Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

He needs to step up more, he knew I had a child. aibu?

742 replies

Itsu · 06/11/2026 17:45

I have a 5 year old little girl from a previous relationship who’s absolutely lovely and the light of my life. I met DP (soon to be DH) when DD was 2. He was always accepting and loving towards her and I loved that about him. We’ve had our struggles over the years due to monetary issues etc, but DD has never been an issue.

I’ve always wanted DD to have a family around her. She sees her dad half the week and is with me half the week. DP is very much orientated to doing what he wants when she is here. I’ve told him I expect him to take part in family activities such as kids days out or even just having late nights together on the couch watching films. He does this occasionally but not every time she’s here. I feel like he’s divorcing himself from being a parental figure when she’s here. To be fair to DP, he does cook for her and occasionally plays with her. But DD absolutely loves him and always wants to play with him - more often than not, DP will have work to do or want to read/chill out and redirects her to play with me.

He’s lovely to her. But he disagrees with some of my decisions as a parent. Just basic things like, he tells me that he doesn’t think that he should be doing bedtime stories with her and that’s “our time”, he says that he won’t look after her on his own if I want to go to the gym or see a friend… it feels like a very “us vs him” situation. Recently my ex has changed the schedule and we have DD every weekend. I like to keep DD up later on Fridays and have a pizza and tv night, but DP doesn’t want to do it. He will go on his phone or do something else. He’s never stopped me doing it but I’d like him to be more involved.

Another thing he dislikes is that I put DDs seat in the front seat and he has to sit in the back?

Or if I ask if he wants to go for meal with DD, he says no thanks, 5pm is too early for me

We use his iPad to play games on and when he comes home from work he expects to be handed it back so he can use it… I just think, don’t you care a child is playing? Can’t you use it when she’s asleep?

DP will come to parents evenings and is very present when he chooses to be… but tonight I’ve had a text from him saying that he’s seeing his friends tomorrow and then needs to go and see his elderly mum on Sunday. So a whole weekend acting like a single man whilst I look after dd…

He’s said to me before he loves DD, but his connection to her is through me, he can’t be expected to be a parent when he’s not. I asked what would happen if DDs dad died. He said obviously that would be different and he’d step up, but he doesn’t need to now.

He says that he can’t sacrifice his whole life to being a stepdad and needs to maintain his friendships and family. He moved to my area so I get this, and we live together so it doesn’t feel like we need to “make an effort” to spend time together. I asked him what he preferred time with me or time with us.., i was upset when he said me on my own.

Am I expecting too much from him?

OP posts:
DecafCoffeeIsPointless · 06/11/2026 19:09

I'm tram DH all the way
YANBU

He shouldn't do bedtime stories
He shouldn't be in the backseat
Tea out at 5 is too early
DD shouldn't be on an iPad.

If you didn't push so much he might do a Friday night pizza night.

She is your DD. You only half her half the week. Enjoy your time .

user3572 · 06/11/2026 19:09

It sounds as though he accepts that your DD exists and will be pleasant to her when she’s around but doesn’t want to be any sort of figure in her life. It’s understandable for him to feel like and it would be fine if you weren’t living together and he rarely saw your daughter.

However, you’re planning to marry him and I think that’s a mistake. As time goes on, he’ll have even less to do with your daughter and she’ll begin to notice. If you were to have children there will be a divide between them and that’s not fair on your daughter.

I’ve been in the position of your daughter with my own mum and step-dad and also nearly made the mistake of accepting a relationship like yours. I think you should walk away from this one but accept that the only relationships you might have while your daughter is young/at home are ones where you see the other person when DD is with her dad.

Sunset6 · 06/11/2026 19:10

readingmakesmehappy · 06/11/2026 18:05

5yos shouldn’t be in the front seat.

Have you talked about what if you have a child together?

If they do have a child together, at least he’ll have some company in the back seat

IsaKnows · 06/11/2026 19:10

I also think this is a reverse.

HoneyChocolate · 06/11/2026 19:12

Elveera · 06/11/2026 17:46

You make him sit in the back seat?!

This stood out to me too! Wtf

HideousKinky · 06/11/2026 19:12

He is not her father. She has a father.

If you are disappointed and genuinely envisaged more, you have a difficult decision to make.

It could be he is not the man for you.

But if you let him choose the level of involvement he has, without pressurising him for more, it may improve over time

SaySomethingMan · 06/11/2026 19:13

Yabvvu

Pleasealexa · 06/11/2026 19:13

DecafCoffeeIsPointless · 06/11/2026 19:09

I'm tram DH all the way
YANBU

He shouldn't do bedtime stories
He shouldn't be in the backseat
Tea out at 5 is too early
DD shouldn't be on an iPad.

If you didn't push so much he might do a Friday night pizza night.

She is your DD. You only half her half the week. Enjoy your time .

Agree with this however not looking after her if Op wants to go to the gym? That's not reasonable.

Does he ever spend solo time, such as she's awake at the same time as him but not you?

I think you need to adjust your expectations and your dd should never be in the front over your partner or an adult (safety). However if he refuses to be an active step dad then are you really going to get through the teen years?

Tweeply · 06/11/2026 19:13

You devalue him when he has to sit in the back seat

Purplecatshopaholic · 06/11/2026 19:14

He is not her dad. You are expecting way too much. You seem to want it both ways. Sitting in the back? No way. If that’s an example of things to come, I’m surprised he’s still there - maybe rethink the wedding

Takeoutyourhen · 06/11/2026 19:16

Sometimes you can find a man who really does step up to being a step dad (and women too) and would practically die for their bonus children, I don’t think this man fits this special criteria.

BitOutOfPractice · 06/11/2026 19:17

he really really doesn’t need to “step up more”. Your DD has 2 involved parents. She doesn’t need another super dad.

why have you accepted the new childcare arrangements. I think your ire should be directed to DD’s dad.

ChavsAreReal · 06/11/2026 19:18

Ive voted YABU because you are.

There is a balance to be had and I agree, as your husband to be, he should step up to support you.

BUT

Your expectations aren't reasonable. This is going to get harder as she gets older. You won't be able to force him to play at Dad.

MyDucksAreHavingAParty · 06/11/2026 19:20

Itsu · 06/11/2026 18:18

The car thing is not a regular occurrence at all. It’s just an example!

I just don’t feel like we’re a unit at all. He’s happily out doing his own things, but when dd isn’t here he will spend time with just me?

he has said that he finds this age harder as she’s very active and needs a lot of input. He thinks that days should be fun for all of us, eg he said he’s not coming to say a theme park paw patrol, but would do a day out to a Forrest etc. but dd should come first? She’s only 5

No she shouldn't anyways come first. Some days out, or even time at home, should be based on her wants and interests. But it's really good for children to also go on days out that they don't particularly want to do. Provided they are age appropriate of course. That's what I always did with my DC and now, as young adults they appreciate a variety of activities and we still do a mix of their interests vs my interests.

A recent example is when DS2 and I went to a museum. He wanted to look at the weapons and so on. So we did. Then we looked at an exhibition I was interested in. We both spewed info at the other in our chosen section. Both learned something new, and had a lovely day together. I suppose it helps that we do like mostly the same things. I'm not a huge fan of weapons, but they are interesting.

purpleme12 · 06/11/2026 19:20

IsaKnows · 06/11/2026 19:10

I also think this is a reverse.

There's something fishy about this so a reverse would make sense actually

greengreenjacket · 06/11/2026 19:20

I think you’re both unreasonable tbh.

You’re unreasonable to expect an adult to sit in the back of a car when a child is in the front. You’re also unreasonable to expect him to be completely dedicated to always wanting to spend time with her (I.e. you don’t want him to have any weekend plans without you. Presumably the weekend is his time off and therefore his time to do such things). Equally she’s not his child, he’s not going to want to play with her 100% of the time (even actual parents don’t want to!!).

He’s being unreasonable to not compromise on certain things, like the iPad or dinner timings.

It’s not unusual that he prefers alone time with you, he may care for her but you’re his partner. If you broke up he’d never see her again so she’s not going to be his priority in life.

Tbh it just sounds like you’re really incompatible and I’d be worried about getting married as it’s already not working. I’d also be concerned if you ended up having a child with him that there would be a big disparity between the two children which isn’t fair

Hankunamatata · 06/11/2026 19:20

Hmm this is difficult. No he is the step parent so he shouldn't be at parents evening or need to be out on weekends trips.
I do see even more problems if you plan on having a child together. Especially if he will take his child and not step child.

PinkDaffs · 06/11/2026 19:20

Itsu · 06/11/2026 17:45

I have a 5 year old little girl from a previous relationship who’s absolutely lovely and the light of my life. I met DP (soon to be DH) when DD was 2. He was always accepting and loving towards her and I loved that about him. We’ve had our struggles over the years due to monetary issues etc, but DD has never been an issue.

I’ve always wanted DD to have a family around her. She sees her dad half the week and is with me half the week. DP is very much orientated to doing what he wants when she is here. I’ve told him I expect him to take part in family activities such as kids days out or even just having late nights together on the couch watching films. He does this occasionally but not every time she’s here. I feel like he’s divorcing himself from being a parental figure when she’s here. To be fair to DP, he does cook for her and occasionally plays with her. But DD absolutely loves him and always wants to play with him - more often than not, DP will have work to do or want to read/chill out and redirects her to play with me.

He’s lovely to her. But he disagrees with some of my decisions as a parent. Just basic things like, he tells me that he doesn’t think that he should be doing bedtime stories with her and that’s “our time”, he says that he won’t look after her on his own if I want to go to the gym or see a friend… it feels like a very “us vs him” situation. Recently my ex has changed the schedule and we have DD every weekend. I like to keep DD up later on Fridays and have a pizza and tv night, but DP doesn’t want to do it. He will go on his phone or do something else. He’s never stopped me doing it but I’d like him to be more involved.

Another thing he dislikes is that I put DDs seat in the front seat and he has to sit in the back?

Or if I ask if he wants to go for meal with DD, he says no thanks, 5pm is too early for me

We use his iPad to play games on and when he comes home from work he expects to be handed it back so he can use it… I just think, don’t you care a child is playing? Can’t you use it when she’s asleep?

DP will come to parents evenings and is very present when he chooses to be… but tonight I’ve had a text from him saying that he’s seeing his friends tomorrow and then needs to go and see his elderly mum on Sunday. So a whole weekend acting like a single man whilst I look after dd…

He’s said to me before he loves DD, but his connection to her is through me, he can’t be expected to be a parent when he’s not. I asked what would happen if DDs dad died. He said obviously that would be different and he’d step up, but he doesn’t need to now.

He says that he can’t sacrifice his whole life to being a stepdad and needs to maintain his friendships and family. He moved to my area so I get this, and we live together so it doesn’t feel like we need to “make an effort” to spend time together. I asked him what he preferred time with me or time with us.., i was upset when he said me on my own.

Am I expecting too much from him?

  1. You can't "tell" him you "expect" him to be involved in family activities with your DD. You can make it clear he's welcome and you'd value his being there sometimes but you can't tell him what to do. He's not your employee.

  2. He's not her dad. It's not his responsibility to look after her whilst you go out. If he feels comfortable to then great but if you want to do stuff and he isn't willing to babysit, you need to sort a sitter. Seeing his friends and his elderly mum is not living the life of Riley as a single man. Looking after your DD is 100% your responsibility. You talk about him as if he is her dad and shirking his responsibilities. He isn't. They aren't his to shirk.

  3. Her car seat shouldn't be in the front of your car for optimal safety. He should not be asked to sit in the back. If you know you're picking him up en route somewhere, put her in the back.

  4. Are you serious about the iPad😂? It's his! The entitlement of you thinking he shouldn't ask for it back until your DD is asleep is off the scale. Buy your own iPad.

  5. Did you expect that he would truthfully say he prefers to be with you and your DD rather than just you? Why do you think he would or should feel thid way?

I agree with PPs that you aren't compatible but suspect it's him who should be running. If this were the other way around and a dad was here posting this about his partner, he'd be handed his ass on a plate tbh. It's no different.

Happyjoe · 06/11/2026 19:21

If this was reversed people would be saying you want a nanny with a fanny. Bedtime stories? Sit in back of the car? Every weekend having to play dad? Baby sit when you go out?

You say he's lovely to her, that's grand. But he isn't her dad.. maybe he's not the one to marry if this is unacceptable to you? Will get very complicated if you have children together too as your daughter will be singled out.

TwoYearsTooMany · 06/11/2026 19:21

TraitorOrFaithful · 06/11/2026 18:20

I'm on the fence here. I think he could step up a bit more in some ways but I also think you're expecting quite a lot.

For example, it's mean of him to say that you should be having "us time" with him instead of reading her a bedtime story. But I don't think it's unreasonable for him to want his own iPad.

Didn't she mean that her boyfriend said bedtime stories are parent-child time? Not "us" op+boyfriend, but "us" = mother and child. The OP wants her boyfriend to put her 5 year old daughter to bed, and he's uncomfortable with that or just doesn't want to, so he's saying it's bonding time for parent and child and mum's boyfriend should stay out of it. That's incredibly reasonable!

Honestly the OP has such blatantly unreasonable examples that I suspect it's a reverse. Stepmothers are frequently and quite rightly told that the children's father should be the one parenting children which are his from a previous relationship, and women are warned about the deadbeat dads just looking for an unpaid nanny to share their bed and pay half the rent.

InterestedObserver · 06/11/2026 19:22

People keep telling you not to marry him, but really he is the one who should not be marrying you. You are expecting way too much of the man. He is doing everything a reasonable person would expect of him.

DewDropsAndCobWebs · 06/11/2026 19:24

You are wanting him, to want to be her dad
He wants to be your partner, and cares about your dad, but doesn't strive to become her dad

MMUmum · 06/11/2026 19:24

Itsu · 06/11/2026 18:18

The car thing is not a regular occurrence at all. It’s just an example!

I just don’t feel like we’re a unit at all. He’s happily out doing his own things, but when dd isn’t here he will spend time with just me?

he has said that he finds this age harder as she’s very active and needs a lot of input. He thinks that days should be fun for all of us, eg he said he’s not coming to say a theme park paw patrol, but would do a day out to a Forrest etc. but dd should come first? She’s only 5

Right that Dd comes first, but that doesn't mean your partner needs to do things he doesn't want to, like going to theme parks etc. You need to listen to what everyone is saying here, he's not Dds father and he doesn't want to play happy families with her. You are trying to force him to live a family life and he doesn't want this at all, it's not going to happen so you need to rethink

Cherrysoup · 06/11/2026 19:24

Hope you’ve turned off the airbag for the front passenger seat! I can’t believe your 5 year old sits in the front, that’s so dangerous.

This bloke has made it clear that he’s not interested in being her dad-she already has one. He’s told you he prefers time alone with you. Are you seriously prioritising him over your 5 year old? She won’t thank you for it in future years.

suburberphobe · 06/11/2026 19:25

IMO its a bad idea to pursue this relationship and an even worse one to get married and have children with him, for so many reasons. Ranging from him treating them differently or being just as checked out. There is no good scenario here.

I agree.

As for making him sitting in the back of the car, I have no words.
Small children should never sit in the passenger seat. They could fly through the windscreen in an accident.