Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to wonder why we accept the state of the NHS?

337 replies

Pinkgorilla101 · 03/11/2026 08:56

Having spent time living abroad and having top quality almost free healthcare (state, not private) I genuinely cannot believe that there hasn’t been a revolt or more done about the state of the NHS. Just this week I have heard of an 80 year old man with heart failure sitting in A&E for 17 hours then being told to go home as they had no beds and they would make him a routine appointment with a cardiologist. Seeing a GP is almost impossible. There are 2 at my NHS practice but both also run private clinics elsewhere. Why do we accept this or am I unreasonably unrealistic in my expectations?

OP posts:
Goosebynature · 04/11/2026 08:23

Andandoporlasplayas · 03/11/2026 10:42

I wasn’t really meaning the common reasons to go part time. I would say most decent employers will do their absolute best to accommodate flex working requests for family type reasons. (Although if I understand correctly a request for flex working doesn’t have to give a reason, just a business case).

But my contract forbids me to work a second job without permission. It stands to reason that if I were to want to reduce my hours because I want to earn from elsewhere, particularly in the same field, I would have to declare it. And need a bloody tight and workable business case to how i propose the gap be filled.

I do see that a tough system like that could only work if conditions in the nhs for staff are improved or yes they may just leave full stop. So the cause is what needs to be addressed and fixed or improved.

NHS consultants have to offer the nhs extra sessions before they can do private work. No consultant is dropping their hours to work privately without it being agreed by their employer (and to my knowledge that just doesn’t happen). Consultants can choose to do no nhs work and only work privately and then they can do what they want.

GPs are different. GP partners run their own businesses and are contracted to do nhs work. They can decide how they work. As can all qualified GPs.

Your arguments about what your private employer would let you do have no bearing on how doctors work.

Batsratscatsgnats · 04/11/2026 10:21

BlueSherbet · 03/11/2026 14:44

I think its because there is never any objective discussion about the NHS, only dewey-eyed propaganda about it and the "heroes" who work in it.

Its pretty poor in my opinion. Inefficient and hugely wasteful. A money pit.

Its riddled with trade unions, meaning there is a self-serving "middle man" between the taxpayer and the service they are paying for.

I also think many NHS staff are totally up themselves and genuinely regard themselves as "heroes".

Remember all that carry on during covid, having folk outside banging pots etc supposedly as a show of support for the NHS?

What other public service is so needy for praise and attention?

My suggestion to improve it is to stop all the propaganda / sickly praise around it and get back to basics. It was invented as a system to treat sickness and injuries. It it limited itself to that, it would do well and have plenty for resources.

It wasnt founded to provide (for example) abortions, IVF, weight loss jabs, "sex changes", harm reduction drugs for gay men, etc etc. These things are not sicknesses or injuries, but mainly lifestyle factors. People should access these things elsewhere out of their own wallets.

(I have several family members who work for the NHS (or did) btw)

Im pretty sure not allowing abortion for example on the NHS is a VERY poor cost saving measure. Bc you would end up.with unwanted children who would potentially need support their entire lives!

x2boys · 04/11/2026 10:30

Batsratscatsgnats · 04/11/2026 10:21

Im pretty sure not allowing abortion for example on the NHS is a VERY poor cost saving measure. Bc you would end up.with unwanted children who would potentially need support their entire lives!

Or women seeking backstreet abortions
No, women should be able to access safe reliable contraception and abortion .

EstoyRobandoSuCasa · 04/11/2026 10:35

Newname26 · 04/11/2026 07:58

Thanks i didn't know they were non-profit.

I'm not convinced they'd be non-profit in the uk.

Even if they were non-profit (and I agree that’s a big if) they would still cost millions every year due to the number of staff required to administer the insurance system.

Badbadbunny · 04/11/2026 10:44

EstoyRobandoSuCasa · 04/11/2026 10:35

Even if they were non-profit (and I agree that’s a big if) they would still cost millions every year due to the number of staff required to administer the insurance system.

Yet we're constantly told we spend less on the NHS than successful European alternatives, which is only to be expected if we're not spending on the much higher admin costs that you and others seem to think would be needed on a co-pay/insurance system. Surely that explains why the European models cost more?? So we're not spending less on actual healthcare after all!!

Newname26 · 04/11/2026 10:44

EstoyRobandoSuCasa · 04/11/2026 10:35

Even if they were non-profit (and I agree that’s a big if) they would still cost millions every year due to the number of staff required to administer the insurance system.

Agreed, I do know if you look at percentage of money spent on admin the NHS is one of the lowest in Europe

EstoyRobandoSuCasa · 04/11/2026 10:51

Badbadbunny · 04/11/2026 10:44

Yet we're constantly told we spend less on the NHS than successful European alternatives, which is only to be expected if we're not spending on the much higher admin costs that you and others seem to think would be needed on a co-pay/insurance system. Surely that explains why the European models cost more?? So we're not spending less on actual healthcare after all!!

Have you considered that we might be spending less on both admin and clinical care?

ILoveKits · 04/11/2026 10:52

Newname26 · 04/11/2026 10:44

Agreed, I do know if you look at percentage of money spent on admin the NHS is one of the lowest in Europe

That's an interesting point but patient time and admin aren't calculated.

Long waits for calls to be dealt with.
Late cancellations of surgery which often create sunk costs for the patient - childcare/fares/etc, not withstanding time spent cancelling and rearranging meetings for working people.
Apts running late, sometimes up.to 90 minutes (zero apology compared to zero tolerance for the patient being late)
Chasing appointments and letters and correcting errors.
Lost productivity due to waiting lists
Lost taxation because people are dismissed due to being unable to work due to waiting lists.

I wonder how much all of that costs the economy.

Badbadbunny · 04/11/2026 10:59

ILoveKits · 04/11/2026 10:52

That's an interesting point but patient time and admin aren't calculated.

Long waits for calls to be dealt with.
Late cancellations of surgery which often create sunk costs for the patient - childcare/fares/etc, not withstanding time spent cancelling and rearranging meetings for working people.
Apts running late, sometimes up.to 90 minutes (zero apology compared to zero tolerance for the patient being late)
Chasing appointments and letters and correcting errors.
Lost productivity due to waiting lists
Lost taxation because people are dismissed due to being unable to work due to waiting lists.

I wonder how much all of that costs the economy.

Well said. All we ever hear about is the NHS "patient blaming" re unhealthy lifestyles, missing/late appointments, etc., but there's never any consideration for the effect on the patient of the NHS inefficiency/mistakes, etc., which does indeed have knock on effects on the overall economy, i.e. prolonged sick leave, multiple time off work for appointments, etc. The NHS doesn't seem to value the time of the patient in any way.

Barrydoughnut · 04/11/2026 11:05

If housing was more affordable in the UK taxes could go up to pay for all this stuff without disposable income being hammered.

I don’t revolt about the NHS because I’ve had 20 odd years of being able to use the health insurance that came as part of my of financial services job (huge company, everyone at every level was offered it as a perk) and now I’ve got it via DH. The DCs are covered too. I think a lot of people who would otherwise go nuts are in the same position as me.

CarbootJunction · 04/11/2026 11:30

Pinkgorilla101 · 03/11/2026 08:56

Having spent time living abroad and having top quality almost free healthcare (state, not private) I genuinely cannot believe that there hasn’t been a revolt or more done about the state of the NHS. Just this week I have heard of an 80 year old man with heart failure sitting in A&E for 17 hours then being told to go home as they had no beds and they would make him a routine appointment with a cardiologist. Seeing a GP is almost impossible. There are 2 at my NHS practice but both also run private clinics elsewhere. Why do we accept this or am I unreasonably unrealistic in my expectations?

Believe it or not, heart failure in an 80 year old person is not an emergency.

I've been unlucky enough to need the NHS quite a bit over the past five years, and I've never had to wait in A&E for 17 hours, I've always got a GP appointment when I needed it, and always got an Outpatient appointment in a timely manner. If you are ill, actually REALLY poorly, the NHS is there for you.

FascinatingCapybara · 04/11/2026 12:02

The system expanded too much and cannot possibly contain every condition people would like to address which were not accomodated for 50 years ago.

My experience of acute NHS care has been good overall, except for maternity care which was mixed. For things I can go private, I will, it saves my and GP's time. I'd prefer not have to but I'm realistic, and do not see things improving.

x2boys · 04/11/2026 12:13

CarbootJunction · 04/11/2026 11:30

Believe it or not, heart failure in an 80 year old person is not an emergency.

I've been unlucky enough to need the NHS quite a bit over the past five years, and I've never had to wait in A&E for 17 hours, I've always got a GP appointment when I needed it, and always got an Outpatient appointment in a timely manner. If you are ill, actually REALLY poorly, the NHS is there for you.

I agree the NHS has many many faults
But they saved my sons life three years ago
He collapsed at home and he was in DKA we had no idea he had Diabetes from phoning 999 where the paramedics immediatley recognised he was in DKA and stabiliised him and blue lighting him to A&E straight through to resus to admitting him to critcal care was about an hour and a half
Im not for one miunte suggeting its world class health care it isnt
But i couldnt fault them with the care my son received

Badbadbunny · 04/11/2026 12:19

CarbootJunction · 04/11/2026 11:30

Believe it or not, heart failure in an 80 year old person is not an emergency.

I've been unlucky enough to need the NHS quite a bit over the past five years, and I've never had to wait in A&E for 17 hours, I've always got a GP appointment when I needed it, and always got an Outpatient appointment in a timely manner. If you are ill, actually REALLY poorly, the NHS is there for you.

No it really isn't. My MIL was languishing on a trolley in a corridor in A&E for 48 hours! Prior to her being blue lighted to A&E, she was fit and healthy and active. Her treatment was an absolute disgrace.

It's a postcode lottery, as we see on various different threads on here, some people can get GP appointments, others can't. My DH who has cancer can't get a GP appointment - always just fobbed off with a GP associate, nurse, or sometimes can't even get past the receptionist. Not spoken to nor seen a GP for several years. That's despite having cancer and associated other health conditions. The oncologist is constantly fobbing him back to his GP, but the GP surgery won't do even the simplest of things that the consultant has written to them to tell them to do, such as refer for an x-ray, issue stronger pain killers, issue stronger iron/vitamin tablets, etc. Couldn't even get a GP surgery appointment to remove staples after a major leg operation despite the release notes (sent to surgery) instructing surgery to remove after x days.

Same with the hospital itself, some departments are actually functional, others are shambolic, i.e. appointment letters posted after the appointment date, some blood tests on the NHS app, some not, some depts can see blood tests and x-rays taken by other depts, some depts say they can't and order their own identical ones.

Smokeywater · 04/11/2026 12:57

Is it our ridiculous adversarial political set up - where when one says they will do something the other says the opposite.
Is it wokeism where what is important to British people is being kind and inclusive ( or being seen that way) and we must spend millions on judicial battles over identity, over right to remain in Britain, everyone's rights except the majority population? So there is no time, interest or intelligence spent on sorting the NHS (or improving it) because MPs want to be seen as kind and not efficient. And it's easier to be 'kind' than to sort the real problems. We need strong leaders or a strong leadership in any Gov. Instead we get factions in fighting in both the main parties.

I have had treatment abroad and did not see any groups of staff chatting in the corner, browsing the internet. They were individuals getting on with their job - this was in the US - private companies don't want employees hanging about or sitting in the nurses station chatting. Everything was streamlined and went like clockwork. Less pandering. Everyone getting themselves there on time. Getting picked up on time. No hospital transport, you got a lift. Too much reliance on the state to sort stuff out here.

EstoyRobandoSuCasa · 04/11/2026 13:08

Badbadbunny · 04/11/2026 12:19

No it really isn't. My MIL was languishing on a trolley in a corridor in A&E for 48 hours! Prior to her being blue lighted to A&E, she was fit and healthy and active. Her treatment was an absolute disgrace.

It's a postcode lottery, as we see on various different threads on here, some people can get GP appointments, others can't. My DH who has cancer can't get a GP appointment - always just fobbed off with a GP associate, nurse, or sometimes can't even get past the receptionist. Not spoken to nor seen a GP for several years. That's despite having cancer and associated other health conditions. The oncologist is constantly fobbing him back to his GP, but the GP surgery won't do even the simplest of things that the consultant has written to them to tell them to do, such as refer for an x-ray, issue stronger pain killers, issue stronger iron/vitamin tablets, etc. Couldn't even get a GP surgery appointment to remove staples after a major leg operation despite the release notes (sent to surgery) instructing surgery to remove after x days.

Same with the hospital itself, some departments are actually functional, others are shambolic, i.e. appointment letters posted after the appointment date, some blood tests on the NHS app, some not, some depts can see blood tests and x-rays taken by other depts, some depts say they can't and order their own identical ones.

Some GP surgeries really are crap, often because they're short of at least one GP and overuse less qualified staff to try to fill the gap, even when this isn't appropriate.

We changed from a crap surgery to a good one and are impressed with the new one. We wish we'd changed years earlier.

AnneElliott · 04/11/2026 13:13

Blankscreen · 03/11/2026 09:02

I don't know amy other industry where you can moonlight to the detriment of your main job and get away with it yet somehow doctors are allowed to run their own practice on the side. Outrageous.

I think that’s what the Labour Gov had to offer to the BMA in 1946 in order to get them to come on board with the NHS. I think the quote was ‘well stuff their mouths with gold’. I always wonder how the BMA squares their self righteous approach to the NHS with their history of being implacably opposed until they were bought off.

Sartre · 04/11/2026 13:30

We don’t have much of a choice. Most people are stretched thin as it is, I can’t imagine many would have the funds for private healthcare. Imagine the many families already struggling just to eat or heat their homes also having to contend with medical bills. Some have dodged the dentist for years because they can’t find an NHS one so can’t afford the hundreds to go private, or they can’t even justify the NHS charges. As a result, people are living with decaying teeth. Same would happen with healthcare because not everyone has spare cash for a GP appointment.

38thparallel · 04/11/2026 13:32

Couldn't even get a GP surgery appointment to remove staples after a major leg operation despite the release notes (sent to surgery) instructing surgery to remove after x days.

A friend got a fishing hook stuck in his hand. He got a GP appointment quickly, but the GP sent him to A & E where needless to say he waited a very long time. Surely a GP could remove a hook?

Badbadbunny · 04/11/2026 13:38

38thparallel · 04/11/2026 13:32

Couldn't even get a GP surgery appointment to remove staples after a major leg operation despite the release notes (sent to surgery) instructing surgery to remove after x days.

A friend got a fishing hook stuck in his hand. He got a GP appointment quickly, but the GP sent him to A & E where needless to say he waited a very long time. Surely a GP could remove a hook?

I think we need to scrap the current system of GP surgeries and set up "clinics" akin to those in lots of European countries, which do all kinds of "minor" things, i.e. prescriptions, bandaging wounds, small x-rays/scans, etc.

There was a time when GP surgeries did a lot more, the GPs would even attend road accidents, other incidents, home visits were pretty normal, they'd do all kinds of minor wound dressings, some even had small wards. Nowadays, they seem to do very little in terms of practical "hands on" treatments, and it seems to have become predominantly a desk job. Our GP surgery don't even do blood tests - they send you to the hospital to wait with dozens of others in the phlebotomy drop in clinic. As we found, they don't even do staple/stitch removal.

Starling78 · 04/11/2026 13:47

Apart from the small, but very mouthy ‘NHS is the untouchable crown jewel of Britain’ brigade, people generally aren’t accepting it anymore. Every other person I talk to (myself included) has private health insurance nowadays. Millions are paying for private GP appointments, scans, surgery etc when 10 years ago it was something only for the very wealthy/elite. It’s an absolute disgrace and personally I’d like to know where my taxes are going - why should I pay for NHS services I can’t even access anymore? Bupa get £100 from me every month out of necessity!

Freyer · 04/11/2026 13:48

YANBU. My dad had a random huge seizure and was unable to walk so he was in a wheelchair in the main ED waiting room for 12 hours overnight. We were then called in from the waiting room, told he had a giant tumour in his brain and shown back out to the waiting room in utter shock. He recently had to have major heart surgery but the doctors that needed to approve the surgery were on leave. Dad kept telling the staff he felt really unwell but no one listened to him. He then collapsed in the canteen of the hospital and we were called to say goodbye at 3am. I have many, many stories of NHS failings sadly.

Witchyhoures · 04/11/2026 14:07

Possibly a lot of money inevitably spent keeping elderly alive. But very little on children. But lack of basics possibly has impacted the numbers with what looks like asd (eg from hearing issues) or adhd things like giant tonsils.

A lot being spent on t2 diabetes too.

Lots of issues with nhs but ultimately trying to cut corners
eg no tonsil removal
no antibiotics for ear infections
not enough course of AB for uti
incorrect lab levels for iron and tsh

Thing is though i wanted my kid’s hearing checked but nhs only..
people may want private adhd assessment but dont want to pay for the meds but gp can refuse shared care.

Even things like good dentistry affect long term health so for kids… yes its free for kids but not for the adults so if the adult isnt going…

But also the percentage of people of healthy weight, with no addictions etc etc is probably low

All the kids i know with asd/adhd had ear infections. And obviously untreated bacterial infection can spread to others…

2 years before adhd aapointment, 3 years for diagnosis, 3.5yrs to trial meds…

helpfulperson · 04/11/2026 14:32

Witchyhoures · 04/11/2026 14:07

Possibly a lot of money inevitably spent keeping elderly alive. But very little on children. But lack of basics possibly has impacted the numbers with what looks like asd (eg from hearing issues) or adhd things like giant tonsils.

A lot being spent on t2 diabetes too.

Lots of issues with nhs but ultimately trying to cut corners
eg no tonsil removal
no antibiotics for ear infections
not enough course of AB for uti
incorrect lab levels for iron and tsh

Thing is though i wanted my kid’s hearing checked but nhs only..
people may want private adhd assessment but dont want to pay for the meds but gp can refuse shared care.

Even things like good dentistry affect long term health so for kids… yes its free for kids but not for the adults so if the adult isnt going…

But also the percentage of people of healthy weight, with no addictions etc etc is probably low

All the kids i know with asd/adhd had ear infections. And obviously untreated bacterial infection can spread to others…

2 years before adhd aapointment, 3 years for diagnosis, 3.5yrs to trial meds…

Seirously? Very little on children ? Have you seen how much is spent on the babies and severe and complex children /adults with little or no quality of life. But it's only the old who have no right to life.

38thparallel · 04/11/2026 15:01

Thing is though i wanted my kid’s hearing checked but nhs only..
people may want private adhd assessment but dont want to pay for the meds but gp can refuse shared care.

I thought if people saw a consultant privately then the consultant could write to the patients’ NHS practice with the prescription and it, the practice, was obliged to put the medicine on the patients’ files and provide it.
However maybe it’s only for repeat prescriptions.