Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder if abuse scandals in places like Scouts are one reason why all-male spaces for boys have declined?

105 replies

Jane3212 · 06/11/2026 21:50

I was reading recently about the history of the Scout and Guide movements and it got me thinking about the decline of spaces for boys and men which gets discussed a lot now.

I think single sex spaces are important for boys to have, but I wonder if the fear of potential abuse is one factor which partly caused the decline& often gets overlooked. I know the Scouts began admitting girls before the revelations due to boys going less for other reasons but it surely didn't help. Probably played a role in men feeling less welcome in roles like primary teaching, also. It's very difficult as male mentors and spaces are needed but the abuse scandals add a difficulty which all female spaces don't have in the same way.

AIBU?

OP posts:
TheFriendlyPotato · 07/11/2026 20:11

renovationchoas · 07/11/2026 19:30

I’m really glad that scouting is mixed sex. I went through guiding in the 90s and found it less outward bound than the scouting equivalent. For example, all the Brownie camps were in church halls and you could only camp at guides from 10, whereas the scouting equivalent was much earlier. I still get that impression (but I only see it from the scout side, as my kids now do cubs and beavers - kids camp outside for beaver camp and at cubs) and that can be a good thing or a bad thing - some girls likely would prefer more craftier options and fewer campfires and night hikes. There are lots of boys at my daughters’ cubs - a majority of them- and it is a bit rowdy sometimes but they are all nice kids and the leaders are great and get “authoritative but fun” spot on.

the boys who go to scouts seem to me to be quite well rounded and not only “geeky”, but they often are not the very sportiest boys, because those boys tend to be committed to two sports which each demand attendance more than once a week. I think that this is a bit of a difference - kids often do more than one sport that needs quite a decent commitment even with not particularly elite teams.

I guess that’s the difficulty - maybe if we had single sex scout, some girls would have to end up in a more girly single sex option that might not be their choice, but it would be unlikely to attract lots more boys to fill those spaces because many boys are committed elsewhere.

I never understood why they dont just do more fun, outward/outdoor boyish stuff at guides instead of opening scouts to girls. That would make far more sense to me.

TheFriendlyPotato · 07/11/2026 20:09

Jane3212 · 06/11/2026 22:40

Why is it so hard to get boys to do Scouts now? It was popular in the past the way Guides was with girls. Why is Guides still popular with girls but Scouts lost popularity with boys? It's a shame.

I would suggest that becoming mixed-sex is potentially one of the reasons for its decline. It is no longer really a boys' space in the traditional sense, but has arguably become more of a glorified social club. That said, I suspect it was already going downhill before girls were invited in.

Here's my suspicion.

Historically, it was an organisation where boys could do traditionally boyish things alongside other boys. A space where they could just be themselves, without worrying about being judged by girls, feeling self-conscious or having to perform in a particular way.

Over the years, however, the culture around boys changed considerably. From the mid-1990s through to the mid-2000s, we seemed to move away from relatively wholesome pursuits towards a culture increasingly dominated by lad culture, video gaming, pornography and binge drinking. Being a Scout gradually stopped being fashionable or particularly cool.

Qualities such as being upstanding, honourable, considerate and respectful were no longer necessarily seen as desirable or aspirational. I remember boys at school being teased for going to Scouts. Wearing the uniform, particularly that little neckerchief, was something many found embarrassing. Why would you want to do that when you could go home, read lads' magazines, play video games and spend time with the supposedly cool crowd?
I genuinely believe the 1990s and 2000s had a profoundly damaging effect on aspects of Western culture, with standards and expectations seemingly eroding along the way.

Fast-forward to today, and almost anything male-centric seems to attract a degree of suspicion. I genuinely feel for boys growing up in 2026, trying to navigate a social minefield that they don't always understand. There seems to be very little room for boys simply to be boys, because so much of traditionally masculine behaviour is now automatically labelled toxic.

I can only speculate, not having experienced it myself, but I cannot imagine how confusing it must be for a young boy trying to develop a sense of masculinity while simultaneously feeling that he has to distance himself from anything that might be perceived as traditionally masculine. There must be a tremendous amount of uncertainty around what is and isn't acceptable.

I suspect we will never quite get those traditional spaces back. And why is that? Who, in today's climate, is genuinely comfortable with the idea of boys getting together, doing their own thing and developing independently without female supervision? I'm not being sarcastic when I say that. There seems to be an underlying reluctance to trust boys to simply be boys, as though they are all potential toxic men in the making.

I feel quite passionately about this because I look at the boys growing up around us and see so many who seem increasingly demoralised, lacking confidence and unsure of their place in the world. I worry about the long-term consequences of that.
Surely we can have compassion for both girls and boys without treating their needs as mutually exclusive? Let girls have their spaces, friendships and opportunities to develop together, and let boys have theirs. There is nothing inherently wrong with recognising that boys and girls sometimes benefit from different environments.

I also think we've lost something in the way we understand boys' social development. At school, I remember watching with some bemusement as boys in my class would get into fights, only to walk away five minutes later as the best of friends. Teachers generally didn't intervene, and if parents were informed, they would often simply be told to let the boys sort things out between themselves.

I'm certainly not advocating fighting or suggesting that aggression should be encouraged. But I do wonder whether we've become so uncomfortable with any form of physical rough-and-tumble, competitiveness or confrontation between boys that we've forgotten these can sometimes be part of how they learn boundaries, resolve disagreements and develop resilience.

There is a difference between genuine bullying and harmful aggression, and boys having the freedom to let off steam, test boundaries and navigate the occasional disagreement amongst themselves.
Perhaps what boys need isn't to be constantly corrected or made to feel that something is inherently wrong with how they naturally interact, but to be given appropriate spaces, guidance and trust to grow into decent, well-rounded young men.

I think there is something quite heartbreaking about the way we have come to view boys and masculinity. In our efforts to challenge inequality and protect girls, I sometimes wonder whether we have inadvertently created an environment in which boys feel they must apologise for simply being boys.

As women, mothers, sisters and daughters, surely we should be able to recognise that boys need nurturing, understanding and spaces where they can grow just as much as girls do. They need friendships, camaraderie, a sense of belonging and the freedom to explore who they are without constantly worrying that their natural instincts or behaviour will be judged through an adult lens.

Lets empower and encourage all children, that way we may get far fewer abusive men our there. And yes I know, not all men :)

renovationchoas · 07/11/2026 19:35

In my parent’s generation (cubs age in 60s), lots of scout and girl guide groups were very different and functioned as a type of youth club, where you turned up with subs on the night (my mum used to not go to brownies and go to the chip shop with her friend and spend her subs there and no one knew - it was very much another age). There were fewer other options. It’s hard to compare numbers going back many years because the model really has changed quite a lot, as has society.

renovationchoas · 07/11/2026 19:30

I’m really glad that scouting is mixed sex. I went through guiding in the 90s and found it less outward bound than the scouting equivalent. For example, all the Brownie camps were in church halls and you could only camp at guides from 10, whereas the scouting equivalent was much earlier. I still get that impression (but I only see it from the scout side, as my kids now do cubs and beavers - kids camp outside for beaver camp and at cubs) and that can be a good thing or a bad thing - some girls likely would prefer more craftier options and fewer campfires and night hikes. There are lots of boys at my daughters’ cubs - a majority of them- and it is a bit rowdy sometimes but they are all nice kids and the leaders are great and get “authoritative but fun” spot on.

the boys who go to scouts seem to me to be quite well rounded and not only “geeky”, but they often are not the very sportiest boys, because those boys tend to be committed to two sports which each demand attendance more than once a week. I think that this is a bit of a difference - kids often do more than one sport that needs quite a decent commitment even with not particularly elite teams.

I guess that’s the difficulty - maybe if we had single sex scout, some girls would have to end up in a more girly single sex option that might not be their choice, but it would be unlikely to attract lots more boys to fill those spaces because many boys are committed elsewhere.

sunshine244 · 07/11/2026 18:49

When I ran cubs we had roughly 50:50 gender split. The big issue we had was that the rules for parents volunteering changed. We weren't allowed to have occasional parent volunteers any more. Everyone was happy to get a PVG but not to do all the extra mandatory training so it all collapsed. It was a shame, as its allowable to be a parent helper at many other clubs and schools with only a pvg.

It was also almost impossible to do things like camps because no one had time to do the multiple training, experience and assessment needed to get the permits as we were all busy parents. So it was a bit less exciting than we would have liked.

The other issue is how short the length is for each group. If you have more than one child this makes it hard to volunteer bevause inevitably you are likely to want to volunteer for the group your child attends. They move every couple of years so volunteers drop off or want to move too.

Whoddathoughtit · 07/11/2026 18:22

Jane3212 · 06/11/2026 22:40

Why is it so hard to get boys to do Scouts now? It was popular in the past the way Guides was with girls. Why is Guides still popular with girls but Scouts lost popularity with boys? It's a shame.

Social media influence at a guess, all boys activities are geared towards sports from what I see

BirdLandedonmyHead · 07/11/2026 18:20

LunarMarmalade · 07/11/2026 17:13

Why out of interest would you prefer it to be school year? I think it's so much better based on age. My summer born cub will eventually get to be a seconder and then a sixer, which is a role usually given to the oldest ones in the pack. He would never get the chance to lead if cubs was run by school year as he's simply not as mature at the children who are over nine months older.

Actually the one exception to my opinion is the transition from Cubs to Scouts. They ary so much at that age. Some would be better moving pretty much at 10 currently, some at 11. Not all groups follow the flex. DD finished her CS Silver way before her tenth birthday, and had to wait a year to move up to Scouts.

Meanwhile we get 8yos at the beginning of Yr3 that arent really mature enough. They grow up a lot in Yr3.

OP posts:
Jane3212 · 07/11/2026 18:02

Newname26 · 06/11/2026 23:53

Depends how far you are going back.
Scouts are 120 next year.

I think Scouts went through a bit of an identity crisis 20-30 years ago, it wasn't seen as a cool thing to do, dyb dyb dyb and Cubs with those daft caps (green ones with yellow piping)

The rise of two car family must also have made a difference people have more choice in the places they could get kids to.

A generation or so ago lots of Scouts and Guides were run out of church halls. Which were local. And walk able which makes it easier if you are a one car, one driver family.

Female leaders have been part of Scouts for a very long time, even if girls weren't allowed Google tells me 1909, and Cubs were started by women.

Edited

'think Scouts went through a bit of an identity crisis 20-30 years ago, it wasn't seen as a cool thing to do, dyb dyb dyb and Cubs with those daft caps (green ones with yellow piping)'

  • yes, I remember my mother saying she didn't get on with Brownies in the 70s as the stuff like 'Brown Owl' seemed twee to her. Guides remaining more popular with girls now maybe means they've more effectively modernised? The other factors you mention I agree with too.
OP posts:
fabricstash · 07/11/2026 18:00

i really don’t recognise scouts as unfashionable in my area. It’s in demand. The volunteering is different now. We try and have 3 leaders to each section so someone can take an evening off if they have other commitments and to share the load and make more fun for adults. We have young leaders too doing Duke of Edinburgh or similarly and parent helpers

Jane3212 · 07/11/2026 17:56

Newname26 · 07/11/2026 12:55

@RedToothBrush

I'd agree its not good that men no longer really have any single sex spaces.

Women have always had knitting bees, fitness classes, WI etc more groups associated with hobbies.

Mens spaces have often been much more casual like "old men's pubs" or if they are looking for organised its the Mens Guild (is that still a thing?) Or the Masons.

Its decades since women had women only sessions in a local pool, men complained they didn't have a men only session, the women's became Adults Only didn't really tick anyone's boxes

Yes, I think single sex fitness spaces are a good option for both to have. Especially as some religious women (and to some extent men) would have difficulties without.

OP posts:
Jane3212 · 07/11/2026 17:54

C8H10N4O2 · 07/11/2026 12:48

What are the numbers? You are stating there are less all male spaces for boys but your post seems to be about the Scouts not all male spaces for boys. Scouts are not the only boys' spaces. One of the choices made by boys in preference to Scouts is boys sports clubs/activities. In general there are far more optional activities than when Scouting was in its heyday.

Scouts, like boys' schools, started admitting girls because they couldn't attract enough boys. This had a negative knock on effect on girls' groups which became less viable.

Primary school teaching has been overwhelmingly female (except for the headships) since I was a child and before. It was seen as the lower status and lower paid area of teaching so suitable for women. There are more male teachers in primary now than when I was a child or when my DC went through primary.

So your title would better be positioned as "Why are scouts less popular with boys" rather than inventing a problem of insufficient boys' spaces.

Edited

'One of the choices made by boys in preference to Scouts is boys sports clubs/activities. In general there are far more optional activities than when Scouting was in its heyday.'

  • that's a good point. I do still think there are issues with lack of male spaces though.
OP posts:
Jane3212 · 07/11/2026 17:52

fridaynightzzz · 07/11/2026 14:28

I’ve had 2 friends quit running GG because they couldn’t cope with the inept and complicated admin. They have full time jobs and just cant cope with doing that as well as running and supervising the sessions.
It all needs to be simplified for the leaders if they want them to do it for free.

That's really a shame. The positions they took during the trans controversies probably put some off also.

OP posts:
Jane3212 · 07/11/2026 17:50

CurlewKate · 07/11/2026 17:19

There was a time not so long ago when a working parent tended to get home from work in time to volunteer for something. Not generally now.

That's true. Otoh despite difficulty with volunteers Guides still seems to have high demand from Girls, Scouts does not seem to have the same from boys- why?

OP posts:
Jane3212 · 07/11/2026 17:49

RedToothBrush · 07/11/2026 12:24

Scouts is seen as unfashionable. It's got fuck all to do with abuse scandals not a lack of single sex spaces.

In our area, the kids who are scouts are almost exclusively the nerd kids and there's high levels of neurodiversity.

Across district I'm struggling to think of a single kid who is part of the 'in crowd'.

Some groups are almost single sex even now anyway. Others are much more balanced. That's due to a number of factors - everything from what night girls football is on to individual leaders.

You get single sex groups for boys at school - they are called the football team and the rugby team.

What has declined is how much we value the importance of men having single sex spaces. I do think men need it and this is really over looked. We didn't give mens groups the opportunity to really evolve to be more modern in things but also to provide a social support network for men. They've all been labelled as regressive and old fashioned and I think that's somewhat unfair.

I think it's backfired on women in a sense to fail to recognise the importance of male spaces which instead led to a radicalisation through marginalised men who grouped together online rather than an in-person broader base of moderate men based on local mutual interest.

I think it's harder for men to volunteer tbh because of the remarks about abuse and that's really been the problem because there's less positive male role models out there. But that's not to do with a lack of single sex groups as such.

'They've all been labelled as regressive and old fashioned and I think that's somewhat unfair.'

  • I agree strongly with this. Even without sexism I think girls and women would still want some female spaces, & boys and men are the same.

I think people conflated sexist exclusion of women from networking (eg. The Garrick Club, to some extent the Freemasons) with male spaces in general, and that was incorrect & unfair.

Why do you think Scouts has a nerdy base in your area?

OP posts:
CurlewKate · 07/11/2026 17:19

There was a time not so long ago when a working parent tended to get home from work in time to volunteer for something. Not generally now.

LunarMarmalade · 07/11/2026 17:13

BirdLandedonmyHead · 07/11/2026 13:53

We started Squirrels in September.
We sort of felt forced into it, as our Veaver recruitment was struggling as by 6, they alrwady have other hobbies.

Id actually prefer it to be by school year, not age. Squirrels YR-Y1, Beavers Y2-Yr3, Cubs Y4-Y5, Scouts Yr6-Y8/9

Why out of interest would you prefer it to be school year? I think it's so much better based on age. My summer born cub will eventually get to be a seconder and then a sixer, which is a role usually given to the oldest ones in the pack. He would never get the chance to lead if cubs was run by school year as he's simply not as mature at the children who are over nine months older.

BirdLandedonmyHead · 07/11/2026 17:00

@Bushmillsbabe we got some complaints moving Scouts to 6.15 - 8.15.
Meanwhile some peoole say Squirrels is too early at 5-6pm. But we need that 15 minute break between them to reset the hall.
Explorers (elsewhere) is 7.30-9.30. That is too late really.

Bushmillsbabe · 07/11/2026 16:24

Newname26 · 07/11/2026 09:28

Thats another issue.
I'm convinced in the 80s things for kids nearly always started at 7 or 7.30.

Now everything seems much earlier.
I ruled a Beaver group out for having a 6pm start. No chance could I finish work, do pickup, feed kids and get there are 6pm.

Beavers is 6-8 years old, so starting later than 6 would be too late I would think for that age group?
With us, Rainbows (5-7) is 4.30-5.30, Brownies (ages7-10) is 5.45-7. Beavers is 5.30-6.30.
DD1 does guides (ages 11-14) 7.15 to 8.45 which is way too late on a school night, even at 11.
I do get that some parents might find these times challenging (although actually they must not looking at our wait lists), but our priority is the right time for the age group.

exhausted97 · 07/11/2026 15:33

I think like anything that runs on volunteers the quality of provision varies by area. My son tried beavers near us and it was awful. Energies went into football instead, and we have both volunteered for the club, my husband is the team manager and has been for 5+years. There are lots of male only spaces in sport still. I agree with the PP who said the rise in computing and tech based clubs has pulled the less sporty boys away from Scouts and into other things, particularly as Scouts seems restrictive and old fashioned.

BirdLandedonmyHead · 07/11/2026 14:37

wombat1a · 07/11/2026 14:23

I think a lot of the lack of single-sex spaces for boys has come about because of demand from girls that these places are no-longer single sex.

This extends to many others places as well - gold clubs, gyms, boxing clubs etc etc

Not a bad thing really but I do think there is a need for all-male spaces - a space where the more sensitive ones can talk to each other without us ladies being present. I have a number of places I can go that DH is not allowed into but I can not think of anywhere DH can go locally where I wouldn't be able too.

Mens Shed
Andys Man Club

fridaynightzzz · 07/11/2026 14:28

Newname26 · 07/11/2026 13:37

I think thats a huge part of it, people want clubs but don't really want to get involved in the running of them.

I’ve had 2 friends quit running GG because they couldn’t cope with the inept and complicated admin. They have full time jobs and just cant cope with doing that as well as running and supervising the sessions.
It all needs to be simplified for the leaders if they want them to do it for free.

wombat1a · 07/11/2026 14:23

I think a lot of the lack of single-sex spaces for boys has come about because of demand from girls that these places are no-longer single sex.

This extends to many others places as well - gold clubs, gyms, boxing clubs etc etc

Not a bad thing really but I do think there is a need for all-male spaces - a space where the more sensitive ones can talk to each other without us ladies being present. I have a number of places I can go that DH is not allowed into but I can not think of anywhere DH can go locally where I wouldn't be able too.

Newname26 · 07/11/2026 14:09

BirdLandedonmyHead · 07/11/2026 13:53

We started Squirrels in September.
We sort of felt forced into it, as our Veaver recruitment was struggling as by 6, they alrwady have other hobbies.

Id actually prefer it to be by school year, not age. Squirrels YR-Y1, Beavers Y2-Yr3, Cubs Y4-Y5, Scouts Yr6-Y8/9

I suspect thats why the Scout organisation wanted to drop the age to 4 rather than 6.

One issue with doing it by school year, is Scotland and England have slightly different ages in each year group but I hear what your are saying.
Scotland approx 6 mth older starting school

BirdLandedonmyHead · 07/11/2026 13:53

We started Squirrels in September.
We sort of felt forced into it, as our Veaver recruitment was struggling as by 6, they alrwady have other hobbies.

Id actually prefer it to be by school year, not age. Squirrels YR-Y1, Beavers Y2-Yr3, Cubs Y4-Y5, Scouts Yr6-Y8/9