Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

That I don't need to pay

362 replies

Notcms · 07/03/2024 11:34

Opinions pls as I don't not know anymore if IABU.
I am a resident parent whose children go to other parent 2 nights every 14.
I am a high earner, and non-resident parent is a mw earner who works part-full time.
I am being told by professionals involved with the children that the difference in the childrens lifestyle is not fair, and I should be financially supporting the non resident parent.
I do not claim CMS or anything from the other parent although obviously I am entitled to.
Aibu to not hand over money to non resident parent who say they are struggling....or should I pay something?

OP posts:
poetryandwine · 07/03/2024 19:16

I think YANBU, OP.

If the NRP needs money they owe you a level of transparency that has not been forthcoming. Without it, I would do no more than provide cinema tickets, pocket money for treats for the DC, etc. The NRP does not sound fully trustworthy. For a therapist to side with them as you have described does not sound professional

Serrina · 07/03/2024 19:13

Notcms · 07/03/2024 12:43

Try to answer Qs.

Post divorce - fair financial settlement was made and both parties happy.

NRP has gone on to another relationship and has a new child.

No idea how many hours they work - but part-full time is what the children are told, and the phone isn't generally answered in working hours.

The professional involved is a family therapist advised by carcass post court case for children.

NRP has met individually several times with the therapist, and in our first joint meeting I was told that I should financially provide for the children while in NRP care.

The children have food, heating etc but NRP is unable to 'do nice things like cinema, swimming etc'

I should say everything for the children is paid for by me, no requests are made to the NRP for school stuff or extracurricular activities.

I genuinely can't decide if this is CF, or if IABU.

Sounds like CF to me, and I don't think YABU.

SauronsArsehole · 07/03/2024 19:11

Angelsrose · 07/03/2024 15:36

Op you don't need to pay anymore. You have the children the majority of the time anyway. If you continue to be overly reasonably then your ex will take advantage and it's clear from what you say that they are already trying to do so. Your ex has another child now, an unusual decision if you can't afford to do "fun" things with the children you already have. There is nothing to stop your partner working more hours if they feel they don't have enough money. It shouldn't be your responsibility.

Yes this! The NRP can do museums and parks ffs.

if you can’t afford nice days out then why on earth have another child?

is the 3rd child missing out?

Or is this a case of 3rd child gets priority from shared parent and first two children get breadcrumbs when there and you are guilt tripped?

Whatonearth07957 · 07/03/2024 19:10

You had an equitable court ordered divorce. Your ex is with another partner it's up to them to manage their money. Giving extra will be the road to entitlement. They have a weekend every fortnight. Save for your kids if you feel guilty. I'm not sure this therapist has seen what they (he?) got from divorce? Maybe time to get them to step up. What do they want to do with children? How can that be supported? If they want to request specific price of extra tickets or other thing they should ask each time. Don't just start paying an amount, you'll get no thanks.

Elber · 07/03/2024 19:07

@Notcms

I read your initial post wondering if you were male, female or were in a same sex relationship : and questioned whether my answer would differ.

I actually think it would. If you were male/same sex I’d say you should pay more. If female then no.

The reason being that typically one person in the relationship (usually the female) tend to take a career back seat for maternity leave etc. Also the unfairness of gender pay gap etc. Did childcare once impact the non resident parents ability to climb the career ladder?

The difference in amount of childcare is significant, and would the other parent see more of their child if they could afford to?

It depends if the extra money DOES go directly on the children/their welfare : and how it’s possible to check that this happens. I can see that maybe the non resident parent doesn’t want to be ‘told’ how to spend money for days out : and maybe wants more control, so long as it goes directly on the child.

Wigtopia · 07/03/2024 19:00

LaCouleurDeMonCiel · 07/03/2024 17:42

If a parent only sees their children 2 week end a month and has no other children-related expenses they can easily entertain them with free activities (crafts, museums, cooking/baking, learn to play chess, scrapbooking, nature trails…).

This was exactly my thought. Many of my childhood memories are of being at home and making “dens” out of chairs tables and blankets or other activities like playing, baking or crafting at home/ playing in the garden, having a picnic in the garden/ visiting the local park. Or a combination of craft and nature - collecting fallen leaves or petals and making mixed media “art” using the nature as well as drawing and painting. It mostly looked like a mess, but was good fun! Also making “perfume” by collecting some rose petals from the garden and mixing with water!!!

I am not sure why the activities have to be paid for, and even less sure why they should be paid for by someone else!!!

Eddielizzard · 07/03/2024 18:59

The ex sounds like a CF and deliberately difficult. I would ask the kids how they're doing there, and give them spending money. I don't see that you owe the ex anything at all.

audweb · 07/03/2024 18:53

Nah your ex is being ridiculous. You offer to pay for activities purchased in advance, but they want the money? Too poor to pay for activities but ok to have another child. You’re already funding your child for the majority of everything. You don’t need to fund your ex as well. Would be different if you didn’t have majority custody.

Zoreos · 07/03/2024 18:52

I wouldn’t be parting with my money unless I had concrete evidence of their earnings and working hours which for transparency reasons is fair and the least I’d expect. That would only happen also IF NRP hadn’t decided to have another child which would limit the money available for your DC to have treats which is all this is about being able to be a Disney parent. Why should you effectively contribute towards someone else’s child because on the surface at least it would be logical to assume more money would be available had NRP not had another child. I know that’s your DC sibling but if the shoe was on the other foot would NRP give you extra because you had another child? I doubt it. You don’t claim CM which id be firmly reminding said “therapist” about although legally you could. If it’s not court ordered I wouldn’t especially after previous gestures had been thrown in your face. I’d not be wasting any more of my hard earned money on this therapist anymore, is it ordered that you must use them because they sound terribly unprofessional? As PP have suggested, If you’re feeling generous I’d look into annual passes etc that they could enjoy both with yourself and NRP and then you know it’s definitely being used for your DC and not for NRP and their partner. My DC father and his partner are both very high earners who EOW set up. I’m a NMW earner but I wouldn’t dream of being so cheeky as to demand more money from them because of the lifestyle differences. If I want to take my DC somewhere I save for it like everyone else. The whole suggestion in my mind that you stump up when you put the hours and work in for your wage is madness to me.

FortofPud · 07/03/2024 18:50

The expectations of your ex sound strange. I think you have no requirement to cough up at all and would be annoyed at the cheekiness of it, but personally I would speak to the children and be led by them.

Perhaps cinema vouchers or restaurant vouchers, season passes to a particular place etc would be a better way of paying for something you children can directly benefit from whilst avoiding controlling days and times like with the theater trip.

Dibbydoos · 07/03/2024 18:49

So the kids need households that are equal? Offer to work a mw job part time. That's equal then.

I've never heard anything so ridiculous. This will give your kids a perspective they would never see if they were with you full time. In any case the other parent can get a full time job, you cope when you have the kids 12 days out of 14!

Shadowonasun · 07/03/2024 18:40

Hell no. I would never subsidize my ex, over my dead body. And it's not about the kids, otherwise ex would just accept cinema tickets, etc.

You're already doing more than enough. 12 nights out of 14, pay for everything, don't claim maintenance. You can take your kids out, they'll be fine without fancy activities for the rest 2 days.

Oh, and I'd change therapists. Either they are deluded/incompetent or a friend of the ex.

Doesn't matter if your ex is a man or a woman - you're already doing enough, OP.

BungleandGeorge · 07/03/2024 18:35

Doing the school run in no way means they re part time, they could be doing a 5-12 shift for all you know or wfh . someone has to do
the school run so perhaps they have to work around it, parents of younger children often have to work part time

Stompythedinosaur · 07/03/2024 18:35

I can't see any reason why it's your responsibility to find your ex tbh. If things are that desperate then sending food for your dc is very kind. But I imagine there's a huge number of dc out there who don't go on paid activities every weekend.

TickingKey46 · 07/03/2024 18:34

So they're a 2 parent family and he also chose to have another child?
No the therapist is way off!

BungleandGeorge · 07/03/2024 18:32

It depends what you mean by ‘high income’ really. 100k? 100000k? More? If you’re a really high earner perhaps you would have some liability for spousal/ child maintenance but if you have a court order for finances that’s final isn’t it?
you shouldn’t be planning theatre etc on times they’re not with you, that’s quite bizarre and controlling. If you really wanted to make a genuine gift buy a voucher!

Spinet · 07/03/2024 18:31

If this therapist was someone you respect then you should listen to them and consider whether or not you are right, not just assume you are.

You are clearly richer than they are but the issue is not the ex's standard of living it is the children's. If your children are living off foodbanks when they are not with you, the parents need more money. It is quite controlling of you to pay for things rather than giving money. You chose to have children with this person and you are not putting them at the centre, you are putting your need to be in the right there.

All this assuming you can afford to pay more money obviously.

SpringtimeAtLast · 07/03/2024 18:24

I suspect, if you are the Dad there is some good old-fashioned sexism from the therapist here — I’ve tried reading this imagining you are dad, and then mum. Either way I think you are being entirely reasonable.

I wonder if NRP has reduced hours worked due to having another child and this is causing them financial difficulty. But really how is this your problem? If the kids are loved, fed, warm and safe then it’s not your responsibility to find “extras”.

The NRP has a new relationship and chose to have a new child. If this is limiting their new family income, that’s absolutely not your problem.

In your shoes I would kindly but firmly stick to your guns and explain to the therapist that you’re under no moral, legal or parenting duty to fend for your ex who has formed a new and separate family.

As long as you aren’t trash-talking the ex to your kids (and I assume you are not!) then by all means lavish your kids with oodles of love, creature comforts, activities, days out, trendy clothes and gifts if you wish. And don’t feel bad about it.

BoohooWoohoo · 07/03/2024 18:23

I think that you should pay as much attention to this professional as a random on here. They have a right to voice an opinion but I can’t help but wonder if they are projecting their personal
circumstances on you. You are already being generous by not requesting child support and providing stuff like clothes that can be used on dad’s days (technically he should be providing for his days but I think it practice many teens take their favourite items to each house - mine always have)

OCDmama · 07/03/2024 18:21

I suspect there's a lot more going on than this.

Why were Cafcass involved?

BedZwift · 07/03/2024 18:19

I have absolutely no time for my ex, but I do give him money to take my DC out sometimes, not that often though. Mainly in school holidays.
For it to be expected and regular isn’t ok, as cafcass have seemed to imply, but I don’t see anything wrong with occasionally helping out so DC can have nice experiences.

Alwaystransforming · 07/03/2024 18:17

Since when was CMS based on the self esteem rating of the NRP?

I mean this is so ridiculous. The NRPs self esteem was fine enough to find someone, start a relationship and have another child. When they couldn’t afford the ones they have.

Why would the RP pay towards the NRP household?

76evie · 07/03/2024 18:14

You are not being unreasonable to not give them money to spend on the children at the weekend. They shouldn’t have gone on to have another child if they couldn’t afford the ones they already had. I would go as far to say, if it was me, I would claim maintenance through the CMS and then give it back to them to spend on the children whilst they are in their care. I think they are being exceptionally cheeky to expect cash hand out for children that they are already not paying anything towards.

If you lost your job tomorrow, would they step in and pay for the children above and beyond the legal minimum they had too? I’d bet my next months wage on them saying no!

LaCouleurDeMonCiel · 07/03/2024 18:13

SomethingUniqueThisTime · 07/03/2024 17:39

I think it’s interesting that OP has hidden her sex, and the sex of the NRP. I wonder why that might be?

You do sound a bit snarky & controlling OP. Surely it’s up to the NRP how they spend the money on the DC.

Edited

I would argue that it is OP’s business how OP’s money is spent.

Also, why would their sex make a difference?