Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think my son isn't fat

210 replies

GeorgeandTimmy21 · 07/11/2026 15:09

I know lots of parents are in denial about this sort of thing but I honestly don't think I am. He is 18 years old, wearing size medium t shirts and 34 inch waist trousers. He weighs 11 stone and I'm not sure exactly how tall he is, less than 6ft but not much less. He runs 10k 2 times a week and 5k 2 times a week. My MIL thinks he is fat (for context my MIL is a size 18).

OP posts:
DecafCoffeeIsPointless · 07/11/2026 16:59

GeorgeandTimmy21 · 07/11/2026 16:55

Just messaged Ds and he says he is 5ft 9.

I think his weight measurement is on the higher side for a young healthy person of that height.

Does he eat healthily and drink alcohol in moderation? Is he at work or college?

MIL should not be body shaming him though.

godmum56 · 07/11/2026 16:59

WilmaaFlintstone · 07/11/2026 15:18

Who cares?

He's an adult, you should've closed the conversation down immediately.

It's nothing to do with your MIL.

this. Irregardless she should keep her beak shut.

Thedam · 07/11/2026 17:01

GeorgeandTimmy21 · 07/11/2026 16:55

Just messaged Ds and he says he is 5ft 9.

So reckon on 5’8 in shoes

Bigtrapeze · 07/11/2026 17:08

OP, what is your plan if the many calculations of Mumsnet decide he does meet the criteria of 'fat'? Men's waist sizes are weird. DH is 5'10ish and was very thin at 11 stone when training for his first marathon and yet still needed a 33/4 inch waist. He is now 12 stone something, not fat at all and still requires a 34 inch waist. It doesn't seem straightforward, as all the discussion in this thread has revealed.

Boreded · 07/11/2026 17:12

I mean this has to be some kind of joke right?

He is just under 6 ft and weighs 11 stone…so basically the exact mid point of the healthy range for BMI?

I’m now here for the comments, and it hasn’t disappointed with someone already calling him fat!

GeorgeandTimmy21 · 07/11/2026 17:12

He is at university. He doesn't drink alcohol and he eats fairly healthy. He eats mainly easy food so frozen food rather than fresh but it includes vegetables and salad etc and he doesn't eat much chocolate, sweets etc. He finds overeating or eating a lot of sugar impacts his running so he is quite careful about what he eats.

OP posts:
GreaterCassowary · 07/11/2026 17:13

Boreded · 07/11/2026 17:12

I mean this has to be some kind of joke right?

He is just under 6 ft and weighs 11 stone…so basically the exact mid point of the healthy range for BMI?

I’m now here for the comments, and it hasn’t disappointed with someone already calling him fat!

I'm not saying he's fat (I have no idea whether he's fat or not) but 5'9" isn't just under 6 foot.

mondaytosunday · 07/11/2026 17:14

My son is 5’11” 30in waist and athletic, weighs about 74kg (11.5 stones). No way in any sense of the word is he fat. You can be overweight and still run though, your son sounds about average with a waist just at the top end of ideal waist to height.
Tell your MIL she shouldn’t be commenting on people’s bodies, fat, slim or average.

GeorgeandTimmy21 · 07/11/2026 17:14

Bigtrapeze · 07/11/2026 17:08

OP, what is your plan if the many calculations of Mumsnet decide he does meet the criteria of 'fat'? Men's waist sizes are weird. DH is 5'10ish and was very thin at 11 stone when training for his first marathon and yet still needed a 33/4 inch waist. He is now 12 stone something, not fat at all and still requires a 34 inch waist. It doesn't seem straightforward, as all the discussion in this thread has revealed.

The plan is to use this thread to work out how much to have a go at MIL when I see her tomorrow.

OP posts:
GreaterCassowary · 07/11/2026 17:16

GeorgeandTimmy21 · 07/11/2026 17:14

The plan is to use this thread to work out how much to have a go at MIL when I see her tomorrow.

Well, she shouldn't be commenting on his body regardless of whether he's overweight or not. 11 stone is within the healthy range for his height and he sounds fit and active so even if he's not the 'ideal' shape/body fat percentage, I'd be telling her to jog on.

twoyearsleft · 07/11/2026 17:16

He’s still in the healthy weight range but wearing waist 34 does suggest he’s a bit podge around the middle. He’s not very tall so a bit of extra weight tends to be more noticeable.

I could put on another stone and a half and still be in the healthy weight range but that would put me up 3 dress sizes and I would definitely be fat.

Shortbreadel · 07/11/2026 17:17

Who cares?

twoyearsleft · 07/11/2026 17:18

GreaterCassowary · 07/11/2026 17:16

Well, she shouldn't be commenting on his body regardless of whether he's overweight or not. 11 stone is within the healthy range for his height and he sounds fit and active so even if he's not the 'ideal' shape/body fat percentage, I'd be telling her to jog on.

Edited

She may just be concerned for him.

ThatChirpyScroller · 07/11/2026 17:18

too many people on here haven’t a clue. I’m 37, 5ft 10 and around 13 stone 12 and not fat, so if he’s 11 stone at that height I wouldn’t say he’s fat, it’s totally dependent on muscle mass and body composition. BMI is a terrible indicator, if he’s running 2 10ks a week then he’s relatively fit as well.

Minasama · 07/11/2026 17:18

When I was young the yardstick was “if you can pinch more than an inch” !
If he has jowls or flab round his middle he’s overweight.

Laurmolonlabe · 07/11/2026 17:19

Hard to say it depends how much of the coverage is muscle,try one of the scales with fat analysis and get MIL to get on it as well,that should settle things.

Apotofrealcoffee · 07/11/2026 17:20

GeorgeandTimmy21 · 07/11/2026 15:13

MIL called him fat. Haven't worked out his BMI. At a guess he is around 5ft 10inches.

I’m 11 stone 3 at 5 ft 9 and I would say I’m heading towards overweight. I also have boobs and flabby hips after my kids, your son shouldn’t have these and is much younger.

rwalker · 07/11/2026 17:20

Mystery solved op. States he’s got a pot belly so probably does look fat

twoyearsleft · 07/11/2026 17:20

ThatChirpyScroller · 07/11/2026 17:18

too many people on here haven’t a clue. I’m 37, 5ft 10 and around 13 stone 12 and not fat, so if he’s 11 stone at that height I wouldn’t say he’s fat, it’s totally dependent on muscle mass and body composition. BMI is a terrible indicator, if he’s running 2 10ks a week then he’s relatively fit as well.

You’re in the overweight category. Are you saying your 194 pounds is mainly muscle?

Pussygaloregalapagos · 07/11/2026 17:22

Weight wise no. 34in waist is quite big for a teenager. Has he got a belly? If he does weights it could be muscle. If he has flabby tummy then could try to lose it.

Boreded · 07/11/2026 17:26

GreaterCassowary · 07/11/2026 17:13

I'm not saying he's fat (I have no idea whether he's fat or not) but 5'9" isn't just under 6 foot.

Yeah I took so long to post my reply after typing it that it crossed over with the update 🫣 I got distracted.

Either way he still has a BMI of 22.7 so has almost a stone comfort room before he gets to overweight. AND is only 7lbs above the absolute midpoint at 11st

Manxexile · 07/11/2026 17:26

I'm a man.

When i was 18 I was 5'10", 10 and a half stone, and wore 28" or 30" waist jeans

I'm now almost 70 and wear 36" M&S chinos. I weigh 86kg. I'm fat and overweight.

I still run about 15 miles a week. (but slower than I did when I was 18)

Being fit doesn't mean you aren't fat.

Being fat doesn't mean you aren't fit

Being fat doesn't necessarily mean you aren't healthy - but it doesn't help

An 18 year old male weighing about 11 stone and under 6' tall with 34 " waist is probably overweight. Should have more upper torso mass and a smaller waist

NotAtMyAge · 07/11/2026 17:29

Tell your MIL that muscle weighs more than fat and an active 18 year-old at 5'10 and 11 stone is just about where he should be.

Thedam · 07/11/2026 17:30

GeorgeandTimmy21 · 07/11/2026 17:14

The plan is to use this thread to work out how much to have a go at MIL when I see her tomorrow.

Seriously? Mumsnet determines you and your husband’s interactions with your DH’s mother?

HisNibs · 07/11/2026 17:30

Assuming he's 5'10" (or 70"), a waist measurement of less than 35" is good. At 18, I was 5'10", weighed 10st 7lb but did have a 30" waist. I was thin. 34" is nothing to be mithering about, MIL should be keeping her trap shut.

ETA - just seen the update that he' 5'9". Still no issue at all. His BMI is 22.7 and well below the "overweight" classification of 25. He's not even close to being fat. What is concerning is that nan has decided that she needs to interfere - I'd be giving it to her both barrels.