Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that every diagnosis of dementia should come with the offer of assisted dying

973 replies

CurdinHenry · 08/11/2026 13:38

Is there really anyone who would hear this news and want to see it out to the bitter end?

It enrages me that I might go out that way and so might everyone I love.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
Squidlette · 08/11/2026 18:06

ownedbymydogs · 08/11/2026 13:53

What a terrifying thread. Strongly recommend people go an have a read of Swift’s ‘Modest Proposal’ (and its historical context) and then have a strong think about what sort of society they want to create.

I read it, a long time ago.

I have a slightly higher chance of alzheimers and dementia, thanks to my mum and her side of the family. I'm in my 40s and already worried that I may only have 20 years left of 'me'.

My mum was adamant that she didn't want to live with the disease, but first, she wouldn't accept she had it and then she was kept alive for years; an incontinent shell of a creature. No thanks.

People have a view of dementia as being delightfully dotty old ladies, keeping their glasses in the butter jar. It's not. It's much, much more inhumane than assisted dying.

kitex · 08/11/2026 18:06

dreamiesformolly · 08/11/2026 17:45

You've put your finger on the problem. Why aren't people starting threads about how care of the living in this country needs to improve, rather than about whether it's OK to kill them to save money and resources?

For me, I don’t ever want to need care for the most basic tasks. I would like to have the choice to end my life when I’ve had enough.

ParkFirstDesk · 08/11/2026 18:11

CurdinHenry · 08/11/2026 15:12

Why is living reliant on care you don't want and nobody wants to give better than assisted dying?

You are assuming everyone’s experience is the same of yours. Not all people resent caring for their loved ones. Of course it is hard but lots of people do it. My mother was in a care home for 2 years, she still had times of enjoyment and pleasure, she had a good relationship with her carers and a good quality of life until the very end. I have had relatives with dementia and they lived good lives until the last few months when care was needed and given in a home. It is not as black and white as you seem to think but I’m sorry it was so hard for you that you think all people with dementia should opt to end their lives early.

ownedbymydogs · 08/11/2026 18:12

kitex · 08/11/2026 18:03

No one has the right, but give people a CHOICE!!

With most diagnoses the choice is there already. You just have to get on a plane to Switzerland.

The vast majority of people won’t do this though. And luckily, at the moment, it’s not legal to make that choice for someone else.

BingoJingo · 08/11/2026 18:14

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

DuckFilledPlatitude · 08/11/2026 18:17

ownedbymydogs · 08/11/2026 18:12

With most diagnoses the choice is there already. You just have to get on a plane to Switzerland.

The vast majority of people won’t do this though. And luckily, at the moment, it’s not legal to make that choice for someone else.

"Just get on a plane"? When you have advanced dementia, you can't 'just' do anything. Getting someone from one side of the room to the other can take half an hour.

Yes, you could get on the plane before you reached that stage, but then you and your loved ones would be sacrificing time you could still enjoy together,

kitex · 08/11/2026 18:18

DuckFilledPlatitude · 08/11/2026 18:17

"Just get on a plane"? When you have advanced dementia, you can't 'just' do anything. Getting someone from one side of the room to the other can take half an hour.

Yes, you could get on the plane before you reached that stage, but then you and your loved ones would be sacrificing time you could still enjoy together,

@ownedbymydogs made it sound so easy!!

TherapyName · 08/11/2026 18:19

With appropriate safeguards, I believe you are correct. In my work I see that often people are not afraid of dying, they are afraid of dying demented or in agony.

I believe that dementia is different from other conditions in that the person loses who they are much sooner than with other conditions. They can live for many years with no sense of self, often confused and afraid. Some people get caught in a time loop reliving the most traumatic episodes of their lives - distressing them and distressing their loved ones. I witnessed this with a relative who spent several weeks reliving the death of their spouse decades earlier. It was like watching a scratched CD skipping is the best way I can describe it.

In a civilised society there is no need for anyone to have this kind of death. I would expand the list to allow many other conditions, I have a serious one myself. When the time comes it would be a great comfort to me to know that I can pass away peacefully without inflicting the trauma of suicide or an agonising death on my loved ones. I understand why people can reach the point where suicide feels like a blessed escape in the context of incurable and enduring illness. There are worse things than death and only the privileged think otherwise.

AnotherAnnie · 08/11/2026 18:21

Why would you want people to think they should consider being killed for being disabled? that seems unhinged and cruel.

BIossomtoes · 08/11/2026 18:22

AnotherAnnie · 08/11/2026 18:21

Why would you want people to think they should consider being killed for being disabled? that seems unhinged and cruel.

Dementia isn’t a disability. It’s a progressive incurable illness that consumes the sufferer.

ownedbymydogs · 08/11/2026 18:22

That’s your experience, @Squidlette , mine was a mother who lived with me for the last ten years of her life. She had dementia, she was doubly incontinent. Recognising most people was very intermittent. But she enjoyed food, music, and just being with family. Not recognising them, but knowing she was loved. I think that’s a worthy life.

Have a read through this thread and see how many people talk about burden, cost, even being able to buy morphine OTC to finish someone off! I said it was terrifying at the beginning and I’m now utterly convinced assisted dying should never be legalised.

ownedbymydogs · 08/11/2026 18:25

I know, @DuckFilledPlatitude , I cared for my mother, who had dementia, for 10 years. Please read my post properly.

DuckFilledPlatitude · 08/11/2026 18:29

ownedbymydogs · 08/11/2026 18:25

I know, @DuckFilledPlatitude , I cared for my mother, who had dementia, for 10 years. Please read my post properly.

I'm still not understanding what you meant. You said With most diagnoses the choice is there already. You just have to get on a plane to Switzerland.
The vast majority of people won’t do this though. And luckily, at the moment, it’s not legal to make that choice for someone else.

Did you mean 'most diagnoses apart from dementia'? Apologies if I misunderstood. You made it sound as though people with dementia could easily travel abroad.

TheRoyalEyeroll · 08/11/2026 18:30

I won’t be taking advice from anyone who can use the language the OP has used in some of their posts.

They really are best ignored whilst coming across the way they do.

ownedbymydogs · 08/11/2026 18:32

kitex · 08/11/2026 18:18

@ownedbymydogs made it sound so easy!!

You are so insulting to me, yet you have not answered any of my questions to you, other than with sneering contempt.

I have much experience of dementia in my family but you just seem to want to insult and offend.

What a frankly unedifying display of grubbiness by some people this thread has been. It has probably put back the campaign for assisted dying by decades, thankfully.

Hedgehogspikes · 08/11/2026 18:32

CurdinHenry · 08/11/2026 13:44

And there is no greater burden than being a dementia patient. I think it's immoral not to care about that tbh.

You think it should be normal and accepted practice for people to choose suicide for fear of being a burden?

Puzzledandpissedoff · 08/11/2026 18:37

CurdinHenry · 08/11/2026 14:02

There is nothing (nothing) worse than dying of dementia so I'm happy to go light on safeguards personally.

I'm happy to go light on safeguards ...

And there it is

Some of us who actually agree with assisted dying in principle would quite like to see proper and rigorous safeguards, but never mind ... let's just chip away at them (as those pushing the last bill were so quick to do) and create a situation where the vulnerable can be coerced Hmm

dreamiesformolly · 08/11/2026 18:41

CurdinHenry · 08/11/2026 15:32

I think it is right tbh - you could ruin your kids' lives with a very early diagnosis and healthy body.

Presumably you'd agree, then, that the next logical step from that line of reasoning is that said kids should be able to override the wishes of the parent and have them killed whether they consent or not. What are your thoughts on that?

NeverDropYourMooncup · 08/11/2026 18:46

CurdinHenry · 08/11/2026 17:25

You don't have the authority to lecture other people on what they ought to want

And dementia isn't just sub optimal health, it is the loss of your self and soul

I'd say that stripping people down to useless eaters and users of resources is a damn sight more soulless than a person with dementia.

Puzzledandpissedoff · 08/11/2026 18:46

TheRoyalEyeroll · 08/11/2026 18:30

I won’t be taking advice from anyone who can use the language the OP has used in some of their posts.

They really are best ignored whilst coming across the way they do.

Very wise of you, eye roll, but TBH I'm not sure that seeing such views expressed is a bad thing in itself

As the last bill progressed it became ever clearer that too many proponents shared similar ones, and happily it resulted in sufficient MPs seeing through it ... even though they'd doubtless have welcomed the potential cost savings it could have brought

GrandmasCat · 08/11/2026 18:49

I just want for everyone to have clear advice and opportunity to sign a non resuscitation order or be allowed to refuse treatment for any degenerative/no curable condition you choose not to fight.

I was talking to someone about this and said I didn’t want to be a burden to my son, then she said but he may want to care for you so much to which I responded “Bollocks to that, I have put him first all his life, he doesn’t get to decide how I die”.

ThingsAreNotWhatTheyWere · 08/11/2026 18:49

TherapyName · 08/11/2026 18:19

With appropriate safeguards, I believe you are correct. In my work I see that often people are not afraid of dying, they are afraid of dying demented or in agony.

I believe that dementia is different from other conditions in that the person loses who they are much sooner than with other conditions. They can live for many years with no sense of self, often confused and afraid. Some people get caught in a time loop reliving the most traumatic episodes of their lives - distressing them and distressing their loved ones. I witnessed this with a relative who spent several weeks reliving the death of their spouse decades earlier. It was like watching a scratched CD skipping is the best way I can describe it.

In a civilised society there is no need for anyone to have this kind of death. I would expand the list to allow many other conditions, I have a serious one myself. When the time comes it would be a great comfort to me to know that I can pass away peacefully without inflicting the trauma of suicide or an agonising death on my loved ones. I understand why people can reach the point where suicide feels like a blessed escape in the context of incurable and enduring illness. There are worse things than death and only the privileged think otherwise.

Having seen rather more of doctors and hospitals than most people since tbe day I was born, I would not describe myself as "privileged" in terms of my health (but I still have a good life within the limitations of my health). I'm not afraid of dying per se, but I am terrified of being made to feel like a burden and coerced into a position where I should do society a favour and "pop off".

Loveofeclairs · 08/11/2026 18:50

DuckFilledPlatitude · 08/11/2026 18:17

"Just get on a plane"? When you have advanced dementia, you can't 'just' do anything. Getting someone from one side of the room to the other can take half an hour.

Yes, you could get on the plane before you reached that stage, but then you and your loved ones would be sacrificing time you could still enjoy together,

But people with advanced dementia would not be the ones benefiting from assisted dying anyway. The person would need to have capacity when given the injection.

There was an excellent article on the BBC website today about a couple from the Netherlands who wanted to die together. The man was suffering from chronic pain and would have liked to postpone the procedure by a few years. His wife was diagnosed with dementia so they had to opt for assisted dying sooner while she still had capacity.

So that choice would still mean sacrificing some time with loved ones or risk waiting until it’s too late.

DuckFilledPlatitude · 08/11/2026 18:55

Loveofeclairs · 08/11/2026 18:50

But people with advanced dementia would not be the ones benefiting from assisted dying anyway. The person would need to have capacity when given the injection.

There was an excellent article on the BBC website today about a couple from the Netherlands who wanted to die together. The man was suffering from chronic pain and would have liked to postpone the procedure by a few years. His wife was diagnosed with dementia so they had to opt for assisted dying sooner while she still had capacity.

So that choice would still mean sacrificing some time with loved ones or risk waiting until it’s too late.

Yes - my thought is that the only way to avoid that dilemma is to be able to give consent in advance, while you still have capacity, for euthanasia to be performed once you have lost capacity, and your quality of life has deteriorated beyond certain thresholds - which you would define when you gave consent.

PencilsInSpace · 08/11/2026 18:58

Reading these threads over the past few years it has been fascinating and horrifying to watch the slow creep of arguments for AD from 'Of course it would only be for terminally ill people with full capacity and of course there would be lots of safeguards to make sure nobody ever felt pressured or coerced', to 'Dementia is so horrible that safeguards should be disregarded and nobody who loves their family should want to be a burden', with a side order of, 'There is a crisis in adult social care so the only solution is to kill people.'

I'm another who has gone from in favour of AD with sufficient safeguards to totally opposed because of attitudes like OP's and a couple of others on this thread.

Someone mentioned a slippery slope 'fallacy'. We already have a slippery slope in the arguments for AD even before legalisation, so where is this fallacy?

There was a case, can't remember if it was in Belgium or NL, where a woman with dementia had signed an advance directive for euthanasia once she reached a certain point in her illness. When that point came she strongly resisted. Her family had to pin her down, kicking and screaming, so the medic could administer the lethal injection. Because she no longer had capacity she was not deemed capable of changing her mind. That is horrific and I will never be in favour of any law that makes that situation a possibility in the UK.

I worked in care homes for the best part of a decade. Dementia is shit, often distressing for the person who has it and even more often for their loved ones. But the idea that everyone with dementia lives a life of unremitting misery and terror is simply not true. Many people with dementia are still able to find joy and contentment in life, right up to the point of actively dying - just like eveyone else. Their lives are worth the same as yours. And no, dementia is not the worst thing that can happen to you. I would prefer dementia to MND, Huntingdons, locked-in syndrome, severe COPD or certain types of cancer.

This is a big site, there will be people reading this thread who themselves have been diagnosed with early stage dementia. You are telling them their lives are not worth living and that it's wrong of them to want to continue living because they will become a 'burden'. How dare you.

Aside from all of that, if we ever did have legal AD, actively offering it should never happen anywhere close to any diagnosis. It's well known that terminal or life altering diagnoses frequently trigger a period of profound depression and despair. But after a while, most people get at least some of their mojo back and want to make the most of the time they have left or their new circumstances.