I have 30 years service in the NHS. Some reflections from me (long and garbled but cathartic!):
Basic care was better 30 years ago in many ways. Particularly if you were a patient on a ward ran by a ‘dragon’. The junior staff were usually scared of the dragon but all the patients were clean and had pain relief. Staff regularly worked 1-3 unpaid additional hours per day and you often didn’t get a break. Maybe the basic care was better because the staff were working in a way that isn’t acceptable today. Or maybe we need more staff plus the dragons back and the staff to have respect for them.
Most patients treated staff with respect and were in hospital because they needed to be. If as a nurse you suspected someone was under the influence of a substance they were treated kindly but firmly. You did not worry they would assault you, film you or complain about you.
People with mental health conditions were not on the acute wards generally. Today we seem to have people in acute hospitals who need a different type of care. It’s impossible to meet their care needs (mental health and substance misuse are just examples) on an acute ward or in an A&E department. We don’t want to go back to institutionalising people but it’s clear the current care in the community isn’t working for everyone. Acute NHS staff are spending ineffective hours trying to contain someone when what they need is specialist help.
Old, outdated practices which we do not want to go back to were used 30 years ago. People were lifted and handled, this meant sometimes patients were injured as were staff; but needs were met more quickly. People for example those with dementia who were distressed or wandering were sedated. This is illegal now, rightly, but safe, effective alternative treatments do not seem to be used in ward settings. Families were more involved in care 30 years ago particularly in the community. This doesn’t seem as possible now (probably as there isn’t a woman at home to do the unpaid caring work).
30 years ago staff ran hospitals to protect the system. Visiting was restricted to maintain privacy and dignity. If people attended A&E and were deemed not to need it they were firmly told this and directed elsewhere. Of course this meant sometimes people were sent away that shouldn’t have been.
People demanded less. People generally didn’t attend A&E or the GPs unless there was something very wrong with them. Sometimes this was the right decision. Sometimes people attended too late.
In 2026 the dragons have all been investigated for bullying. There aren’t enough managers to supervise the staff. Staff work the hours they are paid for. Staff will only follow policy and procedure because they have been trained to do this. Patients complain quite rightly if staff get something wrong so all decisions are made defensively.
There can’t be a policy or procedure for every scenario in the NHS so this means quite often patients bounce around between departments or professionals.
Patients are more demanding, sometimes rightly, you should have pain relief when you need it for example but also patients are asking staff who are very busy to do things like open the door for their deliveroo deliveries multiple times per shift. Staff do not feel able to refuse this or question how ill they are if they’re able to order and eat a takeaway from their bed on the acute ward.
Staff do not dare ask people who are under the influence of drink or drugs to behave appropriately or go elsewhere because what if they have an underlying medical condition and this is missed?
Health care advances are amazing and many more people survive illnesses and injuries than they did 30 years ago. However us humans seem to have started to take good health for granted rather than take responsibility for looking after ourselves.
I’ve worked with other health systems and our NHS is something we should be very proud of and something we should fight for.