Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Have uk cities really became this unsafe?

402 replies

Electricblankettime · 18/10/2026 01:28

I live in a small town and love the countryside life. Recentlhly had to go to a big city. Groups of men hanging around staring like thry had never seen a woman before were intimidating so overly persistent men approaching and following felt terrifying. Men pestering when minding my own business and scaring me.

I thought it was a one of freak thing but when discussing with other women they have said thars just what its like now. I feel very naive as where I live I can go anywhere at any hour and feel safe. When did the world change? Ive travelled worldwide and aa a solo female plenty and never had problems like this. Not been into a city for years and it feels so different.

Do other women feel safety in cities has changed o was I just unlucky?

OP posts:
YorkYapping · 04/11/2026 16:32

Electricblankettime · 04/11/2026 16:20

I do agree alot of women have said that they feel safe in London though. Thst was good to hear

I think it depends on the area in London. I feel very safe in my area and my child who lives on the other side of the river feels safe there. Otherwise we would move. But ofc I accept there are dodgy parts, like in any area.

We are lucky and have the flexibility to move but we don’t want to, as we love our area. London is huge with nine million people, so all parts are not the same.

I am quite glad I don’t live in a wealthy part as I know that people get their watches and phones stolen more there.

And I would definitely encourage you as I said before, to report assaults to police if you feel able to. No man has the right to treat women like this.

RedTagAlan · 04/11/2026 16:44

cryupmykingdom · 04/11/2026 16:15

>Given that something like 17% of the worlds population mainly only have >access to PRC state media, the more demos and riots in democratic countries >they can report on, only makes the Parties domestic position stonger

They really don't. When it comes to Weixin/WeChat and a bunch of other Chinese social media, added to the stories-gone-viral fed back to home, by Chinese travelling overseas, they have access to lots of world news.

In fact, Chinese takes on international news are well worth accessing, as they really make you think, and lots of the commentary is not just rude, it's side-splittingly funny.

Edited

Are you talking about the TikTok refugee to Rednote stuff ?

I remember following that at the time, and the vast majority of the "refugees" were eventually shut out. It was a while ago though, and fuzzy memory. Did Rednote not change to PRC ID only?

Persephonia1966 · 04/11/2026 16:48

RedTagAlan · 04/11/2026 16:28

So is your counselling for "two traumatic experiences with men in 24 hours." because of the incident you mentioned in your opening post ?

That is all I asked. And if you answer that, then maybe the thread might be in a better informed position to help.

I can personally believe she encountered a randomly intimidating group of men/several intimidating groups in the space of a few hours. This happened to me years ago and it was, I think, because there were some PUAs running a "training" event which seemed to entail the trainees repeatedly harassing every women they saw walking down the street. It's not actually illegal behaviour but it is intimidating and odd to be accosted but very "intense" men every few metres. That was years ago so I don't buy the life is so much more dangerous line more now (and for the record none of those men gave asylum seeker vibes). But maybe if there was a secret twattery convention happening nearby it could explain it. I can see how it would be quite upsetting. I don't know what "can be done" about men acting oddly but not illegally though.

StrangerThanA90sTrend · 04/11/2026 16:52

Electricblankettime · 04/11/2026 16:16

If you read my posts I went into more detail. Its simply not true most women said they felt safe. Actually most posters initially accused me of being a Russian bot which made no sense to me. I think some responses were so nuts they were removed and the post was closed for a while. Love the telling a woman her experiences didn't happen though. Hope that works for you

It's been a really weird thread. Your title and opening post don't really match up, as the first post is so vague. You didn't say which city, you said men stared at you and asked the question 'have uk cities became this unsafe?' which couldn't really be answered based on a very unclear account of feeling intimidated somewhere unspecified. Later on, you say that you were subjected to an attempted kidnapping which is of course quite a long way from staring. People can post in erratic and unclear ways for all sorts of reasons, but it can make a thread go to odd places when it's quite hard to follow what the OP is saying.

You have said later that you'd like to talk about whether or not UK cities have become less safe for women lately but you have ignored a lot of what women have said about their experience of UK cities now and in the past - eg the amount of sexual harassment people remember experiencing in the 90s or as teens.

Do women feel safe? Hard to answer - are women ever safe under patriarchy? Are women safe in cities - are they safe in their own homes where statistically they are in the most danger of violence? It's a very big question to pose without the usual parameters of a thread that would ordinarily set out an experience more clearly as the basis for discussion. This one started without much to go on - and so people ran with it, to quite a lot of distant places.

Electricblankettime · 04/11/2026 16:54

RedTagAlan · 04/11/2026 16:28

So is your counselling for "two traumatic experiences with men in 24 hours." because of the incident you mentioned in your opening post ?

That is all I asked. And if you answer that, then maybe the thread might be in a better informed position to help.

It's for the whole trip really. I see your confusion as reading back constant pestering by men doesn't describe what they did or the incidents were specifically. I wasn't just pestered twice but twice thr incidents were bigger and worse

OP posts:
cryupmykingdom · 04/11/2026 16:55

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Flamingojune · 04/11/2026 16:57

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Or a student doing research as has happened on here before

cryupmykingdom · 04/11/2026 16:58

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Daisy54 · 04/11/2026 17:03

I live in zone 2 in London and no I overall I do not feel safe, even during the day.
However, I do walk to work and go out and about in general.
I just make sure I walk confidently and I am vigilant. I may even carry some hairspray, in case I need to do my hair enroute!
Many a time I have had to cross over to the other side of the road to avoid being harassed. It is always due to men or a man.

I avoid walking around at night as I have been followed home a few times.

I live in a normal residential area, not rich or poor.

RedTagAlan · 04/11/2026 17:18

Persephonia1966 · 04/11/2026 16:48

I can personally believe she encountered a randomly intimidating group of men/several intimidating groups in the space of a few hours. This happened to me years ago and it was, I think, because there were some PUAs running a "training" event which seemed to entail the trainees repeatedly harassing every women they saw walking down the street. It's not actually illegal behaviour but it is intimidating and odd to be accosted but very "intense" men every few metres. That was years ago so I don't buy the life is so much more dangerous line more now (and for the record none of those men gave asylum seeker vibes). But maybe if there was a secret twattery convention happening nearby it could explain it. I can see how it would be quite upsetting. I don't know what "can be done" about men acting oddly but not illegally though.

Edited

I do not doubt it is not true. I just think there might be conflating going on, where different incidents that are not connected, are being connected by the OP. That is reasonable I think, given how vague the OP is being.

Root cause branches out in all directions and all that, obscuring the root.

Thatladdo · 04/11/2026 17:26

I'd recommend Deep Heat or similar instead of hairspray, its massively more effective. In case you sprain a muscle while walking.

RedTagAlan · 04/11/2026 17:29

Electricblankettime · 04/11/2026 16:54

It's for the whole trip really. I see your confusion as reading back constant pestering by men doesn't describe what they did or the incidents were specifically. I wasn't just pestered twice but twice thr incidents were bigger and worse

But is your opening post directly related to your later posts?

Because a few posts ago you said ""two traumatic experiences with men in 24 hours.", and now you seem to have changed that a bit to:"I wasn't just pestered twice but twice thr incidents were bigger and worse". That seems to me to be a sort of downgrade, and a big upgrade, at the same time.

Are these 2 incidents directly related to your opening post, where you said " Men pestering when minding my own business and scaring me.".

Because you have gone from a perception thing, to a "traumatic experiences" thing. Are they one and the same incident ?

XenaSharples · 04/11/2026 17:45

I'm sorry this happened to you OP. I don't think it's typical in a UK city to be chased by men. Of course women have to deal with this shit to some degree everywhere, but that level of harassment isn't typical as far as I am aware.

Flamingojune · 04/11/2026 17:54

RedTagAlan · 04/11/2026 17:29

But is your opening post directly related to your later posts?

Because a few posts ago you said ""two traumatic experiences with men in 24 hours.", and now you seem to have changed that a bit to:"I wasn't just pestered twice but twice thr incidents were bigger and worse". That seems to me to be a sort of downgrade, and a big upgrade, at the same time.

Are these 2 incidents directly related to your opening post, where you said " Men pestering when minding my own business and scaring me.".

Because you have gone from a perception thing, to a "traumatic experiences" thing. Are they one and the same incident ?

It is indeed confusing

Electricblankettime · 04/11/2026 19:19

Its really not that complicated. I went on a trip to a big city whivh i do not live in. Had a terrible time with men being pests. Two traumatic incidents occurred with men in addition to lower level creepy man weirdness. I came home. I posted on here. I am currently being cross examined following being told im lying, im right wing, im Russian and that im odd. Pick apart what I'm saying all you like but wont change the facts. Thank you to the women who have responded saying that they do feel safe and thank you to those who responded saying they don't feel safe. Some of the insights about what people are used to have been interesting. The fact that women have to justify themselves over over when they want to discuss women's safety is awful. So many comments deleted from here show how unacceptable the way I jave been spoken to and grilled for having openly said men harassed me and I experienced two more serious instances in that time.

OP posts:
SurferRona · 04/11/2026 20:55

RedTagAlan · 04/11/2026 16:07

This is your opening post.

"I live in a small town and love the countryside life. Recentlhly had to go to a big city. Groups of men hanging around staring like thry had never seen a woman before were intimidating so overly persistent men approaching and following felt terrifying. Men pestering when minding my own business and scaring me.
I thought it was a one of freak thing but when discussing with other women they have said thars just what its like now. I feel very naive as where I live I can go anywhere at any hour and feel safe. When did the world change? Ive travelled worldwide and aa a solo female plenty and never had problems like this. Not been into a city for years and it feels so different.
Do other women feel safety in cities has changed o was I just unlucky?"

Now you are saying "I need counselling as I had two traumatic experiences with men in 24 hours."

I think before you accuse people of victim blaming, can you confirm if these are related to the same incident, or are you conflating ?

You said you felt unsafe And asked for experiences. Then when most posters replied that they did not feel unsafe, it somehow elevated to "I had two traumatic experiences with men in 24 hours."

I think it is only fair to ask if the latter is the former. Are you getting counselling now because of what you described in your first post ?

I think that is a fair question. Do you agree it is a fair question ?

Would you care to answer @RedTagAlan s simple questions please OP?

I think before you accuse people of victim blaming, can you confirm if these are related to the same incident, or are you conflating ?
You said you felt unsafe And asked for experiences. Then when most posters replied that they did not feel unsafe, it somehow elevated to "I had two traumatic experiences with men in 24 hours."
I think it is only fair to ask if the latter is the former. Are you getting counselling now because of what you described in your first post ?
I think that is a fair question. Do you agree it is a fair question ?

or will you choose to ignore and straw man argue a peripheral unrelated point?

💅

Faux naive, faux outrage, faux OP.

Electricblankettime · 04/11/2026 21:05

Ive answered. More than once. Not that your entitled to any answers. Grilling and picking a part a women who has been through what I have for wanting to talk about womens safety is really distasteful.

OP posts:
spongebunnyfatpants · 04/11/2026 22:01

I've recently been to London for the first time in over 10 years.
Travelled by tube, walked around and didn't feel unsafe at all.

TooBigForMyBoots · 05/11/2026 01:29

Was the city you were in Reform led @Electricblankettime? They have form.

www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/c63elky79np7o

RedTagAlan · 05/11/2026 05:10

Electricblankettime · 04/11/2026 19:19

Its really not that complicated. I went on a trip to a big city whivh i do not live in. Had a terrible time with men being pests. Two traumatic incidents occurred with men in addition to lower level creepy man weirdness. I came home. I posted on here. I am currently being cross examined following being told im lying, im right wing, im Russian and that im odd. Pick apart what I'm saying all you like but wont change the facts. Thank you to the women who have responded saying that they do feel safe and thank you to those who responded saying they don't feel safe. Some of the insights about what people are used to have been interesting. The fact that women have to justify themselves over over when they want to discuss women's safety is awful. So many comments deleted from here show how unacceptable the way I jave been spoken to and grilled for having openly said men harassed me and I experienced two more serious instances in that time.

Quote : " I went on a trip to a big city whivh i do not live in. Had a terrible time with men being pests."

Ok. Got that. That is what your thread opener is about.

Quote : "Two traumatic incidents occurred with men in addition to lower level creepy man weirdness. "

So the 2 traumatic incidents happened "in addition to" the what you posted in your opening post here : "Groups of men hanging around staring like thry had never seen a woman before were intimidating so overly persistent men approaching and following felt terrifying. Men pestering when minding my own business and scaring me."

I think that clarifies things somewhat. People are replying to you wanting a discussion about "Groups of men hanging around staring ", and you are replying to some posters about a different thing that happed "in addition to lower level creepy man weirdness. "

Thanks for clarifying. So it seems you are conflating 2 different things. And that's ok, Understandable if you are traumatised by something that happened "in addition to" during your trip to a city.

There is a fair bit of cross purposes discussion going on here, in addition to some of the usual sideline stuff that goes on. I don't think the thread is really so much about you being cross examined by people saying you are lying ( although some might say that in any such discussion), but it is more about there being a confusion because you are talking about incidents "in addition to" the subject of your thread.

Do you agree with that ? Is that what is happening ?

mellongoose · 05/11/2026 05:35

Electricblankettime · 04/11/2026 21:05

Ive answered. More than once. Not that your entitled to any answers. Grilling and picking a part a women who has been through what I have for wanting to talk about womens safety is really distasteful.

OP I think people on here are being unnecessarily hostile and I’m afraid you don’t deserve it.

I also live rurally now but have lived in cities previously. Yes, the intimidation by groups of men can be a thing. Often, not in the tourist centres though, but further out.

I don’t need to know which city you mean. You felt unsafe and wanted to ask if others had felt the same.

I also feel that living rurally skews your senses and perception of the city somewhat. I get a massive sensory overload if I spend too long in London these days, yet happily lived there for over a decade.

I love feeling safe and I love the peace and quiet.

Im sorry you’ve had a rough time on here.

Do better MNers.

ihateprobability · 05/11/2026 08:26

sorry but in the current climate using emotions to manipulate and drive hatred of others is wrong. and i that’s how this OP comes across to me. I can see others read this differently but we are all allowed our opinions

“ I felt unsafe” is - well I guess that’s why they invented the term snowflake.

the title is provocative - it talks about cities being unsafe where there is no evidence of this . just a feeling. Even “men following” - what ? Walking the same way as you?

yes we shouldn’t always ignore feelings but we should look at where they come from and wether they are rational or stemmed from hate of others

OP may have genuinely experienced threatening abusive behaviour or her predujice may have made a normal situation into a drama. Her explanation - no crimes actually being committed, just feelings?

and it does matter because the hate in this country is growing so badly. And most of the additional crime threats in the country are coming from right wing extremists. Who use emotional manipulation in everything they do

Flamingojune · 05/11/2026 08:34

Pps have answered the question 'have uk cities become this unsafe'? with a no, and have been accused of minimising, victim blaming, racism snd hostility.

SomersetBrie · 05/11/2026 10:32

Electricblankettime · 04/11/2026 19:19

Its really not that complicated. I went on a trip to a big city whivh i do not live in. Had a terrible time with men being pests. Two traumatic incidents occurred with men in addition to lower level creepy man weirdness. I came home. I posted on here. I am currently being cross examined following being told im lying, im right wing, im Russian and that im odd. Pick apart what I'm saying all you like but wont change the facts. Thank you to the women who have responded saying that they do feel safe and thank you to those who responded saying they don't feel safe. Some of the insights about what people are used to have been interesting. The fact that women have to justify themselves over over when they want to discuss women's safety is awful. So many comments deleted from here show how unacceptable the way I jave been spoken to and grilled for having openly said men harassed me and I experienced two more serious instances in that time.

All you can do to make things safer for other women is to report what happened to the police. I had no idea from your first post that something criminal had happened, I just thought you were talking about general discomfort (which is also horrible of course).

Or do you have other ideas how you can help women feel safer in cities?

Electricblankettime · 05/11/2026 10:49

Flamingojune · 05/11/2026 08:34

Pps have answered the question 'have uk cities become this unsafe'? with a no, and have been accused of minimising, victim blaming, racism snd hostility.

Thats not what happened and im glad that mumsnet removed some of your earlier posts that breached community standards.

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread