Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Limiting length of visits to see baby despite journey time

428 replies

Neverendingsummer26 · 02/11/2026 13:27

Am I being unreasonable to limit how long people visit my baby even if they have travelled over an hour to see us?

I moved away from the town where I grew up about 5 years ago and I now live about 75 mins car journey away from my family now.

I’ve not long had a baby and we told everyone prior to coming that we were limiting visits to 30 minutes so it didn’t get too overwhelming for me / the baby and also because we want to adjust to being a family of 3 as well. No one had any objections and my sister said she had found a local park that she was taking her children to after so they weren’t getting straight back in the car.

The next time they all came we upped the visit to an hour and then the last time they visited it was also supposed to be an hour but my baby was quite fussy and I was getting a bit stressed so they left after probably about 40 minutes.

Anyway I’ve just messaged my sister about finding a date to come around again and she’s messaged back essentially saying that an hour’s visit isn’t enough given the journey time and until I’m ready for longer visits, she won’t be coming to see us again.

I know some of this will be the hormones but I just feel really upset by her message. When she had her babies I always made the effort to go to see her.

OP posts:
Nothavingagoodvalentinesday · 03/11/2026 00:09

Sorry but you don’t get to decide for both you and your sister. You made your rules, she doesn’t want to stick to them so has made her own. If you want her to visit you are going to have to let her stay longer. She is being totally reasonable in saying she doesn’t want to visit under the conditions you have laid out. She has to think about her own family.

Freebliss · 03/11/2026 00:05

IndieRocknRoll · 02/11/2026 23:25

Jeez when did new mums become like this?! This is the second thread tonight with what amounts to frankly ridiculous behaviour. The other one had a ‘meal train’ where friends and family were expected to cook and deliver meals in narrow time slot for 2 months after the birth!

Wtf is this how new mums are now.

BadLad · 03/11/2026 00:03

saraclara · 02/11/2026 21:39

I swear that pregnant women and new mothers are being advised pretty badly these days. I don't know if it's by professionals or by social media, but instead of being given confidence, they're being made to feel as though they're made of glass and everyone around them should be handling them with enormous care in care they break.

It doesn't take a lot of effort to think about mothers of old, and mothers in other countries and cultures, and recognise how they go about those first few months. And it's really not like this. If anything they're surrounded by family, not fending them off while they "adjust to bring a family of three" or are resting like a young Victorian lady reclining on a chaise longue dabbing her cheeks with a hanky.

I'm trying not to blame this subset if today's new mothers themselves. Like every generation they're looking for advice. I just think the 'keep your family away and centre yourself in every way for months" kind of advice is counter-productive.

Some of this advice is from professionals.

This thread is five years old, but here is an HV apparently having advised the OP to organise her neighbours into starting a meal train.

https://www.mumsnet.com/talk/am_i_being_unreasonable/4301144-To-involve-strangers-in-a-meal-train

To involve strangers in a meal train? | Mumsnet

Just moved house and just had a baby…. We’ve briefly met the neighbours on either side and they seem perfectly pleasant. HV has suggested starting a m...

https://www.mumsnet.com/talk/am_i_being_unreasonable/4301144-To-involve-strangers-in-a-meal-train

HoppingPavlova · 02/11/2026 23:57

Neverendingsummer26 · 02/11/2026 14:55

Ok seems I am being unreasonable.

We just wanted to manage expectations and make sure there is plenty of time for resting etc. Also I love them lots but my nephews are 2 & very active & noisy and it’s exhausting enough just watching them !! But perhaps we need to rethink meetings moving forwards

You do realise that’s what your baby is going to turn into right?

It’s completely unreasonable to expect people to travel that distance for that amount of time. Telling them not to come is going to be damaging. What’s the problem if the baby is fussy? You should be comfortable around your family, they can put the kettle in and make themselves a cuppa if you are busy with baby. Or, what is your DH doing during these visits, is he at home or working? If he is working then just ask your family to make cuppa’s, lunch etc, they will be fine to do this no doubt. If he’s not working, unless he is disabled, then he can manage this aspect when people visit surely. All seems a lot of fuss over nothing.

Eggs2022 · 02/11/2026 23:40

Am I the only one who doesn’t get the ‘we need time to adjust to being a family of 3’ thing? How does having your sister/friend etc visit what is presumably once every couple of days/weekends taking anything away from your family time? It sounds like something you read in a baby book but then realise it’s ridiculous when the baby’s here. Managing expectations, time to rest, etc is all jargon and is sooo unnecessary, it’s like people decide how they feel and what they’ll do before baby even gets here. Your sister has been very reasonable tbh and although its natural to find things upsetting PP, I really think when time passes you’ll have a little laugh at yourself

Newname26 · 02/11/2026 23:28

IndieRocknRoll · 02/11/2026 23:25

Jeez when did new mums become like this?! This is the second thread tonight with what amounts to frankly ridiculous behaviour. The other one had a ‘meal train’ where friends and family were expected to cook and deliver meals in narrow time slot for 2 months after the birth!

No way 2mths!!! 😳
Called supermarket ready meal if your that desperate.

IndieRocknRoll · 02/11/2026 23:25

Jeez when did new mums become like this?! This is the second thread tonight with what amounts to frankly ridiculous behaviour. The other one had a ‘meal train’ where friends and family were expected to cook and deliver meals in narrow time slot for 2 months after the birth!

Newname26 · 02/11/2026 23:21

Emilesgran · 02/11/2026 23:17

Is this a typo or does she really have twin boys of two years old??

If so, you are being VERY VERY unreasonable and you have a massive shock coming in a couple of years time, if you think you need more rest now than your poor sister who managed to get two toddlers in the car to drive such a long distance just to be made feel unwelcome! I wonder how many hours' sleep she had before that journey?

Personally I'm amazed she went back a second time.

I see what you mean, it could be a typo. But even if its 2 boys under school age, its still a big ask to drive that distance for an hour.

And if they are on electric its a pain to recharge it and its not cheap if its petrol.

Emilesgran · 02/11/2026 23:17

Neverendingsummer26 · 02/11/2026 14:55

Ok seems I am being unreasonable.

We just wanted to manage expectations and make sure there is plenty of time for resting etc. Also I love them lots but my nephews are 2 & very active & noisy and it’s exhausting enough just watching them !! But perhaps we need to rethink meetings moving forwards

Is this a typo or does she really have twin boys of two years old??

If so, you are being VERY VERY unreasonable and you have a massive shock coming in a couple of years time, if you think you need more rest now than your poor sister who managed to get two toddlers in the car to drive such a long distance just to be made feel unwelcome! I wonder how many hours' sleep she had before that journey?

Personally I'm amazed she went back a second time.

Newname26 · 02/11/2026 23:11

TeenLifeMum · 02/11/2026 23:02

The “boundaries” people put up are so sad. Chill and enjoy your baby with your family. It’s your sister not a distant relative. I really hope my dc don’t get caught up in all the social media rules around newborns. 30 minutes after driving for an hour? Madness. Asking dsis to come over and bring a meal to share together? Yes. Making her feel unwelcome and like a burden? No.

Given the sis has 2 yo twins, she also has her hands pretty full.

I'd suggest invite over and get take away or something easy to bung in the oven, pizza or something.

If its a decent day go for a walk to the park or somewhere.
Or op goes there, roads work in both directions

alphajuliet123 · 02/11/2026 23:11

Neverendingsummer26 · 02/11/2026 14:55

Ok seems I am being unreasonable.

We just wanted to manage expectations and make sure there is plenty of time for resting etc. Also I love them lots but my nephews are 2 & very active & noisy and it’s exhausting enough just watching them !! But perhaps we need to rethink meetings moving forwards

Yes YABU and this sounds like transaction business speak.

Why do you think you need to set a limit, surely it depends how it goes on the day? You hand the baby to visitors for snuggles and go for a long shower, or sort the laundry out, or potter in the garden while chatting, or nip to the shop solo, or do any of the things that need doing while you have free hands. You definitely need to relax a bit.

boringperson123 · 02/11/2026 23:10

Headflip · 02/11/2026 19:03

Parents of newborns are always a bit self absorbed but it takes something special to think having visitors for more than half an hour with a tiny baby, who doesn't "do" anything is more difficult that travelling with 2yo twins!

This! Absolutely void of empathy

boringperson123 · 02/11/2026 23:09

YABVU she has toddler twins and has been through a toddler newborn phase, she probably thinks you’re a massive wet wipe tbh

TeenLifeMum · 02/11/2026 23:02

The “boundaries” people put up are so sad. Chill and enjoy your baby with your family. It’s your sister not a distant relative. I really hope my dc don’t get caught up in all the social media rules around newborns. 30 minutes after driving for an hour? Madness. Asking dsis to come over and bring a meal to share together? Yes. Making her feel unwelcome and like a burden? No.

EvieBB · 02/11/2026 22:45

blythet · 02/11/2026 13:40

Do you put a timer on when they arrive?

I’m wondering more about your relationship with your sister and if there’s a back story? I loved having my sister round when my baby was a newborn and vice versa as we helped each other. Especially if either of us was stressed hormonal!

do you not feel that comfortable around her?

when my sister had been round when Dd was a newborn and I was stressing she’d have helped settle baby. If I was upset/hormonal she’d have made me a cup of tea, got me chocolate and gave me a hug.
particularly since your sister had older children and been there before you’d think she’d understand and muck in to help

Yeah my sister would come over lots and stay for half a day/nearly full day .....and we both wanted that. Precious times

NotSmallButFunSize · 02/11/2026 22:44

God I loved it when people came over when I had my babies, I would have let my mum or sister stay all day!!

People have gone very weird about having babies - then wondering later where their village is. You have to actually be a villager to have a village!

HannahSqan · 02/11/2026 22:41

Neverendingsummer26 · 02/11/2026 13:27

Am I being unreasonable to limit how long people visit my baby even if they have travelled over an hour to see us?

I moved away from the town where I grew up about 5 years ago and I now live about 75 mins car journey away from my family now.

I’ve not long had a baby and we told everyone prior to coming that we were limiting visits to 30 minutes so it didn’t get too overwhelming for me / the baby and also because we want to adjust to being a family of 3 as well. No one had any objections and my sister said she had found a local park that she was taking her children to after so they weren’t getting straight back in the car.

The next time they all came we upped the visit to an hour and then the last time they visited it was also supposed to be an hour but my baby was quite fussy and I was getting a bit stressed so they left after probably about 40 minutes.

Anyway I’ve just messaged my sister about finding a date to come around again and she’s messaged back essentially saying that an hour’s visit isn’t enough given the journey time and until I’m ready for longer visits, she won’t be coming to see us again.

I know some of this will be the hormones but I just feel really upset by her message. When she had her babies I always made the effort to go to see her.

Nah if you want them to visit and invite people to visit then you have to accept if you cap visits they are not going to come. That is ridiculous.
you are not the first person to have a baby. I have had three, one who spent weeks crying with colic. If you want people to come and drive 1.5 hours (remember you moved away so they are making the effort). You need to find a way to let them stay longer. Are there less stress activities? Can you pop on a movie for her kids? Or can you make the effort to visit them or meet half way and start the car ride when baby falls asleep as babies typically sleep in cars (not all 2/3 my kids slept in cars, 1/3 screamed in cars like it was being tortured).

wildnwilde · 02/11/2026 22:33

Gengha · 02/11/2026 22:25

Blooming heck OP you’ve only had a baby ie what the vast majority of us have done or will do at some point in our lives. Is there really any need for all this rigmarole? Parenting can be tough, don’t alienate your loved ones.

This . You'd think you'd givem birth to second coming 🙌🤭😭😭

wildnwilde · 02/11/2026 22:31

Just tell them not to visit . Honestly I wouldn't want to if that was your attitude anyway .

TubeScreamer · 02/11/2026 22:31

YABVU

don’t push away the people who could be your support network and play an important role in your children’s lives.

ChapmanFarm · 02/11/2026 22:27

I wonder if it's a big of an overhang of coving.

People who had babies in isolation trying to convince themselves it was something wonderful that created a bond no one else has.

I also wonder (ducks) whether extended paternity leave is always helpful. When my husband went back after a fortnight. That was really where I found my stride and confidence. You realise you can fo a lot and care for a baby. It's one of those 'the more you do the more you can manage'.

It was also where I was forced to fill my days with other mothers and brave the baby groups. And that is where I met the people I needed at that time going through the same struggles, offering advice, having a moan.

This 'bubble of three' isn't necessarily what is needed. I bloody loved seeing anyone at new born stage to break up the day.

That said I can imagine two year old twins could be a lot. You probably are better going to hers where they have their own space and toys. It will be easier all round.

When you have a new baby it makes your toddler suddenly look bizarrely massive when they were still your baby just before that.

Tryandmakeadifference · 02/11/2026 22:27

havingoneofthosedays · 02/11/2026 13:32

As they say, it takes a village…
Be careful you don’t burn yours down…

Definitely this 🤔

WaltzingWaters · 02/11/2026 22:25

Blimey, yes YAB really U. No chance I’d be repeatedly doing that drive with 2yo’s for an hours visit. Just pop baby in the pram and go for a walk to the playground with them.

Gengha · 02/11/2026 22:25

Blooming heck OP you’ve only had a baby ie what the vast majority of us have done or will do at some point in our lives. Is there really any need for all this rigmarole? Parenting can be tough, don’t alienate your loved ones.

40notouttoday · 02/11/2026 22:24

I have three kids (one 18m) the thought of chucking them all in a car for an hour to visit for half an hour and come back home again, nope.

I know the adjustment to having one kid is hard but if you're ever planning on having more you might appreciate the mam maths in having more children who don't usually live in your house = easier life.
I have a massive family the comes and goings in the baby days get so much less as they become rambunctious toddlers, personally id tell you not to miss out. Looking at your family's face with love in their eyes is the most precious thing.