Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

He needs to step up more, he knew I had a child. aibu?

742 replies

Itsu · 06/11/2026 17:45

I have a 5 year old little girl from a previous relationship who’s absolutely lovely and the light of my life. I met DP (soon to be DH) when DD was 2. He was always accepting and loving towards her and I loved that about him. We’ve had our struggles over the years due to monetary issues etc, but DD has never been an issue.

I’ve always wanted DD to have a family around her. She sees her dad half the week and is with me half the week. DP is very much orientated to doing what he wants when she is here. I’ve told him I expect him to take part in family activities such as kids days out or even just having late nights together on the couch watching films. He does this occasionally but not every time she’s here. I feel like he’s divorcing himself from being a parental figure when she’s here. To be fair to DP, he does cook for her and occasionally plays with her. But DD absolutely loves him and always wants to play with him - more often than not, DP will have work to do or want to read/chill out and redirects her to play with me.

He’s lovely to her. But he disagrees with some of my decisions as a parent. Just basic things like, he tells me that he doesn’t think that he should be doing bedtime stories with her and that’s “our time”, he says that he won’t look after her on his own if I want to go to the gym or see a friend… it feels like a very “us vs him” situation. Recently my ex has changed the schedule and we have DD every weekend. I like to keep DD up later on Fridays and have a pizza and tv night, but DP doesn’t want to do it. He will go on his phone or do something else. He’s never stopped me doing it but I’d like him to be more involved.

Another thing he dislikes is that I put DDs seat in the front seat and he has to sit in the back?

Or if I ask if he wants to go for meal with DD, he says no thanks, 5pm is too early for me

We use his iPad to play games on and when he comes home from work he expects to be handed it back so he can use it… I just think, don’t you care a child is playing? Can’t you use it when she’s asleep?

DP will come to parents evenings and is very present when he chooses to be… but tonight I’ve had a text from him saying that he’s seeing his friends tomorrow and then needs to go and see his elderly mum on Sunday. So a whole weekend acting like a single man whilst I look after dd…

He’s said to me before he loves DD, but his connection to her is through me, he can’t be expected to be a parent when he’s not. I asked what would happen if DDs dad died. He said obviously that would be different and he’d step up, but he doesn’t need to now.

He says that he can’t sacrifice his whole life to being a stepdad and needs to maintain his friendships and family. He moved to my area so I get this, and we live together so it doesn’t feel like we need to “make an effort” to spend time together. I asked him what he preferred time with me or time with us.., i was upset when he said me on my own.

Am I expecting too much from him?

OP posts:
Kosenrufugirl · 09/11/2026 04:43

BiggerIsAlwaysBetter · 06/11/2026 17:51

Yes and no.

She isn't his and he is being clear that he doesn't want to play dad. And that's fine, but now you know, you need to stop confusing her by playing family.

IMO its a bad idea to pursue this relationship and an even worse one to get married and have children with him, for so many reasons. Ranging from him treating them differently or being just as checked out. There is no good scenario here.

This

rainingsnoring · 09/11/2026 06:05

PuttingOnTheKitsch · 09/11/2026 03:24

It's not a horrible post. There are far too many non-parents who have no understanding of parenting and in some cases, seem to actively dislike children, weighing their oar in on these types of threads and they all have terrible advice to boot.

It is, objectively, a horrible post.

'Your comments are laughable. I feel bad for any kids you might have. Have the Sunday you deserve.'

Awful.

You have no idea whether people are parents or not when they comment. Just because you happen to disagree with others, it does not follow that they are wrong, nor that others have no idea about parenting. Indeed, the majority disagree with you so one could argue that it is you who is wrong!

Thedevilhasfinallycaughtupwithhim · 09/11/2026 06:38

rainingsnoring · 09/11/2026 06:05

It is, objectively, a horrible post.

'Your comments are laughable. I feel bad for any kids you might have. Have the Sunday you deserve.'

Awful.

You have no idea whether people are parents or not when they comment. Just because you happen to disagree with others, it does not follow that they are wrong, nor that others have no idea about parenting. Indeed, the majority disagree with you so one could argue that it is you who is wrong!

I don’t think the majority disagree with her necessarily.
The “AIBU” question is a little obscure in this case.
People will have clicked that she is being unreasonable because they think she’s asking too much of the man AND because they think she is expecting a reasonable contribution from a man who lives with her and her child but that she is unreasonable for having him in her child’s life when he would rather she didn’t exist.

rainingsnoring · 09/11/2026 07:22

Thedevilhasfinallycaughtupwithhim · 09/11/2026 06:38

I don’t think the majority disagree with her necessarily.
The “AIBU” question is a little obscure in this case.
People will have clicked that she is being unreasonable because they think she’s asking too much of the man AND because they think she is expecting a reasonable contribution from a man who lives with her and her child but that she is unreasonable for having him in her child’s life when he would rather she didn’t exist.

The AIBU is 'he needs to step up more, AIBU'. That seems pretty clear. At present, over 90% think she is being unreasonable.
I doubt the OP will be back as the answers didn't fit with what she was hoping for.
I don't think this couple should marry though. They clearly have different expectations.

Thedevilhasfinallycaughtupwithhim · 09/11/2026 07:25

rainingsnoring · 09/11/2026 07:22

The AIBU is 'he needs to step up more, AIBU'. That seems pretty clear. At present, over 90% think she is being unreasonable.
I doubt the OP will be back as the answers didn't fit with what she was hoping for.
I don't think this couple should marry though. They clearly have different expectations.

And then you read the context and decide she is being unreasonable for wanting to marry a man (and wanting him to “step up”) who would prefer her daughter to not exist.

There have been plenty of posters who have expressed this in the thread. Certainly more than 10%.

Simply, “AIBU to want him to step up”

Some posters- Yes because he isn’t the girls’ dad
others- yes because he shouldn’t even be in your life when he doesn’t want to be a family unit with your already existing daughter.

ithinkthereforeyouarewrong · 09/11/2026 07:40

You both want/expect different things. Neither of you are particularly wrong but you are incompatible.
Does he want children? My concern would be that if you had your own kids either he would be equally detached and you would be doing all the work or he would be a full on engaging parent and your dd would be the poor relation.

We have a blended family and my dc were 4/6 when I met dh. I took it slow he met them after 7. Months and saw them gradually. He moved in after 2.5 years and at first I had no expectations I just wanted them to get use to each other. Their dad wasn’t very involved and it got less as they got older so dh took on more and more. He is their dad in every way but I never pushed it, it happened on his/their terms

rainingsnoring · 09/11/2026 07:41

Thedevilhasfinallycaughtupwithhim · 09/11/2026 07:25

And then you read the context and decide she is being unreasonable for wanting to marry a man (and wanting him to “step up”) who would prefer her daughter to not exist.

There have been plenty of posters who have expressed this in the thread. Certainly more than 10%.

Simply, “AIBU to want him to step up”

Some posters- Yes because he isn’t the girls’ dad
others- yes because he shouldn’t even be in your life when he doesn’t want to be a family unit with your already existing daughter.

Edited

I understood your point the first time.

Theroadt · 09/11/2026 07:47

Itsu · 06/11/2026 17:49

Only if I’m driving from somewhere where I’ve taken her out before I got to him!

She should still swap to the back seat. You are bringing her up to be princessy.

ithinkthereforeyouarewrong · 09/11/2026 07:49

ithinkthereforeyouarewrong · 09/11/2026 07:40

You both want/expect different things. Neither of you are particularly wrong but you are incompatible.
Does he want children? My concern would be that if you had your own kids either he would be equally detached and you would be doing all the work or he would be a full on engaging parent and your dd would be the poor relation.

We have a blended family and my dc were 4/6 when I met dh. I took it slow he met them after 7. Months and saw them gradually. He moved in after 2.5 years and at first I had no expectations I just wanted them to get use to each other. Their dad wasn’t very involved and it got less as they got older so dh took on more and more. He is their dad in every way but I never pushed it, it happened on his/their terms

Adding that if the examples you have given -
dh never sat in back of car
i did bedtimes unless I was ill/out
dh would do some day trips but not all. He wouldn’t come to a kids theatre show (unless it was a birthday outing) but he would do a theme park . I liked doing stuff solo with dds
we didn’t have a iPad but if they went on his Xbox he would either play with them or wait till they were done (but that wouldn’t be hours)

Theroadt · 09/11/2026 07:49

Itsu · 06/11/2026 18:18

The car thing is not a regular occurrence at all. It’s just an example!

I just don’t feel like we’re a unit at all. He’s happily out doing his own things, but when dd isn’t here he will spend time with just me?

he has said that he finds this age harder as she’s very active and needs a lot of input. He thinks that days should be fun for all of us, eg he said he’s not coming to say a theme park paw patrol, but would do a day out to a Forrest etc. but dd should come first? She’s only 5

Your daughter should come first to you absolutely, but I think you are expecting too much from him

Detemum · 09/11/2026 10:14

Itsu · 06/11/2026 17:45

I have a 5 year old little girl from a previous relationship who’s absolutely lovely and the light of my life. I met DP (soon to be DH) when DD was 2. He was always accepting and loving towards her and I loved that about him. We’ve had our struggles over the years due to monetary issues etc, but DD has never been an issue.

I’ve always wanted DD to have a family around her. She sees her dad half the week and is with me half the week. DP is very much orientated to doing what he wants when she is here. I’ve told him I expect him to take part in family activities such as kids days out or even just having late nights together on the couch watching films. He does this occasionally but not every time she’s here. I feel like he’s divorcing himself from being a parental figure when she’s here. To be fair to DP, he does cook for her and occasionally plays with her. But DD absolutely loves him and always wants to play with him - more often than not, DP will have work to do or want to read/chill out and redirects her to play with me.

He’s lovely to her. But he disagrees with some of my decisions as a parent. Just basic things like, he tells me that he doesn’t think that he should be doing bedtime stories with her and that’s “our time”, he says that he won’t look after her on his own if I want to go to the gym or see a friend… it feels like a very “us vs him” situation. Recently my ex has changed the schedule and we have DD every weekend. I like to keep DD up later on Fridays and have a pizza and tv night, but DP doesn’t want to do it. He will go on his phone or do something else. He’s never stopped me doing it but I’d like him to be more involved.

Another thing he dislikes is that I put DDs seat in the front seat and he has to sit in the back?

Or if I ask if he wants to go for meal with DD, he says no thanks, 5pm is too early for me

We use his iPad to play games on and when he comes home from work he expects to be handed it back so he can use it… I just think, don’t you care a child is playing? Can’t you use it when she’s asleep?

DP will come to parents evenings and is very present when he chooses to be… but tonight I’ve had a text from him saying that he’s seeing his friends tomorrow and then needs to go and see his elderly mum on Sunday. So a whole weekend acting like a single man whilst I look after dd…

He’s said to me before he loves DD, but his connection to her is through me, he can’t be expected to be a parent when he’s not. I asked what would happen if DDs dad died. He said obviously that would be different and he’d step up, but he doesn’t need to now.

He says that he can’t sacrifice his whole life to being a stepdad and needs to maintain his friendships and family. He moved to my area so I get this, and we live together so it doesn’t feel like we need to “make an effort” to spend time together. I asked him what he preferred time with me or time with us.., i was upset when he said me on my own.

Am I expecting too much from him?

No. You come as a set... mum and daughter.

Honestly? I wouldn't marry him if he doesn't want to be her dad.

I was in a similar position but bio dad wasn't on the scene (his choice) now DH knew my position and she had, until then, only known him as being my friend.. which wasn't too difficult as we had a hobby in common.

He messaged me a long long message telling me how he felt and that he wanted to take us on as a team (so to speak) and be a dad to her if I would let him.

When we got married she had first say in the ceremony if she wanted this to go ahead or not. So basically he married her before me lol. Now she's older she's embarrassed about this... but I tell her it's her fault she forced me to marry him.

I wouldn't marry anyone who didn't see us as a team and expected me to parent separately.
He took her to school when I couldn't and let me go to the gym and baby sat her. It was never something that even came into question.
His parents also wanted to meet my daughter and take her on as a granddaughter.

Thedevilhasfinallycaughtupwithhim · 09/11/2026 10:16

rainingsnoring · 09/11/2026 07:41

I understood your point the first time.

That’s good. Your reply suggested otherwise so thought it might help for clarity to add further information 😊

Andouille · 09/11/2026 10:29

The daughter has a father. The new partner is right to maintain a certain distance and not step on the toes of the real father.

OP needs to give some consideration to her ex and his feelings before asking another man to step into his shoes.

JHound · 09/11/2026 10:54

Itsu · 06/11/2026 17:45

I have a 5 year old little girl from a previous relationship who’s absolutely lovely and the light of my life. I met DP (soon to be DH) when DD was 2. He was always accepting and loving towards her and I loved that about him. We’ve had our struggles over the years due to monetary issues etc, but DD has never been an issue.

I’ve always wanted DD to have a family around her. She sees her dad half the week and is with me half the week. DP is very much orientated to doing what he wants when she is here. I’ve told him I expect him to take part in family activities such as kids days out or even just having late nights together on the couch watching films. He does this occasionally but not every time she’s here. I feel like he’s divorcing himself from being a parental figure when she’s here. To be fair to DP, he does cook for her and occasionally plays with her. But DD absolutely loves him and always wants to play with him - more often than not, DP will have work to do or want to read/chill out and redirects her to play with me.

He’s lovely to her. But he disagrees with some of my decisions as a parent. Just basic things like, he tells me that he doesn’t think that he should be doing bedtime stories with her and that’s “our time”, he says that he won’t look after her on his own if I want to go to the gym or see a friend… it feels like a very “us vs him” situation. Recently my ex has changed the schedule and we have DD every weekend. I like to keep DD up later on Fridays and have a pizza and tv night, but DP doesn’t want to do it. He will go on his phone or do something else. He’s never stopped me doing it but I’d like him to be more involved.

Another thing he dislikes is that I put DDs seat in the front seat and he has to sit in the back?

Or if I ask if he wants to go for meal with DD, he says no thanks, 5pm is too early for me

We use his iPad to play games on and when he comes home from work he expects to be handed it back so he can use it… I just think, don’t you care a child is playing? Can’t you use it when she’s asleep?

DP will come to parents evenings and is very present when he chooses to be… but tonight I’ve had a text from him saying that he’s seeing his friends tomorrow and then needs to go and see his elderly mum on Sunday. So a whole weekend acting like a single man whilst I look after dd…

He’s said to me before he loves DD, but his connection to her is through me, he can’t be expected to be a parent when he’s not. I asked what would happen if DDs dad died. He said obviously that would be different and he’d step up, but he doesn’t need to now.

He says that he can’t sacrifice his whole life to being a stepdad and needs to maintain his friendships and family. He moved to my area so I get this, and we live together so it doesn’t feel like we need to “make an effort” to spend time together. I asked him what he preferred time with me or time with us.., i was upset when he said me on my own.

Am I expecting too much from him?

You making him sit in the back seat is weird but he has an unrealistic view of what it’s like to date a parent, just as you have an unrealistic view of him playing a father role.

This relationship has no future OP.

EveryoneUsingOutro · 09/11/2026 14:26

Isittimeformynapyet · 06/11/2026 23:58

Here are some excerpts from the actual OP:

He was always accepting and loving towards her and I loved that about him.

DD has never been an issue.

He’s lovely to her.

DD absolutely loves him

he does cook for her

DP will come to parents evenings and is very present when he chooses

But you have concluded that he is just "a dick"?

That is not a balanced opinion.

Yeah I guess that poster has some issues that they are projecting onto this bloke …..

EveryoneUsingOutro · 09/11/2026 14:27

Firefly1987 · 07/11/2026 00:14

I have no idea why a childless guy would want this set-up. He'd be a total mug to agree to it when he can go and find a woman without kids and all this headache. I presume he doesn't have many other options for some reason.

“Monetary issues” may play a part in this …

Isittimeformynapyet · 09/11/2026 14:29

EveryoneUsingOutro · 09/11/2026 14:26

Yeah I guess that poster has some issues that they are projecting onto this bloke …..

Yes, that's the conclusion a few of us have come to. There's been a procession of posters tag-teaming with the same inability to discuss an individual scenario on its own merits.

Thedevilhasfinallycaughtupwithhim · 09/11/2026 14:34

EveryoneUsingOutro · 09/11/2026 14:26

Yeah I guess that poster has some issues that they are projecting onto this bloke …..

We all have experiences that shape our opinions but you seem to focus on me and imply that my opinion should be disregarded because of it.

I think a child deserves someone who is fully invested in them and centres them in the family unit if that adult is living in the home.

I don’t think it’s enough to be nice or to occasionally play with them or make them food. I think this is all great for a boyfriend who visits but not a stepdad living in the home.

Thedevilhasfinallycaughtupwithhim · 09/11/2026 14:35

Isittimeformynapyet · 09/11/2026 14:29

Yes, that's the conclusion a few of us have come to. There's been a procession of posters tag-teaming with the same inability to discuss an individual scenario on its own merits.

Edited

Tag teaming you say?
Interesting perspective

Sonato · 09/11/2026 14:38

He is telling you loud and clear his position

You are choosing not to listen

He will never be her parent the way you want him to be.

If you marry this man you will not be happy. And it will be your own fault.

Isittimeformynapyet · 09/11/2026 14:43

Thedevilhasfinallycaughtupwithhim · 09/11/2026 14:34

We all have experiences that shape our opinions but you seem to focus on me and imply that my opinion should be disregarded because of it.

I think a child deserves someone who is fully invested in them and centres them in the family unit if that adult is living in the home.

I don’t think it’s enough to be nice or to occasionally play with them or make them food. I think this is all great for a boyfriend who visits but not a stepdad living in the home.

Finally, you've given your opinion - which is perfectly valid - without the vitriol that made your previous posts stand out from the crowd.

Softly, softly, catchy monkey 🐒

Thedevilhasfinallycaughtupwithhim · 09/11/2026 14:46

Isittimeformynapyet · 09/11/2026 14:43

Finally, you've given your opinion - which is perfectly valid - without the vitriol that made your previous posts stand out from the crowd.

Softly, softly, catchy monkey 🐒

I didn’t level any vitriol at other posters, only the OP’s fiancé

EveryoneUsingOutro · 09/11/2026 14:51

Quine0nline · 07/11/2026 07:35

He may not be the birth father or the sperm donor. If he is invested and wants to be, he could be the "father" - the positive make role model, the man who is interested in helping her; educated her; play with her; listen to her; be there for her as the closest male acting in a fatherly way.

He does not appear interested.
You will not change him.
Be aware of that for the future.

The DD HAS a dad who sees her 50% of the time as said by OP!! So why would he need to be another “father figure”?

EveryoneUsingOutro · 09/11/2026 14:53

PollyBell · 07/11/2026 08:03

So mothers are told their male partner is responsible to do everything for his children she shouldnt have to do anything for them yet when it is reversed he has to do everything

Usual double standard

That’s really not the vast majority of responses on this thread.

Napsarelife · 09/11/2026 15:36

Don't marry this man, you're in different books let alone on the same page. He doesn't want to parent her at all, and you want a man who does want to play families, you cant be mad at him about this, he's got obvious boundaries, stop trying to force something that wont happen. Your resentment will simply grow.