Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not agree with them holding a grudge for so long when dh forgave me !

303 replies

MarigoldPersephonesCookie · 07/11/2026 07:32

Years and years ago I met now dh, things were good but when I got pregnant we split up. We were separated for 2 years. It was me that ended it.
He saw DS regularly and so we did chat a bit. He was alway lovely his family however given any chance would tell me how much they hated me for what I did and how unhappy he was back at home etc.

He got a new job , met someone and then rented a flat. I went round one day to drop DS off and noticed a couple of things that obviously belonged to who he was seeing (apparently his family set him up with someone they knew so they were over the moon about the relationship). I suddenly realised that I had made a massive mistake so told him - and asked him could we try again. He said yes straight away. His family were livid. Told me I was manipulative when in reality I just suddenly realised what I’d lost.

This was so long ago and they still go on about it ? Comments that he’s still ‘under a spell’.

This year we are invited for Christmas and I’m dreading it as it seems to be mentioned at any opportunity. That I cast him aside and then ruined his be relationship. It doesn’t help the woman he was set up with is still a family friend and so they have this issue I think that they were better suited somehow? Always saying how much they had in common how nice she was and telling him he just got blinded by looks and picked the one who will make his life harder than it needs to be ???

Dh says he doesn’t care what they say that he made his choice based on how he felt and what was best for DS. That I need to learn to ignore them but I think he needs to speak to them prior to us going there so they stop going on about nonsense from the past ?

OP posts:
Applesonthelawn · 07/11/2026 15:01

I think the tone of your OP is the reason why the vote is so evenly split. You suddenly regretted dumping him when you realised he had someone else and was moving on. You weren't concerned about him, so obviously his family would be concerned. It reads like an admission that you were playing games with him and doesn't reflect well on you.
If, on the other hand, you had gone through a difficult period and could justify the change that happened in you, it could come across completely differently.
Some people are giving you the benefit of the doubt on that, others less so.
His family will always side with him.

Bunnychubbers · 07/11/2026 15:13

MarigoldPersephonesCookie · 07/11/2026 13:17

I do accept that the situation was difficult for them and heartbreaking for dh. It’s not that I don’t feel bad, I do but I don’t think I need to apologise for something that was beyond my control. Dh has told me I must never say sorry and he would not let me feel guilty in any way.

I completely disagree with this. Mental health does not absolve you from responsibility if you’ve treated someone like shit, even if you weren’t in your right mind at the time. Yes, the in laws should’ve got over it by now but you don’t sound like a particularly pleasant or insightful person going by your attitude here.

squarecrow · 07/11/2026 15:18

Applesonthelawn · 07/11/2026 15:01

I think the tone of your OP is the reason why the vote is so evenly split. You suddenly regretted dumping him when you realised he had someone else and was moving on. You weren't concerned about him, so obviously his family would be concerned. It reads like an admission that you were playing games with him and doesn't reflect well on you.
If, on the other hand, you had gone through a difficult period and could justify the change that happened in you, it could come across completely differently.
Some people are giving you the benefit of the doubt on that, others less so.
His family will always side with him.

His family aren’t siding with him because they’re undermining a decision he made which is none of their business 15 years down the line. You would have to have the patience of a saint to put up with that from your parents all this time.

ETA imagine OP’s husband had a job he seemed to be happy with, then changed to something else because it paid better. 15 years later his parents are still going - the other job would have been much better, you’d have been happy there, we don’t think this other career you chose is good enough, who talked you into it? Was it that friend of yours so and so, what a manipulative arsehole that friend is, why did you listen to him about your career, you should have listened to us BLAH BLAH BLAH. It’s not supportive at all.

PopcornKitten · 07/11/2026 15:20

The In laws need to stay in their lane. Whatever happened in the past was between you and your DH and you have rectified the situation and it’s 15 years down the line.
you don’t owe them anything.
it may well be sad that MIL is in poor health but that does not give her the right to say and do whatever she wants without recourse.
You have been given some good suggestions here about how to close things down but ultimately you do need DH to stand up for you if things start up over Christmas.

Cherrytree86 · 07/11/2026 15:23

they really don’t give a shit about post partum mental health do they?? Twats.

Calliopespa · 07/11/2026 15:23

SylvanMoon · 07/11/2026 13:27

Of course you don't "need" to apologise for something that was beyond your control, nor do you need to feel guilty for it. But what @ReachBeachFairGlum and other PP have been suggesting is that you apologise for how your actions made them feel by explaining why you behaved in the way you did. Saying "I'm sorry that you were all so hurt by the actions that happened at the birth of DS. It was a result of xyz etc." is very different than you saying, "I'm so sorry. I was wrong. etc etc". They are being intransigent in forgiving you, but you and your DH are also being intransigent in not understanding how your actions were (erroneously) perceived by them and how that affected them.

Exactly this.

So well put.

Can you think of it as an acknowledgment rather than an apology OP?

The problem with NOT acknowledging your behaviour was less than ideal is that it suggests it is who you were and how you thought, and is STILL who you are and how you still think, and how you would act again if the occasion arose.

Admitting you are not proud of what happened - whether it was beyond your capability at the time to control it or not - is the acknowledgment they need to understand you don't think it is fine. If my DS or DB were treated that way and 15 years on the person was still just shoulder shrugging as though it was no big deal, it WOULD factor into who I saw them being as a person - currently as well as back then. We should all be allowed to move on and past mistakes, but we need to demonstrate that we actually have moved on.

Pipsquiggle · 07/11/2026 15:24

MarigoldPersephonesCookie · 07/11/2026 13:17

I do accept that the situation was difficult for them and heartbreaking for dh. It’s not that I don’t feel bad, I do but I don’t think I need to apologise for something that was beyond my control. Dh has told me I must never say sorry and he would not let me feel guilty in any way.

@MarigoldPersephonesCookie
You can frame it however you like. The important thing is that you have a one on one conversation with your MIL to clear the air.

Read my earlier comment.

You can say something like
I know the beginning of our relationship was not ideal. I know I deeply hurt your son (and I am sorry for that) it took me a long time to get well after my difficult pregnancy and PND.
I love your son very much. He is my person, we intend to stay married forever, please can we stop the comments on things that happened 15 years ago.

foursquares · 07/11/2026 15:32

MarigoldPersephonesCookie · 07/11/2026 07:32

Years and years ago I met now dh, things were good but when I got pregnant we split up. We were separated for 2 years. It was me that ended it.
He saw DS regularly and so we did chat a bit. He was alway lovely his family however given any chance would tell me how much they hated me for what I did and how unhappy he was back at home etc.

He got a new job , met someone and then rented a flat. I went round one day to drop DS off and noticed a couple of things that obviously belonged to who he was seeing (apparently his family set him up with someone they knew so they were over the moon about the relationship). I suddenly realised that I had made a massive mistake so told him - and asked him could we try again. He said yes straight away. His family were livid. Told me I was manipulative when in reality I just suddenly realised what I’d lost.

This was so long ago and they still go on about it ? Comments that he’s still ‘under a spell’.

This year we are invited for Christmas and I’m dreading it as it seems to be mentioned at any opportunity. That I cast him aside and then ruined his be relationship. It doesn’t help the woman he was set up with is still a family friend and so they have this issue I think that they were better suited somehow? Always saying how much they had in common how nice she was and telling him he just got blinded by looks and picked the one who will make his life harder than it needs to be ???

Dh says he doesn’t care what they say that he made his choice based on how he felt and what was best for DS. That I need to learn to ignore them but I think he needs to speak to them prior to us going there so they stop going on about nonsense from the past ?

Your DH does sound like a wet blanket. I can understand why the family dislike you. Maybe you should stay away from them.

Pipsquiggle · 07/11/2026 15:34

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

kkloo · 07/11/2026 15:39

Calliopespa · 07/11/2026 15:23

Exactly this.

So well put.

Can you think of it as an acknowledgment rather than an apology OP?

The problem with NOT acknowledging your behaviour was less than ideal is that it suggests it is who you were and how you thought, and is STILL who you are and how you still think, and how you would act again if the occasion arose.

Admitting you are not proud of what happened - whether it was beyond your capability at the time to control it or not - is the acknowledgment they need to understand you don't think it is fine. If my DS or DB were treated that way and 15 years on the person was still just shoulder shrugging as though it was no big deal, it WOULD factor into who I saw them being as a person - currently as well as back then. We should all be allowed to move on and past mistakes, but we need to demonstrate that we actually have moved on.

The problem with NOT acknowledging your behaviour was less than ideal is that it suggests it is who you were and how you thought, and is STILL who you are and how you still think, and how you would act again if the occasion arose.

No it doesn't. Maybe to some people but certainly not to everyone or even most. Once I hit mid 20s or even earlier than that I was able to put certain behaviour in some people down to being young ,and didn't assume that was who they were forever more.

In my experience the vast majority of people with grown up children are old enough to actually have this wisdom and a bit of common sense in this regard and don't think that how someone is at 21 is who they are in their 30s and beyond.

Also add into it the fact she was very unwell, most grown adults would also have the common sense and wisdom to be able to forgive and forget and let it go and actually look at the situation with some compassion.

OPs in-laws certainly haven't admitted to their past mistakes when they said she was exaggerating her illness and just had an eating disorder and are clearly horrible people, decent people do not behave like they have just because their DIL left their son back when she was 21 for a period of time. It's not normal behaviour.

foursquares · 07/11/2026 15:42

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

You can understand DH family's perspective. She initially left DH, then came crawling back when she saw he had moved on, breaking up his then current relationship, with a family friend.

In his family's eyes, OP is to blame, but their anger should be directed at DH for being so pathetic. OP should just accept that they have this opinion of her..a lot clearly unsiad and no smoke without fire.

ohdelay · 07/11/2026 15:44

It's 15 years OP, they're not going to forgive you and your husband isn't going to do anything about it. Maybe you should all stay out of each other's way and stop with the socials now your son is older. They will never like or trust you and it's probably mutual after all this time.

BruFord · 07/11/2026 15:44

After 15 years together, it's pretty obvious that your relationship works and that you didn't get back with your DH just because you were jealous of his new relationship. Plus, you were both young when you got pregnant and you had a difficult pregnancy and recovery.

I think you do need to say something to them, not a big announcement at Christmas, but something along the lines of yes, I made a mistake when I was 21, DH forgave me and it's been 15 years - this needs to stop. Can you imagine if they're still harping on about this when you celebrate your 20/25/30th wedding anniversaries, it's ridiculous!

Your MIL sounds v. controlling, all this still trying to get him together with a family friend - people choose their own partners!

MrsRupert · 07/11/2026 15:56

For a those saying the OP should apologise. Have the in-laws apologised for their behaviour ? Dismissing her severe illness etc ? Pretty sure they haven't as they keep throwing it back in her face.

BoredZelda · 07/11/2026 15:57

OutAndAbouting · 07/11/2026 14:53

'Harping on' @crowsfeet57?. Does the fact that history is 'ancient' make it irrelevant? After all, what have the Romans ever done for us?

(Quote - Monty Python. Couldn't resist it.)

History is never unimportant. It is what guides, moulds and develops us and our world, always learning from it. To say otherwise is batshit.

Sure, but it’s been 15 bloody years. Unless she has consistently shown a blatant disregard for her husband all of those 15 years, wouldn’t you say those years are far important than the first two in judging someone’s characters. History is only important to remember if the effects are still being felt by the people involved. OP and her husband are past it, that’s all that matters.

Tink3rbell30 · 07/11/2026 16:14

They have a point, time passing doesn't diminish or cancel out sly manipulative actions. You only wanted him because he had someone else, poor woman getting binned off just like that.

kkloo · 07/11/2026 16:21

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

It is difficult to put yourself in someone elses shoes when they behave in a batshit way

The fact they keep telling him when the ex is single just in case 'he wants to know' is sick, what kind of people would do that and would be apparently happy if their son left his wife who they share a child with. It's not in any way normal.

This is not simply a case of try to imagine how they felt to see their son heartbroken, most people would be able to empathise with that.

This is a case where OPs 'crime' does not fit the punishment. The in-laws are clearly full of hate and anger and despise the OP. That is very difficult to empathise with.

They also at the time said she was exaggerating the sickness and speculated that it was an eating disorder rather than weight loss due to HG. They didn't seem to show any concern for the very young woman who was carrying their grandchild, even if I suspected an eating disorder if my sons partner was pregnant I feel I would be more concerned, not less, because I would think she was extremely mentally unwell.

If I were the OP I would have understood when I got back with my partner if the family were somewhat wary, but I absolutely wouldn't have accepted being treated that way, and I also wouldn't have apologised when I knew how unwell I was.

On the other hand the in-laws were much older and obviously should have had years of life experience behind them and were also dealing with a normal experience, as others have said young people break up and get back together all the time, but yet have shown no compassion or understanding to the OP whatsoever and have dragged this on for 15 years including involving the OPs child.

Hummingbird233 · 07/11/2026 16:23

MarigoldPersephonesCookie · 07/11/2026 07:55

No I haven’t and I won’t be. I was really ill physically and psychologically. It wasn’t anyone’s fault so nobody needs to apologise it was as DH says just a bad situation that escalated quickly and we weren’t mature enough to know what to do except both go home to our parents.

Edited

Apologising isn’t always about assigning fault. It can be a way of recognising hurt you’ve caused, even if it was inadvertent or due to your own illness.

If my child accidentally causes pain, I teach them to apologise.

Your husband was also hurting during your illness, perhaps a general apology would have gone a long way.

I do think it sounds odd that you were fine all the while he was single, but the jumped back in as soon as he met someone. Sounds like you didn’t love him, you just didn’t want him to have anyone else, I can see why they’d doubt your authenticity.

EvieBB · 07/11/2026 16:54

MarigoldPersephonesCookie · 07/11/2026 07:51

We did have as well for the first few years a lot of comments about having another baby so that dh could experience what he lost when I ended things. That caused a lot of resentment that I refused and was very upfront telling them why it wouldn’t happen (my pregnancy with DS was horrible I had HG and was hospitalised , he was premature and then I had PND which is what made me end things and I went home to live with my parents as honestly I needed to be looked after as I was 2.5 stone lighter after giving birth than before pregnancy).

I was never prepared to have another child and risk that again buy they said that DH had missed out. He told them I’m no uncertain terms he wanted his wife and son and that was all and nothing was worth the risk so he got a vasectomy and told BIL and then they all knew and thought I was forcing him !

C'mon - you did leave him. I'm not surprised they're a little pissed off with you....plus they obviously prefer the other woman they set him up with. But after 15 years you wouldve hoped theyd got over it...as long as their son is now happy.

SylvanMoon · 07/11/2026 16:57

kkloo · 07/11/2026 13:39

No they are clearly just an odd bunch.

OP was only 21 and had PND ,they were older and should have been more forgiving and also more wise, instead they chose to behave in this disgraceful way for 15 years. They are obviously aware of the reasons for why it happened and instead chose to hold a grudge and behave this way.

Even so, what has the OP to lose in saying she's sorry for how it's affected them and reiterating what was behind it? If they then choose to continue with their campaign of blaming her, then both she and her DH have every right to call it quits with the family. She doesn't know how they might react to that sort of "apology" from her because she hasn't attempted to offer it.

OutAndAbouting · 07/11/2026 17:01

BoredZelda · 07/11/2026 15:57

Sure, but it’s been 15 bloody years. Unless she has consistently shown a blatant disregard for her husband all of those 15 years, wouldn’t you say those years are far important than the first two in judging someone’s characters. History is only important to remember if the effects are still being felt by the people involved. OP and her husband are past it, that’s all that matters.

Don't want to split hairs, but DH's family aren't over it, are they? So this ancient history is still relevant as it's impacting on everybody's lives. They have yet to learn from it.

AcrossthePond55 · 07/11/2026 17:02

crowsfeet57 · 07/11/2026 11:51

As the mother of sons I would have felt this way too. But I would have moved on for the sake of my son and after 15 years I wouldn't even think about it any more. It's batshit to keep harping on about ancient history.

Edited

Agree.

Mine was a different situation, my exDiL cheated on my son. Then she physically attacked him when he found out. He was absolutely devastated, to the point where we feared for his MH. Our anger and disgust with her was vicious and deep.

There came a time soon after the discovery where he contemplated trying to 'work it out' with her. When that happened I decided that no matter how I felt about her, if she was what he wanted I'd welcome her back with open arms no matter how hard it was for me to do that. Luckily, he sought counseling on his own and that idea disappeared.

My point is that OP's iLs are entitled to be as angry as they want with her. But she is a 'fact of life' in their lives and they need to stop the bullshit. And it's her DH's responsibility to see that happens. I hate when someone says "Oh just don't pay attention" or "you know how they are" when in actuality if they put their foot down and demanded it stop 'or else' those making comments would most likely stfu.

maxslice · 07/11/2026 17:11

Your husband needs to stand up for you. But they’ll probably just attribute what he says to still being under your “spell”.

kkloo · 07/11/2026 17:40

SylvanMoon · 07/11/2026 16:57

Even so, what has the OP to lose in saying she's sorry for how it's affected them and reiterating what was behind it? If they then choose to continue with their campaign of blaming her, then both she and her DH have every right to call it quits with the family. She doesn't know how they might react to that sort of "apology" from her because she hasn't attempted to offer it.

Considering they are batshit I think it's almost certain they will see her apology as justification of how they have treated her and it won't change anything.

Also she doesn't want to apologise (and rightly so) so particularly if she apologised and they still treated her awfully she could find that very upsetting and she could really regret apologising.

She has the right to call it quits regardless, 15 years of that crap and they say it all in front of OPs son also, she had the right to call it quits with them a long, long time ago.

kkloo · 07/11/2026 17:53

@SylvanMoon
I also think it's a terrible example to set to their son, to engage in self-flagellation and take the blame for other peoples disproportionate behaviour that was apparently in response to something you did, when by the sounds of these people I'd say she would have had a nightmare time with them regardless. Normal decent people do not behave like that.

And apologising in this instance would be self-flagellation, considering the nastiness they have shown her.

I think people really have lost all sense of perspective and compassion here if they think someone who was only 21, had a horrific pregnancy and suffered from PND should have to apologise 15 years later to try to get her horrible in-laws to stop treating her like dirt.

Swipe left for the next trending thread