Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be upset at the closure of Samaritans branches?

91 replies

PicklesandPrickles · 03/11/2026 22:11

Seven closures have been announced so far. Many more to come.

I just cant see how this will improve the services. Some of these branches have been going for 50+ years, have 100 or more volunteers and are doing an amazing job fundraising to keep the doors open, running charity shops etc.

This is one article, relating to one of the mergers:

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/cq99z8vkz0x8o

This is the list:

First-Phase Branch Closures

  • Caithness (Scotland)
  • Orkney (Scotland)
  • Shetland (Scotland)
  • Stornoway (Scotland)
  • Grimsby (Northern England)
  • Scunthorpe (Northern England)
  • Worthing (Southern England)

Mergers and Regional Hubs

  • Inverness and Elgin are merging to form a new Highlands branch.
  • Halifax, Huddersfield, and Bradford are combining to create a West Yorkshire hub

I don't know what else to say. Heartbroken and angry.

A Samaritans sign on a railing in front of some bushes. The sign is bright green with black and white writing and gives their contact number - 116 123 -, alongside the words 'talk to us if things are getting to you'.

Samaritans urged to rethink Scunthorpe branch closure

The charity says the Scunthorpe closure is part of plans to focus services on fewer larger branches.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/cq99z8vkz0x8o

OP posts:
DangerousThingsILove · 09/11/2026 23:55

Tinkalinkalink · 09/11/2026 23:20

I really have resented calling the samaritans to describe an extensively painful situation to be shunted off after 20 minutes. Its made me feel even worse and is a horrible practice.

That’s not how we’re trained to talk to callers. I’m sorry you’ve had this experience.

Darker · 10/11/2026 06:29

Thank you for sharing the link.

FuzzySlippers · 10/11/2026 06:41

Shockhorror22 · 03/11/2026 22:21

A friend of mine volunteers for them. Working from home is a problem, firstly for privacy around the calls if anyone else is at home. Secondly, they deal with some very very distressing and difficult situations so being able to talk to another volunteer is really important for their own mental health. If they have to travel further than they used to go into a base, that will cut into the time they have free to volunteer. My friend thinks this is going to be pretty catastrophic for the charity’s future.

This 100%

BadSkiingMum · 10/11/2026 07:09

That article describes the branch as ‘solvent’ when even a very quick glance at their Charity Commission profile would indicate that is not the case. Not very responsible of the Guardian!

@Darker Sorry, I don’t know about the finances of all the other branches due to close but, looking up another example, the Shetland branch has been in deficit for the last five years.

The harsh reality is that, nowadays, it probably isn’t enough to donate time. If we care about a charity, especially a local one, we should probably also donate money on an ongoing basis.

If local supporters of Worthing Samaritans want to save their branch then committing to a monthly direct debit to provide ongoing funding is probably the only way…

AllJoyAndNoFun · 10/11/2026 07:51

@BadSkiingMum The Guardian being financially illiterate? Who'd have thought it! Yeah, Worthing Samaritans is a perfect example of why the branch model is struggling. The shop that they say is funding the service is barely breaking even, and they have hardly more in cash on hand than their loss for the current year. They do have assets but that's the building so it can't be easily liquidated to fund the service.

The central organisation does have considerable cash/ reserves but also posted a £3m deficit this year (and 4 of last 5 years) so they have to do something to make the cost base more manageable.

My understanding is that the restructure involves branch consolidation rather than remote volunteering - that is just a pilot to see if it would support volunteer recruitment. The branch model was presumably initially set up like that to support local rate phone calls, but that's not really relevant now, plus there will inevitably be a trend towards people using the online chat rather than wanting to call. If you were setting up the service now, you wouldn't have 150 branches all across the country. I do get what people are saying about a decentralised system supporting volunteer recruitment (because volunteers will only travel so far) but I guess it's a question of balancing the two things. It's possible that the branches that are closing also have issues with volunteer recruitment/ retention and dont answer enough calls to justify the cost base.

SuddenDaredJelly · 10/11/2026 08:07

Its more that wage costs for the paid staff they do need will have risen due to inflation, market wages increasing, NI costs etc. Unless donations go up by an equivalent amount you are screwed. Samaritans have made a loss for years,its not sustainable. If they've been increasing paid staff its probably also been in a desperate attempt to drive up fundraising.

Few highly skilled people can afford to work for sub market wages for the love of the charity, you arent going to get a finance director volunteering because how would she pay her mortgage,bills & childcare costs?

Thecatandme · 10/11/2026 08:25

BadSkiingMum · 10/11/2026 07:09

That article describes the branch as ‘solvent’ when even a very quick glance at their Charity Commission profile would indicate that is not the case. Not very responsible of the Guardian!

@Darker Sorry, I don’t know about the finances of all the other branches due to close but, looking up another example, the Shetland branch has been in deficit for the last five years.

The harsh reality is that, nowadays, it probably isn’t enough to donate time. If we care about a charity, especially a local one, we should probably also donate money on an ongoing basis.

If local supporters of Worthing Samaritans want to save their branch then committing to a monthly direct debit to provide ongoing funding is probably the only way…

I don’t know about Worthing but I am aware that in our branch very few volunteers claim the travel expenses that they legitimately could

While some volunteers live close to the branch many of us don’t - so we either drive or use public transport. Our income exceeded expenditure by about £8k last year. I’d say that would be swallowed up if we all claimed

ETA

At least some local branches have face to face visitors (stopped and never restarted following Covid for others). So that’s something to factor in in all this

PicklesandPrickles · 10/11/2026 09:11

Branches make a contribution to the National charity as part of their operating agreement.

OP posts:
BadSkiingMum · 10/11/2026 09:23

Thank you @AllJoyAndNoFun, glad that you also see what I am saying. It’s grim, really grim.

BadSkiingMum · 10/11/2026 09:34

Thecatandme · 10/11/2026 08:25

I don’t know about Worthing but I am aware that in our branch very few volunteers claim the travel expenses that they legitimately could

While some volunteers live close to the branch many of us don’t - so we either drive or use public transport. Our income exceeded expenditure by about £8k last year. I’d say that would be swallowed up if we all claimed

ETA

At least some local branches have face to face visitors (stopped and never restarted following Covid for others). So that’s something to factor in in all this

Edited

The problem is that it is not enough for volunteers to not claim expenses, if the Worthing CIO is in deficit it needs regular additional income coming in.

The current operating deficit is £53.7k.

To raise £60k per annum (allowing for increased costs) you need 500 supporters giving £10 per month.

But will people do that? Very unlikely. The accounts show donations of under £3k in the year to March 2026.

It’s a real blind spot in the charity sector, that donations come from someone else…

PicklesandPrickles · 10/11/2026 09:39

A lot of Samaritans income comes from legacies, both local and National.

OP posts:
Thecatandme · 10/11/2026 09:56

BadSkiingMum · 10/11/2026 09:34

The problem is that it is not enough for volunteers to not claim expenses, if the Worthing CIO is in deficit it needs regular additional income coming in.

The current operating deficit is £53.7k.

To raise £60k per annum (allowing for increased costs) you need 500 supporters giving £10 per month.

But will people do that? Very unlikely. The accounts show donations of under £3k in the year to March 2026.

It’s a real blind spot in the charity sector, that donations come from someone else…

Oh I understand that. I am aware how hard it is from our treasurer

Just making the point that volunteers can often contribute (on occasions financially) in other ways.

BadSkiingMum · 10/11/2026 09:58

@PicklesandPrickles But that is not going to help Worthing right now…

The line in the accounts is ‘Donations and legacies’ and the corresponding figure is £2.6k.

They may get an amazing legacy in a couple of years time but that won’t help because the charity will have burned through its cash reserves by then and probably had to close anyway.

BadSkiingMum · 10/11/2026 10:36

The Guardian article says that 7,000 people have signed a petition in support of Worthing Samaritans. If even 1000 of those people committed to a regular and ongoing monthly donation then they would probably be able to keep the local charity running. It is a crude phrase, but people need to ‘put their money where their mouth is’.

Goatsarebest · 10/11/2026 11:03

To be fair, I've just looked at their annual report and there is a very strong comittment to monitoring and evaluation of the expansion of providing services from home for both the clients and volunteers. They seem well aware of potential issues for volunteers. Running a 12 perc deficite for last 3 years is moving into threatening existence terrority for a charity. They have to do something.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page