Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Would you kill 10000 people to save the person you love most?

537 replies

CurdinHenry · 05/10/2026 19:12

Context -

You would just have to press a button and you wouldn't have to see it happen

You would be guaranteed not to know any of them beforehand

No one would know it was you unless you confessed

Yanbu yes
Yabu no

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Thread gallery
5
FriggadyDiggady · 09/11/2026 17:00

InterIgnis · 09/11/2026 15:47

Why would she be fine with that, when it’s her kid you’ve killed to get it? The key point here is being fine with something that benefits you in a specific and highly unusual situation, divorced from the framework of general societal and moral principles.

In that instance the law benefits her, as it benefits all would-be victims of a kidney heist. In a situation where her kid needed a kidney, then she’d presumably be quite prepared to break the law if it meant saving her child.

I am seeing people on this thread saying that it is right to do anything for your child.
I am taking "right" to mean morally right.
My silly example about the kidney is supposed to demonstrate that if an individual is willing to do literally anything for their child, this means they are willing to do acts that they would consider immoral for their child.

I thought this was fairly simple but posters seem to be having difficulty with it. I think it's because they are uncomfortable with the fact that they may not be the moral paragon that they thought they were.
I don't judge anyone for this.

InterIgnis · 09/11/2026 15:47

FriggadyDiggady · 09/11/2026 13:06

Yes, but presumably you don't think that should be a general moral or legal rule. E.g. if my kid needs a kidney transplant and I murder your kid to get it, I've done something legally and morally wrong. Or maybe you would be fine with that?

Why would she be fine with that, when it’s her kid you’ve killed to get it? The key point here is being fine with something that benefits you in a specific and highly unusual situation, divorced from the framework of general societal and moral principles.

In that instance the law benefits her, as it benefits all would-be victims of a kidney heist. In a situation where her kid needed a kidney, then she’d presumably be quite prepared to break the law if it meant saving her child.

Fishwife2 · 09/11/2026 15:14

HappyLizard23 · 09/11/2026 13:08

You’re being inflammatory for no reason. Of course your example is inappropriate and no sane person would agree.

I don’t see the difference between murdering someone do your child can get a new kidney or murdering 10,000 people so your child can survive. Can someone explain that one to me? In the second example, 10,000 people die, yet no sane person would murder 1 persona for a kidney? Even I can say that I might murder someone for a kidney. Like an old person perhaps.

CanadaNotAMum · 09/11/2026 14:51

BorgQueen · 05/10/2026 19:25

Absolutely. There are 3 people I would kill or die for.
I’d put a bullet in peoples’ heads myself if I had to, no qualms at all.

Even if these people had done nothing wrong? You would committ mass murder? I understand being willing to die for your kids, and understand killing to physically defend them. But murdering innocent people, including (presumably) other people's kids?

I don't have kids, but judging from the thread, there are many who do who wouldn't cross that line. It is interesting though.

FriggadyDiggady · 09/11/2026 13:22

HappyLizard23 · 09/11/2026 13:08

You’re being inflammatory for no reason. Of course your example is inappropriate and no sane person would agree.

No, I wanted you to think about what you had written. You don't believe that it's right to do anything for one's child.
That's OK - but I think we have to say that we'd do bad and selfish things for our children, no?

WhyStopThere · 09/11/2026 13:09

No

HappyLizard23 · 09/11/2026 13:08

FriggadyDiggady · 09/11/2026 13:06

Yes, but presumably you don't think that should be a general moral or legal rule. E.g. if my kid needs a kidney transplant and I murder your kid to get it, I've done something legally and morally wrong. Or maybe you would be fine with that?

You’re being inflammatory for no reason. Of course your example is inappropriate and no sane person would agree.

FriggadyDiggady · 09/11/2026 13:06

HappyLizard23 · 09/11/2026 12:55

For me the right thing is often what benefits me and my loved ones the most. I’d do anything to save them.

Yes, but presumably you don't think that should be a general moral or legal rule. E.g. if my kid needs a kidney transplant and I murder your kid to get it, I've done something legally and morally wrong. Or maybe you would be fine with that?

HappyLizard23 · 09/11/2026 12:55

FriggadyDiggady · 05/11/2026 23:17

No, you don't understand the rules. Apparently round here, the "right thing" is the thing which benefits you the most.

For me the right thing is often what benefits me and my loved ones the most. I’d do anything to save them.

FriggadyDiggady · 05/11/2026 23:17

Fishwife2 · 05/11/2026 14:12

I would still say they did the right thing. It’s people like them who give me hope for humanity.

No, you don't understand the rules. Apparently round here, the "right thing" is the thing which benefits you the most.

OtterlyAstounding · 05/11/2026 23:10

EstoyRobandoSuCasa · 05/11/2026 11:35

If I were in Poland, I wouldn’t have dared to shelter a Jewish person. The penalty would have been death, not just for me, but for all my immediate family as well.

I hope I would have taken the risk of helping if I were in one of the countries where the penalties weren’t so harsh.

I like to believe that I would have if I didn't have children and it was just me, or just me and my husband, as I've never been afraid to speak out for others throughout my life even when I knew it would impact me negatively (although obviously, the stakes are immensely higher).

But as a parent, I wouldn't, as it would be hugely irresponsible to endanger my children in that way, when they depend on me to keep them safe.

EstoyRobandoSuCasa · 05/11/2026 21:43

FriggadyDiggady · 05/11/2026 14:12

If this helps you cope with it, fine. It's easier to just accept that you aren't very good, morally speaking.

I think that's a bit harsh. Risking your own life to try and save someone else is selfless. But risking the lives of children who are too young to understand or consent isn't quite the same.

AbraCaStabYa · 05/11/2026 21:09

Does the one you love most include pets? Then yes, absolutely.

Fishwife2 · 05/11/2026 14:12

EstoyRobandoSuCasa · 05/11/2026 13:44

I'm happy to accept they were better than me. They were undoubtably much braver.

However, I don't think everyone would agree that they did the right thing. A Polish woman once talked about a local execution she was forced to watch in WW2 - that of a Jewish couple and their toddler, plus the Gentile family (parents and two young children), who were caught sheltering them. Seven people died in a doomed attempt to save three.

I would still say they did the right thing. It’s people like them who give me hope for humanity.

FriggadyDiggady · 05/11/2026 14:12

EstoyRobandoSuCasa · 05/11/2026 13:44

I'm happy to accept they were better than me. They were undoubtably much braver.

However, I don't think everyone would agree that they did the right thing. A Polish woman once talked about a local execution she was forced to watch in WW2 - that of a Jewish couple and their toddler, plus the Gentile family (parents and two young children), who were caught sheltering them. Seven people died in a doomed attempt to save three.

If this helps you cope with it, fine. It's easier to just accept that you aren't very good, morally speaking.

EstoyRobandoSuCasa · 05/11/2026 13:44

FriggadyDiggady · 05/11/2026 12:06

And yet people did shelter Jews in Poland. That means that those people are better then you (and me). That's OK! Most people aren't paragons (myself included).
The reason I find this thread so objectionable is posters' failure to imagine that someone could have superior moral values to them. The pro-killers insist that everyone is the same as them, but this isn't the case. They want to preserve their sanctimony, but still allow for selfishness.

Edited

I'm happy to accept they were better than me. They were undoubtably much braver.

However, I don't think everyone would agree that they did the right thing. A Polish woman once talked about a local execution she was forced to watch in WW2 - that of a Jewish couple and their toddler, plus the Gentile family (parents and two young children), who were caught sheltering them. Seven people died in a doomed attempt to save three.

FriggadyDiggady · 05/11/2026 12:06

EstoyRobandoSuCasa · 05/11/2026 11:35

If I were in Poland, I wouldn’t have dared to shelter a Jewish person. The penalty would have been death, not just for me, but for all my immediate family as well.

I hope I would have taken the risk of helping if I were in one of the countries where the penalties weren’t so harsh.

And yet people did shelter Jews in Poland. That means that those people are better then you (and me). That's OK! Most people aren't paragons (myself included).
The reason I find this thread so objectionable is posters' failure to imagine that someone could have superior moral values to them. The pro-killers insist that everyone is the same as them, but this isn't the case. They want to preserve their sanctimony, but still allow for selfishness.

Fishwife2 · 05/11/2026 11:55

EstoyRobandoSuCasa · 05/11/2026 11:35

If I were in Poland, I wouldn’t have dared to shelter a Jewish person. The penalty would have been death, not just for me, but for all my immediate family as well.

I hope I would have taken the risk of helping if I were in one of the countries where the penalties weren’t so harsh.

There is a really good museum in Warsaw. I think it’s called the Jewish history museum. It has a room with the history of different people during the war. It also includes people who didn’t help. I can’t remember the details as I went there years back, but it really made me wonder who I would have been back then. I can say who I would wish to be. The one who helped.

EstoyRobandoSuCasa · 05/11/2026 11:35

Fishwife2 · 05/11/2026 08:12

I know this is hypothetical, but it also explains why so many people looked away during the Holocaust. Didn’t shield a Jewish family in their home etc. They were protecting themselves and their family. I think none of us knows who we would have been back then. I like to know I would have been one of the people standing up against the nazis even if it put me and my family in danger, but I don’t know of course.

If I were in Poland, I wouldn’t have dared to shelter a Jewish person. The penalty would have been death, not just for me, but for all my immediate family as well.

I hope I would have taken the risk of helping if I were in one of the countries where the penalties weren’t so harsh.

Wetlegs · 05/11/2026 10:01

This reply has been deleted

Post withdrawn at author's request

I think most people who read your post will have had the empathy to understand that you must be going through something horrendous. Anyone who couldn’t see that was obviously not brought up with kindness, empathy and compassion.

I hope you are okay x

Fishwife2 · 05/11/2026 09:04

Goatsarebest · 05/11/2026 08:44

58 percent of reasonable and rational people on this thread would kill 10000 people if you can convince them those people were a threat to their loved ones and they wouldn't be held accountable.
Well that explains history.

Exactly what I just posted. The Holocaust summed up.

Goatsarebest · 05/11/2026 08:44

58 percent of reasonable and rational people on this thread would kill 10000 people if you can convince them those people were a threat to their loved ones and they wouldn't be held accountable.
Well that explains history.

Goatsarebest · 05/11/2026 08:39

CurdinHenry · 05/10/2026 19:12

Context -

You would just have to press a button and you wouldn't have to see it happen

You would be guaranteed not to know any of them beforehand

No one would know it was you unless you confessed

Yanbu yes
Yabu no

Like sort of put them in a big sealed building and press a button that releases gas to kill them all, are you talking about that sort of thing.

Fishwife2 · 05/11/2026 08:12

I know this is hypothetical, but it also explains why so many people looked away during the Holocaust. Didn’t shield a Jewish family in their home etc. They were protecting themselves and their family. I think none of us knows who we would have been back then. I like to know I would have been one of the people standing up against the nazis even if it put me and my family in danger, but I don’t know of course.

FriggadyDiggady · 05/11/2026 00:14

OtterlyAstounding · 04/11/2026 22:01

No, I'm not inconsistent. I would do whatever it took to prevent my child dying through no fault of their own, if they didn't bear the burden of my actions, but I wouldn’t do it to shield my children from the natural consequences of their own actions.

You are - I've explained why but you don't want to see it.