Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder if abuse scandals in places like Scouts are one reason why all-male spaces for boys have declined?

105 replies

Jane3212 · 06/11/2026 21:50

I was reading recently about the history of the Scout and Guide movements and it got me thinking about the decline of spaces for boys and men which gets discussed a lot now.

I think single sex spaces are important for boys to have, but I wonder if the fear of potential abuse is one factor which partly caused the decline& often gets overlooked. I know the Scouts began admitting girls before the revelations due to boys going less for other reasons but it surely didn't help. Probably played a role in men feeling less welcome in roles like primary teaching, also. It's very difficult as male mentors and spaces are needed but the abuse scandals add a difficulty which all female spaces don't have in the same way.

AIBU?

OP posts:
Velumental · 06/11/2026 22:01

If only there were fewer abusive men. Feels like abusive men are the ones to blame and who can really make a difference here.

Brightbluesomething · 06/11/2026 22:16

Not sure why you think scouts is a single sex space. When I was a scout leader all the volunteers were female. No sex scandals and the kids of both genders had a great time.

mindutopia · 06/11/2026 22:18

I don’t think boys are less likely to be abused in mixed sex spaces. I mean, the place boys are most likely to be abused is at home. There are still plenty of all boy spaces in sport.

I think the problem with things like Scouts is that it’s so hard to get boys to do it at all, that they need girls to bulk out the numbers. And it’s the same issue with volunteer leaders. Our Beavers/Cubs/Scouts wouldn’t exist if we were relying on men to run it.

Allmarbleslost · 06/11/2026 22:20

Brightbluesomething · 06/11/2026 22:16

Not sure why you think scouts is a single sex space. When I was a scout leader all the volunteers were female. No sex scandals and the kids of both genders had a great time.

It's not single sex any more but it used to be

Jane3212 · 06/11/2026 22:40

mindutopia · 06/11/2026 22:18

I don’t think boys are less likely to be abused in mixed sex spaces. I mean, the place boys are most likely to be abused is at home. There are still plenty of all boy spaces in sport.

I think the problem with things like Scouts is that it’s so hard to get boys to do it at all, that they need girls to bulk out the numbers. And it’s the same issue with volunteer leaders. Our Beavers/Cubs/Scouts wouldn’t exist if we were relying on men to run it.

Why is it so hard to get boys to do Scouts now? It was popular in the past the way Guides was with girls. Why is Guides still popular with girls but Scouts lost popularity with boys? It's a shame.

OP posts:
Jane3212 · 06/11/2026 22:42

Allmarbleslost · 06/11/2026 22:20

It's not single sex any more but it used to be

Yes, that was my point...it changed from being a single sex space because numbers were falling and admitting keen girls was a way to boost. The abuse scandals probably also put at least some boys' parents off, though numbers were already falling.

OP posts:
Jane3212 · 06/11/2026 22:44

mindutopia · 06/11/2026 22:18

I don’t think boys are less likely to be abused in mixed sex spaces. I mean, the place boys are most likely to be abused is at home. There are still plenty of all boy spaces in sport.

I think the problem with things like Scouts is that it’s so hard to get boys to do it at all, that they need girls to bulk out the numbers. And it’s the same issue with volunteer leaders. Our Beavers/Cubs/Scouts wouldn’t exist if we were relying on men to run it.

'I don’t think boys are less likely to be abused in mixed sex spaces. I mean, the place boys are most likely to be abused is at home'

  • that's true...otoh mixed sex spaces migjt have a somewhat lower chance if there are many female leaders, as women are less likely to abuse (at least SA).
OP posts:
EvelynBeatrice · 06/11/2026 23:22

I think that two factors are 1) there were less things to do in the past! In an era before phones and the internet and social media, with limited tv choice and no or fewer video games, boys were more willing to get together in such clubs - the clubs were also probably more fun with designated scouts huts and so on and less health and safety paperwork 2) the difficulty in getting adult volunteers.

PollyBell · 06/11/2026 23:31

Allmarbleslost · 06/11/2026 22:20

It's not single sex any more but it used to be

Guides are still i presume but scouts are not allowed to be?

Allmarbleslost · 06/11/2026 23:37

PollyBell · 06/11/2026 23:31

Guides are still i presume but scouts are not allowed to be?

Scouts chose to allow girls to join because their numbers were declining.

Thingcanonlygetbetter · 06/11/2026 23:40

Slightly off topic but I saw the difference in my son going to all boys school with loads of male teachers. Primary school had 100% female staff. Think it is so important for boys to have male role models.

Newname26 · 06/11/2026 23:53

Depends how far you are going back.
Scouts are 120 next year.

I think Scouts went through a bit of an identity crisis 20-30 years ago, it wasn't seen as a cool thing to do, dyb dyb dyb and Cubs with those daft caps (green ones with yellow piping)

The rise of two car family must also have made a difference people have more choice in the places they could get kids to.

A generation or so ago lots of Scouts and Guides were run out of church halls. Which were local. And walk able which makes it easier if you are a one car, one driver family.

Female leaders have been part of Scouts for a very long time, even if girls weren't allowed Google tells me 1909, and Cubs were started by women.

Newname26 · 07/11/2026 00:00

Thingcanonlygetbetter · 06/11/2026 23:40

Slightly off topic but I saw the difference in my son going to all boys school with loads of male teachers. Primary school had 100% female staff. Think it is so important for boys to have male role models.

One of my boys had a male primary teacher. My son adored him.

Funnily enough I also rate the male teacher i had half way though primary as best ever. Looking back he had a different energy in the class, and youth on his side. I came across class photos and was surprised how young he looked

Thingcanonlygetbetter · 07/11/2026 00:04

Jane3212 · 06/11/2026 22:40

Why is it so hard to get boys to do Scouts now? It was popular in the past the way Guides was with girls. Why is Guides still popular with girls but Scouts lost popularity with boys? It's a shame.

Our son joined the Scouts but really didn’t enjoy it. It was a mixed group of boys and girls, and it just wasn’t for him. My husband, on the other hand, was in the Scouts for years and absolutely loved it. Even now, in his fifties, he still talks about all the practical skills he learned, from putting up tents and lighting fires to tying knots and general survival skills. And I’m not being sarcastic when I say that, I’m deadly serious! He never goes on holidays without his Swiss Army knife, and there’s always something we end up needing it for. He’s also brilliant at fixing things. His own father could hardly change a light bulb, so he certainly didn’t learn those skills at home! I just think it’s such a shame because Scouting taught him so many useful skills that have stayed with him for life

Jane3212 · 07/11/2026 02:34

Thingcanonlygetbetter · 07/11/2026 00:04

Our son joined the Scouts but really didn’t enjoy it. It was a mixed group of boys and girls, and it just wasn’t for him. My husband, on the other hand, was in the Scouts for years and absolutely loved it. Even now, in his fifties, he still talks about all the practical skills he learned, from putting up tents and lighting fires to tying knots and general survival skills. And I’m not being sarcastic when I say that, I’m deadly serious! He never goes on holidays without his Swiss Army knife, and there’s always something we end up needing it for. He’s also brilliant at fixing things. His own father could hardly change a light bulb, so he certainly didn’t learn those skills at home! I just think it’s such a shame because Scouting taught him so many useful skills that have stayed with him for life

That's really a shame your son didn't get the same experience. So the main reason he enjoyed it less was that it was a mixed group? I can understand wanting an all-boys one.

I know as pps have said they stopped being boys-only as there wasn't enough demand but it does leave a gap. I know some people do Boys' Brigade instead (which does have some coed groups, but 75% are not) but the Christian focus there wouldn't suit everyone.

OP posts:
Jane3212 · 07/11/2026 02:36

Newname26 · 06/11/2026 23:53

Depends how far you are going back.
Scouts are 120 next year.

I think Scouts went through a bit of an identity crisis 20-30 years ago, it wasn't seen as a cool thing to do, dyb dyb dyb and Cubs with those daft caps (green ones with yellow piping)

The rise of two car family must also have made a difference people have more choice in the places they could get kids to.

A generation or so ago lots of Scouts and Guides were run out of church halls. Which were local. And walk able which makes it easier if you are a one car, one driver family.

Female leaders have been part of Scouts for a very long time, even if girls weren't allowed Google tells me 1909, and Cubs were started by women.

Edited

Good points. Why are church halls used less now? Is that due to churches shutting?

OP posts:
GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 07/11/2026 02:42

Jane3212 · 06/11/2026 22:40

Why is it so hard to get boys to do Scouts now? It was popular in the past the way Guides was with girls. Why is Guides still popular with girls but Scouts lost popularity with boys? It's a shame.

I’m not sure this is the case tbh

Where we live there are loads of boys in Scouts - the majority are boys. Sadly our local Guides had to close for lack of interest.

The Scout leaders are a fairly even mix of men and women.

fabricstash · 07/11/2026 04:58

There are loads of boys doing scouting now and in our area high demand. Loads of girls too. Getting enough adult volunteers to run the different sections is really challenging though. In fact at secondary school age we have a particularly high demand as unless you are into sports or music there are no other youth clubs. Scouts at the the old venture scout level (used to be 15-21yo) also used to be mix sex back in late 80s/early 90s. Now that section is explorer scouts and age 14-17. The reason the lower ages went mixed sex was falling numbers and they took a vote

fabricstash · 07/11/2026 05:03

EvelynBeatrice · 06/11/2026 23:22

I think that two factors are 1) there were less things to do in the past! In an era before phones and the internet and social media, with limited tv choice and no or fewer video games, boys were more willing to get together in such clubs - the clubs were also probably more fun with designated scouts huts and so on and less health and safety paperwork 2) the difficulty in getting adult volunteers.

I second this

Lupin5555 · 07/11/2026 05:08

Jane3212 · 06/11/2026 22:40

Why is it so hard to get boys to do Scouts now? It was popular in the past the way Guides was with girls. Why is Guides still popular with girls but Scouts lost popularity with boys? It's a shame.

In terms of memberships scouts is more popular than guides.

BirdLandedonmyHead · 07/11/2026 05:13

My observation as a leader..

At Squirrels/Beavers... the parents are chosing. Ours are mostly boys, partly due to an active Rainbow unit.

At Cubs... it ebbs and flows between boys and girls. (Apparently the Brownie unit isnt as good as the Rainbows, so they chose to move at 8yo if they can). But children are starting to chose their own hobbies more.

By Scouts... tge sporty active boys chose sport. Usually football or swimming. The swimmers esoecially dont have time for anything else. Its just the quieter boys.
But active girls are still chosing Scouts.

Newname26 · 07/11/2026 08:57

Jane3212 · 07/11/2026 02:36

Good points. Why are church halls used less now? Is that due to churches shutting?

Combination of factors.
Growing up in the 80s more people went to church.
Every church seemed to have either Boys & Girl Brigades or Scouts & Guides.

Scouts like having their own halls which gives space to store stuff, space to dry tents and they aren't confined to only having the hall one night a week.

But there is also an element of the individual leaders make a difference. With some groups having waiting lists and others don't

EvelynBeatrice · 07/11/2026 09:10

Thingcanonlygetbetter · 07/11/2026 00:04

Our son joined the Scouts but really didn’t enjoy it. It was a mixed group of boys and girls, and it just wasn’t for him. My husband, on the other hand, was in the Scouts for years and absolutely loved it. Even now, in his fifties, he still talks about all the practical skills he learned, from putting up tents and lighting fires to tying knots and general survival skills. And I’m not being sarcastic when I say that, I’m deadly serious! He never goes on holidays without his Swiss Army knife, and there’s always something we end up needing it for. He’s also brilliant at fixing things. His own father could hardly change a light bulb, so he certainly didn’t learn those skills at home! I just think it’s such a shame because Scouting taught him so many useful skills that have stayed with him for life

I read here some time ago that the old scouts handbook from the 50s included a section on survival and emergency skills, including a section on how to cut a suicide victim out of a noose! Different times.

The Brownie handbook of the 70s had a section on how to roll someone in a rug if their clothes were on fire. I also remember social etiquette and manners guidance eg if you’re seeing grandma dress up a bit and wash- it pleases her and doesn’t hurt you. If you have a guest staying at your home, offer them a choice of activities so that they can pick their preference, not yours. Etc

Bushmillsbabe · 07/11/2026 09:21

Thingcanonlygetbetter · 06/11/2026 23:40

Slightly off topic but I saw the difference in my son going to all boys school with loads of male teachers. Primary school had 100% female staff. Think it is so important for boys to have male role models.

Primary schools vary. At my daughters junior school, half the class teachers are male, the 2 PE teachers are male, 2 TA's are male.
I think its important for both girls and boys to have positive male examples, especially for those who don't have a father figure in their lives.
And it just suits some children more. My DD11 much prefers male teachers, feels they are fairer with less favouritism, better at cracking down on disruptive behaviour, and 'more fun'. She has a very dry sense of humour and feels male teachers get her better.

Bushmillsbabe · 07/11/2026 09:24

Newname26 · 07/11/2026 08:57

Combination of factors.
Growing up in the 80s more people went to church.
Every church seemed to have either Boys & Girl Brigades or Scouts & Guides.

Scouts like having their own halls which gives space to store stuff, space to dry tents and they aren't confined to only having the hall one night a week.

But there is also an element of the individual leaders make a difference. With some groups having waiting lists and others don't

Also demographics. My affluent home counties village - huge wait lists for Rainbows and Beavers etc. It's seen as 'the thing to do' by the middle class parents. They also have the flexibility of wfh and getting them to these which start from 4.30 onwards.

Swipe left for the next trending thread