I dont think its about education. He knew what he was doing. Its what the defense is meant to do, discredit the prosecution.
TRIGGER WARNING (SEXUAL ASSAULT)... I was assaulted 20 years ago. Not full rape but it was bad enough. I was confused, shocked, incredibly pressured and still think about it now. Would I report it? No. Why? Because I simply couldnt stand being questioned about why I was there, why I stayed afterward, why I didnt report at the time etc. Why? Because I still ask myself those questions. Being 17 years old in a hotel room w a older guy, I felt unable to leave. What if I was kicked out onto the street? Would worse happen? So many factors.
Now is it nice, kind, fair, ethical? Not really. But I would expect to have my account scrutinised in minute detail, because someone may be locked away for years as a result of my reporting. Nothing about that is fair to me, and at the same time if I were accused of a horrific crime I would want to defend myself robustly.
It is a fundamental way in which our courts work. Asking questions of the prosecution is one of only a few lines of defense for some people. You cant prove a negative. You cant prove you havent sexually assaulted someone if you were in a room with them alone. So the only defense is discrediting the narrative of the prosecution.
Asking questions is a legitimate form of defense. It isnt the job of the defense to provide safe spaces for victims, it is to get their clients off charges. Its sad, unethical (when the accused is guilty) and causes devastation for victims. I simply dont want or need to get retraumatised by a process that is meant to bring closure.
I am unsure how we can change the process to be kinder to victims without neutering defense teams.
I am incredibly glad that jurors will now be educated on established trauma responses. As someone who has supported hundreds of traumatised people over decades, it cant come soon enough. I have been told countless times how the trial process was traumatic in itself (a few people said more traumatising!)
The fact is far too many men get off charges despite having committed these horrific crimes. Its something ludicrous like 3% get a conviction. How do we make sure dangerous men are jailed while also maintaining the high burden of proof? Is watering down that standard sensible or dangerous double standard?
I have done years of work on this. I eventually realised that I needed to update my narrative about it through therapy. I am not a victim, or a survivor. It is something that happened to me that was awful and hideous and it is not happening now. I can acknowledge it happened without anger, bitterness, and shame. I can honestly say I believe he doesnt even think he did it. My internal experience was so far removed from his experience of it that if I did report it he would genuinely feel shocked. Why? Because I couldnt speak out at the time. At all.
Sorry if thats TMI and mods are free to gently remove if it is. No offense or triggering intended. I CAN see both my own, his, and societies perspectives on my situation. Some may find this unusual. I DONT defend him in my mind or aloud. But I do see his and other's views on it.
Anyway thanks for reading and please be gentle!