Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Anybody else fuming about Russell Brand and rape myths.

46 replies

ToastAndCoffee8 · 08/11/2026 15:53

I’m furious, so so furious.
My rapist stood trial 2 years ago and was found not guilty. The rape myths chucked at Russell Brands victims by his defense were also used on me. What I was wearing, that I gave in and didn’t attempt to run, didn’t scream loud enough, went back to work and behaved‘normally’ 2 days later etc etc.
There’s all of this talk now of this sort of defense not being allowed in a court room anymore and juries being educated on fight and flight response which is brilliant, it really is, but what about the rest of us??
Am I being selfish, does anyone feel the Same, where’s our justice or apology, is there anything that can be done?
Just to be clear, I’m over the moon that some of the women in this trial got justice and fuck Russell Brand, throw away the key in my opinion but I can’t help but feel a bit disappointed for myself.

OP posts:
mamaof4losingmymind · 08/11/2026 18:25

Im in a similar situation to you accept my rapist did go to jail. I have chose to read as little as possible about this whole thing as I know it would just make me angry and its not worth it. Trials are horrific and I hope I never have to enter another court room in my life. My advice is to ignore the whole thing it will pass and something else will be all over the news in a few weeks

TheFriendlyPotato · 08/11/2026 18:31

@ToastAndCoffee8 to answer your question re AIBU...

Its hard to say. No of course not re the actual experiences you had and the impact on your life.

And... being angry isnt going to change this for you. I found the way out was therapy. It helped me realise that my hating him blaming myself and him, resisting the fact it happened was causing my misery. I was furious at this to start with, then realised my demands of a different past was driving my suffering. The pain of the events was bad enough.

I now approach everything in life with the knowledge that it is like this, in this moment.

I hope you feel better.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 08/11/2026 18:44

I totally know where you are coming from and similar reasons to what you describe as the rape myths in your trial is why I didn’t report mine at the time (which was quite similar circumstances to the one Brand was convicted for so this has brought up a lot of stuff for me). Flowers

MobyDick · 08/11/2026 22:37

Yes I am furious too. You completely have a right to be furious that sounds awful. Too many women are raped and sexually assaulted and our whole culture is geared towards blaming women and not holding men accountable, to preserve the patriarchy. I think we all need to be very very furious. We have to keep standing up and change this culture. Too many women are being traumatised. I'm so sorry this happened to you

Raiderofthelostbattenburg · 08/11/2026 22:43

I am so sorry you went through this OP, and am not surprised you have found this incredibly triggering. I don’t know what can be done to right past wrongs, but I do hope this horrifying case does bring about a change in the victim blaming culture.

Take care of yourself, OP. I hope you have good support around you.

Keepingittogetherstepbystep · 08/11/2026 23:05

I was on the jury of a sexual assault case and it was totally baffling how some of rhe jurors didn't know about the freeze response.

Victim was 17 and the defence was awful to her.

Having been on the inside it was horrible to see the was the deliberations work. Men attempting to bully females so they could get back to work.

Best thing you can do for your own sanity is not read things that might be triggering

MobyDick · 08/11/2026 23:18

I think a lot of women are being triggered right now because so many of us have been sexually assaulted, raped, demeaned and humiliated for so many years. Maybe we need to harness our trauma, join together, and really stand up against the culture of blaming women. The trial is just the tip of the iceberg. Is anyone else wondering why we laughed when brand told jokes about demeaning women? What was going on? How horrible that we knew we had to laugh, we knew we had to act like this was ok. We knew back then that it was dangerous to challenge this. Is anyone else who was around during the brand era feeling cognitive dissonance, sick to your stomach?

MyRubyPanda · 09/11/2026 12:39

His defence barrister makes my blood boil. Men like him are why only around 3% of rapes even get to court. Men like him enable rapists. Men like him are rape culture. If I was his wife I'd be seeking a divorce.

And I'm so very pissed off by Brand being described as a former 'national treasure'. No he wasn't, he was a beady-eyed bully. That much has always been obvious. The revelations that he has likely raped at least double digits of women is the least surprising fact about this case. I'm astounded that he actually faced justice.

bythebanksof · 09/11/2026 13:11

In the UK judges do regularly caution juries against relying on cultural stereotypes or misconceptions, what you refer to as "rape myths", including things such as expecting a victim to physically fight back, scream, display immediate outward distress, or report an incident straight away. That is typically the case today I feel, but was certainly not in the past, so a bit better?

Nowadays I see a more subtle approach to discredit, things like picking up on the exact times, the duration of events, the exact sequence. It's seems less explicit, but the same goal.

Having worked on both sides over decades, I'm still often in shock at some defence barristers. I worked for a few years in Ireland and some of the worst were women! Some very well known in that country too. Hard for me to understand that!

croisette · 09/11/2026 13:14

I’m so sorry for what you went through.

my first thought of the Brand trial was the charges he was found not guilty in respect of. I respect the fact that the jury have to answer the questions put before them, evidence rules and the standard of proof, but I do still feel sorry for those women who went through everything they did only for him to be found not guilty of the charges relating to them — when he so obviously was guilty of all of it and more besides.

DiNozzoComingBack · 09/11/2026 13:16

OP, I'm sorry this happened to you and YANBU to be upset.

There was a piece in the Times yesterday by a woman who points out that the many many women like you, you have tried to raise concerns and weren't believed, were dismissed etc, were like cannon fodder iin the war against men's sexual crimes. She talks about how so many women have had to do this before slowly slowly things are changing - that those women were, in effect, sacrificed with the HOPE that in the long term, the tide will change.

It's truly awful, but what I took from her comments was this realisation tht without all these super brave women standing up, Russel Brand, and other men like him, simply would continue to be let off but that perhaps now things are starting to change.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 09/11/2026 13:18

croisette · 09/11/2026 13:14

I’m so sorry for what you went through.

my first thought of the Brand trial was the charges he was found not guilty in respect of. I respect the fact that the jury have to answer the questions put before them, evidence rules and the standard of proof, but I do still feel sorry for those women who went through everything they did only for him to be found not guilty of the charges relating to them — when he so obviously was guilty of all of it and more besides.

The one I have the most issue with is that he was partially found guilty in that he grabbed the woman’s breasts which was a sexual assault, I don’t believe she was making up that he then went on to orally rape her. But I guess there may not be enough evidence.

sprigatito · 09/11/2026 13:21

You have a perfect right to be angry for the rest of your life. You and every other woman who has endured a sexual assault and then been retraumatised by our rancid patriarchal justice system.

I hope, of course, that you won’t be angry forever, and that there is a future in which you feel at peace and your life isn’t blighted by what that bastard did. But neither I nor anyone else has any right to lecture you or judge you for how you feel.

wishingonastar101 · 09/11/2026 13:32

You are right to be angry OP. I hope you find some peace and heal in time x

ToastAndCoffee8 · 09/11/2026 13:56

bythebanksof · 09/11/2026 13:11

In the UK judges do regularly caution juries against relying on cultural stereotypes or misconceptions, what you refer to as "rape myths", including things such as expecting a victim to physically fight back, scream, display immediate outward distress, or report an incident straight away. That is typically the case today I feel, but was certainly not in the past, so a bit better?

Nowadays I see a more subtle approach to discredit, things like picking up on the exact times, the duration of events, the exact sequence. It's seems less explicit, but the same goal.

Having worked on both sides over decades, I'm still often in shock at some defence barristers. I worked for a few years in Ireland and some of the worst were women! Some very well known in that country too. Hard for me to understand that!

Mine was a woman , she was vile. When I came out of the court room, ready to bloody explode I was met with.. She’s only doing her job! Talk about selling your soul.

OP posts:
Unyonder · 09/11/2026 14:10

Men don’t seem to understand a freeze response. I recall explaining it to my ex and his face was baffled by the concept, that I froze and did not fight.

I said I was prepared to be SA’d, at that point as it was clear I couldn’t stop I it, I had said no, I had explained no, he had decided it was the outcome, but I was not prepared to be hurt or killed so I had to choose one or the other in that moment, so chose my life.

Thats what it came down to for me, I had only 2 choices, and chose the one that meant I got to walk away afterwards. I hand on heart am quite sure I couldn’t fight a man off me for the same reasons, it doesn’t take much for a strong man with his hands round your neck, freezing saves lives but seems to lose court cases. Women shouldn’t have to make these choices and be penalised and degraded further for them

HangingOver · 09/11/2026 14:16

Solidarity with all other victims. Wish I could give you all a hug 😭

Tamaragoldengirl · 09/11/2026 14:38

I agree, but I am a close relative of someone who was falsely accused of rape (proven to be false and actually the woman was attention seeking and a fantasist) there must also be a defense. I of course agree that women should not be questioned on what they were wearing, but I think behaviour afterwards is a grey area for me. I think rape cases and especially historical ones are very difficult ones.

DiNozzoComingBack · 09/11/2026 14:43

Tamaragoldengirl · 09/11/2026 14:38

I agree, but I am a close relative of someone who was falsely accused of rape (proven to be false and actually the woman was attention seeking and a fantasist) there must also be a defense. I of course agree that women should not be questioned on what they were wearing, but I think behaviour afterwards is a grey area for me. I think rape cases and especially historical ones are very difficult ones.

Edited

Behaviour afterwards is not a grey area. It's an aspect of things to consider and often behaviour afterwards does not match the experience or feelings and that's a well known factor.

Hell, I had an argment with DH just last week where, in the moment, my comments and behaviours did not match what I was actually feeling and thinking. And then, because he IS my DH and I DO love and trust him, I was able to be more honest an hour later.

MidlifeMiseryGuts · 09/11/2026 14:45

The final sentencing remarks from the judge were strong though, and helped to kill off some of that noise from his defence team.

DarkAngel23 · 09/11/2026 15:09

I’m really sorry OP. Please be proud that you spoke your truth even if the legal process failed you.

Your rapist may not have been jailed, but his arrest will be on his criminal record. His friends and family will know. He will be tainted in a lot of people’s eyes even though they may not say it to his face. He will need to live with the fact that he lied in court everyday. He will still live in fear of another allegation.

Please try and take a break from the news if you can. I dont know why it surprises me but theres a staggering level of ignorance online. Please take care of yourself

New posts on this thread. Refresh page