Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Shappi Khorsandi says Brand raped her friend

209 replies

SidmouthSummer · 07/11/2026 08:19

This interview of Shappi Khorsandi discussing Brand is interesting to watch.
She describes his unpleasant character in the first few minutes.
At 9 mins in she says Brand doesn't understand consent.
At 9:43 she says he raped her friend.

- YouTube

Enjoy the videos and music that you love, upload original content and share it all with friends, family and the world on YouTube.

https://youtu.be/REm7idI-ifU?is=sUJrgShCZpK0Y3SN

OP posts:
Thread gallery
10
Bowies · 08/11/2026 00:15

MrsRobinsonsHandprints · 07/11/2026 14:29

Now Russell Brand's been convicted of rape, we need to talk about Sylvie Berki. Because she can't speak for herself.

In 2014, Ms Berki said she'd been assaulted by Russell Brand.

But if she talks about it, even now, she risks jail.

Why?

Because Brand (and his then-girlfriend, Jemima Goldsmith) obtained a permanent, life-long, injunction against her.

Brand/Goldsmith said Ms Berki's accusations amounted to harassment, which caused them "anxiety and distress".

We can't see the final injunction, but we can see an interim injunction. It is insane. Berki was forbidden from telling anyone. The only exceptions: Thames Valley Police (to challenge its decision), and lawyers (if involved in the proceedings).

How could this be granted?

Because Ms Berki had no legal representation. Mr Brand had plenty.

You won't find a copy of the judgment anywhere - it was a summary judgment, without a trial. Ms Berki had no representation.

The judge apparently relied on inconsistencies in Berki's changing account and his assessment of her motives.

But how could he assess her credibility and motives, without hearing her evidence tested at trial?

Particularly when she had no lawyer? inforrm.org/2015/11/03/case-law-brand-v-berki-summary-judgment-granted-in-harassment-claim/

This was basically a nasty legal trick. Brand initially threatened libel. But libel law almost never lets you get an interim injunction to silence someone. So Brand's lawyers turned it into a harassment claim. It would never have worked if Ms Berki had had a lawyer.

So what precisely did Ms Berki allege? There's little in the UK press. But there was extensive coverage in the Hungarian press: 24.hu/szorakozas/2014/08/04/vilagsztar-akarta-szexre-kenyszeriteni-szilviat

I don't know if her accusations are true. But I do know Ms Berki should be able to talk about it. A police refusal to prosecute should not result in state-imposed silence.

I doubt Ms Berki has the resources to apply to lift the injunction. She probably can't crowdfund without breaching the injunction. So we'll never hear from her.

Unless...

Witnesses to Parliamentary Committees have absolute parliamentary immunity.

If the House of Women and Equalities Committee called Ms Berki as a witness then she'd be unconstrained by the injunction.

And, for the first time in eleven years, we could hear her side of the story.

I remember the case, there was quite a bit in the U.K. press at the time. It should be revoked after the recent verdict.

Lalgarh · 08/11/2026 00:38

BrandiedAromatics · 07/11/2026 21:23

Yes, it was reported at the time that Khan had arranged this for Brand's birthday, is it just because Ms Berki didn't communicate well with the police as opposed to this powerful, wealthy couple:

Judge tells masseuse to stop harassing Russell Brand and Jemima Khan | Russell Brand | The Guardian
and an archived article:
Judge tells masseuse to stop harassing Russell Brand and Jemima Khan | Culture | The Guardian

Edited

Jemima had originally also contributed to Bail for Julian Assange on his rape charge but had fallen out with him by the mid 2010s.

House12 · 08/11/2026 00:49

Boomer55 · 07/11/2026 15:41

Best she tells the police then, and not the media.

Ever cross your mind that she did?

UnjustifiedAncient · 08/11/2026 01:37

Someone upthread mentioned Brand attended NA meetings.

He actually had proper legend/guru status in NA, AA and other 12-step circles for years and years, which is highly concerning.

I saw him speak at a meeting once and he gave me the absolute fucking creeps. It was an online meeting, and he was lying in bed in his palatial US home, like it was an interview with a rockstar and not a meeting for recovering addicts, many of whom will have been in the early stages of recovery and extremely vulnerable.

He so obviously thrived on having this ‘special’ status and loved the sound of his own voice.

It didn’t sit right with me at all. No humility, just ego ego ego. He didn’t sound like someone who had overcome his demons AT ALL.

LauderSyme · 08/11/2026 02:23

Meredusoleil · 07/11/2026 16:48

Is that DW or ML?

Matt Lucas is openly gay so whilst it isn't impossible for him to be accused of sexually assaulting numerous women, it isn't likely.

Cordeliasdemonbabies · 08/11/2026 08:02

LoyalShaker · 07/11/2026 18:09

I too admire Shappi for her honesty and hope that many more women will come forward with their experiences. I also feel concerned for the women in Brand's trial that were not believed. Could it have anything to do with a male heavy jury?

It's likely not that the jury didn't believe them but there wasn't enough independent evidence of what happened. The rape he was convicted on had loads of other witnesses that the victim talked to about it at the time so a much higher standard of proof.

I reckon if it was civil court ie balance of probability he would have been convicted on all of it but if there is any doubt in criminal court you can't convict.

In some ways it's helpful he was cleared of some charges as it undermines his defence claim that he was stitched up by the media and didn't get a fair trial. Makes the inevitable appeal more difficult.

BrandiedAromatics · 08/11/2026 08:41

LauderSyme · 08/11/2026 02:23

Matt Lucas is openly gay so whilst it isn't impossible for him to be accused of sexually assaulting numerous women, it isn't likely.

Yes, what is upsetting though is that Brand and Walliams both cultivated a myth that they were gay - another technique for their harassment of women. See the video I shared last night of DW with Jonathan Ross (20.53 on this thread). Walliams was promoting his biography - Camp David, no less.

QuickHare · 08/11/2026 08:57

Poor Sapphi Khorsandi - I just watched the interview. It sounds like she feels weirdly guilty - even though she knows rationally that she's not responsible for the culture of comedy back then. It sounds such a cesspit.

ElonAteMyHamster · 08/11/2026 08:57

Overflowingbasket · 07/11/2026 21:16

I remember hearing SK speaking many years ago about her own appalling experiences from male comedians. It sounded like an utterly toxic culture. All the now woke, lefty male ( and female) comedians of a certain age must have known about this culture and kept quiet to protect their careers.

It’s interesting that “protecting your career” is constantly thrown as an accusation for not doing enough but many of us would do the same. I’ve kept quiet about male behaviour at work fowards me (and female bullying over the years) to protect my career - I have a mortgage to pay and kids to feed. Katherine Ryan said the same thing about not speaking up about Brand at the time - she knew it would end her career. It shouldn’t be the case but we live in the real world and sadly it is 😢.

Bethany83 · 08/11/2026 08:58

SidmouthSummer · 07/11/2026 08:19

This interview of Shappi Khorsandi discussing Brand is interesting to watch.
She describes his unpleasant character in the first few minutes.
At 9 mins in she says Brand doesn't understand consent.
At 9:43 she says he raped her friend.

Thank you for sharing this O.P.

Sp powerful and eye opening. Shappi has been so helpful in explaining the reality of the consequences of this behavior.

MrsRobinsonsHandprints · 08/11/2026 09:00

ElonAteMyHamster · 08/11/2026 08:57

It’s interesting that “protecting your career” is constantly thrown as an accusation for not doing enough but many of us would do the same. I’ve kept quiet about male behaviour at work fowards me (and female bullying over the years) to protect my career - I have a mortgage to pay and kids to feed. Katherine Ryan said the same thing about not speaking up about Brand at the time - she knew it would end her career. It shouldn’t be the case but we live in the real world and sadly it is 😢.

I think this is important to note.

Especially when the people who had the power to stop it from happening without having repercussions were happy to promote it as they were chasing ratings/money.

SheilaFentiman · 08/11/2026 09:01

Well said @ElonAteMyHamster

Lalgarh · 08/11/2026 09:02

BrandiedAromatics · 07/11/2026 20:53

Yes, they do seem to know what each other are up to, from about 1.45:

//

It's so telling that the start of that, and his whole book Camp David was that he assumed he was gay, but then discovered acting camp could endear him to girls (who were reassured he wasn't just trying to get with girls. Unlike someone more laddish). Brand says more or less the same thing about his ex addict persona making him seem vulnerable

Beachtastic · 08/11/2026 09:30

QuickHare · 08/11/2026 08:57

Poor Sapphi Khorsandi - I just watched the interview. It sounds like she feels weirdly guilty - even though she knows rationally that she's not responsible for the culture of comedy back then. It sounds such a cesspit.

I think that's the thing about the culture at the time. It was heady and exciting. I remember Loaded magazine, at first, being like a breath of fresh air in the rather buttoned-up publishing world, cocking a snook at the establishment in a very post-punk way. It got darker and darker as the years went on. Many women are only just becoming aware of how it affected us. I was having a conversation with an old friend over the summer, and we compared notes on how our then-husbands treated us. Contempt for women was sewn into the whole design of how men were encouraged to feel and speak. The bit I really related to in the SK interview was her saying how she wanted to be brave and fierce, so cultivated a kind of determined stoicism in the face of insult. She is right that it makes a huge difference to the way we frame thing in our own minds, to have a different language for it nowadays.

HugADiamond · 08/11/2026 10:27

StillTheChickenRun · 07/11/2026 22:00

I so sorry this happened and you were hung out to dry by your colleagues and employers.

What appalling men.

The depressing thing is this treatment of women is so common, many of the men we think of as normal/nice are either these men or enabling/ignoring these men’s abuse.

Thanks . I reported what was going on to management when I noticed some boundary testing, remarks and space invasion. This was just brushed off as me not being able to take a joke and making a fuss about nothing . Looking back this emboldened the harasser and I think he was testing management as much as me . Back then there were no harassment laws , no cameras etc and police and employers didn’t / wouldn’t take it seriously as there were no consequences. Plus women weren’t believed and taken seriously back then . It was thought back then that women led men on . That’s why people such as Brand and Saville got away with things in plain sight .

HugADiamond · 08/11/2026 10:32

MrsRobinsonsHandprints · 08/11/2026 09:00

I think this is important to note.

Especially when the people who had the power to stop it from happening without having repercussions were happy to promote it as they were chasing ratings/money.

This would happen even today . People won’t stand up for others if they think they will lose their job and put their home at risk . Most people just put there heads down because if they speak up they are seen as a troublemaker and become a target .

StillTheChickenRun · 08/11/2026 10:33

HugADiamond · 08/11/2026 10:27

Thanks . I reported what was going on to management when I noticed some boundary testing, remarks and space invasion. This was just brushed off as me not being able to take a joke and making a fuss about nothing . Looking back this emboldened the harasser and I think he was testing management as much as me . Back then there were no harassment laws , no cameras etc and police and employers didn’t / wouldn’t take it seriously as there were no consequences. Plus women weren’t believed and taken seriously back then . It was thought back then that women led men on . That’s why people such as Brand and Saville got away with things in plain sight .

Yes. I worked no in a male dominated environment in the 00s and it was like that.

The depressing thing is that despite laws etc there are still many places where women are seen as the problem for existing while female and wanting to be free of harassment.

i hope you’ve found some peace (though that’s fairly tricky in the ongoing climate of misogyny).

ElonAteMyHamster · 08/11/2026 11:09

HugADiamond · 08/11/2026 10:32

This would happen even today . People won’t stand up for others if they think they will lose their job and put their home at risk . Most people just put there heads down because if they speak up they are seen as a troublemaker and become a target .

It happened to me last week. Senior manager using very inappropriate and offensive language in an open plan office - came off the phone and joked with a (female) senior manager about how everyone is professionally offended these days, should be ok to say that stuff, yada, yada. Lots of laughing.

The whole interaction made me incredibly uncomfortable but what can I do? I’m putting two kids through college and my dh is in redundancy talks 🤷‍♀️.

HRTQueen · 08/11/2026 11:19

It so depressing when things change for the better for woman and girls there is a push back in another way to keep us in our place

Talking with older colleagues in the 70’s and even in the 80’s it was common to get your bum slapped when I started work in the 90’s things had changed but I was too naive to understand the older men taking us out for lunch and drinks before telling us they had fallen for us 🙄 now they would be more careful. During the early 2000’s I was working in the city and the sexism was just out there but it had again changed I was offered in front of a whole team to spend the night with a guy for the £10k cash he had as he showed everyone the cash, they would talk about how lap dancers vaginas smelt and who would do a bit extra, these are the ones that stand out we reported to HR they were warned that was it as they made a lot of money for the com

Now I sit in meetings and even with really senior women in the room men so often take over the conversation and our support at work for women going through the menopause was just words it’s noticeable that few women of this age get promoted while that doesn’t happen with men

and while things may have improved in the workplace that young women have to deal with such aggressive harassment in public now and worry about what’s put on TikTok etc is just awful

It just feels like we have to fight back all the time it’s so depressing

EvieBB · 08/11/2026 12:02

Peppererr · 07/11/2026 15:29

NF too, I’m fairly certain.

NF?

EvieBB · 08/11/2026 12:40

Lalgarh · 08/11/2026 09:02

It's so telling that the start of that, and his whole book Camp David was that he assumed he was gay, but then discovered acting camp could endear him to girls (who were reassured he wasn't just trying to get with girls. Unlike someone more laddish). Brand says more or less the same thing about his ex addict persona making him seem vulnerable

05:58 - DW openly said he would draw them obscene drawings (in meetings, to amuse himself) - sounds like they were pretty young when he did this 😱

Lalgarh · 08/11/2026 13:34

EvieBB · 08/11/2026 12:02

NF?

I too would hope it's Fartage but it's likely

Bake Off Hello GIF by The Great British Bake Off
HugADiamond · 08/11/2026 13:42

StillTheChickenRun · 08/11/2026 10:33

Yes. I worked no in a male dominated environment in the 00s and it was like that.

The depressing thing is that despite laws etc there are still many places where women are seen as the problem for existing while female and wanting to be free of harassment.

i hope you’ve found some peace (though that’s fairly tricky in the ongoing climate of misogyny).

I utterly blame Management for what happened to me . When I reported it initially after being made to feel uncomfortable, a few stern words and it being made plain to the rest of the workforce this was not going to be tolerated would have probably put a stop to it . By brushing it off and making me out to be a spoilsport sent out a message that nothing would be done and things escalated from that moment on . I blame management for what happened with Saville and Brand . They were allowed to do it by people at the top so became emboldened and untouchable.

riceuten · 08/11/2026 14:21

BermudaRhombus · 07/11/2026 18:16

News Corp celebrated and promoted Brand for years. The Sun awarded him shagger of the year three times. They enabled the whole thing to the extent it was virtually symbiotic. Then they suddenly flip 360 and take him down. There is more to this than is apparent.

There's a lot of rightwing press around how Brand has been "taken down" due to his (cough) "religion" and politics, which is completely and utter rubbish. That all the rape and SA accusations are being either made up or exaggerated. Good luck with anyone prepared to die on that hill.