Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Child maintenance q

61 replies

Whatatodo79 · 12/03/2024 18:28

My 1st marriage broke down during IVF and my wife was pregnant with donor sperm at the time. In fact she wouldn't tell me if she was or wasn't pregnant for several weeks but our marriage was just fractured all round by the time she did tell me (she'd banned me from appointments for a couple of weeks). She had moved in with a new partner (a longstanding 'friend', who i think is quite well off, a solicitor i am told) by the time the child was born. I have been paying child maintenance as I was obliged to by the rules around IVF and accepting donor sperm as a married couple, and I didn't want more fighting, but am not named on the birth certificate and she was clear she would go to court if I tried to exert any parental rights. I have never met the child and don't have any feeling that I am a parent to them, i view the child maintaince as just some sort of tax on a previous bad marriage

nearly 10 years on i now have my own son with a new partner, which was a wonderful suprise. We are struggling for cash with only one of us working now - i think i can probably make an argument to pay less child maintenance, but i know that is judged on my income not our whole household income? As the situation is a bit unusual i don't want to make any more mistakes here

aibu i should just continue to pay the same

ainbu and maybe should ask a solicitor to do some calculations?

OP posts:
Chocolatebuttonns · 12/03/2024 19:29

TeaKitten · 12/03/2024 19:11

So if for example they agreed to do donor sperm IVF as a happily married couple, and he then turned into an abusive idiot and the mum had to ban all contact and seek legal advice as a result, do you still think he should never have to pay because they bought sperm rather than using his own?

(This is just an example, I’m not saying he’s abusive, male, or in the wrong, just an example for those assuming poor OP has done nothing wrong and is trapped paying through no fault of their own).

Er no because that wouldn't be a mutual decision and Is also a wildly different situation?

MyGooseisTotallyLoose · 12/03/2024 19:26

PlumbersWifey · 12/03/2024 18:48

Tell her you want your name on the birth certificate. She will highly likely say she wants nothing to do with you and will stop maintenance to make you disappear. Heck, you may even find she's said you disappeared and she's put the other guys name on the birth certificate.

This, what was the time frame of getting pregnant/leaving you/moving in with new man? Could he actually be the father?

Dartmoorcheffy · 12/03/2024 19:14

I'm guessing the op here could be female.

TeaKitten · 12/03/2024 19:11

Chocolatebuttonns · 12/03/2024 19:04

But this simply wouldn't happen in an adoption scenario.

No you can't become a parent on the proviso you stay together. You become a parent on the proviso you remain one.

Which hasn't happened has it? This was not the agreement.

So if for example they agreed to do donor sperm IVF as a happily married couple, and he then turned into an abusive idiot and the mum had to ban all contact and seek legal advice as a result, do you still think he should never have to pay because they bought sperm rather than using his own?

(This is just an example, I’m not saying he’s abusive, male, or in the wrong, just an example for those assuming poor OP has done nothing wrong and is trapped paying through no fault of their own).

Chocolatebuttonns · 12/03/2024 19:04

SecondHandFurniture · 12/03/2024 19:02

You said this:

"On what basis? That they "agreed" ? Presumably they agreed based on the fact they were together, if that changes doesn't it change rights as well?"

That's why I used the adoption scenario. You can't become a parent on the proviso that you stay together.

To be honest I don't know how she managed to keep OP off the birth certificate.

Edited

But this simply wouldn't happen in an adoption scenario.

No you can't become a parent on the proviso you stay together. You become a parent on the proviso you remain one.

Which hasn't happened has it? This was not the agreement.

SecondHandFurniture · 12/03/2024 19:02

Chocolatebuttonns · 12/03/2024 18:50

An adoption wouldn't ever have got through in this scenario would it?

He's not "washing his hands" of them he's asking if he should reduce it but considering he has nothing to do with the child and mum has told him the same... why can't he walk away? That's what they both seem to want, except tye ex is accepting his money?

You said this:

"On what basis? That they "agreed" ? Presumably they agreed based on the fact they were together, if that changes doesn't it change rights as well?"

That's why I used the adoption scenario. You can't become a parent on the proviso that you stay together.

To be honest I don't know how she managed to keep OP off the birth certificate.

SecondHandFurniture · 12/03/2024 18:59

DancefloorAcrobatics · 12/03/2024 18:53

@SecondHandFurniture
He is the parent, according to the courts, so yes. If you knowingly consent to IVF and you are married, you are the legal second parent. At the time of conception the mother was, on paper, agreeing to parent this child with her husband

is there a court case/ law backing this up?
Just very curious...

https://kiddspoorlaw.co.uk/parental-responsibility-and-assisted-conception-via-ivf-or-a-donor/

"Who has parental responsibility after sperm donation?

If conception has been achieved with sperm from a donor, the position will depend on whether this happened in an HFEA licensed clinic, at an unlicensed clinic or informally.

If you gave birth to the child, you will be regarded as the legal mother and have parental responsibility, regardless that you have used a sperm donor.

Sperm donation in an HFEA licensed clinic

  • if you are the married spouse or civil partner, you will have parental responsibility so long as you provide consent;"

I suppose I'm making an assumption an HFEA agreement was signed.

Parental responsibility and assisted conception via IVF or a donor - Kidd & Spoor Law

Nearly 60,000 people benefit from invitro fertilisation (IVF) and donor insemination at HFEA licensed fertility clinics in the UK, and it is not uncommon for an unlicensed clinic or ‘at home’ informal arrangement to be used for sperm donation. While th...

https://kiddspoorlaw.co.uk/parental-responsibility-and-assisted-conception-via-ivf-or-a-donor

DancefloorAcrobatics · 12/03/2024 18:53

@SecondHandFurniture
He is the parent, according to the courts, so yes. If you knowingly consent to IVF and you are married, you are the legal second parent. At the time of conception the mother was, on paper, agreeing to parent this child with her husband

is there a court case/ law backing this up?
Just very curious...

theplanner24 · 12/03/2024 18:53

Navyblueblazer · 12/03/2024 18:34

What about the fact that he isn't on the birth certificate, has no biological link to the child and has never met him? Does that not change circumstances?

Nope

They were married at the time of conception therefore whether he is on the birth certificate or not the law considers him the father

Mummame222 · 12/03/2024 18:52

GwinGwyn · 12/03/2024 18:51

No I wouldn’t. I would be saying the exact same thing as I’ve said already. If there is another child in the equation then that naturally impacts on situation and getting professional advice would be sensible.

I haven’t read your comment personally and my comment wasn’t targeted at you. It was targeted at people baffled by the fact he pays at all.

GwinGwyn · 12/03/2024 18:51

Mummame222 · 12/03/2024 18:46

If this child was biologically his you’d all be slamming him right now.

OP and his ex decided to conceive a baby in their marriage. OP decided not to fight for access. Now OP wants to pay less maintenance because he has a child he wants.

Take IVF out of the equation, would you all be saying the same thing?

No I wouldn’t. I would be saying the exact same thing as I’ve said already. If there is another child in the equation then that naturally impacts on situation and getting professional advice would be sensible.

Chocolatebuttonns · 12/03/2024 18:50

SecondHandFurniture · 12/03/2024 18:47

He is the parent, according to the courts, so yes. If you knowingly consent to IVF and you are married, you are the legal second parent. At the time of conception the mother was, on paper, agreeing to parent this child with her husband.

Adopted children aren't biological either; one parent shouldn't be able to just wash their hands of them.

Edit - anyway, to reply to OP, as far as I know a calculator would reduce the CMS by a percentage now there is another child.

Edited

An adoption wouldn't ever have got through in this scenario would it?

He's not "washing his hands" of them he's asking if he should reduce it but considering he has nothing to do with the child and mum has told him the same... why can't he walk away? That's what they both seem to want, except tye ex is accepting his money?

CrappySack · 12/03/2024 18:50

One option is to call your ex's bluff and say if she insists that you continue to pay maintenance and are the child's parent, you'll be looking to start having visits and building to shared care.

Hopefully she'd rather have less money than all the hassle that would bring. If she wanted to go to court and argue you aren't the legal parent, that's a win for you too as you won't have to pay maintenance then.

DancefloorAcrobatics · 12/03/2024 18:49

Chocolatebuttonns · 12/03/2024 18:43

Could he though?

Can you go to court and get access to a child that isn't yours when you're separated from the other biological parent? Does that actually stand up in court?

On what basis? That they "agreed" ? Presumably they agreed based on the fact they were together, if that changes doesn't it change rights as well?

It's a strange one.

I think this is covered in the IVF agreement / contract.

So on paper OP is responsible for the child as a parent with responsibilities and rights.

Would be interesting if this stands up in court....
Definitely get good, legal advice.

PlumbersWifey · 12/03/2024 18:48

Tell her you want your name on the birth certificate. She will highly likely say she wants nothing to do with you and will stop maintenance to make you disappear. Heck, you may even find she's said you disappeared and she's put the other guys name on the birth certificate.

Chocolatebuttonns · 12/03/2024 18:48

No, I wouldn't but then I think a child who is biologically yours is different in this scenario.

I would still think the ex had behaved badly biologically or not.

But in this situation it seems like neither parent wants to co parent, the child isn't biologically his and already has another parent, mum doesn't want the op involved but is happy to take his cash?

It's a shit show isn't it.

SecondHandFurniture · 12/03/2024 18:47

Chocolatebuttonns · 12/03/2024 18:43

Could he though?

Can you go to court and get access to a child that isn't yours when you're separated from the other biological parent? Does that actually stand up in court?

On what basis? That they "agreed" ? Presumably they agreed based on the fact they were together, if that changes doesn't it change rights as well?

It's a strange one.

He is the parent, according to the courts, so yes. If you knowingly consent to IVF and you are married, you are the legal second parent. At the time of conception the mother was, on paper, agreeing to parent this child with her husband.

Adopted children aren't biological either; one parent shouldn't be able to just wash their hands of them.

Edit - anyway, to reply to OP, as far as I know a calculator would reduce the CMS by a percentage now there is another child.

Mummame222 · 12/03/2024 18:46

If this child was biologically his you’d all be slamming him right now.

OP and his ex decided to conceive a baby in their marriage. OP decided not to fight for access. Now OP wants to pay less maintenance because he has a child he wants.

Take IVF out of the equation, would you all be saying the same thing?

Chocolatebuttonns · 12/03/2024 18:45

I think it's very off of the ex though, accepting mainyence when she'd moved in a replacement dad before the baby she was having with her ex was even born. Talk about having your cake and eating it.

Chocolatebuttonns · 12/03/2024 18:43

Could he though?

Can you go to court and get access to a child that isn't yours when you're separated from the other biological parent? Does that actually stand up in court?

On what basis? That they "agreed" ? Presumably they agreed based on the fact they were together, if that changes doesn't it change rights as well?

It's a strange one.

IsitaHatOrACat · 12/03/2024 18:41

I think we maybe shouldn't assume OP is male. However this doesn't really change the circumstances

TeaKitten · 12/03/2024 18:41

Chocolatebuttonns · 12/03/2024 18:39

I'm not that is presumable actually considering the wife wouldn't tell him she was pregnant.

He could push for access, he even says he doesn’t feel a connection to the child and has not tried to get contact.

MandyMotherOfBrian · 12/03/2024 18:40

Chocolatebuttonns · 12/03/2024 18:34

How can the child be "of the marriage" when op isn't allowed to be involved?

If the OP agreed to the donor process during IVF - which he clearly did - he is the legal parent. He could have gone to court to get parental responsibility and access - regardless of what the ex wife said - just like with any other child he had fathered not via IVF. He presumably chose not to.

TeaKitten · 12/03/2024 18:40

Navyblueblazer · 12/03/2024 18:34

What about the fact that he isn't on the birth certificate, has no biological link to the child and has never met him? Does that not change circumstances?

Why would it change it? He paid money to buy sperm to create a child in marriage, he is legally responsible for them. He has chosen not to go for any contact, but his responsibilities are still there.

However I do think it’s worth speaking to a solicitor to see if you are paying the right amount.

Chocolatebuttonns · 12/03/2024 18:39

Luckydog7 · 12/03/2024 18:38

Presumably op isn't involved out of choice and could push for access if they wanted.

I'm not that is presumable actually considering the wife wouldn't tell him she was pregnant.

Swipe left for the next trending thread