Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be upset at the closure of Samaritans branches?

91 replies

PicklesandPrickles · 03/11/2026 22:11

Seven closures have been announced so far. Many more to come.

I just cant see how this will improve the services. Some of these branches have been going for 50+ years, have 100 or more volunteers and are doing an amazing job fundraising to keep the doors open, running charity shops etc.

This is one article, relating to one of the mergers:

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/cq99z8vkz0x8o

This is the list:

First-Phase Branch Closures

  • Caithness (Scotland)
  • Orkney (Scotland)
  • Shetland (Scotland)
  • Stornoway (Scotland)
  • Grimsby (Northern England)
  • Scunthorpe (Northern England)
  • Worthing (Southern England)

Mergers and Regional Hubs

  • Inverness and Elgin are merging to form a new Highlands branch.
  • Halifax, Huddersfield, and Bradford are combining to create a West Yorkshire hub

I don't know what else to say. Heartbroken and angry.

A Samaritans sign on a railing in front of some bushes. The sign is bright green with black and white writing and gives their contact number - 116 123 -, alongside the words 'talk to us if things are getting to you'.

Samaritans urged to rethink Scunthorpe branch closure

The charity says the Scunthorpe closure is part of plans to focus services on fewer larger branches.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/cq99z8vkz0x8o

OP posts:
Darker · 04/11/2026 23:18

I’m sure they’ll recruit new volunteers but it will be a different type of person who signs up to remote volunteering from the off. I can see more short term volunteers - fewer of the ones that stay for years and years, and spend their weekends holding a collection bucket or running the charity shop

Wearesurrounded · 05/11/2026 00:25

I am not a Samariton, but I do various volunteer roles.
I had heard about the ongoing changes.

In the future will Samaritons be using

1
Teams or video conferencing for debriefing amongst volunteers office & home based ?
I have used this successfully in my job, speaking with people based in many locations UK & abroad.

2
Real time Chat

3
Chat can be used at the same time as Teams

However, I understand that some people enjoyed volunteering in their local office.
But some people are free & willing to WFH too.

Technology has moved on

I wonder if this charity will revert back to local bases in the future ? Only time will tell.

Perhaps a merger with another charity or other services in the future too ?

Good luck

Darker · 05/11/2026 03:58

So many mental health problems are down to loss of connection, erosion of social networks.

Local branches are so much more than bricks and mortar. In my view, we should be investing in these local hubs, for the sake of the volunteers well-being and for the potential for delivering more services locally, such as face to face, as statutory services dwindle.

TheRealSmurfette · 05/11/2026 05:40

For goodness sake, they won’t be closing because they want to! It’s so tough out there for charities at the moment to raise the funds they need to operate of course they’re closing physical branches…volunteers dropping out in a huff is not gonna help.

ZarathustaCallico · 05/11/2026 06:02

I think that's a more than valid feeling.

I'm sure they (the 'big bosses') have their reasons, and I want the charity to stick around, but not at the expense of the health of their volunteers either 1. Having to 'work' from home with no support, struggling after a draining call or 2. Choosing to stop something that's hard, but they enjoyed doing, and losing part of their community and lifestyle. For a lot of volunteers, the role is just as important as a job and also offers a social world.

I've both called the Samaritans and used their email service, around a decade ago now. I did it a lot, honestly. It was, clearly, a hard time. When I was having a particularly awful night, the same volunteer called me back in the morning. They didn't have to do that - they went the extra distance and it made me feel safe and even happy for a couple of days. They were a stranger, but I felt like someone was still glad I was there the next morning, and I told them how grateful I was.

I'm a lot better now, and I'm training to be a volunteer for another MH charity (I won't out myself by naming it) that works using a chat system, so everyone 'works' from home but there's 8 weeks shadowing, on-going training, groups for volunteers on SM and WhatsApp (both for formal things like transferring shifts and informal things like support, community, small talk etc.) and I feel like if the Samaritans hadn't been there for me - and able to support each other on some of the worst calls - I may not be here, or at least not well enough to, volunteer for another MH service.

So yeah, it bums me out ti see their presence disappearing. I hope it doesn't impact their ability to help people, but I also hope it doesn't put their volunteers at risk, either. They deserve support, too. You can't pour from an empty cup, and more importantly they're human, too.

IamnotSethRogan · 05/11/2026 06:48

I didn't even realise they had call centres. I know a few people who volunteer and they've all done it remotely. I know that, as pp has said, they are incredibly well supported on shift.

However, based on this thread I can see how working remotely wouldn't suit everyone.

BadSkiingMum · 05/11/2026 07:17

There will be costs to the restructure (redundancy etc) but it is far better to incur those costs now while there are still assets and reserves to meet those costs. Rather than keep going and arrive at a situation where the operating deficit has eroded reserves to such an extent that it is no longer possible to pay everyone their redundancy (plus notice etc) and the organisation becomes effectively insolvent.

Also bear in mind that the costs of redundancy keep gradually increasing year on year as employees serve longer and receive pay increases.

The whole point of a charity is its charitable purpose:

TO ENABLE PERSONS WHO ARE EXPERIENCING FEELINGS OF DISTRESS OR DESPAIR, INCLUDING THOSE WHO MAY BE AT RISK OF SUICIDE, TO RECEIVE CONFIDENTIAL EMOTIONAL SUPPORT AT ANY TIME OF THE DAY OR NIGHT FROM APPROPRIATELY TRAINED SAMARITANS IN ORDER TO IMPROVE THEIR EMOTIONAL HEALTH AND TO REDUCE THE INCIDENCE OF SUICIDE; AND (B) TO PROMOTE A BETTER UNDERSTANDING IN SOCIETY OF SUICIDE, SUICIDAL BEHAVIOUR AND THE VALUE OF EXPRESSING FEELINGS WHICH MAY OTHERWISE LEAD TO SUICIDE OR IMPAIRED EMOTIONAL HEALTH.

Beyond that, the charity can be configured in any way that meets those needs.

The board may believe (with the evidence that they have) that it is better to configure the charity as a smaller, lighter organisation and serve fewer people, rather than cease to exist altogether.

The operating deficit is the warning signal and it has been sounding for several years.

thisismeithinkorisit · 05/11/2026 07:20

TheRealSmurfette · 05/11/2026 05:40

For goodness sake, they won’t be closing because they want to! It’s so tough out there for charities at the moment to raise the funds they need to operate of course they’re closing physical branches…volunteers dropping out in a huff is not gonna help.

it isn't about dropping out in a huff if they're literally closing the only place you can get to to volunteer!

Darker · 05/11/2026 08:38

@BadSkiingMum many (not all) Samaritans branches are independent, self-governing charities in their own right.

Do you not think that changes the dynamic here? These branches have been responsible for their own fundraising and governance, all on the back of unpaid volunteers and local supporters. Should they be ok with hanging it all over to sort out a deficit they didn’t create?

BadSkiingMum · 05/11/2026 10:06

I don’t know the exact setup but the central Samaritans charity probably has little power over those independent charity branches. So the branches being closed are likely to be the ones tied to the central organisation.

But what if the central charity does collapse? It will then be in the hands of an insolvency practitioner. The independent local branches will still exist but will have no central Samaritans services, no access to central HR or training support, no access to any centralised database, no right to use national branding…The independent branches will just become local suicide prevention charities and need to compete with other local charities for funding.

As per my first post, I was involved in an organisation that had to close and it really wasn’t pretty.

If you think that staff and volunteers are being treated poorly now then that is nothing compared to what happens when a charity has to cease trading.

PicklesandPrickles · 05/11/2026 10:39

I haven't looked at them all but Worthing branch is a CIO.

https://www.samaritans.org/branches/worthing/

It looks as if it has been struggling a bit, but it runs a charity shop and has assets. Not unsalvagable... but if they did hit the rocks I imagine the assets would transfer to the national charity anyway. I'm not a lawyer, though.

Worthing

https://www.samaritans.org/branches/worthing/

OP posts:
Darker · 06/11/2026 16:41

Great post on the Save Worthing Samaritans Facebook page on why local branches matter. Copied and pasted here:

We are delighted to share a powerful and deeply personal message from Melanie Peters, founder of the Worthing Community Awards and a passionate mental health awareness campaigner who has been raising awareness and campaigning for better mental health support in Worthing since 2013.

Melanie has worked tirelessly with local organisations to improve access to support, and has first-hand experience of the life-changing impact Worthing Samaritans has had within our community.

Here, Melanie shares why our local branch matters so much and why she believes it must be protected:

'I’ve been involved in raising awareness of mental health in Worthing since 2013, organising Mental Health Awareness events, working with local organisations and campaigning to make support more accessible to those who need it.

Over the years, I’ve worked closely with Worthing Samaritans, but there’s one particular story that will always stay with me and shows exactly why having them in our community is so important.

During one of my Mental Health Awareness events at the Guildbourne Centre in Worthing, a lady happened to walk through the event. What nobody knew at the time was that she had already made the decision to take her own life.

By chance, she stopped and spoke to one of the Worthing Samaritans volunteers who was there that day.

That conversation saved her life.

It’s something I’ve never forgotten. Had that volunteer not been there, the outcome could have been very different.

That same volunteer later went on to win an award at my Worthing Community Awards, something that made me incredibly proud.

For me, that one experience sums up why Worthing Samaritans matters so much. You never know what somebody is going through, and sometimes all it takes is having the right person there, at the right time, willing to listen.

I’ve also known other people who have turned to Samaritans for help during incredibly difficult periods of their lives.

Another thing I’m particularly proud of is working directly with Worthing Samaritans to help secure funding for signs to be installed at high-risk locations.

I was actively involved in helping to make this happen, ensuring that people experiencing emotional distress or suicidal thoughts could see that help and support was available.

Having a local Samaritans branch isn’t just about answering telephone calls. It’s about having volunteers out in our community, attending events, raising awareness and reaching people who might never otherwise have asked for help.

After more than a decade of campaigning for better mental health awareness in Worthing, I find the proposed closure of our local Samaritans branch incredibly upsetting.

How can we talk about the importance of mental health and suicide prevention while allowing a service that has genuinely saved lives in our town to disappear?

I sincerely hope those responsible for this decision will reconsider. Worthing Samaritans has made a real difference to people’s lives, and I know that firsthand.

We should be protecting and supporting our local branch, not fighting to save it.'

Melanie Peters
Rocket Marketing
Founder, Worthing Community Awards
Mental Health Awareness Campaigner

themagicmonkey · 08/11/2026 19:00

I completely get there are strong feelings about the branch closures, especially because so many Samaritans invest so much of their own time in keeping the branches going - out of love. But as a relative newcomer to Sams I would add to the discussion above, this debate seems very black and white to me and I think the better answer is somewhere in the grey zone. Which is of course the place Sams are happiest occupying during calls!

There are lots of people who have been Sams for a long time and are...rather stuck in their ways. eg there's a contigent who think (and were taught, I think) that no call should last longer than 20 minutes unless it's an active suicide. I had a shift with one of this group who - one whole minute after the shift had "ended" - was pretty much banging my computer screen to emphasise the time and mouthing "THEY'VE HAD MORE THAN TWENTY MINUTES!!" So I think the views of "long-serving" volunteers are a view, not the view, about what's best for the Sams' future.

I'm also surprised there isn't more work being done to explore how Sams keeps experience even after physical branches close. That just takes people out of the pool of listeners (which I get is what many longserving Sams want to do) but there is no reason why those people couldn't do work in their community, fundraise, or take on other non-listening duties on behalf of Sams more widely. eg being the shift leader on the end of the phone for other branches, topped up with less frequent listening shifts which they might have to travel further for. I don't disagree with the focus on having more people listening during the middle of the night, and our own branch (which is big and in a big city) often has to close overnight shifts because of illness etc. Not an exaggeration to say that can take out 5% of the Sams national capacity at 3am when the calls are longer, there's a lot of distress and fewer volunteers working.

I don't think I'd want to take calls at home either, but I don't need to. I don't see the issue with careful trials to see if it could be an option for those who want to do it, if it helps with more capacity when there's the most demand.

themagicmonkey · 08/11/2026 19:09

(I do think the initial closure of the remote/island branches in Scotland is probably going to end up being a PR own goal for the central HQ.)

PicklesandPrickles · 08/11/2026 20:09

Hi @themagicmonkey I agree there are some 'old school' Samaritans. It was a bit like that when I started, but its much less like that now. I can't imagine anyone interrupting my calls the way you were! I am very happy with the ethos of my branch.

I am not against home working per se, and yes there is plenty of room for innovation and ways of getting more volunteers, especially during hours of need.

I just can't see that closing branches will increase capacity. Many of those volunteers will leave for good.

I know that the service is about the callers but volunteering is really good for wellbeing, reducing isolation, and personal development. Its given me new skills and new perspectives. This has to be a good thing for society. And a huge loss to communities which will no longer have a Samaritans branch at its heart. We need MORE branches, not less.

OP posts:
Wearesurrounded · 09/11/2026 10:57

In the news recently, my county has announced a new number to contact for 24x7x365 mental health support. This will be manned by professionals.

Not to decrease what Samaritans do, but every little helps

Darker · 09/11/2026 11:09

Who is delivering that, @Wearesurrounded ? Is it health services? Could you link to the news?

I’m glad there is more 24 hour support is being made available, even if locally.

PicklesandPrickles · 09/11/2026 13:07

I'm quite surprised at the outcome of the vote, that 37% voted unreasonable.

OP posts:
BadSkiingMum · 09/11/2026 19:06

The description of the Worthing branch upthread is absolutely what the Samaritans should be about. But sadly the branch has been in deficit for three out of the last five years…As of end March the expenditure is several times higher than the branch income. How can it realistically survive? After a certain point the independent examiner will raise questions about whether or not the charity is a going concern and the trustees are obliged to make a decision on its future.

Darker · 09/11/2026 19:14

But this isn’t about closing a few branches that are not economically. It’s about systematically closing branches that have been part of our communities for decades.

Worthing runs the listeners scheme at Ford Prison. They run a charity shop. Their deficit is small in the scheme of things.

BadSkiingMum · 09/11/2026 21:08

The local charity in Worthing is in deficit. The national charity is in deficit.
Where is this money to come from to meet the operating costs? At this rate the Worthing charity would burn through the cash reserves in under two years.

https://register-of-charities.charitycommission.gov.uk/en/charity-search/-/charity-details/5092138/financial-history

It is really sad, but the trustees of both the local and national charities need to act now, ahead of time, to avoid collapse.

Darker · 09/11/2026 22:58

@BadSkiingMum are ALL the branches under threat in deficit?

If being in deficit was the issue, branches could have been given goals to reach and a timescale.

Remember these are volunteers. Funds raised on an incredible ROI.

Branches that do well with fundraising contribute generously to national funds. It’s part of the operating agreement.

National office fundraisers are not volunteers. Their fundraising costs a lot, lot more.

Tinkalinkalink · 09/11/2026 23:20

I really have resented calling the samaritans to describe an extensively painful situation to be shunted off after 20 minutes. Its made me feel even worse and is a horrible practice.

suki1964 · 09/11/2026 23:40

For those of us who prefer a messaging service for help - SHOUT to 85258, its manned 24/7