Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think donating to charity is a bit like sponsoring a panda?

191 replies

ThatDeepGoose · 06/11/2026 08:57

I give money in the hope that it reaches those it’s intended to help but there’s always a little voice in the back of my mind wondering where it actually ends up.

It’s a bit like sponsoring a panda. I sincerely hope the panda gets the money, but part of me fears it’s being spent on drugs and prostitutes.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
nomas · 06/11/2026 10:29

TempestTost · 06/11/2026 10:24

I don't think this is true, and it comes off as dismissive.

Everyone understands that worker, those actually doing work, need to be paid. And really they should be paid fairly.

Some people are even ok with CEOs getting a pretty substantial wage.

What people are less likely to be ok with is charities where money is being diverted to local politicians, or warlords, or other political factions.

Or where there seems to be a rolling class of well paid people moving from organisation to organisation. (All the big charities it seems.)

Or where the leadership seems to be quite distant from and even opposed to the kinds of things the workers and supporters are trying to accomplish.

Where they seem to have lost sight of their purpose.

Where keeping the organisation growing is more important than accomplishing a task.

Anyone ho follows the news sees these things happening in many big charities.

Edited

I'm not trying to be dismissive at all.

What people are less likely to be ok with is charities where money is being diverted to local politicians, or warlords, or other political factions.

I'm not close to the charity sector so I didn't know this was happening.

How do the UK charities reconcile this with their obligations to report to the commission on how they spend donations?

EdgyNewt · 06/11/2026 10:37

BuffaloCauliflower · 06/11/2026 09:37

I work for a charity and can easily explain to you where your money would go if you gave to us. It pretty much all goes on paying the people who work for the charity as we deliver a (very successful and effective) programme, we don’t give any money to anyone else. So it’s all running cost. People only seem to want to give to charities that have no running costs or staff.

This is part of the problem.

Small charities are generally run by volunteers with people claiming expenses. Personally I only donate to small charities, preferably local ones.

When a charity starts getting much bigger, the admin costs soon start ramping up, and you start having to pay staff salaries, and director salaries, CEO salaries etc...

The CEO of most big charities earn 6 figure salaries. e.g. the Blue Cross CEO earns around £130,000 I think. If members of the public donate £10 a month direct debit, then that's £120 a year. £130,000/£120 = 1083. So that's 1083 people whose yearly donation is just paying the director.

Someone I know worked in an admin role for a large charity and earned £60k a year which is very high for the area, then also got bonuses when she persuaded people to leave money to the charity in their wills or make large donations etc...

So although you say all the money goes to the charity and some is paying towards people who work for it and deliver the program, I would argue that some of these amounts are unethical.

Some of the door to door chuggers are clearly getting commission for direct debits that are signed up because they can be so persuasive, almost a little aggressive at times!

AllJoyAndNoFun · 06/11/2026 10:37

nomas · 06/11/2026 10:29

I'm not trying to be dismissive at all.

What people are less likely to be ok with is charities where money is being diverted to local politicians, or warlords, or other political factions.

I'm not close to the charity sector so I didn't know this was happening.

How do the UK charities reconcile this with their obligations to report to the commission on how they spend donations?

This is most common in international development charities which can be very complex and sometimes, yes, I imagine payments have to be made to certain people or organisations so that work can be done/ safe passage ensured. Obviously it doesnt say "bribery to local warlords". It would say "logistics" or something. I guess it comes down to "at what cost does this feeding programme/ vaccination programme happen?"

Saturdaysfairies · 06/11/2026 10:38

TempestTost · 06/11/2026 10:24

I don't think this is true, and it comes off as dismissive.

Everyone understands that worker, those actually doing work, need to be paid. And really they should be paid fairly.

Some people are even ok with CEOs getting a pretty substantial wage.

What people are less likely to be ok with is charities where money is being diverted to local politicians, or warlords, or other political factions.

Or where there seems to be a rolling class of well paid people moving from organisation to organisation. (All the big charities it seems.)

Or where the leadership seems to be quite distant from and even opposed to the kinds of things the workers and supporters are trying to accomplish.

Where they seem to have lost sight of their purpose.

Where keeping the organisation growing is more important than accomplishing a task.

Anyone ho follows the news sees these things happening in many big charities.

Edited

Most charities today are an industry with pretty good wages and on few hands.
We have stopped supporting the bigger ones.
We support a few local with low costs.

Darker · 06/11/2026 10:39

Piccante · 06/11/2026 10:16

I'm a trustee for a charity that helps young people. My sister is the CEO. The charity has been running for the past 19 years. The CEO's salary is £35k - she's about to take a pay holiday for the next three months in order to keep her skeleton staff employed, because funding is drying up. The bulk of our funding pays for the projects we run, not lunches. If you're concerned as to where your money is going when you donate, you can find out all you need to know from the Charities Comission.

I’m worried that the charity has a trustee who is closely related to the CEO…. Should be independent.

nomas · 06/11/2026 10:43

AllJoyAndNoFun · 06/11/2026 10:37

This is most common in international development charities which can be very complex and sometimes, yes, I imagine payments have to be made to certain people or organisations so that work can be done/ safe passage ensured. Obviously it doesnt say "bribery to local warlords". It would say "logistics" or something. I guess it comes down to "at what cost does this feeding programme/ vaccination programme happen?"

I can that could happen but if a charity is able to put large expenses under 'logistics' and not provide evidence then I'm not sure how that satisfies the charity commission and why charities have such respect in accounting circles.

ACynicalDad · 06/11/2026 10:45

I'm a fundraiser, I'm far more effective at growing income than a fund manager, I've had years when the income I have generated has been 20 times my salary. Would you rather you give £10 to charity and it goes on the cause or you give £10 to charity, they employ me with it and make £200?

Blueseaurchin · 06/11/2026 10:47

I worked in the charity sector for 30 years and I would not donate a single penny to the majority of the big UK & international charities.

I have seen too many questionable fundraising practices and money being wasted on vanity projects and CEO and directors salaries.

Front line staff is usually dedicated and good at their jobs but so many charities have poor senior management and trustees. They also too often tend to treat their staff and volunteers poorly and I have seen bullying take place in too many charities.

I always advise people to scrutinise the charity annual accounts and their frontlibe work before donating anything.

I donate only to local charities where I can see the work being done with my own eyes. The only bigger charity I support is the RNLI because I live in a seaside town and again I can see everyday all the incredible work they do.

Saturdaysfairies · 06/11/2026 10:50

ACynicalDad · 06/11/2026 10:45

I'm a fundraiser, I'm far more effective at growing income than a fund manager, I've had years when the income I have generated has been 20 times my salary. Would you rather you give £10 to charity and it goes on the cause or you give £10 to charity, they employ me with it and make £200?

And the charity pays you £180 for the job? Or the CEO or other staff are paid £200?
Sorry but it's isn't £200 straight to charity is it?
It comes with a price tag.

AllJoyAndNoFun · 06/11/2026 10:51

nomas · 06/11/2026 10:43

I can that could happen but if a charity is able to put large expenses under 'logistics' and not provide evidence then I'm not sure how that satisfies the charity commission and why charities have such respect in accounting circles.

They do provide evidence. The accounts will be audited but expenses are grouped under cost categories when presented. But also these relationships are very complex. It's not like they just give the warlord an envelope of cash. There will be some sort of agreement whereby that warlord (who some people will view as the legitimate government of that region, whether you agree with that or not), agrees to provide certain services to the NGO to facilitate that programme and is paid for that. Typically international development charities work with local partners on the ground which might be other NGOs or community organisations or government agencies because those are the groups who can get access to the end beneficiaries.

Ultimately if Red Cross has to pay X organisation which is currently the unofficial government in Y to provide an armed escort to get aid trucks to Z where children are starving, then arguably that's a legitimate expense.

JeffLebowski · 06/11/2026 10:52

katzrooldogzdrool · 06/11/2026 10:25

Given the panda's notoriously low sex drive, I suppose desperate measures are called for if the creatures are ever to reproduce at all.

Just because some pandas can't get it up doesn't excuse the international trade in black and white sex slaves.

Holeymoley28 · 06/11/2026 10:52

I only give to the soup kitchen.

I know exactly where it’s going to hungry people’s belly’s.

CountryShepherd · 06/11/2026 10:53

Some charities need big budgets and experienced staff to direct their activities. A few volunteers down at the village hall, no matter how hard they work, aren't going to find a cure for cancer.
I also work in fundraising, supporting individual and community fundraisers to raise as much as they can - it is such a priviledge. It's a medium sized medical charity (not CRUK!) and we run a very tight ship, people work extremely hard to support us and we do as much as we can with those donations.

TheRealSmurfette · 06/11/2026 10:54
Biscuit
CountryShepherd · 06/11/2026 10:58

Saturdaysfairies · 06/11/2026 10:50

And the charity pays you £180 for the job? Or the CEO or other staff are paid £200?
Sorry but it's isn't £200 straight to charity is it?
It comes with a price tag.

Edited

It's a fallacy to believe you can raise money without it costing anything!

CountryShepherd · 06/11/2026 11:00

Saturdaysfairies · 06/11/2026 10:38

Most charities today are an industry with pretty good wages and on few hands.
We have stopped supporting the bigger ones.
We support a few local with low costs.

Edited

I wish the wages were pretty good. It's a very skilled role and to be honest, the salaries are mediocre at best. Luckily, there's other money coming into the household and I really enjoy what I do - it's incredibly rewarding.

AutumnOakTree · 06/11/2026 11:01

WitchesBritches · 06/11/2026 09:45

Everyone is being so black-and-white about this!!

Brill!

tomorrowfollowstoday · 06/11/2026 11:02

BuffaloCauliflower · 06/11/2026 09:37

I work for a charity and can easily explain to you where your money would go if you gave to us. It pretty much all goes on paying the people who work for the charity as we deliver a (very successful and effective) programme, we don’t give any money to anyone else. So it’s all running cost. People only seem to want to give to charities that have no running costs or staff.

Yes people seem to want charities to give all the money away, but often what they 'give' is access to services e.g. advice from a specialist nurse, counselling, care services - in order to give these things the charity must pay the staff who do it.

AutumnOakTree · 06/11/2026 11:03

Well, this panda got an all expenses trip to Scotland. Can you bear that?

To think donating to charity is a bit like sponsoring a panda?
ACynicalDad · 06/11/2026 11:05

Saturdaysfairies · 06/11/2026 10:50

And the charity pays you £180 for the job? Or the CEO or other staff are paid £200?
Sorry but it's isn't £200 straight to charity is it?
It comes with a price tag.

Edited

In my last job which was pure fundraising I was paid under £50k a year and raised over £1m my on costs were minimal. The rest went on funding programmes that saved the lives of children with Cancer. Yes they had to divert £50k ish to me, but you can do a lot more with £950k than 50k. A fund manager would dream of the retuns of a fundraiser.

Saturdaysfairies · 06/11/2026 11:06

CountryShepherd · 06/11/2026 10:58

It's a fallacy to believe you can raise money without it costing anything!

Of course it is.

Look at the fundraiser who here happily writes she gets the first year of contributions not the charity.
No way I will support that or support CEOs on high wages and pensions. A good choice for me to support smaller local charities with less people to gain from the organisations.

TempestTost · 06/11/2026 11:07

nomas · 06/11/2026 10:43

I can that could happen but if a charity is able to put large expenses under 'logistics' and not provide evidence then I'm not sure how that satisfies the charity commission and why charities have such respect in accounting circles.

I think you are being very naive about what they have to show to the charily commission. They can only see what is in the books.

When an organisation goes into a foreign country they are working with all kinds of other organisations. Not least the governments in those places.

Many of them have massive, endemic corruption. "Taxes". Fake or corrupt local charities and businesses find ways to divert funds. Being required to work through corrupt government entities. Being required to "exchange" currency at inflated prices. Sometimes simply being stolen from directly, or things going "missing".

Another issue where a charity takes on a job, like running schools or digging wells. This can free up tax money for the state to do other things with. Like give their leader some really pretty impressive housing.

The thing is, on paper these don't look like the organisation is being evil. It looks like they are victims of crime, or that they are making the best of it in difficult circumstances. There's no cause for the charity commission to strip away their status even though they are enriching bad actors.

If you want an example, you can look at Syria. Charitable money that goes there is exchanged at predatory rates through the government, who is making bank.

Saturdaysfairies · 06/11/2026 11:09

ACynicalDad · 06/11/2026 11:05

In my last job which was pure fundraising I was paid under £50k a year and raised over £1m my on costs were minimal. The rest went on funding programmes that saved the lives of children with Cancer. Yes they had to divert £50k ish to me, but you can do a lot more with £950k than 50k. A fund manager would dream of the retuns of a fundraiser.

Good for them and good for you. I won't fund your £50000 wage a year in the charity industry. So I just support charities working differently.

CountryShepherd · 06/11/2026 11:11

Saturdaysfairies · 06/11/2026 11:06

Of course it is.

Look at the fundraiser who here happily writes she gets the first year of contributions not the charity.
No way I will support that or support CEOs on high wages and pensions. A good choice for me to support smaller local charities with less people to gain from the organisations.

That's specifically face-to-face fundraising - they are not salaried in the way that in house fundraisers are. They also have to pay their bills. It's not a role that volunteers would happily undertake - it's very hard going.

All charitiable giving is good - so if that makes you happy - that's great!

Judystilldreamsofhorses · 06/11/2026 11:13

I think with charity donations many people (myself included) are realistic that there is an admin cost involved, but give what they can afford in good faith, and hope for the best. I have direct debits to our local Cats Protection - where we adopted our cat from - and I hope it directly helps cats living locally, and to a small dog rescue in Manchester.

My DP has a direct debit to a meningitis charity as he was very ill with it as a child.

Swipe left for the next trending thread