Reading these threads over the past few years it has been fascinating and horrifying to watch the slow creep of arguments for AD from 'Of course it would only be for terminally ill people with full capacity and of course there would be lots of safeguards to make sure nobody ever felt pressured or coerced', to 'Dementia is so horrible that safeguards should be disregarded and nobody who loves their family should want to be a burden', with a side order of, 'There is a crisis in adult social care so the only solution is to kill people.'
I'm another who has gone from in favour of AD with sufficient safeguards to totally opposed because of attitudes like OP's and a couple of others on this thread.
Someone mentioned a slippery slope 'fallacy'. We already have a slippery slope in the arguments for AD even before legalisation, so where is this fallacy?
There was a case, can't remember if it was in Belgium or NL, where a woman with dementia had signed an advance directive for euthanasia once she reached a certain point in her illness. When that point came she strongly resisted. Her family had to pin her down, kicking and screaming, so the medic could administer the lethal injection. Because she no longer had capacity she was not deemed capable of changing her mind. That is horrific and I will never be in favour of any law that makes that situation a possibility in the UK.
I worked in care homes for the best part of a decade. Dementia is shit, often distressing for the person who has it and even more often for their loved ones. But the idea that everyone with dementia lives a life of unremitting misery and terror is simply not true. Many people with dementia are still able to find joy and contentment in life, right up to the point of actively dying - just like eveyone else. Their lives are worth the same as yours. And no, dementia is not the worst thing that can happen to you. I would prefer dementia to MND, Huntingdons, locked-in syndrome, severe COPD or certain types of cancer.
This is a big site, there will be people reading this thread who themselves have been diagnosed with early stage dementia. You are telling them their lives are not worth living and that it's wrong of them to want to continue living because they will become a 'burden'. How dare you.
Aside from all of that, if we ever did have legal AD, actively offering it should never happen anywhere close to any diagnosis. It's well known that terminal or life altering diagnoses frequently trigger a period of profound depression and despair. But after a while, most people get at least some of their mojo back and want to make the most of the time they have left or their new circumstances.