Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder if abuse scandals in places like Scouts are one reason why all-male spaces for boys have declined?

105 replies

Jane3212 · 06/11/2026 21:50

I was reading recently about the history of the Scout and Guide movements and it got me thinking about the decline of spaces for boys and men which gets discussed a lot now.

I think single sex spaces are important for boys to have, but I wonder if the fear of potential abuse is one factor which partly caused the decline& often gets overlooked. I know the Scouts began admitting girls before the revelations due to boys going less for other reasons but it surely didn't help. Probably played a role in men feeling less welcome in roles like primary teaching, also. It's very difficult as male mentors and spaces are needed but the abuse scandals add a difficulty which all female spaces don't have in the same way.

AIBU?

OP posts:
allicansayisdidums · 07/11/2026 13:53

my son has been in scouting since beavers and is now an explorer and a young leader for scouts. it has been the making of him and he thrives in the environment. the leaders are all make except one woman who tends to just join the camps. as his father is a total car crash of a person it is good he has good male role models. their troupe does have a few girls but it doesn’t seem to change the dynamics particularly as they have come through from beavers and cubs together. i work in child protection so i’m acutely aware of how some predators seek out trusted voluntary roles. but i have seen child sexual abuse perpetrated across every layer of society, every profession and none. scouts absolutely did not have the processes and oversight in years gone by. but neither did many organisations and things have improved significantly. i see it as my role as his mum to make sure we talk, i listen, promote dialogue, approach tricky topics before they become problematic and create an environment where he could come to me with a worry about himself or someone else. in terms of popularity, in our area scouts is much better attended than brownies and guides and from what i gather the girls who do scouts enjoy the physical and outside life side much more than what guides seem to offer.
i've just dropped my son off to a hiking competition and there were teams from about 50 different troupes in the area. when they have the big annual camp for the county there are over 1000 there.
overall safeguarding your children is a multi faceted task and it’s important not to limit opportunities through fear. the overwhelming majority of children abused now are harmed in their homes or by a close relative or family friend.

RedToothBrush · 07/11/2026 13:52

LemonPuppyPorkChop · 07/11/2026 12:35

Who is the ‘we’ who no longer value men’s spaces?

British society as a whole.

Does that clarify enough for your pedantry?

Newname26 · 07/11/2026 13:43

calypsosails · 07/11/2026 13:35

We’ve just started squirrels, what’s the issue with it?

Needs more leaders, more hall time, another section to run.

4 is very young, lots of 4 yos are still in preschool.

I know Rainbows is officially 4 but I also know leaders from different groups say they prefer the girls to be 5. And girls are generally a bit more mature than boys.

I think it would make more sense to include 5yos with Beavers.

Newname26 · 07/11/2026 13:37

GingerbreadPeople · 07/11/2026 13:23

The Scouts ended in my area, because the people that ran the group died & nobody has taken up the role.

People want clubs

However, people do not want to commit to volunteering. It is a big responsibility.

Parents now have to travel to another area if they want clubs

I think thats a huge part of it, people want clubs but don't really want to get involved in the running of them.

calypsosails · 07/11/2026 13:35

Newname26 · 07/11/2026 09:44

Beavers had their 40th birthday last year.

I'm not convinced Squirrels was the right move, but they must have trialled it somewhere.

We’ve just started squirrels, what’s the issue with it?

GingerbreadPeople · 07/11/2026 13:23

The Scouts ended in my area, because the people that ran the group died & nobody has taken up the role.

People want clubs

However, people do not want to commit to volunteering. It is a big responsibility.

Parents now have to travel to another area if they want clubs

Itchthescratch · 07/11/2026 13:01

I think it's the age old problem.

Anything associated with males is always seen as more prestigious or worthwhile than their female equivalent. There is some truth to it of course as old boys clubs have been the source of so much networking and deal making historically. In a world where women have fought for equality then male only spaces have been an obvious target and the expectation that women and girls can join has increased. This though obviously leaves boys with no single sex spaces or groups and leaves them with fewer options in general as they aren't going to want to join a traditionally female groups due to the social stigma. I always see far more girls in football teams than I see boys in ballet. It's very sad. Until we achieve true equality between the masculine and feminine then equality will always be build of women being able to access traditionally male spheres.

Newname26 · 07/11/2026 12:55

@RedToothBrush

I'd agree its not good that men no longer really have any single sex spaces.

Women have always had knitting bees, fitness classes, WI etc more groups associated with hobbies.

Mens spaces have often been much more casual like "old men's pubs" or if they are looking for organised its the Mens Guild (is that still a thing?) Or the Masons.

Its decades since women had women only sessions in a local pool, men complained they didn't have a men only session, the women's became Adults Only didn't really tick anyone's boxes

C8H10N4O2 · 07/11/2026 12:51

CurlewKate · 07/11/2026 12:45

Scouts chose to take girls because of falling rolls. Guides chose not to because of demand.

The guides do admit some male guides resulting in the loss of some female guides.

Smokeywater · 07/11/2026 12:49

I wonder why men don't teach in primary schools - maybe the future graduates WILL teach as other opportunities disappear due to AI - I suppose there's no chance of pushing this as it would be sexist but they could push for both sexes to move into teaching

C8H10N4O2 · 07/11/2026 12:48

Jane3212 · 06/11/2026 21:50

I was reading recently about the history of the Scout and Guide movements and it got me thinking about the decline of spaces for boys and men which gets discussed a lot now.

I think single sex spaces are important for boys to have, but I wonder if the fear of potential abuse is one factor which partly caused the decline& often gets overlooked. I know the Scouts began admitting girls before the revelations due to boys going less for other reasons but it surely didn't help. Probably played a role in men feeling less welcome in roles like primary teaching, also. It's very difficult as male mentors and spaces are needed but the abuse scandals add a difficulty which all female spaces don't have in the same way.

AIBU?

What are the numbers? You are stating there are less all male spaces for boys but your post seems to be about the Scouts not all male spaces for boys. Scouts are not the only boys' spaces. One of the choices made by boys in preference to Scouts is boys sports clubs/activities. In general there are far more optional activities than when Scouting was in its heyday.

Scouts, like boys' schools, started admitting girls because they couldn't attract enough boys. This had a negative knock on effect on girls' groups which became less viable.

Primary school teaching has been overwhelmingly female (except for the headships) since I was a child and before. It was seen as the lower status and lower paid area of teaching so suitable for women. There are more male teachers in primary now than when I was a child or when my DC went through primary.

So your title would better be positioned as "Why are scouts less popular with boys" rather than inventing a problem of insufficient boys' spaces.

CurlewKate · 07/11/2026 12:45

Scouts chose to take girls because of falling rolls. Guides chose not to because of demand.

Runningupthecurtains · 07/11/2026 12:42

PollyBell · 06/11/2026 23:31

Guides are still i presume but scouts are not allowed to be?

It chose not to be legally it could have continue as a group for boys if it wanted to.

GoodGirlFaith · 07/11/2026 12:39

fabricstash · 07/11/2026 12:10

I think beavers, cubs, scouts and explorers is still so relevant. Teach kids to work together, try new skills, builds confidence, step away from devices etc. Safeguarding is also super strict now - as it should be.

I wish it was possible for all children to attend Scouts. It’s teaches numerous important life skills and lessons.

GoodGirlFaith · 07/11/2026 12:38

Why would not being able to attend boys only activities put a boy off pursuing a career in teaching?

Your OP is just a big word salad that relates in no way to real life.

My sons both did Scouts and I was a leader. We had mostly boys and a few girls. Men and women leaders. Strict rules are in place to ensure children are not ever alone with an adult.

My sons also both did football from age 4-17. There were a couple of girls on the teams, the club subsequently set up a girls team. Either myself or DH were always spectating on the sidelines.

Both activities were hugely beneficial and fun. There’s no need to bring the very small chance of abuse into everything.

LemonPuppyPorkChop · 07/11/2026 12:35

RedToothBrush · 07/11/2026 12:24

Scouts is seen as unfashionable. It's got fuck all to do with abuse scandals not a lack of single sex spaces.

In our area, the kids who are scouts are almost exclusively the nerd kids and there's high levels of neurodiversity.

Across district I'm struggling to think of a single kid who is part of the 'in crowd'.

Some groups are almost single sex even now anyway. Others are much more balanced. That's due to a number of factors - everything from what night girls football is on to individual leaders.

You get single sex groups for boys at school - they are called the football team and the rugby team.

What has declined is how much we value the importance of men having single sex spaces. I do think men need it and this is really over looked. We didn't give mens groups the opportunity to really evolve to be more modern in things but also to provide a social support network for men. They've all been labelled as regressive and old fashioned and I think that's somewhat unfair.

I think it's backfired on women in a sense to fail to recognise the importance of male spaces which instead led to a radicalisation through marginalised men who grouped together online rather than an in-person broader base of moderate men based on local mutual interest.

I think it's harder for men to volunteer tbh because of the remarks about abuse and that's really been the problem because there's less positive male role models out there. But that's not to do with a lack of single sex groups as such.

Who is the ‘we’ who no longer value men’s spaces?

RedToothBrush · 07/11/2026 12:24

Scouts is seen as unfashionable. It's got fuck all to do with abuse scandals not a lack of single sex spaces.

In our area, the kids who are scouts are almost exclusively the nerd kids and there's high levels of neurodiversity.

Across district I'm struggling to think of a single kid who is part of the 'in crowd'.

Some groups are almost single sex even now anyway. Others are much more balanced. That's due to a number of factors - everything from what night girls football is on to individual leaders.

You get single sex groups for boys at school - they are called the football team and the rugby team.

What has declined is how much we value the importance of men having single sex spaces. I do think men need it and this is really over looked. We didn't give mens groups the opportunity to really evolve to be more modern in things but also to provide a social support network for men. They've all been labelled as regressive and old fashioned and I think that's somewhat unfair.

I think it's backfired on women in a sense to fail to recognise the importance of male spaces which instead led to a radicalisation through marginalised men who grouped together online rather than an in-person broader base of moderate men based on local mutual interest.

I think it's harder for men to volunteer tbh because of the remarks about abuse and that's really been the problem because there's less positive male role models out there. But that's not to do with a lack of single sex groups as such.

fabricstash · 07/11/2026 12:10

I think beavers, cubs, scouts and explorers is still so relevant. Teach kids to work together, try new skills, builds confidence, step away from devices etc. Safeguarding is also super strict now - as it should be.

Peterbyres1 · 07/11/2026 10:44

I feel fortunate that I had such brilliant male role models, not that they would like that description, when I was a child. I remember even now, and am late 50s, the brilliant cub and scout leaders, both groups all male then. I was also a chorister and had great male leaders, both clergy and non clergy. Yes, I know there are horror stories about clergy but I didn't experience that and perhaps learned more than I knew at the time being around decent, caring men.

Newname26 · 07/11/2026 10:44

topcat2014 · 07/11/2026 10:29

I was a beaver leader for 7 years - we had male and female leaders. DD went through beavers to explorers. Our Beavers was Saturdays, and not every week - so easier for leaders with busy lives to fit in some time. Probably 1/3 girls

I definitely don't think i could be bothered with Beavers on a Saturday. Either as a leader or a parent. The odd event i can cope with but not regularly

topcat2014 · 07/11/2026 10:29

I was a beaver leader for 7 years - we had male and female leaders. DD went through beavers to explorers. Our Beavers was Saturdays, and not every week - so easier for leaders with busy lives to fit in some time. Probably 1/3 girls

Newname26 · 07/11/2026 10:22

fabricstash · 07/11/2026 09:44

Possibly. Getting volunteers has been a lot harder since Covid

Yes a lot of volunteers walked away during covid.
As did kids, I don't know about laws in England but Scotland allowed indoor sports before they allowed youth groups so lots of kids walked.

And remember a fair percentage of leaders are parents.
Very few leaders just appear as leaders, most are either home grown by Scouts, people get involved because of their own kids and the occasional young leader who is looking for experience working with kids while at uni (teachers social worker etc)

IsItSnowing · 07/11/2026 10:03

Scandals are bound to put people off wanting to send their kids to an organisation.
Unfortunately, the more these organisations try to cover up historic abuse, the more they are sending out a message to would be offenders that they are a safe haven for abuse. What that does is encourage that sort to become involved as leaders and helpers etc. It would be far better to deal openly and harshly with these abusers and send out the message that they are not welcome.
But it seems to be a recurring theme that various organisations would rather try and cover things up.

Newname26 · 07/11/2026 09:47

turkeyboots · 07/11/2026 09:32

In Ireland Scouts was nearly destroyed by sex abuse scandals, which are still having an impact on the organisation as they appear to be still covering up historic abuse. Why would you put your kids into an organisation which attracted headlines like this?

www.theguardian.com/society/2021/jul/25/uk-ireland-child-sexual-abuse-scout-movement

The biggest route for abusers is now private tuition (music, extra lessons, 121 situations)

I don't see anything saying scouts tried to cover it up.

fabricstash · 07/11/2026 09:44

LlynTegid · 07/11/2026 09:31

I wonder if the demands of many jobs especially to be available outside traditional working hours has reduced people willing to be Scout leaders. Or simply the hassle of dealing with unreasonable parents, paperwork and allied things.

Possibly. Getting volunteers has been a lot harder since Covid