Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Husband thinks we’ve left baby 2 too late

343 replies

Leftittoolatenow · 07/11/2026 18:54

We have a 2 year old - since we had our 1st, I always said I wanted to a 3 year age gap. The main reason for me is DH works long hours and travels frequently so mainly I’m on my own which I’m absolutely happy with but I didn’t want 2 ‘babies’ and I thought by 3 then it’s more likely our child would be potty trained, can be a bit more independent, walk safely etc

Anyway DH wanted a smaller gap but ultimately would also be happy with 1 so didn’t really push it.

The issue now is that everyone we know has either had their 2nd or is pregnant with their 2nd and we just got the news that our last set of friends who were in the same boat of us is now pregnant. So we are the only couple still with 1 child.

DH is really cross and saying we’ve left it too late now, if we do have another one now then the children will never get on as the age gap is too big and said it will probably take us ages now as we are older… I still feel like a 3 year age gap is ok but I suppose I do have an element of feeling like we are being left behind a bit now.

AIBU to think that we haven’t left it too late ? I feel nervous now that if it doesn’t happen straight away he will just insist we stick with 1 child.

OP posts:
Kelly1969 · 08/11/2026 19:50

I think it’s an odd argument, 3 years is fine but you can never guarantee anything so I wouldn’t have been so rigid.
it doesn’t matter what your friends are doing, I don’t have any friends with similar aged kids, it shouldn’t be a consideration at all.
Hate to say it but fertility is never guaranteed so how can either of you be so rigid?

Marycontrarygarden · 08/11/2026 19:46

WTAF did I just read.....who the hell cares how many babies your friends have and how old they are. And excuse me, he's really "cross" about what?! And with who?! Madness.

Chillyegg · 08/11/2026 19:46

Just wanted to wade in and say your time line concerns are bonkers.
I'm 34 and pregnant with second child
My dc1 is 11 . She will be 12 two months after the baby is born.
Sometimes life happens , just try TTC if you wish if not don't . Your children will not be friends or close because of their age, it's the relationships you foster with them.

T

ChampagneLassie · 08/11/2026 19:44

i had my second at 41, it took us about 10 months but we didn’t actually manage to do the deed every month. I’ve got impaired fertility. Obviously everyone is different but you’ve no reason to assume you wouldn’t be fine

grrrlatrix · 08/11/2026 19:37

I have a four year age gap because I was so traumatised by birth 1 that I swore I was never ever having children again.

It worked out great.

kindyetfirm84 · 08/11/2026 19:34

Firstly, it doesn't matter what your friends are doing. Secondly, my second child died midway through pregnancy, and I had to wait another 12 years before I became pregnant with my third. So please try and be happy with what you have, and stop trying to roll/fit in with the status quo.

UnbeatenMum · 08/11/2026 19:33

Why not take the view that there are positives about all age gaps? We had under 2 years and then a much bigger gap but every child was wanted and brought joy to our family.

seahorsessky · 08/11/2026 19:33

Are you meaning you think he doesn't want another now? I'm trying to get what you mean by he's "cross", because if you've not been trying, it's not going to be sadness or anger at not managing? I'd think carefully if you feel he's unsure, because there can be more problems/issues with later pregnancies (not always, but sadly I do talk from experience), so maybe he just wants you to both enjoy what you have, and if you feel you're different from friends, do you really want to start all over again, with another, and be changing nappies/potty training when school starts? Not that I feel you should judge yourself by friends, but from your post, I'm not sure if you just think you're "supposed" to have another but maybe neither of you does now?

MyLittleNest · 08/11/2026 19:32

Your husband is so ridiculous, I am annoyed just reading this.

Shufflebumnessie · 08/11/2026 19:18

I always thought we'd have a 2-3 year age gap between baby 1 & 2. However, due to DS suffering unforeseen serious illness and dealing with the aftermath of that, our two ended up being 5 years apart.
DS & DD get on phenomenally well and thankfully hardly ever squabble, they're 14 & 9 now. I'm hopefully that their relationship will always be like that.
You absolutely have not left it too late and your DH is being ridiculous!

Snaketime · 08/11/2026 19:16

I have a 3 year age gap between my 2 and they get on well. They argue a bit more now my DD is a tween as obviously younger brother are just "so annoying" but they get on more than they don't and her friends include him and vice versa.

Candyfloss1985 · 08/11/2026 19:07

If it helps I had mine at 39 now 41, partner has a daughter now 20 and they absolutely adore each other. Your still young no need to rush at all just think of all the energy you have for your 1 rather than splitting it between 2 and being drained. It is not a race it’s called being sensible to what you personally can manage.

GreyCarpet · 08/11/2026 19:06

There are 7 and a half years between mine. It wasn't the plan, just how life turned out.

They've always been close. They're now 27 and 20 and I can't imagine how they could be closer, tbh.

How close they are has far more to do with their personalities/characteristics, how you raise them and how well you foster a relationship between them than any age gap.

What your friends are doing is irreelwvant.

ImagineImagine · 08/11/2026 19:02

It’s not a race, and you’re not in a competition with your friends. Three years is a perfect gap, I have that between my 1st and 2nd and it worked well for all the reasons you stated. Then there’s 6yrs between 2 and 3 ( loss and just took a while) then 2.5yrs between 3&4. Eldest was 12 when youngest was born. They still have a good bond even though they’re at very different stages of their lives. Unfortunately however I feel your husband is using this as an excuse not to have baby no.2. You need to talk to him and see if this is the case then decide if you feel ok about it.

Gonners · 08/11/2026 18:55

My sister is almost 8 years younger than me - 7 years 10 months, to be precise. I can't say I appreciated the compulsory babysitting when she was about 8-10, as she was a nightmare, but I left home, we got over it and we get on fine now (she is on the other side of the world, which possibly helps). Her two kids are about 3 years apart, which is absolutely nothing and a perfectly sensible gap.

Blackcat2026 · 08/11/2026 18:51

Jesus, lots of people have bigger age gaps. Sometimes there's less competition between the kids with a slightly bigger gap.

What Your friends are doing is irrelevant. The age hap is a complete non-issue here and I suspect he just doesn't want another. Instead of just staying that, he's trying to make out you've done something wrong. Nice.

SuperSue77 · 08/11/2026 18:34

Leftittoolatenow · 07/11/2026 18:59

I’m 33, my husband is a few years older - we got super lucky first time and conceived straight away but I suppose we might not be soo lucky that time.

A few of my friends have conceived quicker than expected and got a smaller gap than they wanted.

My DH and I fell pregnant with our first much quicker than we expected, and had same with number 2, so hopefully it will be the same for you. He's an idiot to be angry about this. My kids age gap is roughly 3 years and it works for us.

Cetim · 08/11/2026 18:34

The longer he moans about how long you have left it the longer the gap will be. I have 4 year age gap and all was well. It was nice because the older was in preschool when I had the baby so I got to sepmd time with the baby.

Franpie · 08/11/2026 18:27

Your DH is talking out of his arse. You have no way of predicting whether your children will play together and be close regardless of how close they are in age.

I have a 20 month gap and my youngest has always adored his big sister but she has always found him annoying! Only now that they are 15 and 17 are they close. It’s literally just happened in the last 6 months or so.

Trottersup · 08/11/2026 18:25

He's really cross? What a nob.

Mcdhotchoc · 08/11/2026 18:24

Your dh doesn't want another child and just needs to be honest about it.

ByRealLemonFox · 08/11/2026 18:21

I have a 3 year gap between my oldest 2 and the no.3 came along 10 years later. It doesn't matter about your friend what they are doing. I have some great friends from children 1&2 and an ever better one with no.3.

mtobrokeme · 08/11/2026 18:21

Your husband is talking shite. There’s 4.5 years between me and my sister and we’re as close as you get.

Also, I find it really odd that so much of your post talks about what your mates are doing. Why’s it matter?

5128gap · 08/11/2026 18:20

Sounds like your H doesn't want a second child and is using the age gap business to avoid it. Firstly with a suggestion at an interval that you didn't want, and now making an extra year a deal breaker. You need to talk to him to establish whether this is the case.

Latteapparel · 08/11/2026 18:14

Almost 5 years between my sister and I and we are the very best of friends, we got on brilliantly as children too.

Swipe left for the next trending thread