Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Have uk cities really became this unsafe?

402 replies

Electricblankettime · 18/10/2026 01:28

I live in a small town and love the countryside life. Recentlhly had to go to a big city. Groups of men hanging around staring like thry had never seen a woman before were intimidating so overly persistent men approaching and following felt terrifying. Men pestering when minding my own business and scaring me.

I thought it was a one of freak thing but when discussing with other women they have said thars just what its like now. I feel very naive as where I live I can go anywhere at any hour and feel safe. When did the world change? Ive travelled worldwide and aa a solo female plenty and never had problems like this. Not been into a city for years and it feels so different.

Do other women feel safety in cities has changed o was I just unlucky?

OP posts:
DeftGoldHedgehog · 04/11/2026 12:11

Never had this. Sounds like you are confusing UK cities with Kyzyl, Shakhty or Chelyabinsk to me.

mcmuffin22 · 04/11/2026 12:14

SomersetBrie · 04/11/2026 11:30

If it's not about race, and you never said it was, what do you think has changed in cities that make them more unsafe?

Is it more unemployment, more alcohol, more drugs, just more people hanging out? More men?

I don't live in a city and the ones I visit are quite nice, but there are certainly areas I would avoid especially in the evening, partly due to open drug use. I don't know though if that has got worse.

Fewer visible police officers (not only making it feel less safe but also resulting in more people feeling they can behave however they want as there will be no one to pull them up on it. Central London feels very safe to me as it there is a visible police presence.

Thatladdo · 04/11/2026 12:17

Theres a world of differance between someone being racist and someone noticing patterns of behaviour and being aware people from different places have different beleifs which lead them to treat women and children (the whole point of this social site) very badly by the standards that we uphold in the "west", leading them to be at greater risk than they otherwise should.

To ignore this is nothing more than idiotic, suicidal empathy at best and willful desecration of everything this nations inhabitants have worked to build and died to protect over many, many generations.

Electricblankettime · 04/11/2026 12:19

LeastOfMyWorries · 04/11/2026 11:38

I live in a small city and haven't ever experienced any of this but I am really sorry you have visited a British city and in one visit experienced two things you are needing counselling for AND a multitude of other unpleasant experiences- I don't think people are being unreasonable in asking which city this is, and I sincerely hope you have raised those issues with the police or some other official body.

I hope you find a way forward and don't curtail your life long term because that would be a real shame on the back of an isolated (looking at the replies here) incident.

Thank you. I think i feel quite attacked for saying what happened on here. That's when I've been really vague so glad i didnt go into the specifics as then all the mocking would feel even more personal. I was going to speak to the counsellor about reporting to the police but the attitudes on here are purting me off reporting to the police when im feeling so delicate with whars happened. I dont think I could cope with the police if they have the same hostility as people here. I do think one of the men may be traceable potentially and it would protect other women but my tank is so empty right now

OP posts:
Tomikka · 04/11/2026 13:09

EmeraldRoulette · 03/11/2026 19:40

@TheSilverTeapot I can certainly see the logic in some of that

However, I can’t see what the benefit would be in making particular areas look dangerous. I can see what the benefit is to individual troublemakers on social media. But Russia?

But my own experience of a rough part of London was not positive - I lived there for years and it wasn’t rough originally. Obviously you don’t know me. I’m just someone posting on the Internet. So I accept that you have no reason to trust me. I do think a lot of us are speaking from personal experience when we talk about being nervous in our local area. I was glad to leave. London is obviously massive and it was just one small part.

Edited

I can see what the benefit is to individual troublemakers on social media. But Russia?

To generate fear, disrupt, lack of confidence in government / society, cause division etc

The same goes for American Christian nationalists pushing their narratives and point of view
Russia in particular differs and is very accomplished in numerous contradictory narratives - either for confusion in all the contradictions or for the division caused through supporting extremism in opposing views

Persephonia1966 · 04/11/2026 13:10

Electricblankettime · 04/11/2026 09:04

What is find the most wild about this thread raising two terrifying incidents by men which have affected me deeply asking if this is the norm in UK cities is

  1. Women saying I must not be believed unless I disclose more information as though they are entitled to it.
  2. The assumptions being made about me and the men who harassed me and then using those assumptions to say I am lying. This nonsense is why so many things go unreportrd to the police. Someone even used the phrase "gullible and a liar " about people. I maybe am a bit gullible but gullible or less street smart women should still be fine to travel surely.
  3. Women accepting not being safe as a norm. For example the women who says she feels safe in cities but then has to put things in front of her hotel as though Women should have to do these things as thoigh they are normal.
  4. People being so hostile to me whilst making it about their own narrative such as politics, race or whatever. I am a deeply traumatised after two MEN related incidents. And yes I do know not all men. Maybe that's part of the problem that at home the men aroind me would never tolerate never mind engage in this shifty behaviour

Cant we just discuss if women being harassed in UK cities by men is a bigger issue on recent years and support each other as women or no?

On the safety thing for me there's a difference between keeping your purse closed/a tight grip on your phone and worries about violence/sexual violence. The first is just basic situational awareness and something I do in cities/crowded places all over the world. Yes I guess in an ideal world I wouldn't need to but I don't think just being used to being careful (something men and women need to do equally) is the same as an acceptance of sexual harassment/threatened assault as a way of life. I've noticed people conflate these things on line a lot, usually the argument starts about violence/safety figures and then it becomes about phone theft. I think phone theft is bad and obviously if small crimes are ignored it might make bigger crimes more likely. But the conflation is annoying because I think it shows an inability to engage with why harassment/sexual assault are so bad. I don't think that's what you were doing. I think of anything it comes from men online not really getting it...

I feel safer in eg London than I did in the past if anything. But I have also (in the past) experienced weird days when there are clusters of really threatening incidents. So I can completely believe you might have had that happen.

RedTagAlan · 04/11/2026 13:30

Tomikka · 04/11/2026 13:09

I can see what the benefit is to individual troublemakers on social media. But Russia?

To generate fear, disrupt, lack of confidence in government / society, cause division etc

The same goes for American Christian nationalists pushing their narratives and point of view
Russia in particular differs and is very accomplished in numerous contradictory narratives - either for confusion in all the contradictions or for the division caused through supporting extremism in opposing views

And Reform. It benefits them.

But on Russia, and authoritarian states in general, I saw this in Chinese state media today.

The ‘myth’ of Western-style democracy is losing its appeal even in the West: Global Times editorial - Global Times

It's not about any state or regime wanting to take over, it can also be for their home audience. As in, look how bad the democratic west is, but I/we care about you. We protect you from this discord.

And it is easy to do.

Note, I am not making a comment about the OP here, or this thread. Just replying to a post.

The ‘myth’ of Western-style democracy is losing its appeal even in the West: Global Times editorial - Global Times

https://www.globaltimes.cn/page/202611/1373583.shtml

JHound · 04/11/2026 13:36

Thatladdo · 04/11/2026 12:17

Theres a world of differance between someone being racist and someone noticing patterns of behaviour and being aware people from different places have different beleifs which lead them to treat women and children (the whole point of this social site) very badly by the standards that we uphold in the "west", leading them to be at greater risk than they otherwise should.

To ignore this is nothing more than idiotic, suicidal empathy at best and willful desecration of everything this nations inhabitants have worked to build and died to protect over many, many generations.

A lot of the time the “noticing patterns of behaviour” is really confirmation bias driven by people’s racism.

Not always. But often.

Apotofrealcoffee · 04/11/2026 13:37

JHound · 04/11/2026 13:36

A lot of the time the “noticing patterns of behaviour” is really confirmation bias driven by people’s racism.

Not always. But often.

Yeah, no. That won’t work anymore I’m afraid.

cryupmykingdom · 04/11/2026 13:52

RedTagAlan · 04/11/2026 13:30

And Reform. It benefits them.

But on Russia, and authoritarian states in general, I saw this in Chinese state media today.

The ‘myth’ of Western-style democracy is losing its appeal even in the West: Global Times editorial - Global Times

It's not about any state or regime wanting to take over, it can also be for their home audience. As in, look how bad the democratic west is, but I/we care about you. We protect you from this discord.

And it is easy to do.

Note, I am not making a comment about the OP here, or this thread. Just replying to a post.

Global Times is obviously likely to run with this, given who they are (!) but Pew Charitable Trusts, who funded that research, seem relatively non-controversial, at least publicly?

They focus on things from marine conservation, to massive US imprisonment rates, to critiques of police practice/police reforms to curb excessive force, to public health, to research on overdose reversal drugs and so on.

And a lot of local projects in Philadelphia, where the Pew family (Sun Oil Co. founders) are from.

YorkYapping · 04/11/2026 13:53

Persephonia1966 · 04/11/2026 13:10

On the safety thing for me there's a difference between keeping your purse closed/a tight grip on your phone and worries about violence/sexual violence. The first is just basic situational awareness and something I do in cities/crowded places all over the world. Yes I guess in an ideal world I wouldn't need to but I don't think just being used to being careful (something men and women need to do equally) is the same as an acceptance of sexual harassment/threatened assault as a way of life. I've noticed people conflate these things on line a lot, usually the argument starts about violence/safety figures and then it becomes about phone theft. I think phone theft is bad and obviously if small crimes are ignored it might make bigger crimes more likely. But the conflation is annoying because I think it shows an inability to engage with why harassment/sexual assault are so bad. I don't think that's what you were doing. I think of anything it comes from men online not really getting it...

I feel safer in eg London than I did in the past if anything. But I have also (in the past) experienced weird days when there are clusters of really threatening incidents. So I can completely believe you might have had that happen.

Exactly. Me keeping my bag and phone safe in central London is just basic safety from pickpockets and doesn’t make me feel personally threatened as such. I’m the same if I’m in Paris or Rome or New York. Feeling like I was at risk of being stabbed or raped would be a different matter.

If I lived somewhere where groups of men were staring at me and intimidating me, I would absolutely hate it and avoid the area. Luckily, that’s not happened to me and my friends in nearly 40 years of living in London.

OP if you’ve been assaulted and threatened by disgusting men, you need to report it, whatever it happened. No woman should have to deal with that.

RedTagAlan · 04/11/2026 14:12

cryupmykingdom · 04/11/2026 13:52

Global Times is obviously likely to run with this, given who they are (!) but Pew Charitable Trusts, who funded that research, seem relatively non-controversial, at least publicly?

They focus on things from marine conservation, to massive US imprisonment rates, to critiques of police practice/police reforms to curb excessive force, to public health, to research on overdose reversal drugs and so on.

And a lot of local projects in Philadelphia, where the Pew family (Sun Oil Co. founders) are from.

Edited

Yes, Pew research is pukka. But read the article. It does not link the resarch, it says "A poll released by the Pew Research Center this year shows..."

I had a look, and the Pew article appears to be this one. From Feb 2026.

As the U.S. Nears Its 250th Birthday, Dissatisfaction With Democracy Is Widespread | The Pew Charitable Trusts

Yet the Global times are writing about it now, just as the US mid terms are in the news. And very little of the Pew reseach is in the Global times article.

Note this bit in the GT article.

"According to a relevant OECD survey released this year, 68 percent of respondents believe that voting in an election has a significant or moderate influence on what government does, but only 31 percent are confident that people like them have a say in what government does"

See what the article is doing there ? See the " but only 31 percent" bit. They are switching the imortance of the percenteges.

But many people see the word Pew in the article, and automatically think the article is all factual. It's an appeal to authority fallacy in a way. It's an opinion piece, disguised as from authority.

cryupmykingdom · 04/11/2026 14:18

RedTagAlan · 04/11/2026 14:12

Yes, Pew research is pukka. But read the article. It does not link the resarch, it says "A poll released by the Pew Research Center this year shows..."

I had a look, and the Pew article appears to be this one. From Feb 2026.

As the U.S. Nears Its 250th Birthday, Dissatisfaction With Democracy Is Widespread | The Pew Charitable Trusts

Yet the Global times are writing about it now, just as the US mid terms are in the news. And very little of the Pew reseach is in the Global times article.

Note this bit in the GT article.

"According to a relevant OECD survey released this year, 68 percent of respondents believe that voting in an election has a significant or moderate influence on what government does, but only 31 percent are confident that people like them have a say in what government does"

See what the article is doing there ? See the " but only 31 percent" bit. They are switching the imortance of the percenteges.

But many people see the word Pew in the article, and automatically think the article is all factual. It's an appeal to authority fallacy in a way. It's an opinion piece, disguised as from authority.

may not link to it, but refers to it.

and as i did say to you, this is 'global times'. we all know whose mouthpiece they are ....!

Wetlegs · 04/11/2026 14:22

JHound · 04/11/2026 13:36

A lot of the time the “noticing patterns of behaviour” is really confirmation bias driven by people’s racism.

Not always. But often.

Bollocks.

Come and stay with me for a week. You’ll change you tune when you have experienced the area I live in.

P.S. I’m of Indian heritage.

AnnoyedAsAllHeck · 04/11/2026 14:38

Apotofrealcoffee · 04/11/2026 10:18

rotherham was dreadful as it shows the complete disregard for troubled young girls

Primarily it was dreadful as it showed how many men of Pakistani origin were forming groups to rape women and girls.

Hopefully, several people noted that "troubled young girls" were basically blamed for the grooming gangs. I think the poster you quoted joined "Mysogynistics United" and got elected President

RedTagAlan · 04/11/2026 15:06

cryupmykingdom · 04/11/2026 14:18

may not link to it, but refers to it.

and as i did say to you, this is 'global times'. we all know whose mouthpiece they are ....!

Yup. I am just saying that division is used to advantage by autoritarians. The Global Times article was just one I saw today.

Given that something like 17% of the worlds population mainly only have access to PRC state media, the more demos and riots in democratic countries they can report on, only makes the Parties domestic position stonger.

But the narrative in the West is more often than not that these regimes want world dominance. Not really the case. It is to help them domestically. In fact, if one looks at the global picture:

"HRF notes that according to the tracker’s current assessments, 75 percent of the world’s population lives under authoritarianism. "

Source for that :

New “Tyranny Tracker” maps the world’s authori­tarian regimes (democracywithoutborders.org)

From that, I think we can say that there are maybe more regimes in the world that want to see the experiment in democracy fail, rather than succeed. And yes, modern liberal democracy is a relativey new experiment.

Again, not directed at the OP. Just a side discussion.

New “Tyranny Tracker” maps the world’s authori­tarian regimes

A new index by Human Rights Foundation rates 179 countries as democratic, hybrid or authoritarian, using electoral competition, freedom of dissent, and institutional accountability for regime classification.

https://www.democracywithoutborders.org/40940/new-tyranny-tracker-maps-the-worlds-authoritarian-regimes/#:~:text=HRF%20notes%20that%20according%20to%20the%20tracker%E2%80%99s%20current,percent%20of%20the%20world%E2%80%99s%20population%20lives%20under%20authoritarianism.

SurferRona · 04/11/2026 15:33

Electricblankettime · 03/11/2026 21:24

Explained in post you quoted. Your category 3 by the way. Angry at me for raising the issue.

No, you haven’t explained why you aren’t naming the city, and that is hugely important.

Some cities are safer than others. They are different. And people are asking because saying yes I feel safe in city X, when you experience was in city Y 500 miles away with an entirely different population makes that answer to you to irrelevant.

Why do you need counselling? Are you particularly vulnerable because of a past experience? In which case, as a PP says you should or get help to work on your assertiveness or other strategies to manage your response.

Your woolly replies and vague suggestions hinting at awful things alongside your aggressive defensiveness and weaponised feminist rhetoric doesn’t help either.

That is why people think you are a propagandist for either Putin or more likely homegrown racist right wingers.

I am in the South and feel safe day and night on my own in all cities near me.

Electricblankettime · 04/11/2026 15:55

SurferRona · 04/11/2026 15:33

No, you haven’t explained why you aren’t naming the city, and that is hugely important.

Some cities are safer than others. They are different. And people are asking because saying yes I feel safe in city X, when you experience was in city Y 500 miles away with an entirely different population makes that answer to you to irrelevant.

Why do you need counselling? Are you particularly vulnerable because of a past experience? In which case, as a PP says you should or get help to work on your assertiveness or other strategies to manage your response.

Your woolly replies and vague suggestions hinting at awful things alongside your aggressive defensiveness and weaponised feminist rhetoric doesn’t help either.

That is why people think you are a propagandist for either Putin or more likely homegrown racist right wingers.

I am in the South and feel safe day and night on my own in all cities near me.

I need counselling as I had two traumatic experiences with men in 24 hours. None of these things and my reaction and feelings about what happened are my fault for being vulnerable, weak or lacking assertion but thanks for being persistent and confused why I wouldn't want to share more with victim blaming attitudes like yours. Im not even going to respond to all this Russian, far right crap as I havent alluded to any of that and the fact your so obsessed with it to the point you would tell a traumatised women she must have made her experiences up because of a country she is not from and has no links to is insane. Would you stand outside a rape crisis centre to shout at the women that they are all lying because "Russia".? Choose not to believe me I don't care and 2ont engage with you or anyone else that says it's a Russian or far right thing as its quite simply a load of shite

OP posts:
Notonmyland · 04/11/2026 15:56

BBC Manchester News: right now. Sounds fun.

More arrests in £1m university fraud investigation
The arrests are part of a "complex investigation" into the University of Greater Manchester, police say.

Posted
3 hours ago3h

Two held after boy, 16, stabbed at party
Attribution
Manchester

Group of 60 attacked pub with fireworks, landlady says
Attribution
Manchester

'Floating tractors' clean up weed-choked waterways
Attribution
Manchester

Trial of nine men hears husband who raped unconscious wife tried to drug her food and drink
Attribution
Manchester

Two killed in van crash on country lane
Attribution
Manchester

A blue police banner saying Do Not Cross in blue letters on a white background. The background is grey and blurred.
Ryanair passenger says bomb threat was 'traumatic'
Attribution
Manchester

RedTagAlan · 04/11/2026 16:07

Electricblankettime · 04/11/2026 15:55

I need counselling as I had two traumatic experiences with men in 24 hours. None of these things and my reaction and feelings about what happened are my fault for being vulnerable, weak or lacking assertion but thanks for being persistent and confused why I wouldn't want to share more with victim blaming attitudes like yours. Im not even going to respond to all this Russian, far right crap as I havent alluded to any of that and the fact your so obsessed with it to the point you would tell a traumatised women she must have made her experiences up because of a country she is not from and has no links to is insane. Would you stand outside a rape crisis centre to shout at the women that they are all lying because "Russia".? Choose not to believe me I don't care and 2ont engage with you or anyone else that says it's a Russian or far right thing as its quite simply a load of shite

This is your opening post.

"I live in a small town and love the countryside life. Recentlhly had to go to a big city. Groups of men hanging around staring like thry had never seen a woman before were intimidating so overly persistent men approaching and following felt terrifying. Men pestering when minding my own business and scaring me.
I thought it was a one of freak thing but when discussing with other women they have said thars just what its like now. I feel very naive as where I live I can go anywhere at any hour and feel safe. When did the world change? Ive travelled worldwide and aa a solo female plenty and never had problems like this. Not been into a city for years and it feels so different.
Do other women feel safety in cities has changed o was I just unlucky?"

Now you are saying "I need counselling as I had two traumatic experiences with men in 24 hours."

I think before you accuse people of victim blaming, can you confirm if these are related to the same incident, or are you conflating ?

You said you felt unsafe And asked for experiences. Then when most posters replied that they did not feel unsafe, it somehow elevated to "I had two traumatic experiences with men in 24 hours."

I think it is only fair to ask if the latter is the former. Are you getting counselling now because of what you described in your first post ?

I think that is a fair question. Do you agree it is a fair question ?

cryupmykingdom · 04/11/2026 16:15

>Given that something like 17% of the worlds population mainly only have >access to PRC state media, the more demos and riots in democratic countries >they can report on, only makes the Parties domestic position stonger

They really don't. When it comes to Weixin/WeChat and a bunch of other Chinese social media, added to the stories-gone-viral fed back to home, by Chinese travelling overseas, they have access to lots of world news.

In fact, Chinese takes on international news are well worth accessing, as they really make you think, and lots of the commentary is not just rude, it's side-splittingly funny.

Electricblankettime · 04/11/2026 16:16

RedTagAlan · 04/11/2026 16:07

This is your opening post.

"I live in a small town and love the countryside life. Recentlhly had to go to a big city. Groups of men hanging around staring like thry had never seen a woman before were intimidating so overly persistent men approaching and following felt terrifying. Men pestering when minding my own business and scaring me.
I thought it was a one of freak thing but when discussing with other women they have said thars just what its like now. I feel very naive as where I live I can go anywhere at any hour and feel safe. When did the world change? Ive travelled worldwide and aa a solo female plenty and never had problems like this. Not been into a city for years and it feels so different.
Do other women feel safety in cities has changed o was I just unlucky?"

Now you are saying "I need counselling as I had two traumatic experiences with men in 24 hours."

I think before you accuse people of victim blaming, can you confirm if these are related to the same incident, or are you conflating ?

You said you felt unsafe And asked for experiences. Then when most posters replied that they did not feel unsafe, it somehow elevated to "I had two traumatic experiences with men in 24 hours."

I think it is only fair to ask if the latter is the former. Are you getting counselling now because of what you described in your first post ?

I think that is a fair question. Do you agree it is a fair question ?

If you read my posts I went into more detail. Its simply not true most women said they felt safe. Actually most posters initially accused me of being a Russian bot which made no sense to me. I think some responses were so nuts they were removed and the post was closed for a while. Love the telling a woman her experiences didn't happen though. Hope that works for you

OP posts:
JuliaAgrippina · 04/11/2026 16:20

Notonmyland · 04/11/2026 15:56

BBC Manchester News: right now. Sounds fun.

More arrests in £1m university fraud investigation
The arrests are part of a "complex investigation" into the University of Greater Manchester, police say.

Posted
3 hours ago3h

Two held after boy, 16, stabbed at party
Attribution
Manchester

Group of 60 attacked pub with fireworks, landlady says
Attribution
Manchester

'Floating tractors' clean up weed-choked waterways
Attribution
Manchester

Trial of nine men hears husband who raped unconscious wife tried to drug her food and drink
Attribution
Manchester

Two killed in van crash on country lane
Attribution
Manchester

A blue police banner saying Do Not Cross in blue letters on a white background. The background is grey and blurred.
Ryanair passenger says bomb threat was 'traumatic'
Attribution
Manchester

I think all cities have some crime.

We were in Manchester - used to live there - this summer doing art galleries and msusums so round uni area - oxford road - and city center. It did feel run down in some back streets and through old umist campus which been shut down to what it used to be but didn't feel unsafe.

The only large group of people hanging around were LGBT group meeting to commerate some event and they were lovely and friendly to us.

Our city center can feel dodgey at times - but when police are out and rare occaions it's busy it really doesn't.

As Op seems to be having a hard time generally it could be perception combined with bad luck, a rougher city than most and a bad time.

Electricblankettime · 04/11/2026 16:20

RedTagAlan · 04/11/2026 16:07

This is your opening post.

"I live in a small town and love the countryside life. Recentlhly had to go to a big city. Groups of men hanging around staring like thry had never seen a woman before were intimidating so overly persistent men approaching and following felt terrifying. Men pestering when minding my own business and scaring me.
I thought it was a one of freak thing but when discussing with other women they have said thars just what its like now. I feel very naive as where I live I can go anywhere at any hour and feel safe. When did the world change? Ive travelled worldwide and aa a solo female plenty and never had problems like this. Not been into a city for years and it feels so different.
Do other women feel safety in cities has changed o was I just unlucky?"

Now you are saying "I need counselling as I had two traumatic experiences with men in 24 hours."

I think before you accuse people of victim blaming, can you confirm if these are related to the same incident, or are you conflating ?

You said you felt unsafe And asked for experiences. Then when most posters replied that they did not feel unsafe, it somehow elevated to "I had two traumatic experiences with men in 24 hours."

I think it is only fair to ask if the latter is the former. Are you getting counselling now because of what you described in your first post ?

I think that is a fair question. Do you agree it is a fair question ?

I do agree alot of women have said that they feel safe in London though. Thst was good to hear

OP posts:
RedTagAlan · 04/11/2026 16:28

Electricblankettime · 04/11/2026 16:20

I do agree alot of women have said that they feel safe in London though. Thst was good to hear

So is your counselling for "two traumatic experiences with men in 24 hours." because of the incident you mentioned in your opening post ?

That is all I asked. And if you answer that, then maybe the thread might be in a better informed position to help.