Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Shappi Khorsandi says Brand raped her friend

209 replies

SidmouthSummer · 07/11/2026 08:19

This interview of Shappi Khorsandi discussing Brand is interesting to watch.
She describes his unpleasant character in the first few minutes.
At 9 mins in she says Brand doesn't understand consent.
At 9:43 she says he raped her friend.

- YouTube

Enjoy the videos and music that you love, upload original content and share it all with friends, family and the world on YouTube.

https://youtu.be/REm7idI-ifU?is=sUJrgShCZpK0Y3SN

OP posts:
Thread gallery
10
MyDpsanarse · 07/11/2026 19:06

Let's be honest, in all walks of life there are men that think rising up the ranks in their job means they get to have free sexual access to women, especially young women, they think success equals the right to lean on women for sex. Even Brand's wife admits he's very promiscuous, it's not hard to believe that means a man who will take what he wants, with consent or not

pettingzoosforeveryone · 07/11/2026 19:06

Fortuity · 07/11/2026 18:58

Not really. There isn't, and couldn't be, any rule whereby summary judgment is never available if one of the parties doesn't have a lawyer. We haven't seen the evidence that the judge saw.

You haven't read any of the details, have you?

pettingzoosforeveryone · 07/11/2026 19:11

LoyalShaker · 07/11/2026 18:58

Which amounts to the same thing? If they were believed, then he would have been found guilty. How much evidence can you produce? It usually comes down to, who do you believe.

In the first rape complaint, there was some confusion about whether it occurred on the Thursday or the Friday and therefore whether the corroborating evidence supported the complaint or not.

I suspect that would have been enough for the jury to feel they couldn't be "sure" he was guilty, hence not guilty.

If that complaint was heard in a civil trial where the decision is made on the balance of probabilities (rather than beyond reasonable doubt), I wouldn't be surprised by a different outcome. So I don't think it's necessarily that they didn't believe her.

LoyalShaker · 07/11/2026 19:16

SheilaFentiman · 07/11/2026 19:05

Dear goddess, did you read anything about the trial? There WAS corroborating evidence for the guilty verdicts.

A civil case is balance of probabilities. If you think one party is 51% likely to be telling the truth, you can find in their favour. For a criminal case, beyond reasonable doubt is probably 95% or so. So being 80% percent sure is not enough, but thinking the defendant has a 20% possibility of being truthful isn’t “believing the defendant and disbelieving the victim”, by any stretch of the maths.

I bow to your obviously superior knowledge! The conviction rate is so low in rape cases and perhaps this needs looking at? I have been reading about the case and it seems that outdated assumptions were made about the women concerned. Commentators who were actually in the court, said that the women felt that it was themselves on trial because of the aggressive questioning by the defense.
By the way, whats with the goddess? I am just expressing my opinion, in the same way that you just have.

SavBlancinRecovery · 07/11/2026 19:18

Sorry if this has been posted already and I missed it. But Dan Neidle (tax associates) is someone shining a light on this dark sinister world and all praise to him for speaking up. He is an excellent investigative writer.

https://taxpolicy.org.uk/2026/11/07/russell-brand-secret-injunction/

I too feel like it’s people like Shappi and indeed Katherine Ryan who deserve praise for speaking about this disgusting “culture” in which brand had no accountability or boundaries. Even Bob Geldoff got it right in his description of RB calling him a “see you next Tuesday” 🤮

Russell Brand

Russell Brand’s secret injunction: the order that silenced his accuser

The never-published High Court order Russell Brand won in 2015: a lifelong gag on his accuser, Sylvie Berki, that bars her even from speaking to the police.

https://taxpolicy.org.uk/2026/11/07/russell-brand-secret-injunction/

SheilaFentiman · 07/11/2026 19:25

Commentators who were actually in the court, said that the women felt that it was themselves on trial because of the aggressive questioning by the defense.

The defence barrister was a shit bag who said to a journalist (Rosamund Urwin) after the verdict that she had “fucked it.” Urwin was the one who led on investigating for the 2023 programme about RB.

if anything is to be done in court, it’s judges giving less leeway for aggressive questioning. However, for “justice” to be done, the defendant should have a chance to question witnesses so it can be a fine line.

Apologies for being snappy in my prior post.

Beachtastic · 07/11/2026 19:29

I've posted this on another thread, but this documentary is well worth a watch to explain the toxicity of the culture back then.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/m002389y

Gail Porter is a poignant victim, I'd love to go back in time and wrap her in cotton wool.

Those times were brutal. And I was part of it. I remember seeing Sally Phillips in an Edinburgh Fringe comedy and slagging her off on the staircase because her role seemed so pointless. I cringe about this now because (a) she overheard me and (b) it was not her fault; she was given that role because women in comedy back then just didn't count.

BBC Four - Arena, Loaded: Lads, Mags and Mayhem

A nostalgic romp through the rise – and fall – of the 90s lads mag phenomenon.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/m002389y

worldshottestmom · 07/11/2026 19:29

God he's a fucking repulsive disgrace and that's putting it kindly. I hope he gets the same treatment in prison, though hopefully worse. For those who might say that violence doesn't fix violence, don't fight fire with fire etc., I say bollocks. I know enough people who only learn this way as it all that they know. It is so deeply ingrained into them that nothing else gets through. Until they have happen to them what they have done to others, they do not give their actions a second thought. So long as they get away with it (physically) unscathed, they don't care.

I always cry and get really angry listening to these accounts of sexual assault. As a victim of rape I just find it so hard to listen to and talk about. Even reading the word or writing it is hard for me. I didn't read anything containing the word for years and would physically leave conversations where it came up. I have checked online if films/tv shows contain sexual assualt scenes before deciding to watch them for last 11 years because of it.

But with time, and cases like these I have come to learn how deeply, deeply important it is to talk about it. They want us silent, they want us too scared to speak. I am so glad that his victims came forward and more are doing so now. Shaparak is such a wonderful woman, I adore her. Listening to that interview really hurt me. And for her friend to go through that at the hands of that fucking scruff, god. I want to burn the world down sometimes.

Now all the big names are getting put on the list. I cannot WAIT to witness their downfall and cheer every step of the way for their victims getting the justice they deserve.

SheilaFentiman · 07/11/2026 19:34

I’m so sorry that happened to you @worldshottestmom and I wish you strength throughout these awful cases

EmeraldShamrock000 · 07/11/2026 19:34

I find it very worrying that an alarming number of people —men— are defending Russel Brand.
I can’t stand him. When he stepped into the world of fake redemption and recovery from addiction, I could not watch any of his stuff. He always gave me weird vibes. Hopefully this will teach g others that the past can come back for justice.
Between Mike Tyson and Donald Trump, we are in the era where rape is only a short term stain on the character of the rapists.

worldshottestmom · 07/11/2026 19:38

SheilaFentiman · 07/11/2026 19:34

I’m so sorry that happened to you @worldshottestmom and I wish you strength throughout these awful cases

Thank you I really do appreciate that. I hope they are able to provide justice for all.

PerdreLeBleu · 07/11/2026 19:40

Sadly I watched Shappi’s interview and it was like she was describing my early years in the Police. I was indecently assaulted on more than one occasion by a 53 year old Police officer when I was 23. I was the only female and had no one I could talk to. In fact my boyfriend at tge time contacted my Sergeant to tell him and no one believed me and it was treated as one big joke until my Sergeant witnessed an assault. Pervert got a bollocking and told never to touch me again but I was never spoken to at all. That took place in amongst all the daily harassment and misogyny which was common place during that period day. Like Brand the officer in my case known as a pervert and again it was all treated as a big joke.

This whole situation makes me really angry. What Brand did didn’t occur in a vacuum. He was allowed to carry whilst, literally sometimes, people stood by and watched.

ScrollingLeaves · 07/11/2026 19:45

PerdreLeBleu · 07/11/2026 19:40

Sadly I watched Shappi’s interview and it was like she was describing my early years in the Police. I was indecently assaulted on more than one occasion by a 53 year old Police officer when I was 23. I was the only female and had no one I could talk to. In fact my boyfriend at tge time contacted my Sergeant to tell him and no one believed me and it was treated as one big joke until my Sergeant witnessed an assault. Pervert got a bollocking and told never to touch me again but I was never spoken to at all. That took place in amongst all the daily harassment and misogyny which was common place during that period day. Like Brand the officer in my case known as a pervert and again it was all treated as a big joke.

This whole situation makes me really angry. What Brand did didn’t occur in a vacuum. He was allowed to carry whilst, literally sometimes, people stood by and watched.

Part of the show.

Beachtastic · 07/11/2026 19:51

Beachtastic · 07/11/2026 19:29

I've posted this on another thread, but this documentary is well worth a watch to explain the toxicity of the culture back then.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/m002389y

Gail Porter is a poignant victim, I'd love to go back in time and wrap her in cotton wool.

Those times were brutal. And I was part of it. I remember seeing Sally Phillips in an Edinburgh Fringe comedy and slagging her off on the staircase because her role seemed so pointless. I cringe about this now because (a) she overheard me and (b) it was not her fault; she was given that role because women in comedy back then just didn't count.

Edited

Also, come to think of it, the comedian she was performing with said to my then-DH when I arrived "Can I fuck your wife?" I laughed it off, of course.

To say times have changed (thank god!) is an understatement.

I can echo @PerdreLeBleu 's accounts of working for the police back then. One of them made a point of throwing me over the desk every morning and dry-humping me.

JustAnotherWhinger · 07/11/2026 19:51

Fortuity · 07/11/2026 18:58

Not really. There isn't, and couldn't be, any rule whereby summary judgment is never available if one of the parties doesn't have a lawyer. We haven't seen the evidence that the judge saw.

We should not have a system that allows wealthy people with lawyers to silence, to the point of banning them from speaking to the police about a potential crime, someone who doesn’t have the means to have one.

Legal advice, free if necessary, should be offered to someone in that situation. Judges should have to show that someone actively declined any legal advice proper to a summary judgment if they have no lawyer.

Allowing rich people to continue their abuse through the legal system is abhorrent (also very common in family court) and simply should be stopped.

Mummyduckplusduckling · 07/11/2026 19:58

EmpathyMatters77 · 07/11/2026 14:54

Depends on their crime I guess.

I don’t know, there are few that I wouldn’t pity for having to share their daily existence with Brand!

NDfan · 07/11/2026 20:01

MrsRobinsonsHandprints · 07/11/2026 14:31

It is from this account - I think it is important to credit the people that are shining a light on this.

But if this is true then it shows again how the establishment has been complicit, and how money eases the way.

I agree it is laudable when people speak out against injustice.
However, it is difficult (for me personally anyway) to admire or support an individual who chose to use the Good Law Project to assist him in his own legal matters. Given that when someone funds his or her own defence, there are numerous sources of excellent advice and assistance, without resorting to using an organisation that actively persecutes women and speaks out so vocally about mens' rights.

thestudio · 07/11/2026 20:11

Katypp · 07/11/2026 17:50

Any other names you want to randomly chuck in the ring?
It's disgusting.

but not as disgusting as their craven lack of acknowledgment that - at the very least - they were happy to associate with a man that everyone knew was a predator.

Priorities, eh?

StillTheChickenRun · 07/11/2026 20:14

Thortour · 07/11/2026 14:58

Jenima Khan has apparently said she would allow the injunction to be overturned. But they would need Brand to agree to it as well.

While he’s in jail can his consent be suspended??

Mummyduckplusduckling · 07/11/2026 20:16

I put this into chat and asked it to explain it. Grim, absolutely grim.

User864753 · 07/11/2026 20:19

I worked in a very male dominated scientific field in the late 90s and early 2000s and everything Shappi says sounds so familiar. I was constantly sexually harassed by a coworker and nobody thought it was a big deal. The same guy propositioned a new hire and really upset her. She told me about it. I didn't even think of officially reporting it but I asked some of the 'nicer' guys to ask the harasser to leave her alone and the general consensus was that she needed to toughen up. I also heard stories that a couple of guys got another coworker drunk and persuaded her to have a threesome. I didn't know her well, but it seemed out of character for her, and now I think it was probably rape.

thestudio · 07/11/2026 20:21

Shappi ❤and 😡

Peppererr · 07/11/2026 20:32

thestudio · 07/11/2026 20:11

but not as disgusting as their craven lack of acknowledgment that - at the very least - they were happy to associate with a man that everyone knew was a predator.

Priorities, eh?

Exactly.

Fireants · 07/11/2026 20:35

I was the only woman (secretary) in an all male environment in 1979. One bloke would talk about how he got into my drawers. I opened the filing cabinet to retrieve his leave file. Luckily there were two men who told him to back off.

thestudio · 07/11/2026 20:52

MrsRobinsonsHandprints · 07/11/2026 14:29

Now Russell Brand's been convicted of rape, we need to talk about Sylvie Berki. Because she can't speak for herself.

In 2014, Ms Berki said she'd been assaulted by Russell Brand.

But if she talks about it, even now, she risks jail.

Why?

Because Brand (and his then-girlfriend, Jemima Goldsmith) obtained a permanent, life-long, injunction against her.

Brand/Goldsmith said Ms Berki's accusations amounted to harassment, which caused them "anxiety and distress".

We can't see the final injunction, but we can see an interim injunction. It is insane. Berki was forbidden from telling anyone. The only exceptions: Thames Valley Police (to challenge its decision), and lawyers (if involved in the proceedings).

How could this be granted?

Because Ms Berki had no legal representation. Mr Brand had plenty.

You won't find a copy of the judgment anywhere - it was a summary judgment, without a trial. Ms Berki had no representation.

The judge apparently relied on inconsistencies in Berki's changing account and his assessment of her motives.

But how could he assess her credibility and motives, without hearing her evidence tested at trial?

Particularly when she had no lawyer? inforrm.org/2015/11/03/case-law-brand-v-berki-summary-judgment-granted-in-harassment-claim/

This was basically a nasty legal trick. Brand initially threatened libel. But libel law almost never lets you get an interim injunction to silence someone. So Brand's lawyers turned it into a harassment claim. It would never have worked if Ms Berki had had a lawyer.

So what precisely did Ms Berki allege? There's little in the UK press. But there was extensive coverage in the Hungarian press: 24.hu/szorakozas/2014/08/04/vilagsztar-akarta-szexre-kenyszeriteni-szilviat

I don't know if her accusations are true. But I do know Ms Berki should be able to talk about it. A police refusal to prosecute should not result in state-imposed silence.

I doubt Ms Berki has the resources to apply to lift the injunction. She probably can't crowdfund without breaching the injunction. So we'll never hear from her.

Unless...

Witnesses to Parliamentary Committees have absolute parliamentary immunity.

If the House of Women and Equalities Committee called Ms Berki as a witness then she'd be unconstrained by the injunction.

And, for the first time in eleven years, we could hear her side of the story.

This is utterly shocking - and i know a few stories.

Fucking hell - how can you get a summary judgement on anything that relates to a claim of sexual violence? Fucking, fucking hell.

Jemima Goldsmith - if you're a different person now, I hope you are utterly repulsed by your younger (though by no means young) self, and take action to rebuild your integrity.

For example, you yourself are not covered by the injunction - only the victim. You have the luxury of speaking out.

And if you're still the same person - well, know that we are all utterly repulsed by you. Probably meaningless, but as I get older I see more and more instances of what people call karma, and I very much hope it knocks on your door.