their sole job is to make the accuser look like a liar. Their job is not t9 ensure justice is served, that’s rhe judges and rhe juries, their job is to get their Client found not guilty

they’d not use the tactics they use if they didn’t work, so the answer here is to teach people so the jury understand, then they will stop.

Ksjwks · 08/11/2026 17:15

Wildfairy · 08/11/2026 17:09

The thing is it’s the defenses job to get the accused off, and they will attempt to do so by discrediting the accuser and casting as much doubt as possible in their story,
it’s very difficult to not do this and win, their sole job is to make the accuser look like a liar. Their job is not t9 ensure justice is served, that’s rhe judges and rhe juries, their job is to get their Client found not guilty

they’d not use the tactics they use if they didn’t work, so the answer here is to teach people so the jury understand, then they will stop.

Edited

I understand that, but there have to be limits on what is an acceptable line of questioning if it perpetrates misinformation and mistruths and is highly damaging to those being questioned.

Matrons · 08/11/2026 17:18

Rape report and conviction rates are appallingly low. The whole evidential basis for convictions should be reconsidered.

It's awful how hard it is for victims to secure justice

JapanesePotWeed · 08/11/2026 17:22

Understanding very well what it would be like in the court, is the reason I didn't try to get my rapist prosecuted.
A relative called the police against my wishes, after they saw bite marks and bruises on me. The police attended but I didn't give a report or name him, instead we settled with them logging an incident on that date - it would help me in case I changed my mind in the future.
My rapist was my then boyfriend - very wealthy, from an influential local family. He raped me in a deluded jealous rage, then started to cover his tracks straight away - by texting lies to his friends. The officers actually agreed that it would be traumatic to try and bring a case against him - he would get the best lawyers money can buy. I would be portrayed as a gold-digger who likes it rough and it would be down to me and my previous sexual partners to try and prove otherwise.

When he attacked me, I was asleep in a different bedroom to get away from his questioning and arguing. I had already very clearly turned down his advances. I woke up to him trying to tie my hands together with neck ties, then he pressed his whole body on me and just started to bite me... This was so out of character, that I was scared he was intent to torture and kill me. I didn't scream and I didn't fight. I let him assault me, whilst I was trying to push the ties behind the bed, so he can't find one to strangle me with... Once he was done, he got up and went to pack my bags for me, took his key off my key ring and called me a cab.
Money protects many monsters like these.

Wildfairy · 08/11/2026 17:24

Ksjwks · 08/11/2026 17:15

I understand that, but there have to be limits on what is an acceptable line of questioning if it perpetrates misinformation and mistruths and is highly damaging to those being questioned.

You’d think so wouldn’t you, but that’s a complex road to go down, and of course false accusations happen,

JLou08 · 08/11/2026 17:25

YANBU. It's a horrible, degrading, re-traumatising event having to go through the criminal process as a rape victim. How barristers could pursue such awful lines of questioning is beyond me. We all know about consent and the freeze response. Barristers are intelligent, they know, they're just going for the win.

Rainingasusual · 08/11/2026 17:45

YANBU
Mr Winter's defence was disgusting. It perpetuates and legitimises these awful rape myths and victim blaming. So many feel justified regurgitating this utter bullshit.

These attitudes are why so many women have never got justice nor even sought it.

Sending solidarity.

ToastAndCoffee8 · 08/11/2026 17:49

I don’t think I’m explaining myself very well and I probably need to stay away from social media for a bit because it’s triggering the hell out of me.
I read last week that there were points in the Brand trial that the judge (rightly so) stopped the defense and told him to stop with some of his tactics.
In my trial I was put on a stand and the first question was.. what were you wearing that night? I argued and argued and tried really hard to stand up for myself.
The defense literally turned to the jury and said.. As you can see we have a fiesty woman here who is coming across to me as a woman who can clearly stand up for herself. She didn’t on the night in question because she didn’t need to, this man has done nothing wrong.
No judge banging his hammer and telling her to stop, I had over 2 hours of this shit thrown at me.
This was only 2 years ago, it needs to change and it’s disgusting that it’s happened in the first place.
Maybe i was naive but it shocked me and I wasn’t prepared for it.

OP posts:
MrsBennetsPoorNervesAreBack · 08/11/2026 17:51

I'm so sorry about what happened to you, OP.

Sadly, I don't think it will be possible to right past wrongs, but let's hope that they can stop these dreadful arguments being used in future trials.

ConfusedNoMore · 08/11/2026 18:04

Misogyny in the courts is horrendous. I have had my experience of it in family court.

I am sorry this happened to you and your feelings are completely valid.

There's a huge societal issue here. Courts and attitudes in general even in 2026. I've had experiences which legally were rape but I have never really acknowledged because sometimes it's easier to frame it differently to cope in this world. Certainly not situations where I would have reported it or had it taken seriously.

Shappi Korsandi spoke to a reporter this week and I found what she said so familiar and yet so horrendous. It is just normal for so many women my age who lived through those times.

My own mother was victim blaming yesterday and I felt absolutely furious. It brought up so many feelings I've had to bury. I just feel like the world relies on women shutting up and taking it. It's horrific.

Sorry my post is a bit muddled but I feel quite mixed up with how I feel this week.

TheFriendlyPotato · 08/11/2026 18:21

ExtraOnions · 08/11/2026 16:09

Some of the langague used by Ian Winter was archaic, offensive, damaging, and in no way truthful.

That someone so educated could get up in court, and repeat such myths, is a disgrace.

He had rightly been called out by victim advocacy groups, and has reported himself to the standards committee.

I dont think its about education. He knew what he was doing. Its what the defense is meant to do, discredit the prosecution.

TRIGGER WARNING (SEXUAL ASSAULT)... I was assaulted 20 years ago. Not full rape but it was bad enough. I was confused, shocked, incredibly pressured and still think about it now. Would I report it? No. Why? Because I simply couldnt stand being questioned about why I was there, why I stayed afterward, why I didnt report at the time etc. Why? Because I still ask myself those questions. Being 17 years old in a hotel room w a older guy, I felt unable to leave. What if I was kicked out onto the street? Would worse happen? So many factors.

Now is it nice, kind, fair, ethical? Not really. But I would expect to have my account scrutinised in minute detail, because someone may be locked away for years as a result of my reporting. Nothing about that is fair to me, and at the same time if I were accused of a horrific crime I would want to defend myself robustly.

It is a fundamental way in which our courts work. Asking questions of the prosecution is one of only a few lines of defense for some people. You cant prove a negative. You cant prove you havent sexually assaulted someone if you were in a room with them alone. So the only defense is discrediting the narrative of the prosecution.

Asking questions is a legitimate form of defense. It isnt the job of the defense to provide safe spaces for victims, it is to get their clients off charges. Its sad, unethical (when the accused is guilty) and causes devastation for victims. I simply dont want or need to get retraumatised by a process that is meant to bring closure.

I am unsure how we can change the process to be kinder to victims without neutering defense teams.

I am incredibly glad that jurors will now be educated on established trauma responses. As someone who has supported hundreds of traumatised people over decades, it cant come soon enough. I have been told countless times how the trial process was traumatic in itself (a few people said more traumatising!)

The fact is far too many men get off charges despite having committed these horrific crimes. Its something ludicrous like 3% get a conviction. How do we make sure dangerous men are jailed while also maintaining the high burden of proof? Is watering down that standard sensible or dangerous double standard?

I have done years of work on this. I eventually realised that I needed to update my narrative about it through therapy. I am not a victim, or a survivor. It is something that happened to me that was awful and hideous and it is not happening now. I can acknowledge it happened without anger, bitterness, and shame. I can honestly say I believe he doesnt even think he did it. My internal experience was so far removed from his experience of it that if I did report it he would genuinely feel shocked. Why? Because I couldnt speak out at the time. At all.

Sorry if thats TMI and mods are free to gently remove if it is. No offense or triggering intended. I CAN see both my own, his, and societies perspectives on my situation. Some may find this unusual. I DONT defend him in my mind or aloud. But I do see his and other's views on it.

Anyway thanks for reading and please be gentle!