Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think my son isn't fat

210 replies

GeorgeandTimmy21 · 07/11/2026 15:09

I know lots of parents are in denial about this sort of thing but I honestly don't think I am. He is 18 years old, wearing size medium t shirts and 34 inch waist trousers. He weighs 11 stone and I'm not sure exactly how tall he is, less than 6ft but not much less. He runs 10k 2 times a week and 5k 2 times a week. My MIL thinks he is fat (for context my MIL is a size 18).

OP posts:
Soontoomuch · 07/11/2026 18:26

My DH is 6ft and weighs11st 8lbs and is skinny (over 80ys)

DuckFilledPlatitude · 07/11/2026 18:33

His BMI is within a healthy range, plus it sounds as though his lifestyle generally is healthy, so what your MIL thinks is a. incorrect and b. none of her business anyway.

Chilihealer · 07/11/2026 19:01

Next time maybe just say ‘yeah he is isn’t he, he must get it from your side’. Should put a stop to it all, sometimes you just have to respond to rude with rude. I wouldn’t say those measurements equal fat personally and he’s definitely healthy running 4 times a week, tell her to fuck off.

Namezerchangezer · 07/11/2026 19:15

I bought my 16 year old size 34 waste trousers for school this year and they are massive on him, he’s 5 11 and has always had a good amount of meat on him. Fat isn’t a slur we are all different sizes, it’s not a measure of someone’s value.

Boreded · 07/11/2026 19:27

ThatChirpyScroller · 07/11/2026 18:06

nope I still disagree, all it takes into account is height and weight, there’s so many more variables than that even without muscle.

Well, that’s nice for you, but unfortunately the medical profession and decades of peer-reviewed research would suggest you’re wrong. Nobody claims BMI is a perfect measure of individual health, but its limitations are already well understood and accounted for. I’m not entirely sure why you think pointing them out is some sort of revelation that has escaped the attention of medical researchers.

Newsenmum · 07/11/2026 19:45

is he slim all over but carry a tiny bit on his belly?
anyway not that it matters, wtf is wrong with this women why is she telling you this?

Oxaloacetate · 07/11/2026 20:14

ThatChirpyScroller · 07/11/2026 17:51

yes, I have visible abs and have weight trained for 18 years, I also run 4 times a week.

You’re basing this on BMI and it’s totally ancient, the NHS need to stop using it.

Something new is being developed - it’s in the works. It includes certain measurements that split people into ‘clinical obesity’ and ‘preclinical obesity’ which essentially defines if your weight over the BMI boundary is due to something that is clinically significant to your health or not. It looks at actual risk to health rather than just weight.

The Lancet Diabetes & Endocrinology Commission released it last year.

ThatChirpyScroller · 07/11/2026 20:45

Boreded · 07/11/2026 19:27

Well, that’s nice for you, but unfortunately the medical profession and decades of peer-reviewed research would suggest you’re wrong. Nobody claims BMI is a perfect measure of individual health, but its limitations are already well understood and accounted for. I’m not entirely sure why you think pointing them out is some sort of revelation that has escaped the attention of medical researchers.

the nhs is decades behind, it’s woeful.

ThatChirpyScroller · 07/11/2026 20:47

Oxaloacetate · 07/11/2026 20:14

Something new is being developed - it’s in the works. It includes certain measurements that split people into ‘clinical obesity’ and ‘preclinical obesity’ which essentially defines if your weight over the BMI boundary is due to something that is clinically significant to your health or not. It looks at actual risk to health rather than just weight.

The Lancet Diabetes & Endocrinology Commission released it last year.

Boreded should read this one

somanychristmaslights · 07/11/2026 20:50

Even if he’s not fat, he’d still saying that is bang out of order! I’d be saying something along the lines of pot calling the kettle black.

Yogafiend · 07/11/2026 20:58

twoyearsleft · 07/11/2026 15:15

I would say waist 34 is entering being a bit fat.

My 18 yr old is 6ft 4” with a 30” waist.

This is not necessarily correct. My husband is 6ft4 inches as well and his waist can be between 33 and 36 depending on how much he is doing at the gym. And he’s not fat at all. I would probably consider your son very slim. My BIL for example is slightly shorter than my husband and he’s a 32 inch waist and he’s slim.

MandemChickenShop · 07/11/2026 21:28

something amiss here, an 18 yr old, running 4 times a week to 30km total, doesn't drink alcohol, eats well.

no way should he have a 34 inch waist.

Thats something for men in the 40s.

Boreded · 07/11/2026 23:42

ThatChirpyScroller · 07/11/2026 20:45

the nhs is decades behind, it’s woeful.

Yes, you’ve made your opinion of the NHS quite clear. But BMI isn’t something the NHS invented, nor is it something only the NHS uses. It’s an internationally recognised screening tool supported by decades of research.

Do you genuinely believe the entire international medical and scientific community has simply failed to notice the limitations you’ve identified?

Calling something outdated doesn’t make the evidence supporting it disappear.

Boreded · 07/11/2026 23:47

ThatChirpyScroller · 07/11/2026 20:47

Boreded should read this one

I’m already aware of the Lancet Commission’s recommendations, thank you. I’m also aware of what they actually mean.

They’re proposing a more comprehensive approach to diagnosing clinical obesity, using additional measurements and evidence of health impacts rather than relying on BMI alone.

What they’re not doing is declaring BMI obsolete or suggesting it has no value. In fact, they explicitly recommend retaining it as a screening tool and for assessing populations.

This is precisely the point I’ve been making. BMI has recognised limitations, particularly at an individual level, but that doesn’t invalidate decades of research demonstrating its usefulness.

The development of more sophisticated diagnostic criteria isn’t evidence that the existing science was wrong. It’s evidence of medical science continuing to evolve. That’s how research works.

Perhaps you should take your own advice and read the research you’re directing me towards. You might find it doesn’t support your argument quite as well as you think it does.

LaidOnYourBackWithTheBoyWithTheArabStrap · 07/11/2026 23:47

No idea if he’s fat but if he’s exercising regularly and isn’t eating only crap then he’s doing ok and your MIL should be firmly
told to stop making personal comments about his appearance as it’s very rude to do so.

ThatChirpyScroller · 07/11/2026 23:50

Boreded · 07/11/2026 23:47

I’m already aware of the Lancet Commission’s recommendations, thank you. I’m also aware of what they actually mean.

They’re proposing a more comprehensive approach to diagnosing clinical obesity, using additional measurements and evidence of health impacts rather than relying on BMI alone.

What they’re not doing is declaring BMI obsolete or suggesting it has no value. In fact, they explicitly recommend retaining it as a screening tool and for assessing populations.

This is precisely the point I’ve been making. BMI has recognised limitations, particularly at an individual level, but that doesn’t invalidate decades of research demonstrating its usefulness.

The development of more sophisticated diagnostic criteria isn’t evidence that the existing science was wrong. It’s evidence of medical science continuing to evolve. That’s how research works.

Perhaps you should take your own advice and read the research you’re directing me towards. You might find it doesn’t support your argument quite as well as you think it does.

you keep saying “recognised limitations” but plenty of people on this thread are clearly showing it’s not fit for purpose…. as do many people in the NHS, you can give me all the big wordy responses and research you want, I still think you’re wrong 😂

Boreded · 07/11/2026 23:53

ThatChirpyScroller · 07/11/2026 23:50

you keep saying “recognised limitations” but plenty of people on this thread are clearly showing it’s not fit for purpose…. as do many people in the NHS, you can give me all the big wordy responses and research you want, I still think you’re wrong 😂

Well, that’s settled then. A handful of Mumsnet anecdotes and your personal opinion outweigh decades of peer-reviewed scientific research. What a time to be alive. 😂

ThatChirpyScroller · 07/11/2026 23:56

Boreded · 07/11/2026 23:53

Well, that’s settled then. A handful of Mumsnet anecdotes and your personal opinion outweigh decades of peer-reviewed scientific research. What a time to be alive. 😂

you say scientific research but it’s body weight and height, hardly rocket science is it? hence why it’s not for for purpose… it’s about as useful as me looking at someone and saying “yeah you’re over weight”

it’s useful in the sense that someone 5ft 3 shouldn’t weigh 18 stone but common sense tells you the same thing

fridakahlosmoustache · 07/11/2026 23:57

He does sound rather well-covered, or fleshy.

Boreded · 08/11/2026 00:02

ThatChirpyScroller · 07/11/2026 23:56

you say scientific research but it’s body weight and height, hardly rocket science is it? hence why it’s not for for purpose… it’s about as useful as me looking at someone and saying “yeah you’re over weight”

it’s useful in the sense that someone 5ft 3 shouldn’t weigh 18 stone but common sense tells you the same thing

Blood pressure is just two numbers. Body temperature is just one. Neither gives us a complete picture of someone’s health, so shall we dismiss those too?

The scientific value of a measurement isn’t determined by how complicated it is to calculate, but by what decades of research tell us it can predict.

I’m genuinely amazed this needs explaining.

ThatChirpyScroller · 08/11/2026 00:04

Boreded · 08/11/2026 00:02

Blood pressure is just two numbers. Body temperature is just one. Neither gives us a complete picture of someone’s health, so shall we dismiss those too?

The scientific value of a measurement isn’t determined by how complicated it is to calculate, but by what decades of research tell us it can predict.

I’m genuinely amazed this needs explaining.

it doesn’t need explaining but you’re contradicting your self and it comes back to the very point that BMI in the context of this thread is pointless, it doesn’t tell us anything at all about whether they are fat or not and that’s the point

bigboykitty · 08/11/2026 00:10

fridakahlosmoustache · 07/11/2026 23:57

He does sound rather well-covered, or fleshy.

Mystic Meg has spoken 🔮

wordsfromthebathroom · 08/11/2026 00:25

Parents have been shown to be bad at identifying their own kid as overweight. So who knows. But also in a way who cares? Your son gets plenty of exercise. BMI is imperfect but you can encourage a healthy lifestyle anyway like you probably already do. You might want to influence his diet (though he is, of course, an adult!) Does he eat enough fruit, veg and protein? If so… leave the rest whatever your MIL says. Probably not helpful for anyone to be over-focused on your very active young son’s weight.

Lilyhatesjaz · 08/11/2026 00:45

BMI may well be inaccurate but calculating it from the size of his trousers is even more inaccurate.
Shop sizes vary even for supposedly measured mens clothes, my DH has trousers in the same size from different shops some fit, some need a belt.
Also people wear their clothes differently, some wear them tighter than others.
Not that it really matters he sounds within nor weight and fit and healthy.

Tulipsriver · 08/11/2026 00:50

GeorgeandTimmy21 · 07/11/2026 17:14

The plan is to use this thread to work out how much to have a go at MIL when I see her tomorrow.

But it's irrelevant for that purpose?

Regardless of his size, your MIL was completely out of order to call him fat and you should tell her so.

How would she feel if you walked in and told her she looked fat?