Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think donating to charity is a bit like sponsoring a panda?

191 replies

ThatDeepGoose · 06/11/2026 08:57

I give money in the hope that it reaches those it’s intended to help but there’s always a little voice in the back of my mind wondering where it actually ends up.

It’s a bit like sponsoring a panda. I sincerely hope the panda gets the money, but part of me fears it’s being spent on drugs and prostitutes.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
CharityVolunteer · 06/11/2026 12:16

I ran a mid size charity for while after the ceo had to leave and there were a number of problems to resolve (I was unwaged and did not take expenses either). I was shocked at the levels of theft and tolerance of appalling behaviour by some employees. You need a good ceo that is able to keep on top of the management and has the professionalism to tackle issues, most board of trustees don’t look closely enough at what the ceo is telling them and are not close enough to realise when things are going wrong and they aren’t being told.

I also found most employees had no understanding of the running costs including the costs of just paying them. Every employees salary costs the charity quite a bit more in pension contributions, overhead costs etc, so a fundraiser on £50k generating £1M in contributions is not doing that in isolation and just the cost of paying them £50k is costing the charity rather more than £50k. I would expect them to understand how charity finances work. That said id regards a paid fundraiser as an essential role in any mid to large charity. Running costs are normal and should be expected. A professional employee base can ensure donations are used effectively.

Watching the way charities like the RSPCA, NSPCC, Oxfam, Amnesty International have operated over past few years I won’t give to any of those large charities. And I regard the charity commission as largely toothless, in particular it needs a whistleblowing option to raise complaints where the person raising issues knows they won’t be identified to the charity.

Although I’m Christian I now also won’t give to Christian charities with pastors/ministers as trustees. Every pastor trustee I met was dangerously naive about the finances and legalities of running a charity and so keen to perform forgiveness that theft and harassment by employees was tolerated without regard for who suffered as a result or indeed any sense of responsibility to donors by ensuring donations were used wisely. And conversion especially by the more Evangelical pastors seemed more important to them than genuinely helping those in need. There was also a lot of intolerance of other religions.

I look very hard at any charity before donating now. I do still support some but the days of chucking money at charities without scrutiny is long gone and I’m mortified I gave so much to Amnesty International and Oxfam over the years.

We need more pandas in the world.

SorcererGaheris · 06/11/2026 12:20

Springtimeinsunshine · 06/11/2026 11:59

I won't touch Oxfam, even the government suspended funding to them as recently as 2021, long past the Haiti scandal, because they are rotten to the core. Same with Amnesty.

I prefer to donate locally, and preferably with items rather than cash, ie cat food to CP/local rescues or paying a vet directly for a TNR rescue. At least my money is directly benefiting who I want. Same as pp above with soup kitchens.

@Springtimeinsunshine

I'm no fan of the way Oxfam operates in certain aspects. My sole reason for volunteering in the shop is because it's a bookshop and I enjoy the work. I don't volunteer out of any interest in the cause or attachment to the charity itself.

SorcererGaheris · 06/11/2026 12:22

Scrambledomelette · 06/11/2026 12:01

The Haiti scandal, which involved all the major charities who turned a blind eye to their workers trading aid for sex with women and girls, was the tipping point for me. If I had missed that, then the Oxfam training guide that was finger wagging at white women for being complicit in violence for wanting 'bad men' aka rapists to be locked up would have swung it too.

@Scrambledomelette

then the Oxfam training guide that was finger wagging at white women for being complicit in violence for wanting 'bad men' aka rapists to be locked up would have swung it too.

I thought that was ridiculous and downright offensive. Being a volunteer in the shop also opens my eyes to the way Oxfam operates in other aspects that I don't think is right. However, I don't volunteer there because I care about the charity and the cause - my only reason for volunteering there is because I enjoy the work. I volunteer purely for my own pleasure.

Itsasecretnow · 06/11/2026 12:25

BusyGreySnail · 06/11/2026 09:18

Well pandas are well known to be frivolous, foot loose and fancy free, so I wouldn't be sending any money their way unless you are willing to let it go on all sorts.

Never give money to a charity via chuggers - always sign up directly. The chuggers, or the company that arranges them, takes a huge chunk of the money.

It's possible to look up for individual charities how much money actually goes to the causes they support and how much goes on other activities - they legally have to declare it. You often find that smaller, local, charities do better as huge ones often operate like a massive corporate company.

They are all those things but they’re also infamously lazy and I don’t reckon they’ve got the energy to be partying the money away. I mean they clearly haven’t discovered coke or anything, because they’d be a lot more energetic. Or viagra, they’re notoriously bad at mating so maybe if they did spend their money on viagra they wouldn’t be endangered. Maybe the money just keeps them in bamboo, the lazy feckers, I don’t think they’re helping themselves with whatever they’re doing with the charity money currently.
But then I’ve only ever been on a charity committee for people charities, and seen the ins and outs of their finances, which were very well controlled for what they could use certain grants etc for. Very well regulated. Pandas could probably do with a better finance committee.

roundaboutthehillsareshining · 06/11/2026 12:27

I donate to a charity which I'm proud to say spends most of my donation on drugs....... (and other healthcare essentials - Medecins Sans Frontieres)

SorcererGaheris · 06/11/2026 12:32

EdgyNewt · 06/11/2026 10:37

This is part of the problem.

Small charities are generally run by volunteers with people claiming expenses. Personally I only donate to small charities, preferably local ones.

When a charity starts getting much bigger, the admin costs soon start ramping up, and you start having to pay staff salaries, and director salaries, CEO salaries etc...

The CEO of most big charities earn 6 figure salaries. e.g. the Blue Cross CEO earns around £130,000 I think. If members of the public donate £10 a month direct debit, then that's £120 a year. £130,000/£120 = 1083. So that's 1083 people whose yearly donation is just paying the director.

Someone I know worked in an admin role for a large charity and earned £60k a year which is very high for the area, then also got bonuses when she persuaded people to leave money to the charity in their wills or make large donations etc...

So although you say all the money goes to the charity and some is paying towards people who work for it and deliver the program, I would argue that some of these amounts are unethical.

Some of the door to door chuggers are clearly getting commission for direct debits that are signed up because they can be so persuasive, almost a little aggressive at times!

@EdgyNewt

The CEO of most big charities earn 6 figure salaries. e.g. the Blue Cross CEO earns around £130,000 I think. If members of the public donate £10 a month direct debit, then that's £120 a year. £130,000/£120 = 1083. So that's 1083 people whose yearly donation is just paying the director.

I think it's worth pointing out that salaries between £120,000-£200,000 (which is the range for most big charities) is still significantly less than if they worked in the private sector, where they'd probably be paid at least £300,000. So there is a substantial pay "cut", if you like.

Charities need qualified, experienced and skilled people to effectively run a charity, and it's unlikely they will get those kinds of people without offering the salaries they currently do.

In the long run, charities would lose more money if they paid a low CEO salary but, in consequence, got a CEO that wasn't up to the job.

Scrambledomelette · 06/11/2026 12:34

SorcererGaheris · 06/11/2026 12:22

@Scrambledomelette

then the Oxfam training guide that was finger wagging at white women for being complicit in violence for wanting 'bad men' aka rapists to be locked up would have swung it too.

I thought that was ridiculous and downright offensive. Being a volunteer in the shop also opens my eyes to the way Oxfam operates in other aspects that I don't think is right. However, I don't volunteer there because I care about the charity and the cause - my only reason for volunteering there is because I enjoy the work. I volunteer purely for my own pleasure.

I'm not expecting volunteers to down tools and protest. I still think charity shops are valuable to the customers that they serve and to the communities that they are in.

It seems ridiculous to me that charities don't spend more time listening to the people who have happily given up their time and support their cause to sense check their batshit top-down literature and public communications though.

JeffLebowski · 06/11/2026 12:36

TwoLeftSocksWithHoles · 06/11/2026 12:16

@angelasim
"Obviously an individual panda doesn't receive specific donation..."

I'm not so sure of that, can younexplain this photo?

Have you considered that the panda could have stolen that car?

SorcererGaheris · 06/11/2026 12:38

Scrambledomelette · 06/11/2026 12:34

I'm not expecting volunteers to down tools and protest. I still think charity shops are valuable to the customers that they serve and to the communities that they are in.

It seems ridiculous to me that charities don't spend more time listening to the people who have happily given up their time and support their cause to sense check their batshit top-down literature and public communications though.

@Scrambledomelette

To be honest, I suspect the majority of volunteers don't read the literature and public communications. There's no requirement to do so - volunteers don't need to be aware of that stuff in order to effectively do their shop tasks. I certainly don't bother reading it - the only reason I know about the aforementioned one was because I saw it mentioned in a Mumsnet thread.

Given that I have no interest in the charity and its work in itself (like I said, the only reason I volunteer there is that I find the bookshop work fun) there's no personal motivation for me to read any of Oxfam's literature.

Campanulaceae · 06/11/2026 12:39

I donate a lot of money to charity. However, I will only donate to local charities now, and will give more for specific fundraising tasks. I would never donate to a mid or large charity again due to so much mismanagement of funds (e.g. The City Bridge Foundation).

MossMystery · 06/11/2026 12:41

TheSmallAssassin · 06/11/2026 11:54

According to the British Red Cross, only 12% of their spending is on fundraising, 74% is spent on helping people in crisis, 13% on support costs, so your calculations have gone wrong somewhere.

https://www.redcross.org.uk/get-involved/donate/donation-questions/how-we-spend-the-money-we-receive

Only if you assume my donations were the average amount. I image they get huge donations from people leaving it them in wills and corporate events and stuff which would dwarf mine and make the maths work!

I know my money goes into a big pot that then gets divided up between various stuff and I'm counting it as if my money is separated out just for me. And that they must bring in way more money than it costs them to hire these call centre workers etc, but it still just left a nasty taste in my mouth!

Sartre · 06/11/2026 12:45

They spend an enormous amount on marketing and staff to get more donations, it’s pretty crazy when you think about it. Say 80% is marketing and staff in order to get the 20% for the actual cause.

spreadandsprinkles · 06/11/2026 12:57

roundaboutthehillsareshining · 06/11/2026 12:27

I donate to a charity which I'm proud to say spends most of my donation on drugs....... (and other healthcare essentials - Medecins Sans Frontieres)

Did you know about this?

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/c74ykjl8mx3o

An unidentified woman wearing an abaya and hijab walks through a camp in Chad. Her face is not visible.

MSF staff abused Sudanese refugees in sex-for-food scandal

Some victims said they chose not to speak out because they feared staff would cut off access to aid.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/c74ykjl8mx3o

roundaboutthehillsareshining · 06/11/2026 13:10

@spreadandsprinkles Yes I did, but war attracts evil people and always has. On the whole I believe the charity does a lot more good than harm.

LiuBei · 06/11/2026 13:12

IdleGossip · 06/11/2026 09:04

The Charity Commission requires far more financial information about charities than regular businesses are required to provide.

You can go onto their website, or the website of any charity, and see exactly where the money is going.

CEO of a charity here: You are technically correct, but I don't think that helps as much as you'd think.

The charity commission are genuinely good at preventing fraud, in the sense where the charity gives private benefit to individuals, rather than working on the intended cause.

This is not even close to the same as making sure the money is spent well. It's possible to totally waste money, in a non-fraudulent way. For example, if you hire idiots, who are bad at their jobs, then they won't deliver great results for the intended beneficiaries, but this does not count as fraud.

I'm sure most people have seen their employer spend money in a way that doesn't benefit the shareholders/customers/taxpayer. But in all of those cases the shareholders/customers/taxpayer has some influence, either through investment decisions, purchasing decisions, or elections. Charities are worse, because there is no mechanism where the intended beneficiaries can influence the decision making. Many charities are sufficiently anti-market, that they don't even recognise that this is a problem.

Hugasaurusrex · 06/11/2026 13:13

My first thought when I read your post was ‘are you certain that the panda doesn’t spend the money on prostitutes and coke when he gets it in his paw?’

Honestly they seem like the type.

Them and killer whales always look dodgy to me, not so much zebras though 🤔

CountryShepherd · 06/11/2026 13:27

Sartre · 06/11/2026 12:45

They spend an enormous amount on marketing and staff to get more donations, it’s pretty crazy when you think about it. Say 80% is marketing and staff in order to get the 20% for the actual cause.

I'm not sure where those figures come from but no charity would get very far with those sorts of costs!

dottiedodah · 06/11/2026 13:30

A well known Cancer Charity has a CEO on around 200k .I appreciate this seems a lot ,but having had Ovarian Cancer twice .They have been so helpful and kind, ,The helpline is open 12 hours a day .And staffed by Fully trained Cancer Nurses. and also provides help for money related worries as well .I think the days of rattling a tin and hoping for the best are naive at best . The sheer scale of running a business (which it is ) are huge and you need professionals at the helm .

Anarchy99 · 06/11/2026 13:32

I know for a fact there are certain charities where the money doesn’t go to the right places so I don’t give anymore

Sartre · 06/11/2026 13:40

CountryShepherd · 06/11/2026 13:27

I'm not sure where those figures come from but no charity would get very far with those sorts of costs!

It wasn’t exact but I know they spend an awful amount on it, it’s a higher proportion than what actually makes it to the cause.

ChimpanzeeThatMonkeyNews · 06/11/2026 13:45

Boreded · 06/11/2026 09:09

Maybe it is spent on drugs and prostitutes for the panda

And the rest is wasted.

AllJoyAndNoFun · 06/11/2026 13:51

Sartre · 06/11/2026 13:40

It wasn’t exact but I know they spend an awful amount on it, it’s a higher proportion than what actually makes it to the cause.

Charities are required to disclose "costs of raising funds" in their audited accounts so it's there as a matter of public record- just look on the CC website. Per the CC the average is around 10% for charities with income >500k, so for every £1 they raise, they spend 10p raising it, either in staff costs or event costs or costs of running charity shops. The highest I've ever seen was close to 50% but that was a charity with a high dependency on fundraising events which tend to be low margin (think Race for Life has a 10% margin but they would argue it has huge value in raising awareness etc ). Larger charities with high dependency on individual donors (e.g. cancer, kids, animals) tend to have higher costs because it's a more expensive model. I've seen largish charities who are predominantly funded by trusts and foundations or government commissioning (i.e. who don't get much from the general public and dont chase those donors because it's not a high emotion cause) get as low as 4% fundraising costs as they tend to have a low number of high ticket donors

CountryShepherd · 06/11/2026 13:51

Sartre · 06/11/2026 13:40

It wasn’t exact but I know they spend an awful amount on it, it’s a higher proportion than what actually makes it to the cause.

Where have you seen these figures?

HelpMeGetThrough · 06/11/2026 13:56

I’m more a Snow Leopard person myself.

faithfultoGeorgeMichael · 06/11/2026 13:57

@CountryShepherd they discussed Oxfam on You and Yours on R4 (this or last week) recently which is where I got the £6 in £100 from

Swipe left for the next trending thread