Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To let Dc go on screens all day

74 replies

Novemberusedtobemyfave · 08/11/2026 13:17

I'm having guilt about it, but is it that bad?

Just had a week of half term, been out every day-dog walks, cafes, shopping, play dates at our home, played with neighbour friends, full day at a zoo type place, crafts, baking etc

It's cold and stormy today, fire on, Dh and Ddog snoozing and I just want to go on my phone or watch tv
Dd has been on the desktop computer playing a game where she builds houses since this morning. I feel guilt about it, but should I? everyone is happy and relaxed, she's back at school tomorrow and did all her homework days ago.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Rockpunkdisco · 11/11/2026 17:37

Of course it's fine, time to kick back and all chill! Xx

Rejoinedforthis · 11/11/2026 13:19

ImFckingMattDamon · 11/11/2026 13:14

OMG core memory unlocked!!!! I loved this game!

You fight like a dairy farmer 😂

ImFckingMattDamon · 11/11/2026 13:14

Rejoinedforthis · 09/11/2026 12:51

As a kid I spent HOURS on my old PC playing Monkey Island. And when I say hours I mean HOURS 😵‍💫 I’m in my 40s now and I still absolutely love point/click adventure puzzle games and escape rooms. I also read a lot as a kid, I still do, and got a first class law degree so I don’t think those days spent with Guybrush Threepwood as a kid were misspent 😂😂😂

OMG core memory unlocked!!!! I loved this game!

Discodance1988 · 11/11/2026 11:46

I'm an only child, also a child of the 90s so I grew up doing both, spending a lot of time out and about with my friends and spending a lot of time playing on my sega/super Nintendo/Nintendo 64/playstation etc (as they all came out not all at once lol) didn't do me any harm.

You don't need to entertain your kids every second of every day with crafts and baking and days out etc sometimes you can just let them have a screen and know they are fine and happy.

Dinosaurhearmeroar · 09/11/2026 18:24

I put you are being
unreasonable to say that it was fine but not sure that’s what your choices meant!

in the 90s I played on my gameboy and my computer allllll day. Loved it. I’m fine 🙂

WaterlooHowDoesItFeel · 09/11/2026 13:21

We did two caravan holidays in half term. Yesterday my daughter spent practically all day on her tablet watching kids YouTube and playing roblox with her friends. I dont feel any guilt whatsoever. It was one day, she was happy, I was happy. We had a lovely day!

Rejoinedforthis · 09/11/2026 12:51

As a kid I spent HOURS on my old PC playing Monkey Island. And when I say hours I mean HOURS 😵‍💫 I’m in my 40s now and I still absolutely love point/click adventure puzzle games and escape rooms. I also read a lot as a kid, I still do, and got a first class law degree so I don’t think those days spent with Guybrush Threepwood as a kid were misspent 😂😂😂

Novemberusedtobemyfave · 09/11/2026 12:47

Myplantsmyrules · 09/11/2026 04:25

That's the difference between parents now and then, boomer parents just left us to it on our own. And we had to tidy it all up. Or was that just my mum? I recall a lot of my childhood just wandering around annoying the dogs!

Yes, my childhood was similar too, just left to my own devices 🤣

OP posts:
Novemberusedtobemyfave · 09/11/2026 12:46

Velumental · 09/11/2026 06:49

PJs all day?I'm not being scandalous or pearl clutvhy but unless yorue I'll why do you want that?

😂To relax on a stormy, cold day, why not

OP posts:
Pansykavalier · 09/11/2026 07:58

WhatHappenedToYourFurnitureCuz · 08/11/2026 15:18

When building houses it's Lego but where the blocks are digital instead of physical.

Thank you for this very succinct explanation 🤗

ProtestantTraybakeQueen · 09/11/2026 06:51

Velumental · 09/11/2026 06:49

PJs all day?I'm not being scandalous or pearl clutvhy but unless yorue I'll why do you want that?

Comfort.

Velumental · 09/11/2026 06:49

Novemberusedtobemyfave · 08/11/2026 13:55

We've done all those things every day all week, not going out today, pjs all day, roast later

PJs all day?I'm not being scandalous or pearl clutvhy but unless yorue I'll why do you want that?

Velumental · 09/11/2026 06:47

Will she really do it all day though? My 8 year old is and has always been a keen gamer as long as the option existed for him. Even he would game for an hour or 2 then demand more intercation. I'd have to take him a walk or to the park or he'd be bouncing off the walls literally. Then he likes to talk about everything he's doing,so there's no way he'd just be sat on a screen not interacting.

Do you really want to actually do nothing at all? Won't you be bored out of your tree too? I could do a couple of hours happily but after that I'd get cabin fever.

Myplantsmyrules · 09/11/2026 04:25

Novemberusedtobemyfave · 08/11/2026 15:18

I love all these and we've done many this week, but i'm being lazy and this all involves a fair amount of setting up, tidying and involvement 😂

Anyway, she's off it now and watching a horse show, which I much prefer for some reason

That's the difference between parents now and then, boomer parents just left us to it on our own. And we had to tidy it all up. Or was that just my mum? I recall a lot of my childhood just wandering around annoying the dogs!

Novemberusedtobemyfave · 08/11/2026 18:56

sofaguarantee · 08/11/2026 18:52

I do, probably, you're right. I let myself get irked by the completely OTT handwringing about a day of The Sims. I was a bit surprised nobody else thought the OP was being a bit much, but maybe it's me on this occasion.. It was also the OP's performative "eh???"s and "what do you meeeean, it's meeeeaningless" when I was perfectly clear about what I was saying.

Ok, listen, take care.

OP posts:
Novemberusedtobemyfave · 08/11/2026 18:55

WhatHappenedToYourFurnitureCuz · 08/11/2026 18:25

Don't let them derail your thread, though I know it's annoying when they want to have the last word.

You're completely right, very odd, but I hope they find some help as it wasn't my intention to trigger or upset anyone with the simple question about screen time and it's true I do get worried about it.

OP posts:
sofaguarantee · 08/11/2026 18:52

thisismeithinkorisit · 08/11/2026 18:21

kindly, of you're this triggered by someone asking if it's ok they're being a. lazy b. letting their kids have too much screens when everyone is constantly going on about how kids shouldn't have too much screens, maybe you need a break from reading other people's questions. perhaps getting some support for what you have going on your own life with your kids would be more useful to you

I do, probably, you're right. I let myself get irked by the completely OTT handwringing about a day of The Sims. I was a bit surprised nobody else thought the OP was being a bit much, but maybe it's me on this occasion.. It was also the OP's performative "eh???"s and "what do you meeeean, it's meeeeaningless" when I was perfectly clear about what I was saying.

WhatHappenedToYourFurnitureCuz · 08/11/2026 18:25

Novemberusedtobemyfave · 08/11/2026 18:05

What on earth are you talking about?

There are many many different posts on Mn on all types of issues, you cannot simply act like this because some people have bigger problems (which I have already stated that you have zero idea about other people's lives and what they choose to share) It's not a race to the bottom.
Completely pointless and mean spirited post, spend your energy elsewhere, it will benefit you more than making complete strangers feel shit.

Don't let them derail your thread, though I know it's annoying when they want to have the last word.

thisismeithinkorisit · 08/11/2026 18:21

sofaguarantee · 08/11/2026 14:16

OK I get that for you this feels huge and you feel guilty. I am just handing you a grip,because you appear to know so little about what computer usage actually is for children, what level is or isn't harmful, and also you are fretting about something that is (in the scheme of the broader info you give about their lives), so, so, unlikely to harm them.

Also NB privilege doesn't mean you are all-round wealthy and fancy it just means that in this one aspect of parenting, you have a lot of things that are not apparently problems for you. I don't know your whole life and you may have other problems which of course I don't know about. But speaking to this one issue you seem to be fretting not counting your blessings. This is privilege about the one issue. There are a lot of painful situations that many parents have, that would put your worries in perspective, that you seem blissfully unaware of. That's the privilege.

Reading it through the lens of my own life is like reading someone saying "oh my god my child has only done 4 hours music practice this week do you think that will harm them forever". Imagine if your own child is, I dunno, in hospital with PANS, or in autistic burnout and unable to get out of bed, or you yourself are ill and unwell and have to ration what you all do, or maybe the children are spending the weekend with their deadbeat dad who only feeds them macdonalds and doesn't make them brush their teeth.... just the thought of music practice might be a world away, and seem an insignificant problem. I would be delighted if that was my main problem this weekend related to potential harms my child might suffer.

There is so much that can harm children. And so often, a parent has to live with the excruciating knowledge that their child isn't having the safe, cared for life they want them to have, however hard they try and whateer effort they put in. This isn't your situation (based only on what you have said) so that's why my reaction is "get a grip".

And of course people can worry about small things, even if others have big things to worry about. But honestly your concern is an absolute nothingburger, there is no way playing a game most of today will hurt her.

To hear someone worrying about such a small thing as you are worrying about just sounds distasteful to me. Your children are obviously surrounded with care and support and have access to lots of enrichment and have the capacity and health to benefit from it.

You are all OK. Let her play Minecraft.

kindly, of you're this triggered by someone asking if it's ok they're being a. lazy b. letting their kids have too much screens when everyone is constantly going on about how kids shouldn't have too much screens, maybe you need a break from reading other people's questions. perhaps getting some support for what you have going on your own life with your kids would be more useful to you

thisismeithinkorisit · 08/11/2026 18:17

Pansykavalier · 08/11/2026 13:38

Relaxing the rules is perfectly fine, but all day on screens is taking it too far.

Alternatives include messing with paints or clay, collages, making plaster of Paris casts or Christmas tree decorations, etc.

Also card or board games, puzzles, various trivia games, Scrabble……..

Or watching a really good movie - or even just IJ and the Temple of Doom or Toy Story 113 or Jurassic Park.

which defeats the object.
paints, clay, crafts - all makes mess and often requires parental input.
card or board games, limited which ones you can play alone l, esp trivia quizzes and Scrabble.
IJ and the Temple.... and Jurassic Park are both recommended 11+, DD is 8.

Novemberusedtobemyfave · 08/11/2026 18:05

sofaguarantee · 08/11/2026 16:47

My contribution was by no means meaningless. I'll recap it for you.

  1. No, it's not a big deal if an otherwise healthy and ok 8 year old watches screens for a day. Get a grip, there are bigger things to worry about. It is so nothingy, and the OP included something that looked like faux naive lack of understanding about constructive, creative screen time in the form of building games, so it actually read like a stealth brag.
  1. If she is not otherwise healthy or there is something else about the situation that makes a difference to that advice, tell us upfront if you want useful advice, and if you have bigger things to worry about I am profoundly sorry, I really am.
  1. Seeing people fretting over a day of screens after a week where you have been out every day-dog walks, cafes, shopping, play dates at our home, played with neighbour friends, full day at a zoo type place, crafts, baking etc- is triggering and tone deaf for those of us whose children cannot do those other things.

The definition of "meaningless" is not "she was mean and I didnt agree with her".

Maybe "sorry, yeah, I get that everyone has bigger issues, this really bothered me because of other stuff" would be more graceful.

Edited

What on earth are you talking about?

There are many many different posts on Mn on all types of issues, you cannot simply act like this because some people have bigger problems (which I have already stated that you have zero idea about other people's lives and what they choose to share) It's not a race to the bottom.
Completely pointless and mean spirited post, spend your energy elsewhere, it will benefit you more than making complete strangers feel shit.

OP posts:
sofaguarantee · 08/11/2026 16:47

My contribution was by no means meaningless. I'll recap it for you.

  1. No, it's not a big deal if an otherwise healthy and ok 8 year old watches screens for a day. Get a grip, there are bigger things to worry about. It is so nothingy, and the OP included something that looked like faux naive lack of understanding about constructive, creative screen time in the form of building games, so it actually read like a stealth brag.
  1. If she is not otherwise healthy or there is something else about the situation that makes a difference to that advice, tell us upfront if you want useful advice, and if you have bigger things to worry about I am profoundly sorry, I really am.
  1. Seeing people fretting over a day of screens after a week where you have been out every day-dog walks, cafes, shopping, play dates at our home, played with neighbour friends, full day at a zoo type place, crafts, baking etc- is triggering and tone deaf for those of us whose children cannot do those other things.

The definition of "meaningless" is not "she was mean and I didnt agree with her".

Maybe "sorry, yeah, I get that everyone has bigger issues, this really bothered me because of other stuff" would be more graceful.

Novemberusedtobemyfave · 08/11/2026 16:38

sofaguarantee · 08/11/2026 16:25

And neither do you, which was my point too. The initial post read like someone focusing on an insignificant thing, with no sense of broader perspective.

I suspected once I pushed back that there would be a drip feed that I didn't know what I was talking about and that you had a host of other issues and I shouldn't asssume, etc etc. In that case the other issues you have are in fact relevant to the general principle.

"Is my 8 year old, who has x y z traumatic going on, ok to be on screens all day?" is a super different question to "is my 8 year old, who has nothing else going on, ok to be on screens all day? This bothers me only because I am weirdly perfectionist about screen time and parenting".

If you do indeed have other challenges - and I am honestly sorry to hear it if so - you do need to indicate it in your post. Because the advice. Is. Different. And now you have posted something partial, and I have responded as it upset me, and you have responded as you've now been upset in your turn by my response. There was no need for any of it really.

I responded purely to the initial post you made, which on its face looked like you were worrying about absolutely nothing.

You're right, there was no need for any of this. What a completely meaningless contribution.
Really odd.

OP posts:
sofaguarantee · 08/11/2026 16:25

Novemberusedtobemyfave · 08/11/2026 15:07

Jesus! You have zero idea about any problems we may have, which for context are many and i'm not going into them here. This post was about screen time, just that, it doesn't mean we have no other issues going on, we actually do, this is most definitely not the only thing to worry about, how bloody patronising!
Interestingly, my Dd does have an issue that is one you posted above and is related to my worry about excessive screen time too. That is something I didn't want to bring into it, a post can be about one thing, it does not cancel out all other possible issues that you are not privy to
Please do think before you post as you really have no idea about anyone's life.

And neither do you, which was my point too. The initial post read like someone focusing on an insignificant thing, with no sense of broader perspective.

I suspected once I pushed back that there would be a drip feed that I didn't know what I was talking about and that you had a host of other issues and I shouldn't asssume, etc etc. In that case the other issues you have are in fact relevant to the general principle.

"Is my 8 year old, who has x y z traumatic going on, ok to be on screens all day?" is a super different question to "is my 8 year old, who has nothing else going on, ok to be on screens all day? This bothers me only because I am weirdly perfectionist about screen time and parenting".

If you do indeed have other challenges - and I am honestly sorry to hear it if so - you do need to indicate it in your post. Because the advice. Is. Different. And now you have posted something partial, and I have responded as it upset me, and you have responded as you've now been upset in your turn by my response. There was no need for any of it really.

I responded purely to the initial post you made, which on its face looked like you were worrying about absolutely nothing.

TheChosenTwo · 08/11/2026 15:26

I really couldn’t get worked up about this but I wouldn’t do it, endless hours of staring at a screen for an 8 years old is too much imo.
I’d at least encourage her to come and play some card games or do some colouring with you for half an hour a few times during the day. Stick a film on or something that you can do together but doesn’t take any energy.