Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Would you kill 10000 people to save the person you love most?

537 replies

CurdinHenry · 05/10/2026 19:12

Context -

You would just have to press a button and you wouldn't have to see it happen

You would be guaranteed not to know any of them beforehand

No one would know it was you unless you confessed

Yanbu yes
Yabu no

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
Fishwife2 · 04/11/2026 19:37

OtterlyAstounding · 04/11/2026 19:18

I'm sure, in this hypothetical, your self-righteousness over morals and values will be a great comfort to you when you've actively chosen to (unnecessarily) let your children die. I'm sure they'd appreciate that you valued your morals over their lives too, except that they'd be dead, so...

What is self righteous about not opting to kill 10,000 people. Scary that people like you actually exist.

Wetlegs · 04/11/2026 19:38

SuperMaria · 04/11/2026 19:27

Simply pressing a button is one thing. You’re not confronted with the reality, plenty of people would do that because you disassociate from it.

IMO anyone saying they’d do ‘anything’, including killing (or worse?) to other people’s children, ridiculous and dishonest at best, and a bit scary if they’re being sincere.

Honestly, I think if I was ever in a situation where I had to kill anyone for my child to live, I would. Of course I would. Instinct to protect your child’s life would take over.

There was a story my grandmother told me about one of her friends when they were young.

Thr village in Hertfordshire where they lived was bombed during the war. Her friend was a childminder. Her only thought was to grab her own two children over the others. She got them to safety without a thought for the other children in her care (no one died). But she left them. Her only thought was for her own sons. She was racked with guilt and only told my grandmother the truth.

No matter how much people talk about morals, your instincts can’t be overridden. Of course if it came down to it, most people would indeed to anything for their children. Including killing someone in cold blood.

FriggadyDiggady · 04/11/2026 21:11

OtterlyAstounding · 04/11/2026 19:11

There aren't 10,000 people in my town, I don't know anyone in my town beyond a passing greeting, and that would take quite a long time if you had to do it personally.

I'm not 'kill happy', I just value my children's lives more than anyone else's. And no, I'm not sure there's a line I wouldn't cross if my children never found out. It would probably ruin me, but if I could save their lives then I couldn't do anything else. I'm surprised that others would just choose to let their children die (in effect, choosing to kill them).

OK, so you'd, let's say, personally do the holocaust again to save your children. Great.
What about other things? If your child was disfigured, would you torture mine to death to remove the disfigurement?

OtterlyAstounding · 04/11/2026 21:21

FriggadyDiggady · 04/11/2026 21:11

OK, so you'd, let's say, personally do the holocaust again to save your children. Great.
What about other things? If your child was disfigured, would you torture mine to death to remove the disfigurement?

Look, if you're hypothetically happy to let your child die to save strangers' lives, that's your look out – but I doubt that you wouldn’t push the button when it came down to it.

InterIgnis · 04/11/2026 21:21

FriggadyDiggady · 04/11/2026 16:54

You've accused me of making other people's trauma about me. No-one actually said that they have trauma; you, InterIgnis, defender of the right to kill, are the one who has intuited trauma.
If the hypothetical means this much to you, perhaps you should <deep breath> go to therapy?

Ah, and I’m also not the one inventing new and more extreme scenarios to get outraged about. Lol.

The PP gave the strong impression that her answer was based on what she is currently experiencing. If said suspicion is correct, I don’t think it’s unreasonable to consider that being in such a position would be traumatic. Your response? “But what about my child?!”.

‘Rights’ don’t come into it. If you ask someone to sacrifice others to save their own, then a significant proportion would do just that regardless of whether or not they have the legal right to do so. It is what it is.

FriggadyDiggady · 04/11/2026 21:30

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

OtterlyAstounding · 04/11/2026 21:40

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

It's interesting to me how overwrought you're getting over a hypothetical, coming up with ever more unrelated and extreme scenarios. Why is that?

FriggadyDiggady · 04/11/2026 21:43

OtterlyAstounding · 04/11/2026 21:40

It's interesting to me how overwrought you're getting over a hypothetical, coming up with ever more unrelated and extreme scenarios. Why is that?

Why do you think it might be?
(I note that you still don't answer)

OtterlyAstounding · 04/11/2026 21:48

FriggadyDiggady · 04/11/2026 21:43

Why do you think it might be?
(I note that you still don't answer)

I think it's because you would push the button, but don’t want to admit that you would.

And my children wouldn’t be expelled from school, but if they were, injuring someone over it is hilariously disproportionate. I also can’t imagine, given the people they are, that they would rape anyone – but if they did, I'd fully support them being convicted and imprisoned for it. And if they were innocent of any wrongdoing and their life hung in the balance, I would rather kill strangers than deliberately choose to let them to die.

FriggadyDiggady · 04/11/2026 21:54

OtterlyAstounding · 04/11/2026 21:48

I think it's because you would push the button, but don’t want to admit that you would.

And my children wouldn’t be expelled from school, but if they were, injuring someone over it is hilariously disproportionate. I also can’t imagine, given the people they are, that they would rape anyone – but if they did, I'd fully support them being convicted and imprisoned for it. And if they were innocent of any wrongdoing and their life hung in the balance, I would rather kill strangers than deliberately choose to let them to die.

Thanks for answering, but it just demonstrates how inconsistent you are.
Is injuring someone over a school place any more "hilariously disproportionate" than doing literally anything to prevent your kid dying (e.g. killing the entire population of the earth or something)? I don't think so.
Also, is their guilt or innocence relevant? Maybe a bit more complicated, but again I don't think so - in both scenarios (pressing the button or covering up your kid's misdeeds you are promoting a great injustice).

OtterlyAstounding · 04/11/2026 22:01

FriggadyDiggady · 04/11/2026 21:54

Thanks for answering, but it just demonstrates how inconsistent you are.
Is injuring someone over a school place any more "hilariously disproportionate" than doing literally anything to prevent your kid dying (e.g. killing the entire population of the earth or something)? I don't think so.
Also, is their guilt or innocence relevant? Maybe a bit more complicated, but again I don't think so - in both scenarios (pressing the button or covering up your kid's misdeeds you are promoting a great injustice).

No, I'm not inconsistent. I would do whatever it took to prevent my child dying through no fault of their own, if they didn't bear the burden of my actions, but I wouldn’t do it to shield my children from the natural consequences of their own actions.

chattyness · 04/11/2026 23:24

This reply has been withdrawn

Post withdrawn at author's request

FriggadyDiggady · 05/11/2026 00:14

OtterlyAstounding · 04/11/2026 22:01

No, I'm not inconsistent. I would do whatever it took to prevent my child dying through no fault of their own, if they didn't bear the burden of my actions, but I wouldn’t do it to shield my children from the natural consequences of their own actions.

You are - I've explained why but you don't want to see it.

Fishwife2 · 05/11/2026 08:12

I know this is hypothetical, but it also explains why so many people looked away during the Holocaust. Didn’t shield a Jewish family in their home etc. They were protecting themselves and their family. I think none of us knows who we would have been back then. I like to know I would have been one of the people standing up against the nazis even if it put me and my family in danger, but I don’t know of course.

Goatsarebest · 05/11/2026 08:39

CurdinHenry · 05/10/2026 19:12

Context -

You would just have to press a button and you wouldn't have to see it happen

You would be guaranteed not to know any of them beforehand

No one would know it was you unless you confessed

Yanbu yes
Yabu no

Like sort of put them in a big sealed building and press a button that releases gas to kill them all, are you talking about that sort of thing.

Goatsarebest · 05/11/2026 08:44

58 percent of reasonable and rational people on this thread would kill 10000 people if you can convince them those people were a threat to their loved ones and they wouldn't be held accountable.
Well that explains history.

Fishwife2 · 05/11/2026 09:04

Goatsarebest · 05/11/2026 08:44

58 percent of reasonable and rational people on this thread would kill 10000 people if you can convince them those people were a threat to their loved ones and they wouldn't be held accountable.
Well that explains history.

Exactly what I just posted. The Holocaust summed up.

Wetlegs · 05/11/2026 10:01

This reply has been deleted

Post withdrawn at author's request

I think most people who read your post will have had the empathy to understand that you must be going through something horrendous. Anyone who couldn’t see that was obviously not brought up with kindness, empathy and compassion.

I hope you are okay x

EstoyRobandoSuCasa · 05/11/2026 11:35

Fishwife2 · 05/11/2026 08:12

I know this is hypothetical, but it also explains why so many people looked away during the Holocaust. Didn’t shield a Jewish family in their home etc. They were protecting themselves and their family. I think none of us knows who we would have been back then. I like to know I would have been one of the people standing up against the nazis even if it put me and my family in danger, but I don’t know of course.

If I were in Poland, I wouldn’t have dared to shelter a Jewish person. The penalty would have been death, not just for me, but for all my immediate family as well.

I hope I would have taken the risk of helping if I were in one of the countries where the penalties weren’t so harsh.

Fishwife2 · 05/11/2026 11:55

EstoyRobandoSuCasa · 05/11/2026 11:35

If I were in Poland, I wouldn’t have dared to shelter a Jewish person. The penalty would have been death, not just for me, but for all my immediate family as well.

I hope I would have taken the risk of helping if I were in one of the countries where the penalties weren’t so harsh.

There is a really good museum in Warsaw. I think it’s called the Jewish history museum. It has a room with the history of different people during the war. It also includes people who didn’t help. I can’t remember the details as I went there years back, but it really made me wonder who I would have been back then. I can say who I would wish to be. The one who helped.

FriggadyDiggady · 05/11/2026 12:06

EstoyRobandoSuCasa · 05/11/2026 11:35

If I were in Poland, I wouldn’t have dared to shelter a Jewish person. The penalty would have been death, not just for me, but for all my immediate family as well.

I hope I would have taken the risk of helping if I were in one of the countries where the penalties weren’t so harsh.

And yet people did shelter Jews in Poland. That means that those people are better then you (and me). That's OK! Most people aren't paragons (myself included).
The reason I find this thread so objectionable is posters' failure to imagine that someone could have superior moral values to them. The pro-killers insist that everyone is the same as them, but this isn't the case. They want to preserve their sanctimony, but still allow for selfishness.

EstoyRobandoSuCasa · 05/11/2026 13:44

FriggadyDiggady · 05/11/2026 12:06

And yet people did shelter Jews in Poland. That means that those people are better then you (and me). That's OK! Most people aren't paragons (myself included).
The reason I find this thread so objectionable is posters' failure to imagine that someone could have superior moral values to them. The pro-killers insist that everyone is the same as them, but this isn't the case. They want to preserve their sanctimony, but still allow for selfishness.

Edited

I'm happy to accept they were better than me. They were undoubtably much braver.

However, I don't think everyone would agree that they did the right thing. A Polish woman once talked about a local execution she was forced to watch in WW2 - that of a Jewish couple and their toddler, plus the Gentile family (parents and two young children), who were caught sheltering them. Seven people died in a doomed attempt to save three.

FriggadyDiggady · 05/11/2026 14:12

EstoyRobandoSuCasa · 05/11/2026 13:44

I'm happy to accept they were better than me. They were undoubtably much braver.

However, I don't think everyone would agree that they did the right thing. A Polish woman once talked about a local execution she was forced to watch in WW2 - that of a Jewish couple and their toddler, plus the Gentile family (parents and two young children), who were caught sheltering them. Seven people died in a doomed attempt to save three.

If this helps you cope with it, fine. It's easier to just accept that you aren't very good, morally speaking.

Fishwife2 · 05/11/2026 14:12

EstoyRobandoSuCasa · 05/11/2026 13:44

I'm happy to accept they were better than me. They were undoubtably much braver.

However, I don't think everyone would agree that they did the right thing. A Polish woman once talked about a local execution she was forced to watch in WW2 - that of a Jewish couple and their toddler, plus the Gentile family (parents and two young children), who were caught sheltering them. Seven people died in a doomed attempt to save three.

I would still say they did the right thing. It’s people like them who give me hope for humanity.

AbraCaStabYa · 05/11/2026 21:09

Does the one you love most include pets? Then yes, absolutely.