Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To let Dc go on screens all day

74 replies

Novemberusedtobemyfave · 08/11/2026 13:17

I'm having guilt about it, but is it that bad?

Just had a week of half term, been out every day-dog walks, cafes, shopping, play dates at our home, played with neighbour friends, full day at a zoo type place, crafts, baking etc

It's cold and stormy today, fire on, Dh and Ddog snoozing and I just want to go on my phone or watch tv
Dd has been on the desktop computer playing a game where she builds houses since this morning. I feel guilt about it, but should I? everyone is happy and relaxed, she's back at school tomorrow and did all her homework days ago.

OP posts:
SomersetBrie · 08/11/2026 13:50

DD has two parents.
DH has obviously decided it's fine, so I don't think OP should be getting a hard time about this.

A day of screens is not a big deal in the grand scheme of things. (Though I admit, I would also feel guilty about it)

Colourfulfeathers · 08/11/2026 13:52

All day playing computer games for an 8 year old seems a bit much. Can she do reading, play with other toys, go to the library, shops with you, get involved in house chores, watch a movie with you, baking, board games, colouring.

Those games are so addictive. 2 hours is plenty

Novemberusedtobemyfave · 08/11/2026 13:55

Colourfulfeathers · 08/11/2026 13:52

All day playing computer games for an 8 year old seems a bit much. Can she do reading, play with other toys, go to the library, shops with you, get involved in house chores, watch a movie with you, baking, board games, colouring.

Those games are so addictive. 2 hours is plenty

We've done all those things every day all week, not going out today, pjs all day, roast later

OP posts:
Novemberusedtobemyfave · 08/11/2026 13:56

Colourfulfeathers · 08/11/2026 13:52

All day playing computer games for an 8 year old seems a bit much. Can she do reading, play with other toys, go to the library, shops with you, get involved in house chores, watch a movie with you, baking, board games, colouring.

Those games are so addictive. 2 hours is plenty

But I agree yes, she should really

OP posts:
Notmycircusnotmyotter · 08/11/2026 13:57

Novemberusedtobemyfave · 08/11/2026 13:37

Yes that's the norm tbh, but she always wants to play with us or her friends-who are all just home having a lazy day too. I'm tired today 😫

Too tired to play / read with one child? I wouldn't feel good about screens all day.

Novemberusedtobemyfave · 08/11/2026 13:59

Notmycircusnotmyotter · 08/11/2026 13:57

Too tired to play / read with one child? I wouldn't feel good about screens all day.

I actually am today as we've done it all week and Dd is very high energy
But yes I feel like a crap mum about it

OP posts:
ProtestantTraybakeQueen · 08/11/2026 14:00

Novemberusedtobemyfave · 08/11/2026 13:31

But all day 😬 I wouldn't mind the tv, but on the computer all day just makes me feel guilty for some reason

Ah see I’d rather they actively game than passively watch TV. Goes to show there is pros and cons to everything 😁

Novemberusedtobemyfave · 08/11/2026 14:02

ProtestantTraybakeQueen · 08/11/2026 14:00

Ah see I’d rather they actively game than passively watch TV. Goes to show there is pros and cons to everything 😁

Do you think so, maybe it is better?

OP posts:
ProtestantTraybakeQueen · 08/11/2026 14:05

Novemberusedtobemyfave · 08/11/2026 14:02

Do you think so, maybe it is better?

Depends on the child too I guess. Some computer games will be more stimulating than some tv shows and vice versa.

My eldest seems to have epic off-the-scale dopamine needs and can game all day happily. Still excels at school, does all his homework, is kind, is fit and healthy, has outside interests.
The other 2 can only handle an hour or 2 then go off and do other stuff!

mynameiscalypso · 08/11/2026 14:10

My 7 year old will be spending this afternoon playing a game where you build houses/communities on his Switch this afternoon too. As others say, I’d rather he did that than mindlessly consume TV and he’s also doing things like drawing maps of his city to plan it and making lists of residents etc so it’s fairly creative.

EdgyNewt · 08/11/2026 14:12

@Novemberusedtobemyfave it's ONE day, and I'd quite happily do the same myself all day if I didn't have work and chores to do!

She will enjoy it! Sims by any chance??

Two of mine are currently gaming after a morning of sports! My DD has to do her homework first before she can game.

Totaldramallama · 08/11/2026 14:15

Personally I wouldn't. I just couldn't, I would find it so hard to relax. We're having a lazy day at home. For us this has meant DD had some tv, then played in her room, then our neighbour knocked and they've been playing together. They're having lunch now then I'm sending the friend home so I can do some baking with DD. Then she has spellings to practice so we're going to play schools and have a spelling lesson. She also has a Lego to finish. And I have agreed she can play an hour of a computer games (building houses on Sims, might be what your daughter is dojng?) After dinner we're going to play a board game. DH has walked the dog. She is 8 for context.

Funnily enough as a young teen I played hours and hours of computer games and turned out fine 😂

sofaguarantee · 08/11/2026 14:16

Novemberusedtobemyfave · 08/11/2026 13:48

And what on earth is there to show off about? go me I'm letting my child play video games all day instead of interacting with her and doing the other things that I guiltily feel would be better for her, but I really can't be arsed today

OK I get that for you this feels huge and you feel guilty. I am just handing you a grip,because you appear to know so little about what computer usage actually is for children, what level is or isn't harmful, and also you are fretting about something that is (in the scheme of the broader info you give about their lives), so, so, unlikely to harm them.

Also NB privilege doesn't mean you are all-round wealthy and fancy it just means that in this one aspect of parenting, you have a lot of things that are not apparently problems for you. I don't know your whole life and you may have other problems which of course I don't know about. But speaking to this one issue you seem to be fretting not counting your blessings. This is privilege about the one issue. There are a lot of painful situations that many parents have, that would put your worries in perspective, that you seem blissfully unaware of. That's the privilege.

Reading it through the lens of my own life is like reading someone saying "oh my god my child has only done 4 hours music practice this week do you think that will harm them forever". Imagine if your own child is, I dunno, in hospital with PANS, or in autistic burnout and unable to get out of bed, or you yourself are ill and unwell and have to ration what you all do, or maybe the children are spending the weekend with their deadbeat dad who only feeds them macdonalds and doesn't make them brush their teeth.... just the thought of music practice might be a world away, and seem an insignificant problem. I would be delighted if that was my main problem this weekend related to potential harms my child might suffer.

There is so much that can harm children. And so often, a parent has to live with the excruciating knowledge that their child isn't having the safe, cared for life they want them to have, however hard they try and whateer effort they put in. This isn't your situation (based only on what you have said) so that's why my reaction is "get a grip".

And of course people can worry about small things, even if others have big things to worry about. But honestly your concern is an absolute nothingburger, there is no way playing a game most of today will hurt her.

To hear someone worrying about such a small thing as you are worrying about just sounds distasteful to me. Your children are obviously surrounded with care and support and have access to lots of enrichment and have the capacity and health to benefit from it.

You are all OK. Let her play Minecraft.

moominontherun · 08/11/2026 14:21

Sounds like a lovely chill day after a very busy time.

My two are currently building a zoo together in Minecraft and have been absorbed in it for ages. We’ve gone nowhere, done nothing, and it’s great.

Don’t look on here for validation. Enjoy your day. It’s really not worth overthinking.

Pansykavalier · 08/11/2026 14:22

Cuttertheduck · 08/11/2026 13:43

Why is building Lego houses that much better than building houses in Minecraft?
And what is better about just consuming a movie vs. actually creating something?

Sorry but I’m ancient and have absolutely no idea of what Minecraft actually is, though I am willing to believe that it’s a perfectly satisfactory alternative to my other suggestions.🤗

Bearbookagainandagain · 08/11/2026 14:41

The issue for me is that even if I want to spend the day on my phone/TV or whatever screen, and feel fine at the time, there is a point where I'll start feeling rubbish and sluggish.

Then it goes from a relaxing experience to one that makes me feel tired, overstimulated, anxious in a way and unable to focus my attention on other things.

I can see the same things with my kids when they watch TV for too long, they'll be fine then 10-15 min they'll suddenly be crying and overstimulated.
That doesn't happen when they play with Legos or their train set, it's very much the screens.

So in itself I don't have an issue with an 8yo chilling and doing what they want all day, but I do think that screens need a limit. And they won't find that limit themselves.
If she's played all morning, I would make her do something else this afternoon. Or at least take her for a walk outside for an hour or so, and see if she wants to play again when she gets back.

maggisimpson · 08/11/2026 14:46

Comedycook · 08/11/2026 13:30

How old? You can have a lazy chill day without resorting to screens for the entire day...how else did previous generations amuse themselves

My generation (80s child) could definitely use screens all day 😂

maggisimpson · 08/11/2026 14:48

Sundays I don't want to do anything.
I don't care what the kids are doing so long as they're not bothering me.

TheTortiePuffinNeedsHerBreakfast · 08/11/2026 14:48

I think it's fine once in a while. Back in the 1980s I used to have days in the holidays where I watched TV most of the day. If it's a couple of times during an otherwise active time off, it really doesn't have ill effects.

Myplantsmyrules · 08/11/2026 14:59

Comedycook · 08/11/2026 13:30

How old? You can have a lazy chill day without resorting to screens for the entire day...how else did previous generations amuse themselves

Some suggestions: Drawing, colouring in, water paints, making scrap books (lots of cutting out and gluing), playdough, reading, watching television, playing with dolls and teddies, making mud pies (outside of course!), staring out the window, playing with pets, making perfume (water and petals in sure my mum threw out within days), looking through old magazines and brochures, more staring out the window.

I know half those things aren't probably even possible now (brochures 🤷‍♀️) and there's nothing wrong with screens but some kids probably would enjoy making things with their hands and creating worlds with their imagination as well as computer games.

Novemberusedtobemyfave · 08/11/2026 15:07

sofaguarantee · 08/11/2026 14:16

OK I get that for you this feels huge and you feel guilty. I am just handing you a grip,because you appear to know so little about what computer usage actually is for children, what level is or isn't harmful, and also you are fretting about something that is (in the scheme of the broader info you give about their lives), so, so, unlikely to harm them.

Also NB privilege doesn't mean you are all-round wealthy and fancy it just means that in this one aspect of parenting, you have a lot of things that are not apparently problems for you. I don't know your whole life and you may have other problems which of course I don't know about. But speaking to this one issue you seem to be fretting not counting your blessings. This is privilege about the one issue. There are a lot of painful situations that many parents have, that would put your worries in perspective, that you seem blissfully unaware of. That's the privilege.

Reading it through the lens of my own life is like reading someone saying "oh my god my child has only done 4 hours music practice this week do you think that will harm them forever". Imagine if your own child is, I dunno, in hospital with PANS, or in autistic burnout and unable to get out of bed, or you yourself are ill and unwell and have to ration what you all do, or maybe the children are spending the weekend with their deadbeat dad who only feeds them macdonalds and doesn't make them brush their teeth.... just the thought of music practice might be a world away, and seem an insignificant problem. I would be delighted if that was my main problem this weekend related to potential harms my child might suffer.

There is so much that can harm children. And so often, a parent has to live with the excruciating knowledge that their child isn't having the safe, cared for life they want them to have, however hard they try and whateer effort they put in. This isn't your situation (based only on what you have said) so that's why my reaction is "get a grip".

And of course people can worry about small things, even if others have big things to worry about. But honestly your concern is an absolute nothingburger, there is no way playing a game most of today will hurt her.

To hear someone worrying about such a small thing as you are worrying about just sounds distasteful to me. Your children are obviously surrounded with care and support and have access to lots of enrichment and have the capacity and health to benefit from it.

You are all OK. Let her play Minecraft.

Jesus! You have zero idea about any problems we may have, which for context are many and i'm not going into them here. This post was about screen time, just that, it doesn't mean we have no other issues going on, we actually do, this is most definitely not the only thing to worry about, how bloody patronising!
Interestingly, my Dd does have an issue that is one you posted above and is related to my worry about excessive screen time too. That is something I didn't want to bring into it, a post can be about one thing, it does not cancel out all other possible issues that you are not privy to
Please do think before you post as you really have no idea about anyone's life.

OP posts:
Novemberusedtobemyfave · 08/11/2026 15:18

Myplantsmyrules · 08/11/2026 14:59

Some suggestions: Drawing, colouring in, water paints, making scrap books (lots of cutting out and gluing), playdough, reading, watching television, playing with dolls and teddies, making mud pies (outside of course!), staring out the window, playing with pets, making perfume (water and petals in sure my mum threw out within days), looking through old magazines and brochures, more staring out the window.

I know half those things aren't probably even possible now (brochures 🤷‍♀️) and there's nothing wrong with screens but some kids probably would enjoy making things with their hands and creating worlds with their imagination as well as computer games.

I love all these and we've done many this week, but i'm being lazy and this all involves a fair amount of setting up, tidying and involvement 😂

Anyway, she's off it now and watching a horse show, which I much prefer for some reason

OP posts:
WhatHappenedToYourFurnitureCuz · 08/11/2026 15:18

Pansykavalier · 08/11/2026 14:22

Sorry but I’m ancient and have absolutely no idea of what Minecraft actually is, though I am willing to believe that it’s a perfectly satisfactory alternative to my other suggestions.🤗

When building houses it's Lego but where the blocks are digital instead of physical.

WhatNoRaisins · 08/11/2026 15:24

Novemberusedtobemyfave · 08/11/2026 15:18

I love all these and we've done many this week, but i'm being lazy and this all involves a fair amount of setting up, tidying and involvement 😂

Anyway, she's off it now and watching a horse show, which I much prefer for some reason

I came up with a rule in lockdown that I'm not doing anything that takes more set up and tidy up time than the time it will keep them entertained for.

TheChosenTwo · 08/11/2026 15:26

I really couldn’t get worked up about this but I wouldn’t do it, endless hours of staring at a screen for an 8 years old is too much imo.
I’d at least encourage her to come and play some card games or do some colouring with you for half an hour a few times during the day. Stick a film on or something that you can do together but doesn’t take any energy.

Swipe left for the next trending thread