Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not agree with them holding a grudge for so long when dh forgave me !

303 replies

MarigoldPersephonesCookie · 07/11/2026 07:32

Years and years ago I met now dh, things were good but when I got pregnant we split up. We were separated for 2 years. It was me that ended it.
He saw DS regularly and so we did chat a bit. He was alway lovely his family however given any chance would tell me how much they hated me for what I did and how unhappy he was back at home etc.

He got a new job , met someone and then rented a flat. I went round one day to drop DS off and noticed a couple of things that obviously belonged to who he was seeing (apparently his family set him up with someone they knew so they were over the moon about the relationship). I suddenly realised that I had made a massive mistake so told him - and asked him could we try again. He said yes straight away. His family were livid. Told me I was manipulative when in reality I just suddenly realised what I’d lost.

This was so long ago and they still go on about it ? Comments that he’s still ‘under a spell’.

This year we are invited for Christmas and I’m dreading it as it seems to be mentioned at any opportunity. That I cast him aside and then ruined his be relationship. It doesn’t help the woman he was set up with is still a family friend and so they have this issue I think that they were better suited somehow? Always saying how much they had in common how nice she was and telling him he just got blinded by looks and picked the one who will make his life harder than it needs to be ???

Dh says he doesn’t care what they say that he made his choice based on how he felt and what was best for DS. That I need to learn to ignore them but I think he needs to speak to them prior to us going there so they stop going on about nonsense from the past ?

OP posts:
JayJayj · 07/11/2026 18:03

LoveItaly · 07/11/2026 14:58

Fair enough if the OP doesn’t want to go, but the child has two parents and neither should be vetoing the other one.

Of course they can. Can’t be civil to the mother why should the child go?

squarecrow · 07/11/2026 18:19

AcrossthePond55 · 07/11/2026 17:02

Agree.

Mine was a different situation, my exDiL cheated on my son. Then she physically attacked him when he found out. He was absolutely devastated, to the point where we feared for his MH. Our anger and disgust with her was vicious and deep.

There came a time soon after the discovery where he contemplated trying to 'work it out' with her. When that happened I decided that no matter how I felt about her, if she was what he wanted I'd welcome her back with open arms no matter how hard it was for me to do that. Luckily, he sought counseling on his own and that idea disappeared.

My point is that OP's iLs are entitled to be as angry as they want with her. But she is a 'fact of life' in their lives and they need to stop the bullshit. And it's her DH's responsibility to see that happens. I hate when someone says "Oh just don't pay attention" or "you know how they are" when in actuality if they put their foot down and demanded it stop 'or else' those making comments would most likely stfu.

Absolutely this. They’re entitled to be angry, but they never should have vocalised that. If they did want to confront her about it the time to do that was 15 years ago, and they could have had a frank conversation in which OP could have presented her own side of things and it should have been put to bed.

The fact they make their snide comments all this time later and ignore the DH’s explanations and feelings tells you a lot about their maturity. It should be the DH that insists they respect his wishes and his choices and butt out, or else HE will stop contact. He shouldn’t be telling his wife to put up with them behaving badly.

saraclara · 07/11/2026 18:30

MarigoldPersephonesCookie · 07/11/2026 13:17

I do accept that the situation was difficult for them and heartbreaking for dh. It’s not that I don’t feel bad, I do but I don’t think I need to apologise for something that was beyond my control. Dh has told me I must never say sorry and he would not let me feel guilty in any way.

As I said in an earlier post, an apology isn't necessary, but an acknowledgement that your actions hurt others, would go a long way.

Every single loving parent would respond with anguish and anger too are their son or daughter going through what your DH did. And it went on for several years. They absolutely shouldn't be bringing it up again and again, but I suspect that if you'd ever acknowledged the effect that your actions had on others, they'd have let go by now.

My DD's boyfriend cheated on her when they'd been together for a couple of years. Her sister and I felt she should dump him, but she didn't. They've now been together for 16 years, are very happy together, and he's a great husband and father. I'm very fond of him and can't fault him in the way he treats DD. I've completely forgiven him, but I'll never forget what he did. And that situation only lasted a few weeks. If he'd done what OP did over a period of years, I suspect I wouldn't be as sanguine

Bluebeast · 07/11/2026 18:44

Its hard for any of us to know really. The fact so many of them dislike you and have done for so long... maybe you are the problem??

kkloo · 07/11/2026 19:06

Bluebeast · 07/11/2026 18:44

Its hard for any of us to know really. The fact so many of them dislike you and have done for so long... maybe you are the problem??

Do you think so @bluebeast?

Does any of the in-laws behaviour seem normal and reasonable to you and like something that normal,decent and reasonable people would do?

  • Saying a very young pregnant woman carrying their grandson/nephew/whatever relation to them was exaggerating her illness and just had an eating disorder
  • Trying to manipulate and guilt her into having another baby to make amends
  • Dismissing everything the son says and just telling him he's shallow
  • 15 years later, bringing up at every opportunity that she cast him aside and ruined his relationship.
  • Trying to push him towards that ex by telling him every time she's single 'in case he wants to know' (what kind of batshit behaviour is that when your son is married with a child)
kkloo · 07/11/2026 19:16

saraclara · 07/11/2026 18:30

As I said in an earlier post, an apology isn't necessary, but an acknowledgement that your actions hurt others, would go a long way.

Every single loving parent would respond with anguish and anger too are their son or daughter going through what your DH did. And it went on for several years. They absolutely shouldn't be bringing it up again and again, but I suspect that if you'd ever acknowledged the effect that your actions had on others, they'd have let go by now.

My DD's boyfriend cheated on her when they'd been together for a couple of years. Her sister and I felt she should dump him, but she didn't. They've now been together for 16 years, are very happy together, and he's a great husband and father. I'm very fond of him and can't fault him in the way he treats DD. I've completely forgiven him, but I'll never forget what he did. And that situation only lasted a few weeks. If he'd done what OP did over a period of years, I suspect I wouldn't be as sanguine

Every single loving parent would respond with anguish and anger too are their son or daughter going through what your DH did

Only the crazy ones would go on like they did.

I suspect that if you'd ever acknowledged the effect that your actions had on others, they'd have let go by now.

No they wouldn't have let it go, they're batshit crazy and felt like she should have had another baby to make amends.

If he'd done what OP did over a period of years,

Which was just that she broke up with him when she was very unwell and then later asked if they could get back together and he said yes.
In between they seemed friendly and civil and he regularly saw his son.

You remind me of my ex MIL who thinks that women aren't allowed to break up with her sons, the difference between us was I felt really bad for her when she wanted to leave her husband and her sons all told her that if she did they'd never speak to her again so she stayed with him, but then that's the way she raised them, to think that if a woman dared to break up with them that she had done a serious wrong to them.

RedSheep26 · 07/11/2026 20:04

Let’s be real here. DH’s nasty family isn’t making shitty comments to you out of loyalty or love to your husband or your son. They are purely doing it to punish you.

They are actively seeking to destroy your marriage – the thing they characterise you as irredeemably evil for doing, they want to cause to happen again. Except they’ve got no (diagnosed) mental health conditions, and if they succeeded your son would be dealing with his parents separating as a teenager – not as a baby too young to know otherwise. Both hypocritical and disgusting of them.

This whole hate campaign has nothing to do with how hurt your DH was at the time, or they wouldn’t be rubbing salt in the wound by bringing it up perpetually. It’s everything to do with you being the villain and the scapegoat, and them wanting to get back in control. You were 21 and your DH was a similar age when this happened. Something tells me they expected to continue to treat you both like children even once you established your own family. Then they were furious you made a choice that took you and your son out of their orbit.

You do not have anything to apologise for. People break up all the time. People get back together all the time. Apologising (for what?) would only legitimise their foulness over 15 years.

The only conversation needs to be between your husband and MIL/whoever the ringleader is. And it needs to be him saying that he expects them to treat his family with respect. They do not get to speak to his wife like that and they do not get to undermine his marriage in front of his child. It’s unacceptable and another comment will mean that they don’t see the family at Christmas or afterwards. Have the conversation now and let the dust settle, so you can be there for MIL like you want to be.

I can’t imagine how awful this has been both for you but also for your son. His whole life, his grandparents and aunts/uncles have been openly sniping at his mother and trying to destroy his family. For a small child this would be so destabilising and horrible. Again their actions do not come out of love, it’s just inexcusable.

Doctordoolittle · 07/11/2026 20:54

MarigoldPersephonesCookie · 07/11/2026 13:17

I do accept that the situation was difficult for them and heartbreaking for dh. It’s not that I don’t feel bad, I do but I don’t think I need to apologise for something that was beyond my control. Dh has told me I must never say sorry and he would not let me feel guilty in any way.

I don’t think you need to apologise for being unwell when you broke up, but looking at it from their perspective at the time it does sound manipulative. I would probably have apologised for how the situation had made them feel, given it must have been very upsetting for your husband and his family to be away from your child.

If your husband has forgiven you however they need to move on or you just stay away from them.

It’s fine him saying you shouldn’t feel guilty, but you are feeling these other bad feelings instead!

Everlygreen · 07/11/2026 21:11

I can’t imagine why you would want to please people who openly hate you, I mean are you really placing these people above your self respect? Who cares if your mil is ill ? She’s not ill enough to keep this on for 15years. Like hell would I even share breathing space with them, let alone go along and play happy family at Christmas.

Pipsquiggle · 07/11/2026 22:17

foursquares · 07/11/2026 15:42

You can understand DH family's perspective. She initially left DH, then came crawling back when she saw he had moved on, breaking up his then current relationship, with a family friend.

In his family's eyes, OP is to blame, but their anger should be directed at DH for being so pathetic. OP should just accept that they have this opinion of her..a lot clearly unsiad and no smoke without fire.

@foursquares

Lack of empathy & emotional intelligence in terms of:
OP not figuring out why the ILs are still cold with her - it's very obvious to most of us.
OP not willing to dispel ILs concerns by having a candid conversation with them.
DH's family wondering about OP's situation and health - most people know about the effects of a complicated pregnancy and PND
DH just not effective bringing the parties together or explaining their different valid reasons

PollyBell · 07/11/2026 22:22

I do wonder what their version of what happened then and the last 15 years is, how different would it be from the op's?

And whose version would be the truth?

SomebodyElsesGuy · 07/11/2026 22:27

PollyBell · 07/11/2026 22:22

I do wonder what their version of what happened then and the last 15 years is, how different would it be from the op's?

And whose version would be the truth?

Didn't expect anything different from you Polly!

goldengoats · 07/11/2026 22:31

arethereanyleftatall · 07/11/2026 07:51

Have you ever properly apologised and taken accountability for what you did?

Apologised for what?

She had every right to end the relationship. She also had every right to ask him if they could rekindle. He didn’t have to say yes. She didn’t force him.

kkloo · 07/11/2026 22:39

Pipsquiggle · 07/11/2026 22:17

@foursquares

Lack of empathy & emotional intelligence in terms of:
OP not figuring out why the ILs are still cold with her - it's very obvious to most of us.
OP not willing to dispel ILs concerns by having a candid conversation with them.
DH's family wondering about OP's situation and health - most people know about the effects of a complicated pregnancy and PND
DH just not effective bringing the parties together or explaining their different valid reasons

Op is reading the situation accurately, that their behaviour is unreasonable, not ok, undeserved and they should have stopped holding a grudge by now.

”Dispel their concerns” It’s been 15 years 😂 they’ve been back together for 15 YEARS and are late thirties now fgs

Jimmyjumpy · 07/11/2026 22:43

If it has been years and years then surely you would have been in a similar situation with family gatherings many times?

TittyForlorn · 08/11/2026 00:37

BingoJingo · 07/11/2026 14:12

I am not excusing the in laws I just think there is waaay more to this than meets the eye. Someone who does not have the moral fibre or capacity to apologise for such pain is a 'wrong un' and would remain such in my eyes...

🤮🤮🤮

BingoJingo · 08/11/2026 00:51

TittyForlorn · 08/11/2026 00:37

🤮🤮🤮

Thank you for such an informed and insightful response.

TittyForlorn · 08/11/2026 01:15

BingoJingo · 08/11/2026 00:51

Thank you for such an informed and insightful response.

It was still more informed and insightful than yours.

TittyForlorn · 08/11/2026 01:18

Bluebeast · 07/11/2026 18:44

Its hard for any of us to know really. The fact so many of them dislike you and have done for so long... maybe you are the problem??

🤮🤮🤮

Stompythedinosaur · 08/11/2026 01:45

You don't have to apologize, but they aren't obligated to forgive either. You all have to live with the consequences of what happened.

OneandFiveOnly · 08/11/2026 02:38

I wouldn’t be going. End of. And frankly, your DH isn’t the catch you seem to think he is: he stands by and watches you be humiliated and badgered. Not much of a man, is he?

OneandFiveOnly · 08/11/2026 02:41

MarigoldPersephonesCookie · 07/11/2026 08:06

They know as DH told them at the time. They saw me afterwards and it was just comments when I was pregnant about how I was exaggerating the sickness, speculation it was ‘just an eating disorder’ rather than weight loss due to HG and afterwards dismissal of MH issues very much a ‘most people just get on with it’ mentality. I think my mind just went into survival mode really that’s why I ended it and went home to my parents to be looked after as I was skeletal during pregnancy and it was the worst time of my life

Jesus Christ your MIL is a nasty bitch. No wonder you ended it. She was the bloody cause of it.

And it’s unbelievable your DH just stood by and allowed it to continue whilst you were so unwell.

And to drag your child into it too.

You really need to put your foot down.

OneandFiveOnly · 08/11/2026 02:47

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Are you the MIL?

OneandFiveOnly · 08/11/2026 03:12

Additup · 07/11/2026 09:39

When people are mentally unwell they don't always own their own action FGS. OP was very seriously unwell.

It's a bit like saying I know you have a broken leg but you own your own actions so walk.

YANBU OP. They should have put it all behind them by now.

This.

someone has a stroke, or cancer, or a car accident, people don’t demand they ‘own’ their actions.

But mental illness? It’s always the same story ‘brough it in yourself’ ‘’you still had self control’ blah blah blah.

There but for the grace of god….

BingoJingo · 08/11/2026 03:12

TittyForlorn · 08/11/2026 01:15

It was still more informed and insightful than yours.

I can see you have 'form'.