I would suggest that becoming mixed-sex is potentially one of the reasons for its decline. It is no longer really a boys' space in the traditional sense, but has arguably become more of a glorified social club. That said, I suspect it was already going downhill before girls were invited in.
Here's my suspicion.
Historically, it was an organisation where boys could do traditionally boyish things alongside other boys. A space where they could just be themselves, without worrying about being judged by girls, feeling self-conscious or having to perform in a particular way.
Over the years, however, the culture around boys changed considerably. From the mid-1990s through to the mid-2000s, we seemed to move away from relatively wholesome pursuits towards a culture increasingly dominated by lad culture, video gaming, pornography and binge drinking. Being a Scout gradually stopped being fashionable or particularly cool.
Qualities such as being upstanding, honourable, considerate and respectful were no longer necessarily seen as desirable or aspirational. I remember boys at school being teased for going to Scouts. Wearing the uniform, particularly that little neckerchief, was something many found embarrassing. Why would you want to do that when you could go home, read lads' magazines, play video games and spend time with the supposedly cool crowd?
I genuinely believe the 1990s and 2000s had a profoundly damaging effect on aspects of Western culture, with standards and expectations seemingly eroding along the way.
Fast-forward to today, and almost anything male-centric seems to attract a degree of suspicion. I genuinely feel for boys growing up in 2026, trying to navigate a social minefield that they don't always understand. There seems to be very little room for boys simply to be boys, because so much of traditionally masculine behaviour is now automatically labelled toxic.
I can only speculate, not having experienced it myself, but I cannot imagine how confusing it must be for a young boy trying to develop a sense of masculinity while simultaneously feeling that he has to distance himself from anything that might be perceived as traditionally masculine. There must be a tremendous amount of uncertainty around what is and isn't acceptable.
I suspect we will never quite get those traditional spaces back. And why is that? Who, in today's climate, is genuinely comfortable with the idea of boys getting together, doing their own thing and developing independently without female supervision? I'm not being sarcastic when I say that. There seems to be an underlying reluctance to trust boys to simply be boys, as though they are all potential toxic men in the making.
I feel quite passionately about this because I look at the boys growing up around us and see so many who seem increasingly demoralised, lacking confidence and unsure of their place in the world. I worry about the long-term consequences of that.
Surely we can have compassion for both girls and boys without treating their needs as mutually exclusive? Let girls have their spaces, friendships and opportunities to develop together, and let boys have theirs. There is nothing inherently wrong with recognising that boys and girls sometimes benefit from different environments.
I also think we've lost something in the way we understand boys' social development. At school, I remember watching with some bemusement as boys in my class would get into fights, only to walk away five minutes later as the best of friends. Teachers generally didn't intervene, and if parents were informed, they would often simply be told to let the boys sort things out between themselves.
I'm certainly not advocating fighting or suggesting that aggression should be encouraged. But I do wonder whether we've become so uncomfortable with any form of physical rough-and-tumble, competitiveness or confrontation between boys that we've forgotten these can sometimes be part of how they learn boundaries, resolve disagreements and develop resilience.
There is a difference between genuine bullying and harmful aggression, and boys having the freedom to let off steam, test boundaries and navigate the occasional disagreement amongst themselves.
Perhaps what boys need isn't to be constantly corrected or made to feel that something is inherently wrong with how they naturally interact, but to be given appropriate spaces, guidance and trust to grow into decent, well-rounded young men.
I think there is something quite heartbreaking about the way we have come to view boys and masculinity. In our efforts to challenge inequality and protect girls, I sometimes wonder whether we have inadvertently created an environment in which boys feel they must apologise for simply being boys.
As women, mothers, sisters and daughters, surely we should be able to recognise that boys need nurturing, understanding and spaces where they can grow just as much as girls do. They need friendships, camaraderie, a sense of belonging and the freedom to explore who they are without constantly worrying that their natural instincts or behaviour will be judged through an adult lens.
Lets empower and encourage all children, that way we may get far fewer abusive men our there. And yes I know, not all men :)