Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Just told DH I will Divorce him over a fucking wedding Part two

716 replies

KeenHiker · 04/03/2024 09:52

https://www.mumsnet.com/talk/am_i_being_unreasonable/5018658-just-told-dh-i-will-divorce-him-over-a-fucking-wedding

I can’t believe the responses that I had.

Essentially I am going to that wedding so it won’t backfire on me and then as people have suggested reassess when everything has calmed down after Easter.

I am never going to look at MiL in the same light as she clearly thinks my daughter is an impediment to her own granddaughter.

Just told DH I will divorce him over a fucking wedding | Mumsnet

This is my first post. I think my head’s going to explode. BiL has shown no interest whatsoever in my daughters, not my eldest who isn’t my husband’...

https://www.mumsnet.com/talk/am_i_being_unreasonable/5018658-just-told-dh-i-will-divorce-him-over-a-fucking-wedding

OP posts:
Unknown987 · 04/03/2024 12:42

As a mum of two girls married remarried to another man and having a child with him I can't imagine the pain this situation is causing.

people are toxic. My own family don't want anything to do with any of my children so posts like this just highlight how different some people are in terms of decency.
all you can control is how you treat your children and who you allow access to your children.

Dutchairfryer · 04/03/2024 12:41

doodlepants · 04/03/2024 12:37

One thing I've learned from Mumsnet is that people love children- until it comes to weddings. Then the attitude is "eff those kids, I have the most money in this situation, I can be as awful as I want to children and parents!". And because it's a wedding (much more important than children), everyone agrees.

My sympathies, people that want to celebrate the start of their family but making you feel like yours isn't important are not good people.

What a bizarre comment

Someone’s wedding will usually always be more important to them than the kids of family members and friends.

Your family is factually not important to them, nor should it be

GreatGateauxsby · 04/03/2024 12:39

Wow wow wow.

Your DH and the inheritance and private school bombshells
I dont envy you @KeenHiker this is a horrible situation to be in especially as your own DH doesnt view the 4 of you as a family unit together 😪

You'd think even by virtue of the fact its his child's sister (her only family once you both die) he would do the decent thing.

On a very boring related note: your will...
Is it up to date and watertight with everything going to the girls?
You clearly cant leave anything to your dh at all as you can't trust him to pass it on fairly.
Eg. If your estate is worth 400k so 200k is to go to your DD... if he gets it he either wont give it to her or will give that exact amount when he dies. But lets be real 200k in 2026 is not the same as 200k in 2050.

You also potentially .and more seriously leave a mess in terms of conflict and resentment between the girls..

God such a mess. I really feel for you...

doodlepants · 04/03/2024 12:37

One thing I've learned from Mumsnet is that people love children- until it comes to weddings. Then the attitude is "eff those kids, I have the most money in this situation, I can be as awful as I want to children and parents!". And because it's a wedding (much more important than children), everyone agrees.

My sympathies, people that want to celebrate the start of their family but making you feel like yours isn't important are not good people.

Dutchairfryer · 04/03/2024 12:33

Jeschara · 04/03/2024 12:17

I think your husband is playing the good Father to blindside you. He is notbl a good stepfather, he is manipulative, he has only just told you about sending his biological child to a private school but has no intention of paying for his step daughter. He is just playing the good step dad for show.
To be fair you cannot expect your child to inherit from his family though.
I really think your elder daughter is at a disadvantage from this set up, and I feel you should make it clear the private school is not happening unless the same offer is extended to your 1st daughter as they are both your children.
I notice he was also quick to say about her biological Father doing nothing. I would never advise you what to do but good luck with whatever you decide.

Why would he pay for his step child’s private education?

Have a word

Could you imagine the responses if someone posted here ‘AIBU to not want to pay for my step childs private school’ everyone would be in favour of not paying

PlenvuIsNoFun · 04/03/2024 12:33

@Surprisedbuthappy you’re right. Thank you.

Dutchairfryer · 04/03/2024 12:31

As is usually the case you started off being reasonable and have descended into being unreasonable due to the stress most likely

Ask on here about step parents thinking and treating their step kids the same as their own children and you’d get similar views to your in laws

Your DH isn’t your eldests dad, his family do not consider her the same as your youngest, which is quite common.

After all this id not be going to the wedding as it seems to have just blown up and will be quite awkward all round

Surprisedbuthappy · 04/03/2024 12:24

InterIgnis · 04/03/2024 12:19

It was her choice, and as the one with the child she most definitely had the responsibility for that child, to marry her husband and have another child. It doesn’t sound like her husband has ever had this expectation of his family in regards her eldest, and nor does it sound like he has taken her on as fully his own - OP herself doesn’t consider his an equal parent to her eldest, and she has accepted the fact that he hasn’t included her in his will.

It sounds more like OP has always known this, but the wedding issue means it’s come to a head and she’s been forced to confront it.

Yep, OP most likely should have seen the warning signs a lot earlier and probably should have made different decisions in the past. But she didn't. She's here - married to a liar with a nasty family.

LadyBird1973 · 04/03/2024 12:19

@britneyisfree tbh I can't imagine resenting the presence of a child I'd known since she was 4. I get that it might be different seeing bio grandchildren alone, if step grandchildren came on the scene later on, after your own dgc were already born and you didn't really know the step children. Idk, I just can't imaging treating two young children, who are sisters and live together ft, differently just because one isn't blood.

InterIgnis · 04/03/2024 12:19

Surprisedbuthappy · 04/03/2024 12:03

OP has been called all sorts of names for feeling as she does though. Yes, she has to come to terms with it. It seems like OP is perfectly aware of that. She's only just starting that process as she's only just understood the depth of feeling from her husband and in-laws. She doesn't need kicking when she's down and made to feel like it's all her fault for the family set-up she's got. She married a man who claimed he'd treat her daughter as his own. He's not living up to his claims.

(And yes, that was his choice and no, he can't force his family to take the child on in the same way he claimed he would - but he bloody well could have supported OP by standing up for eldest daughter to at least be invited to the wedding, not to mention the whole private school thing which is absolutely awful of him.)

It was her choice, and as the one with the child she most definitely had the responsibility for that child, to marry her husband and have another child. It doesn’t sound like her husband has ever had this expectation of his family in regards her eldest, and nor does it sound like he has taken her on as fully his own - OP herself doesn’t consider his an equal parent to her eldest, and she has accepted the fact that he hasn’t included her in his will.

It sounds more like OP has always known this, but the wedding issue means it’s come to a head and she’s been forced to confront it.

Jeschara · 04/03/2024 12:17

I think your husband is playing the good Father to blindside you. He is notbl a good stepfather, he is manipulative, he has only just told you about sending his biological child to a private school but has no intention of paying for his step daughter. He is just playing the good step dad for show.
To be fair you cannot expect your child to inherit from his family though.
I really think your elder daughter is at a disadvantage from this set up, and I feel you should make it clear the private school is not happening unless the same offer is extended to your 1st daughter as they are both your children.
I notice he was also quick to say about her biological Father doing nothing. I would never advise you what to do but good luck with whatever you decide.

Surprisedbuthappy · 04/03/2024 12:03

InterIgnis · 04/03/2024 11:37

I’m not saying it isn’t a problem for OP - equally her expectations of her in laws are a problem for them as well as for her husband. They have been in her life since she was tiny, yes, but that doesn’t mean they have to consider her a relative in the same way the youngest is (and clearly they don’t!). Not considering her a grandchild/stepniece isn’t the same as treating her like she’s nothing at all.

What she, and they, decide to do is up to them. They’re not going to share the same views here, and OP is going to have to come to terms with that, regardless of whether she or anyone else thinks she’s reasonable for feeling as she does.

OP has been called all sorts of names for feeling as she does though. Yes, she has to come to terms with it. It seems like OP is perfectly aware of that. She's only just starting that process as she's only just understood the depth of feeling from her husband and in-laws. She doesn't need kicking when she's down and made to feel like it's all her fault for the family set-up she's got. She married a man who claimed he'd treat her daughter as his own. He's not living up to his claims.

(And yes, that was his choice and no, he can't force his family to take the child on in the same way he claimed he would - but he bloody well could have supported OP by standing up for eldest daughter to at least be invited to the wedding, not to mention the whole private school thing which is absolutely awful of him.)

Crazycrazylady · 04/03/2024 12:02

Op

I think you need to take a breath here: of course you're disappointed that your husbands extended family don't see your daughter in the same way as they see their biological granddaughter, I'm sure that was your hope when you got married and youre clear that your dh had never treated them differently which is as it should be , having said that you can't dictate that what your in laws feel and neither can your dh. As the girls have different fathers and extended families , they are going to have different opportunities in life. It sounds like your younger daughter will have an inheritance form her fathers family where your oldest won't and that sucks for her and you. Having said that they can choose who to leave money to and you can't dictate that

At this stage . I'd attend the wedding and let them take their photo with the grandkids but take a massive step back from your relationship in real life in order that your daughter doesn't feel so hurt when the penny drops that they don't view her the same way as her sister .
Your dh can facilitate the relationship with your younger how ever he chooses to do so.

Blended families are hard. Feel sorry for your daughter in all of this. Such a pity that her fathers family are so flakey. It would make the world of difference if she had her own relationships there.

WaitingForMojo · 04/03/2024 11:55

I’ve just read your update op, you must be reeling. How utterly awful of your dh. It’s so awful that I even started to wonder about the veracity of this thread (not troll hunting - just gobsmacked that anyone would behave that way).

All the posters saying you’re depriving your younger daughter of what she is entitled to, and advantages in life - absolutely not. What the dh is doing is potentially creating a divide between two sisters. Who would actually want to be in the younger sister’s shoes? I wouldn’t, and I wouldn’t do it to my dc.

Inthedeep · 04/03/2024 11:54

Has your DH ever suggested paying for your eldest daughter to go to private school? This is definitely something I’d bring up and speak to him about.

Your DH’s family sound horrid, you’d think they’d want to include your daughter and make her feel one of the family. How cruel to want to exclude a young girl who they’ve watched grow up.

I too have a different father to my siblings, I don’t have a relationship with my biological father and I was 3 when my Mum met my step-dad. He never officially adopted me (although I now have his surname) and to be honest we haven’t always had the best relationship, we clashed a lot when I was younger. However right from the beginning his family treated me as another grandchild/niece etc. There was literally no difference to how I was treated. I’ve been included in every family event/family photos etc since. When my grandmother died and my Aunt put an obituary in the paper I was listed in the obituary as one of her grandchildren. When I was younger I used to go and stay with her on my own and she always seemed equally happy to see and spend time with me as she did my younger siblings. That’s how a family should act, just because you aren’t blood it doesn’t mean you can’t still be a family.

britneyisfree · 04/03/2024 11:47

LadyBird1973 · 04/03/2024 11:41

As for mil bitching that she doesn't see dd2 without dd1 - words fail me!

All the rest of the stuff I agree they're very wrong but surely it's fair enough to want to see your grandchild alone occasionally?

I'm not a step parent but if I became one I reckon my mum would insist on seeing my DC alone sometimes. It's a special bond and if OP and hubby split she'll never see the eldest again anyway. He hasn't adopted her so he isn't committed to this for life imo

Tomatoblush · 04/03/2024 11:44

It seems like the wedding has brought everything to the fore.
And now grandma wants to see youngest on her own and probably always has but been too worried to say. The floodgates have opened.
And now your husband has really put the boot in with the private school etc.

I feel so much for you and your eldest. I couldn’t continue in this marriage because the hurt from all this be too much for me.
I just couldn’t forgive or forget.

LakieLady · 04/03/2024 11:43

I'm utterly appalled by your IL's attitude to your DD, OP, but even more so by your DH's. They've all made it perfectly clear that what matters to them is the DNA the children have inherited and nothing else.

I'd be seriously considering ending the marriage. They all sound horrible.

LadyBird1973 · 04/03/2024 11:41

As for mil bitching that she doesn't see dd2 without dd1 - words fail me!

InterIgnis · 04/03/2024 11:40

Caerulea · 04/03/2024 11:34

But this is all technical BS - an actual decision is made about how that child is treated & that's where the difference lies in being good or shitty, sorry 🤷🏼‍♀️

As an example -

My eldest DS is my husbands step son. DS now has a baby. DH is now a grandad & absolutely adores his grandson. Eldest is DH son & he loves him as such. He brought him up, loved him, advocated for him as his son.

FIL got remarried a few years ago. His new wife is step-mum technically but cos we're talking adults, she's not mum to DH & is referred to by her name. None of our 3 children are related to her by blood at all. She has no children of her own & is not remotely maternal. She's a strong, independent woman & I've got a lot of respect for her. She's improved the relationship between DH & FIL no end cos he was a bit selfish & distant prior. We see them a few times a year.

HOWEVER! Entirely of her own volition she now considers herself great grandma to a child who is not even blood to her husband. She looked fit to bust when she first met DGS, just smitten & immediately referred to herself as great grandma (which really took me by surprise). They've both stepped up to help eldest & his girlf out financially, we've just handed over a beautifully wrapped gift to DGS they sent him.

Sure, no one has to feel that way but that's the difference between good, ordinary, emotionally mature people & shitty elitist ones. The former just are that way, the latter choose to be.

OPs in-laws happen to be the latter & sadly for her, so does her husband.

Your family is free to operate in the way that works best for it, same as OP’s in laws are free to.

You can think it’s BS and shitty as much as you like, that’s the reality OP is dealing with. It’s the reality for a lot of people who aren’t suddenly going to change because they’re heartbroken by you considering them shitty people.

LadyBird1973 · 04/03/2024 11:39

@KeenHiker I'm so glad you started a new thread. I read your update in the last one and I'm absolutely horrified at your husband's attitude.
Forget the wedding - this is the least of your problems and has just thrown into focus what already bubbling under the surface.

I can't believe your h has made plans for your youngest re private school without discussing with you first and don't offering the same opportunity to your oldest.

It's all very well for posters to think that the kids have different dads and therefore different opportunities, but then a person marries someone who has a child already (and no other parent in the picture) and claims they will take that child on as their own, to then treat the child differently to their own is cruel. He's lied to you OP and you have every right to be furious and hurt.

While you can't make his family love dd or share their wealth with her, your husband absolutely should be sharing his. It's absolutely appalling to send dd2 to private school but not dd1. He couldn't make his priorities clearer if he tattooed them in his forehead!

I'd ltb!

InterIgnis · 04/03/2024 11:37

Surprisedbuthappy · 04/03/2024 11:31

It is a problem for OP though, since she actually cares about her daughter's feelings. Unlike the people who've been in her life since she was tiny, but think it's acceptable to treat her like she's nothing at all since she doesn't share their blood. Actually, no, worse than nothing at all - a hindrance to their relationship with their blood relative just by being around! They feel like that and OP can't force them to feel or act otherwise - fine.

However, the people backing OP are saying she's justified in being hurt by their words and actions, because they are hurtful. How she decides to act on that is up to her, but she's not crazy or unreasonable for feeling that way.

I’m not saying it isn’t a problem for OP - equally her expectations of her in laws are a problem for them as well as for her husband. They have been in her life since she was tiny, yes, but that doesn’t mean they have to consider her a relative in the same way the youngest is (and clearly they don’t!). Not considering her a grandchild/stepniece isn’t the same as treating her like she’s nothing at all.

What she, and they, decide to do is up to them. They’re not going to share the same views here, and OP is going to have to come to terms with that, regardless of whether she or anyone else thinks she’s reasonable for feeling as she does.

Caerulea · 04/03/2024 11:34

InterIgnis · 04/03/2024 11:12

How has he not accepted her as part of his family? He has, as his stepdaughter. That it’s a different relationship to the one he has with his daughter doesn’t mean she's not family. As far as the extended family go, she’s an in-law to them, same as OP is. She isn’t their granddaughter any more than OP is their daughter, and whether they’re family or not is entirely dependent on whether OP remains married to their son.

Blended families are not the same as nuclear ones, no matter how much some may want them to be. The daughters are equal in OP’s eyes as she’s the mother of both, but that doesn’t mean the girls have all the same relatives in common. They don’t. Op can’t change that, regardless of whether she divorces her husband or not.

And OP, you knew this was the case. You know your husband is leaving everything to his biological child in his will. You also clearly don’t think he gets an equal say to you in regards to your eldest.

You can’t force your husband and in laws to think, feel, and act the way you want them to. All the calling them dicks and ranting about how unfair and wrong they are won’t change that. That is what you need to come to terms with

But this is all technical BS - an actual decision is made about how that child is treated & that's where the difference lies in being good or shitty, sorry 🤷🏼‍♀️

As an example -

My eldest DS is my husbands step son. DS now has a baby. DH is now a grandad & absolutely adores his grandson. Eldest is DH son & he loves him as such. He brought him up, loved him, advocated for him as his son.

FIL got remarried a few years ago. His new wife is step-mum technically but cos we're talking adults, she's not mum to DH & is referred to by her name. None of our 3 children are related to her by blood at all. She has no children of her own & is not remotely maternal. She's a strong, independent woman & I've got a lot of respect for her. She's improved the relationship between DH & FIL no end cos he was a bit selfish & distant prior. We see them a few times a year.

HOWEVER! Entirely of her own volition she now considers herself great grandma to a child who is not even blood to her husband. She looked fit to bust when she first met DGS, just smitten & immediately referred to herself as great grandma (which really took me by surprise). They've both stepped up to help eldest & his girlf out financially, we've just handed over a beautifully wrapped gift to DGS they sent him.

Sure, no one has to feel that way but that's the difference between good, ordinary, emotionally mature people & shitty elitist ones. The former just are that way, the latter choose to be.

OPs in-laws happen to be the latter & sadly for her, so does her husband.

Surprisedbuthappy · 04/03/2024 11:31

InterIgnis · 04/03/2024 11:23

Sometimes they are, sometimes they’re not. As it stands the eldest has now been invited, and OP now has a problem with the great grandmother having photos taken with her direct biological descendants.

As far as ‘general consensus is they’re not very nice!’ - okay, and? It’s not the general consensus in their actual circle, or indeed in plenty of others. That isn’t a ‘them’ problem.

It is a problem for OP though, since she actually cares about her daughter's feelings. Unlike the people who've been in her life since she was tiny, but think it's acceptable to treat her like she's nothing at all since she doesn't share their blood. Actually, no, worse than nothing at all - a hindrance to their relationship with their blood relative just by being around! They feel like that and OP can't force them to feel or act otherwise - fine.

However, the people backing OP are saying she's justified in being hurt by their words and actions, because they are hurtful. How she decides to act on that is up to her, but she's not crazy or unreasonable for feeling that way.

MidnightPatrol · 04/03/2024 11:29

What amazes me most about this, is that the decision was made to not invite the eldest daughter, with the assumption that what - no one would comment?

So often I see these threads where family members / children are excluded from events, do these people not have any empathy?

Do they not think how it might look to exclude the step child? How that step child might feel about it, given she's 10?

Swipe left for the next trending thread