Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Husband thinks we’ve left baby 2 too late

343 replies

Leftittoolatenow · 07/11/2026 18:54

We have a 2 year old - since we had our 1st, I always said I wanted to a 3 year age gap. The main reason for me is DH works long hours and travels frequently so mainly I’m on my own which I’m absolutely happy with but I didn’t want 2 ‘babies’ and I thought by 3 then it’s more likely our child would be potty trained, can be a bit more independent, walk safely etc

Anyway DH wanted a smaller gap but ultimately would also be happy with 1 so didn’t really push it.

The issue now is that everyone we know has either had their 2nd or is pregnant with their 2nd and we just got the news that our last set of friends who were in the same boat of us is now pregnant. So we are the only couple still with 1 child.

DH is really cross and saying we’ve left it too late now, if we do have another one now then the children will never get on as the age gap is too big and said it will probably take us ages now as we are older… I still feel like a 3 year age gap is ok but I suppose I do have an element of feeling like we are being left behind a bit now.

AIBU to think that we haven’t left it too late ? I feel nervous now that if it doesn’t happen straight away he will just insist we stick with 1 child.

OP posts:
MeowDoku · 07/11/2026 20:18

There is a 2 year gap between me and my brother, we have nothing in common, no beef but we're not close and haven't been really ever. My best friend has a brother ten years older and they are very close. DS is an only but there are lots of 4 plus year age gaps with his friends, two lots of nursery fees was a lot until the new funding came in for the younger ones

SunnyWasp · 07/11/2026 20:18

We had a 3 year age gap. Would have been slightly shorter but we had a loss in between. 3 years has been absolutely amazing.

  • meant I was on maternity so my 3 year old could switch to a term time only pre school with shorter days which were covered by free hours. But also I could have 1:1 time with the baby.
  • she was potty trained, could get herself dressed, fairly amenable and responsible
  • now he’s 18 months and she’s 4.5 and they are absolute best friends, the age gap is not an issue because they can play together things like dancing, toy kitchen, football etc. he just goes along with what she wants. She’s been at school all day so has plenty of stimulation with kids her own age and is happy to ‘dumb down’ her play to play with him and just be silly and physical with him

I’m now a SAHM anyway, but friends who’ve had 3/4 year gaps have also enjoyed being on maternity/ part time as the eldest has started school and been able to support that transition.

chaosmaker · 07/11/2026 20:18

@Leftittoolatenow Does your husband actually want a 2nd kid?

HRTtoHeart · 07/11/2026 20:17

About 3 years is a great age gap - time to focus attention on each baby/toddler, close enough to get on when they get a bit older, and not have two in nursery or in university at the same time.

Mariposa79729 · 07/11/2026 20:15

Fupoffyagrasshole · 07/11/2026 19:01

He’s being ridiculous - so many in my circle have near 4 years of an age gap as nobody could afford 2 in nursery at the same time 🤷‍♀️

it’s a normal age gap

This! Almost everyone I know is doing this (including me!)

hendricks79 · 07/11/2026 20:12

There's 5 years between my ds's and they get on brilliantly and always have

notacooldad · 07/11/2026 20:09

What ever the age gap is it is not a guarantee that they will get on. There is 18 months between my brother and sister and those two don't get on,never have. They are in their 50s now. There's 3 years between my two. Sometimes they get on,sometimes they dont. Age gaps has nothing to do with compatability.

Besidemyselfwithworry · 07/11/2026 20:09

Leftittoolatenow · 07/11/2026 18:54

We have a 2 year old - since we had our 1st, I always said I wanted to a 3 year age gap. The main reason for me is DH works long hours and travels frequently so mainly I’m on my own which I’m absolutely happy with but I didn’t want 2 ‘babies’ and I thought by 3 then it’s more likely our child would be potty trained, can be a bit more independent, walk safely etc

Anyway DH wanted a smaller gap but ultimately would also be happy with 1 so didn’t really push it.

The issue now is that everyone we know has either had their 2nd or is pregnant with their 2nd and we just got the news that our last set of friends who were in the same boat of us is now pregnant. So we are the only couple still with 1 child.

DH is really cross and saying we’ve left it too late now, if we do have another one now then the children will never get on as the age gap is too big and said it will probably take us ages now as we are older… I still feel like a 3 year age gap is ok but I suppose I do have an element of feeling like we are being left behind a bit now.

AIBU to think that we haven’t left it too late ? I feel nervous now that if it doesn’t happen straight away he will just insist we stick with 1 child.

My kids are 14, 11 and 7 (nearly 8)
3 years between them all
it’s fine they get on really well

don’t worry about what everyone else is doing, do what is right for you.

RoseandGrace · 07/11/2026 20:09

You are really over thinking this, well your DH is because siblings will literally have no other experience instead of the one they get given so the age gap doesn’t exactly matter because not every family is the same!

Im 33 and I have a 16 year old a 12 year old (girls) who get on great and I’m 28 weeks pregnant with #3! (Boy)

#3 was IVF and took us 6 years but the gap would have still been quite substantial!

diddl · 07/11/2026 20:07

If husband seriously wanted a smaller age gap perhaps he could have looked at ways to make that workable for you?

He sounds very odd!

So if you don't fall pregnant within a certain time will he want to stop ttc rather than have a bigger age gap than he would like?

Weirdpig · 07/11/2026 20:07

The best age gap is the one you get. There's no point in thinking anything else.

MindBlip · 07/11/2026 20:06

Omg if this is the sort of thing that makes your DH "really cross" he must have had a charmed life so far. You both need to take a chill pill.

Yanbu for wanting a decent gap between them if you manage on your own a lot, but you both need to get a grip with all the micromanaging and copying your friends.

SapphireSteel28 · 07/11/2026 20:05

My DD now 22 and DS18 have always got on extremely well and been very close despite a 4 year and 4 month age gap.

TruJay · 07/11/2026 20:04

That’s crazy, a 3 year gap is nothing. Some people can plan their families to exactly what they want and some can’t.
The gap between my two eldest is larger than it was supposed to be due to an early second trimester miscarriage. Then what life threw at us since that regarding family planning meant we also have a 10 year gap between them and baby number 3. It’s just the way things went.

I think people with any arrangement of age gaps will have pros and cons of each but really all you can do is talk about the age gaps you have personally with the children you were given. I think children’s personalities matter hugely regarding sibling bonds, not so much their ages. Every circumstance is entirely unique.

If you both want a second baby, just start trying now and the gap you get is the gap you get. A lot of my friends have two babies very close together. I adored being with my eldest on his own for 4 years before baby 2 arrived. I’d take him to his preschool mornings and then have a few hours with the baby before picking him back up and having our afternoons altogether. That first year of having two was so wonderful and a fond memory.

Then having older children and a baby has (for us) again been wonderful, everyone told me it wasn’t a good idea and we had so many unsolicited opinions.
Do what is right for your family.

SuzyCoo · 07/11/2026 20:03

you are absolutely not being unreasonable but your husband has made his feelings clear. it ultimately comes down to how you can communicate and care for each other.

Notellinganyone · 07/11/2026 20:02

I had a four year gap between my three - it’s fine and you’re still young.

Evidentally · 07/11/2026 20:01

Me and my DSis are 18 months apart and barely speak. We were NEVER close as kids, despite having a loving home and a happy childhood. The 'right' age gap is meaningless. We had no natural closeness whatsoever.

I'm 5 years older than my other sibling and we've always been really, really close. They're my best friend as adults.

With my own DC, exactly the same. The closer the age gap, the wider the closeness 'gap'!

It's personalities, basically.

ILoveKits · 07/11/2026 20:00

@Leftittoolatenow one doesn't necessarily get to chose the gap. We got three years, five months and certainly didn't.

However, it meant I never had to do heavy duty childcare. The children adore each other. Theynare 28 and 31 now.

TY78910 · 07/11/2026 19:57

What does your DH know about age gaps? Mine are 4y apart and they’re inseparable

Peonies12 · 07/11/2026 19:57

Jrisix · 07/11/2026 19:48

Apparently “in the wild” for humans the natural age gap between babies is about 4 years. Mine are exactly 2 years apart and in hindsight it was too close together, very tough in the early years.

This is what I was reading about recently! Particularly with it being common to breastfeed longer as other food limited / unsafe water. Seems very sensible to me i do not get this current obsession around me with having 2 under 2. Mine is 2 and it is more than enough

Peonies12 · 07/11/2026 19:55

Your husband is being ridiculous. You are absolutely right to wait until you are ready given you do the majority of the parenting work. Are you even sure you want / can handle another? It’s ridiculous to make your family’s decisions because of what others are doing. There is no guarantee siblings with any age gap will get on. But everyone I know thats had a bigger age gap (4 years) has found it much easier as the oldest is more emotional developed; no naps or nappies, can sit and play themselves more happily.

noworklifebalance · 07/11/2026 19:55

You are both massively over thinking it - age gaps, which month they will be born etc.
Assuming no imminent major change in finance or health that can be forseen, then there is usually no perfect time to have a baby and no perfect age gap.

Allswellthatendswelll · 07/11/2026 19:54

3- 4 years is called nature's gap because it is the gap you would have with pre industrial birth spacing (can't be bothered to go into it too much but based on work of antrapologists!). It is better for your body and arguably the children.

We started ttc when DC1 was 18 months, I freaked out because it took ages and loads of friends got pregnant with a two year gap. Finally got pregnant when DC1 was 3 and then really enjoyed the almost 4 year gap plus met loads of people with a 3.5- 5 year gap- turns out its really common.

Sounds like DH has gone off baby no 2 idea and is finding excuses?

FancyKitten · 07/11/2026 19:52

Get in there. Have that baby. Stop thinking about it. Do not mention TTC or Baby Dancing… Put on sexy knickers, job done!

tarheelbaby · 07/11/2026 19:51

Apologies but ... My high-speed read is that he's lost his taste for fatherhood and is not keen on Baby2 so he's trying to put you off by blaming the age gap - utter rubbish.

But perhaps a reason not to have another DC with this man-baby b/c you will be carrying the full load.

If YOU want more DCs, go for it; the gaps will sort themselves. Your reasoning for a 3yr gap is good. My DD1 was fully potty-trained and could walk everywhere plus had outgrown the rear-facing car seat and lots of clothes/toys. We re-used everything but were still geared for small children and babies.

People have age gaps of all lengths and everyone manages. My DDs have 3yrs and 1 day! They were fast friends from the start and are still as close as jam on toast.
DSis and I have a 3.5yr gap - we talk and text frequently.