Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

He needs to step up more, he knew I had a child. aibu?

742 replies

Itsu · 06/11/2026 17:45

I have a 5 year old little girl from a previous relationship who’s absolutely lovely and the light of my life. I met DP (soon to be DH) when DD was 2. He was always accepting and loving towards her and I loved that about him. We’ve had our struggles over the years due to monetary issues etc, but DD has never been an issue.

I’ve always wanted DD to have a family around her. She sees her dad half the week and is with me half the week. DP is very much orientated to doing what he wants when she is here. I’ve told him I expect him to take part in family activities such as kids days out or even just having late nights together on the couch watching films. He does this occasionally but not every time she’s here. I feel like he’s divorcing himself from being a parental figure when she’s here. To be fair to DP, he does cook for her and occasionally plays with her. But DD absolutely loves him and always wants to play with him - more often than not, DP will have work to do or want to read/chill out and redirects her to play with me.

He’s lovely to her. But he disagrees with some of my decisions as a parent. Just basic things like, he tells me that he doesn’t think that he should be doing bedtime stories with her and that’s “our time”, he says that he won’t look after her on his own if I want to go to the gym or see a friend… it feels like a very “us vs him” situation. Recently my ex has changed the schedule and we have DD every weekend. I like to keep DD up later on Fridays and have a pizza and tv night, but DP doesn’t want to do it. He will go on his phone or do something else. He’s never stopped me doing it but I’d like him to be more involved.

Another thing he dislikes is that I put DDs seat in the front seat and he has to sit in the back?

Or if I ask if he wants to go for meal with DD, he says no thanks, 5pm is too early for me

We use his iPad to play games on and when he comes home from work he expects to be handed it back so he can use it… I just think, don’t you care a child is playing? Can’t you use it when she’s asleep?

DP will come to parents evenings and is very present when he chooses to be… but tonight I’ve had a text from him saying that he’s seeing his friends tomorrow and then needs to go and see his elderly mum on Sunday. So a whole weekend acting like a single man whilst I look after dd…

He’s said to me before he loves DD, but his connection to her is through me, he can’t be expected to be a parent when he’s not. I asked what would happen if DDs dad died. He said obviously that would be different and he’d step up, but he doesn’t need to now.

He says that he can’t sacrifice his whole life to being a stepdad and needs to maintain his friendships and family. He moved to my area so I get this, and we live together so it doesn’t feel like we need to “make an effort” to spend time together. I asked him what he preferred time with me or time with us.., i was upset when he said me on my own.

Am I expecting too much from him?

OP posts:
Thedevilhasfinallycaughtupwithhim · 07/11/2026 09:47

Isittimeformynapyet · 07/11/2026 09:45

I was going to comment on another post you made this morning where you used words like he "demands" and he "refuses" and "avoids", when the information OP has given tell us the opposite.

Now you've added "like the plague"!

You're just ramping things up. In a few posts time he'll be locking her in a cupboard.

Maybe you have a negative personal experience of this situation which is causing you to take a very negative view of this man and only see it through that lens, but as I said earlier, it's not a balanced view.

You are choosing to completely dismiss a lot of detail that has actually been given and are doggedly sticking with things you've exaggerated or made up yourself.

Edited

Ok

What is your experience of this situation?

rainingsnoring · 07/11/2026 09:52

Thedevilhasfinallycaughtupwithhim · 07/11/2026 08:44

I don’t think he should act as an equal parent.

But he shouldn’t avoid her like the plague when he’s sharing a home with her and marrying her mum.

I've no idea where you get that impression from when the OP, who is complaining, literally says that he is loving towards her and is lovely to her and cooks for her. He just doesn't want to take an equal parenting role as he is not her parent. He wants to sometimes see his friends or his elderly mother at the weekend. Given that the little girl is now with them every weekend, it is hardly unreasonable that he wants some time off work to spend as he chooses. On the other hand, the Mum seems to want to palm off her DD when she only has her 50% of the time now. That seems much more unreasonable to me.

Restlessdreams1994 · 07/11/2026 09:53

I can’t get past the fact that you think your daughter should have HIS ipad to play games on even when he’s home and wants to use it.

Let this poor man go.

And think about how entitled and spoiled your daughter risks becoming if you carry on like this. Have a read of some of the posts on here from mums with ungrateful, out of control teenagers who don’t respect or care about them. Teaching a child that their needs trump the needs of everyone else around them is where it starts.

kkloo · 07/11/2026 09:54

Meadowfinch · 07/11/2026 09:05

This nails it. You want to create a family of three and he doesn't.

If you marry and have a child with him, he will put his child first, leave your dd out in the cold, and do irreperable harm.

If you want to protect your dd, call off the wedding and stop kidding yourself.

Edited

He may well be the same with his own biological children.

Alexisclarerose · 07/11/2026 10:01

he is not her father. She has two involved parents. She is your and your ex’s child. She does not need another father because she has one. You should have addressed these boundaries much earlier

TheLemonLemur · 07/11/2026 10:02

He is telling you he doesnt want to be a dad but you are continually pushing this on him because you want the perceived happy family unit. Your daughter spends half the week with her dad she doesnt need your boyfriend to be a dad just let him continue with what he is comfortable doing or don't be with him

Bestfootforward11 · 07/11/2026 10:09

I’m a bit mixed here. I understand what you want is that you are a team with your DD but at the same time that is not how you are acting. Making him sit in the back seat or not returning his iPad is not on. I think you should be doing bedtime as your DD is not with you the whole week. And when she is away, that is the time when I think you should be going to the gym and seeing friends. If she’s with you on weekends why not make the Friday night about you and her and you go out for a brunch and walk all together the next day? Youve not actually been together for all that long and your DD is navigating two separate homes at a very young age. I think you should be focusing on her and not what he is or isn’t doing.

Isittimeformynapyet · 07/11/2026 10:11

Thedevilhasfinallycaughtupwithhim · 07/11/2026 09:47

Ok

What is your experience of this situation?

My parents divorced when I was 12 and I lived with my dad. My dad remarried. She had four kids. They didn't have more children of their own. She was always lovely to me and gave me her time but she had a special relationship with her own daughter and I had an awesome relationship with my mum. We were treated "differently" but that was OK for me (I was older than OP's DD).

My best friend's SM actively treated her very badly.

Two similar situations, four separate people, but two very different outcomes.

But the main basis of my take on this thread is simply reading the information that the OP has given us on her own individual situation.

Sweetandsours · 07/11/2026 10:12

Why have you moved in a man that clearly has zero interest in being with a woman with a child?

This is not in your childs interest.
It will be a lot worse if you are foolish enough to have another child with him.

He doesn't want to be a family with you.
Could it be any clearer?

I think it is absolutely dreadful you have moved someone like that into your childs home.

As for marrying him?
Unbelievable.

You clearly must think a man is more important than your child, and she will grow up knowing that.

Your daughter deserves so much better than living with a man who has no wish to be around her.

Poor little mite.

Thedevilhasfinallycaughtupwithhim · 07/11/2026 10:14

Isittimeformynapyet · 07/11/2026 10:11

My parents divorced when I was 12 and I lived with my dad. My dad remarried. She had four kids. They didn't have more children of their own. She was always lovely to me and gave me her time but she had a special relationship with her own daughter and I had an awesome relationship with my mum. We were treated "differently" but that was OK for me (I was older than OP's DD).

My best friend's SM actively treated her very badly.

Two similar situations, four separate people, but two very different outcomes.

But the main basis of my take on this thread is simply reading the information that the OP has given us on her own individual situation.

Edited

So you could say that your experience has shaped your opinion of this situation? And that his indifference to the daughter is not going to harm her because you had a step mother who prioritised her own children and you were always ok with that?

So why do aggressively dismiss my opinion simply because you think I have prior negative experience?

Isittimeformynapyet · 07/11/2026 10:23

Thedevilhasfinallycaughtupwithhim · 07/11/2026 10:14

So you could say that your experience has shaped your opinion of this situation? And that his indifference to the daughter is not going to harm her because you had a step mother who prioritised her own children and you were always ok with that?

So why do aggressively dismiss my opinion simply because you think I have prior negative experience?

I don't feel I have been aggressive.

I've been pretty clear that I'm looking at OP's situation as its own entity. Not from my experience, not from my friend's experience (which was horrible and loomed large for a big chunk of our childhoods. I was so angry at the injustice on behalf of my friend).

I haven't actually said that the OP's partner's "indifference" won't harm her DD. It might.

I agree with the vast majority here that they are incompatible and should not marry. But I don't agree with you that he is a "dick" and that he is a terrible human.

zingally · 07/11/2026 10:25

I'm not often on the man's side, but on this case, I am.

He's not her dad, with all respect. He shouldn't be expected to do 50% of the parenting of a child that isn't his. If you want another person to do that, she needs to spend 50% of her time with her bio dad.
He's not going to change, and honestly? I don't think he should. If that's a deal breaker for you, you should end it.

Thedevilhasfinallycaughtupwithhim · 07/11/2026 10:25

Isittimeformynapyet · 07/11/2026 10:23

I don't feel I have been aggressive.

I've been pretty clear that I'm looking at OP's situation as its own entity. Not from my experience, not from my friend's experience (which was horrible and loomed large for a big chunk of our childhoods. I was so angry at the injustice on behalf of my friend).

I haven't actually said that the OP's partner's "indifference" won't harm her DD. It might.

I agree with the vast majority here that they are incompatible and should not marry. But I don't agree with you that he is a "dick" and that he is a terrible human.

I said he was a dick. He is. You can’t move into a home with a child but would actually prefer for them to not exist.
That’s a dick move.

Isittimeformynapyet · 07/11/2026 10:27

Thedevilhasfinallycaughtupwithhim · 07/11/2026 10:25

I said he was a dick. He is. You can’t move into a home with a child but would actually prefer for them to not exist.
That’s a dick move.

OK.

Fair enough 🤷🏻

Rightsraptor · 07/11/2026 10:29

This does not bode well.

My ExH was the father of our children and he persistently opted out of stuff he didn't want to do, like reading particular stories, being a swimming pool with them as their adult ('I get cold'), playing any game he didn't want to play. He was jealous of them as I later discovered.

No easy answers but you need to talk it through and decide what and who is more important to you.

Monty36 · 07/11/2026 10:31

He is not some sort of performing toy. That you can switch on to ‘ daddy’, mode when you want that. Or off for that matter.

He comes home, yes he wants to use his IPAD. It is not your daughter’s toy.
And sometimes, yes, he has to work.

As to the front seat. I am amazed he gets in the back seat. If you know you are going somewhere first, the seat goes in the back.

Going to see your mum is not being a single bloke. It is going to see his mum.

I think he senses you are critical of him, and no, he doesn’t want to look after your daughter on her own. In case he did that wrong in some way which disappointed you.

rainingsnoring · 07/11/2026 10:35

Thedevilhasfinallycaughtupwithhim · 07/11/2026 10:14

So you could say that your experience has shaped your opinion of this situation? And that his indifference to the daughter is not going to harm her because you had a step mother who prioritised her own children and you were always ok with that?

So why do aggressively dismiss my opinion simply because you think I have prior negative experience?

The other poster hasn't been aggressive at all. She suggested that you may have had some sort of negative experience of your own. You didn't answer her question but turned the question onto her and then decided, after she responded, that this explained her particular opinion, just because it didn't fit with your own!
There is no evidence from what is actually written, as opposed to whatever is in your own imagination, that this man is 'a dick'. Your opinion appears to be influenced by your personal, negative experience.

rainingsnoring · 07/11/2026 10:36

Rightsraptor · 07/11/2026 10:29

This does not bode well.

My ExH was the father of our children and he persistently opted out of stuff he didn't want to do, like reading particular stories, being a swimming pool with them as their adult ('I get cold'), playing any game he didn't want to play. He was jealous of them as I later discovered.

No easy answers but you need to talk it through and decide what and who is more important to you.

That's a completely different situation! This is your DC's father. This child already has a loving father, who cares for her 50% of the time!

MrsBennetsPoorNervesAreBack · 07/11/2026 10:37

He doesn't want to be your dd's second dad. She isn't his child, and he's not that interested.

As long as he is consistently kind to her, I don't think that's necessarily a problem, but ultimately, it's for you to decide whether you can accept him as he is or whether it isn't enough. You can't force him to step up if he doesn't want to.

I don't think I could ever love someone's child in the way that a parent would, so I wouldn't personally have put myself in the position of being a step parent, nor would I ever have brought a step parent into my dd's life. I don't think it's reasonable or realistic to expect them to love your dc like you do. But that's just how I see it.

VanquishedColston · 07/11/2026 10:42

Thedevilhasfinallycaughtupwithhim · 07/11/2026 09:04

It’s been three years and the majority of her life.
She won’t remember him NOT being a part of her life.

Yes and it was the same for me with my stepdaughter, who was only 2 when I met her.

But I was as not presented to her as another mother figure, the first year was spent with me seeing her every few weeks for a day out or short visit so she had time to get to know me and not feel her time with her dad was being taken away - I assume it has been similar for OP and her partner since she sounded like a responsible parent.

Also children know many people for the majority of their lives - doesn't mean they regard them as a parental figure.

Some things take time and need to be allowed to grow organically. You can't just throw and unrelated adult and child together and expect them to immediately fuse to the level of a parent and child. It's mad and a recipe for disaster.

Thedevilhasfinallycaughtupwithhim · 07/11/2026 10:43

rainingsnoring · 07/11/2026 10:35

The other poster hasn't been aggressive at all. She suggested that you may have had some sort of negative experience of your own. You didn't answer her question but turned the question onto her and then decided, after she responded, that this explained her particular opinion, just because it didn't fit with your own!
There is no evidence from what is actually written, as opposed to whatever is in your own imagination, that this man is 'a dick'. Your opinion appears to be influenced by your personal, negative experience.

I found her tone incredibly aggressive.
And I questioned why it was wrong for my personal experience to form my opinion but not hers.

Thedevilhasfinallycaughtupwithhim · 07/11/2026 10:46

@VanquishedColston
”Also children know many people for the majority of their lives - doesn't mean they regard them as a parental figure.”

He lives in her house. You seem to be glossing over a lot of the facts here.

He’s not mum’s friend or even boyfriend.
He lives in the girl’s home and intends to marry her mum.

LancsMa · 07/11/2026 10:52

He's right about the bedtime stories. He's right about looking after her on his own. He's right about the iPad. He's right about the car.

But it doesn't sound like your ideas align about what it means to be a step parent, which is the bigger problem.

rainingsnoring · 07/11/2026 11:11

Thedevilhasfinallycaughtupwithhim · 07/11/2026 10:43

I found her tone incredibly aggressive.
And I questioned why it was wrong for my personal experience to form my opinion but not hers.

Objectively, that isn't the case though.
You are the one who has called the DP 'a dick' and made dramatic statements about him 'avoiding her like the plague'. It certainly sounds as if your view has been coloured by some sort of negative experience, which you have chosen not to share.

VanquishedColston · 07/11/2026 11:20

Thedevilhasfinallycaughtupwithhim · 07/11/2026 10:46

@VanquishedColston
”Also children know many people for the majority of their lives - doesn't mean they regard them as a parental figure.”

He lives in her house. You seem to be glossing over a lot of the facts here.

He’s not mum’s friend or even boyfriend.
He lives in the girl’s home and intends to marry her mum.

Edited

I'm not glossing over the facts, I am speaking as someone who has actually navigated this dynamic and come out of the other side positively. Presumably he has not been living with her for 3 years. You cannot just force an adult and child together because the parent wants a readymade family unit. It's a huge adjustment for both the little girl and the man here.

What happens when DD gets a bit older and she doesn't want this DP playing daddy to her because she has her daddy already?? Or DP starts wanting an input on choices made for her because he's raised her as his own and OP tells him to back off because it's not his business?

The important thing at this stage is that they have decent relationship, he's kind to her and he allows her to still spend time wit h her mum. If all goes well they have years to do more together.