Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Just told DH I will Divorce him over a fucking wedding Part two

716 replies

KeenHiker · 04/03/2024 09:52

https://www.mumsnet.com/talk/am_i_being_unreasonable/5018658-just-told-dh-i-will-divorce-him-over-a-fucking-wedding

I can’t believe the responses that I had.

Essentially I am going to that wedding so it won’t backfire on me and then as people have suggested reassess when everything has calmed down after Easter.

I am never going to look at MiL in the same light as she clearly thinks my daughter is an impediment to her own granddaughter.

Just told DH I will divorce him over a fucking wedding | Mumsnet

This is my first post. I think my head’s going to explode. BiL has shown no interest whatsoever in my daughters, not my eldest who isn’t my husband’...

https://www.mumsnet.com/talk/am_i_being_unreasonable/5018658-just-told-dh-i-will-divorce-him-over-a-fucking-wedding

OP posts:
BruFord · 04/03/2024 14:02

Surprisedbuthappy · 04/03/2024 14:00

@BruFord And? Why does he get to unilaterally decide youngest goes to private school?

@Surprisedbuthappy Why doesn't the OP just say no if she disagrees with it? Can he force their DD to go to a certain school? For a private school, I think the parents would have to sign a contract, wouldn’t they?

I genuinely don’t know the answer as I’ve never been in this situation.

Winterstormm · 04/03/2024 14:00

You said in your last update on the previous thread that you're upset that your eldest dd won't inherit from her step family and her step dad won't pay for private school. Your eldest is not your DH's biological or adopted DD so of course he's going to save money for his bio dd.

You mentioned that your family love your dds so I think you should focus on them instead. Your DH can take his dd (your youngest) to see her side of the family.

InterIgnis · 04/03/2024 14:00

InterIgnis · 04/03/2024 13:54

OP can’t just say no to her youngest going to private school, given that it’s a decision they’re both responsible for (or a court is, if they remain in disagreement and it escalates to that point). She should also be mindful about not denying her youngest the opportunities that aren’t available to her older sister. As far as ‘dividing the sisters’ goes, that type of thing can very easily, and does, cause resentment in the youngest who doesn’t want to be denied things as a means of compensating their sibling. As much as some may like to think the youngest will naturally ‘side’ with her mother and think badly of her father and paternal family, that is wishful thinking. ‘Protecting’ her eldest should not come at the expense of her youngest.

She should stop expecting then, given the disappointment it’s already led to. They’re not ‘equal’, are they? They don’t share the same family members, opportunities and financial resources. That’s the reality.

Surprisedbuthappy · 04/03/2024 14:00

@BruFord And? Why does he get to unilaterally decide youngest goes to private school?

Inthedeep · 04/03/2024 13:59

Katbum · 04/03/2024 13:24

We’re they wealthy? I think working class families (I’m from one) tend to be easier about accepting ‘other than their blood’ into the fold. Money, particularly’family money’ makes things more tricky.

Thats a tricky one, there was generational wealth on my step-dad’s father’s side (however he died before I was born), but my (step) grandmother came from a less affluent family herself and probably would have been classed as working class before marriage. My Mum’s family overall were/are far wealthier than my step-dad’s though (my poor grandfather was shipped off to boarding school at 6 😳). Everything monetary in my (step) grandmother’s will was split equally between her two children, however I got left a special locket which probably had more sentimental and monetary value than anything my siblings or cousins received. I know everything in my Mum and step Dad’s wills gets left equally between us 4 children.

BruFord · 04/03/2024 13:58

Surprisedbuthappy · 04/03/2024 13:55

Ugh! Some of you are so determined to make OP out to be completely unreasonable! She hasn't said she expects H to pay for private education for her daughter. She expects equal opportunities for them both - since he claimed they're equal in his eyes. She'd be happy with younger daughter going to the same school as the eldest. He's the one insisting on private education for the younger one.

@Surprisedbuthappy She’s the only person in this scenario who has the right to make decisions regarding both girls’ education.

Her DH can’t decide to send her eldest DD to private school, he doesn’t have PR. He can make decisions about the youngest, with the OP’s consent. If she disagrees about private school, she can say so.

BruFord · 04/03/2024 13:56

@Lovelylydia I’m guessing that her DH doesn’t have parental responsibility for her eldest daughter, the OP and the child’s father do. So her DH literally has no right to make decisions regarding her education.

Surprisedbuthappy · 04/03/2024 13:55

Ugh! Some of you are so determined to make OP out to be completely unreasonable! She hasn't said she expects H to pay for private education for her daughter. She expects equal opportunities for them both - since he claimed they're equal in his eyes. She'd be happy with younger daughter going to the same school as the eldest. He's the one insisting on private education for the younger one.

InterIgnis · 04/03/2024 13:54

OP can’t just say no to her youngest going to private school, given that it’s a decision they’re both responsible for (or a court is, if they remain in disagreement and it escalates to that point). She should also be mindful about not denying her youngest the opportunities that aren’t available to her older sister. As far as ‘dividing the sisters’ goes, that type of thing can very easily, and does, cause resentment in the youngest who doesn’t want to be denied things as a means of compensating their sibling. As much as some may like to think the youngest will naturally ‘side’ with her mother and think badly of her father and paternal family, that is wishful thinking. ‘Protecting’ her eldest should not come at the expense of her youngest.

BruFord · 04/03/2024 13:53

I agree with PP’s who say that there are two separate issues here. The DH’s family have been horrible regarding the wedding, they deliberately excluded a child until pressurized into inviting her. That’s so unkind.

Re. Financial provision (private school and inheritance) I’m guessing that your DH doesn’t have parental responsibility so has no right to make decisions regarding your eldest DD’s education? You and her father both have PR and make those decisions. If you want your eldest to go to private school but need financial help to do this, you’ll have to raise it with your DH.

Inheritance is also tricky because your DH’s family can leave their money to whomever they wish, as can your eldest DD’s paternal side. Your DH himself may leave something to both girls (or leave everything to you if he goes first) but that’s all he can control.

Different circumstances but my Dad remarried after my Mum died and I didn’t inherit anything from my step-Mum. Everything went to her side of the family, which was fine by me, it was her money.

Justkeeepswimming · 04/03/2024 13:39

Lovelylydia · 04/03/2024 13:20

I don’t get this ‘blood’ related argument. As a mother to adopted children it’s highly offensive. Blood isn’t what makes a family, it goes much deeper than that.
In any case, for those who are so intent on making this about blood relations, the eldest daughter is blood related to the younger daughter. They’re sisters and should be treated a such by the whole family.

@Lovelylydia again - adoption is different: 2 parents, child entirely theirs…

Step child has a father and he and his family is not contributing.

Rather than take responsibility for this herself, OP is wanting her new DH and his family to front money and opportunity for her elder daughter to make up for her parents being unable to.

Rightly they don’t want to as it will take resources away from the younger daughter, and lots of other children in the family that they have responsibility to.

Justkeeepswimming · 04/03/2024 13:34

Katbum · 04/03/2024 13:17

You expected to marry into a wealthy family and have them treat your existing unrelated child the same in terms of inheritance? That’s unreasonable and a little mad. I have a stepchild and no, she will not be inheriting from me or my parents. Why would she? She is not our descendant! If you split with your DH your youngest is still going to benefit from having well off paternal family as that’s her family. It still won’t be your eldest’s family. Once again, the only person to blame here is you - you had a child in a relationship that didn’t work out; you married into a wealthy family (rich ppl are not known for giving their money away out of blood family bonds); you felt entitled that your existing child would Be treated as blood - all you. You divorcing because you didn’t think through the reality of your two kids having very different fathers is just creating another mess your kids will suffer from. Please get some therapy and strategies for helping your eldest navigate a broken family dynamic. Ideally, help her have a relationship with her paternal grandmother, who clearly loves her

Agreeing with this.

OP, while your husband may be happy to house and provide for your elder daughters needs, even holidays and days out….

To expect him to take on paying for a private school education and to advocate for her to have a major inheritance is loopy. It diverts money away from his daughter who only has him as a father.

Your elder daughter has a father. And a family on his side. If they are poor or are failing in their obligations towards her that is their fault - and yours for deciding to have a child with him.

All you are achieving by creating this almighty fuss is to destroy familial relations and ruin prospects for your younger daughter as well - who has every right to a relationship with her family and to inherit from them when the time comes.

Your elder daughter is not the financial responsibility of your husband and his family - she has two parents and their associates families who should be stepping up for her, clearly they aren’t!!

Katbum · 04/03/2024 13:24

Inthedeep · 04/03/2024 11:54

Has your DH ever suggested paying for your eldest daughter to go to private school? This is definitely something I’d bring up and speak to him about.

Your DH’s family sound horrid, you’d think they’d want to include your daughter and make her feel one of the family. How cruel to want to exclude a young girl who they’ve watched grow up.

I too have a different father to my siblings, I don’t have a relationship with my biological father and I was 3 when my Mum met my step-dad. He never officially adopted me (although I now have his surname) and to be honest we haven’t always had the best relationship, we clashed a lot when I was younger. However right from the beginning his family treated me as another grandchild/niece etc. There was literally no difference to how I was treated. I’ve been included in every family event/family photos etc since. When my grandmother died and my Aunt put an obituary in the paper I was listed in the obituary as one of her grandchildren. When I was younger I used to go and stay with her on my own and she always seemed equally happy to see and spend time with me as she did my younger siblings. That’s how a family should act, just because you aren’t blood it doesn’t mean you can’t still be a family.

We’re they wealthy? I think working class families (I’m from one) tend to be easier about accepting ‘other than their blood’ into the fold. Money, particularly’family money’ makes things more tricky.

Lovelylydia · 04/03/2024 13:20

I don’t get this ‘blood’ related argument. As a mother to adopted children it’s highly offensive. Blood isn’t what makes a family, it goes much deeper than that.
In any case, for those who are so intent on making this about blood relations, the eldest daughter is blood related to the younger daughter. They’re sisters and should be treated a such by the whole family.

ChangeAgain2 · 04/03/2024 13:19

Your DH isn't treating DD1 as his own. He is the problem. You are a family. He wants to give DD2 opportunities he's not prepared to finance for DD1. Personally, I wouldn't accept that. He can't make his family treat DD1 the same and as family but he bloody well should.

The inheritance thing I understand. He will leave his money to DD2. You will leave your money to DD1 and DD2. DD1 has her own paternal family she will inherit from.

I dint think it's unreasonable for MIL to want to spend the occasional day will DD2 alone.

The family photo is what it is. I think you need to explain to DD1 that all family's are different. You are a blended family. This is DD2 family because its DD2s dad's family. Her bio family is your family and her dad's family. Sometimes DD2 will get gifts/ trips that she won't get and vice versa.

Make sure your will is water tight so DD1 definitely inherits from you. I have a few friends who got nothing because there parent dies first and the step parent inherited and then left all the money to their bio kids.

In all honestly I don't think I'd continue the relationship with DH. He doesn't seem to accept DD1 as his.

I personally don't want a step anything daughter, son, niece, nephew. I've done it before and got hurt. After 14 years of treating the kids as my family the relationship broke down and I was told the kids aren't anything to do with me. However, I wouldn't be cruel. I think not inviting DD1 to the wedding was cruel.

Anameisaname · 04/03/2024 13:18

It seems like in honesty you and DH have to sit down and have a very long conversation about things.

You think he should treat both your children equally and he thinks there's a difference (despite what he says) and treating them differently is OK for some things.

If your eldest was due to get a massive inheritance from your ex. What would you do in that scenario? Would you make her split it with her sister? Probably not? It would be a bit wierd. And when they get older then you won't be able to make them do anything like that.

I'm afraid that these two girls are not the same. And there will be differences in family and relationships. If you split from your DH, it's likely that your eldest would lose some or all of the relationships she's built with him and his family. That's just a fact. Not least because he would have no ability to enforce it (see sep thread about a step dad overreaching post split). What about when she is a teen, will you (and she) allow him to discipline her or will you want to take the lead? What if the dad comes back into her life and wants to do things differently?

So you need to sit down and talk about what you want and all the scenarios and permutations. This wedding has just exposed something here and you both probably need to get to the bottom of it.

Katbum · 04/03/2024 13:17

You expected to marry into a wealthy family and have them treat your existing unrelated child the same in terms of inheritance? That’s unreasonable and a little mad. I have a stepchild and no, she will not be inheriting from me or my parents. Why would she? She is not our descendant! If you split with your DH your youngest is still going to benefit from having well off paternal family as that’s her family. It still won’t be your eldest’s family. Once again, the only person to blame here is you - you had a child in a relationship that didn’t work out; you married into a wealthy family (rich ppl are not known for giving their money away out of blood family bonds); you felt entitled that your existing child would Be treated as blood - all you. You divorcing because you didn’t think through the reality of your two kids having very different fathers is just creating another mess your kids will suffer from. Please get some therapy and strategies for helping your eldest navigate a broken family dynamic. Ideally, help her have a relationship with her paternal grandmother, who clearly loves her

Caerulea · 04/03/2024 13:14

@ChampagneLassie I'm sorry, I don't want you to feel bad. If it helps, before FIL got remarried he was pretty useless & spineless (unless it was calling me a gold digger 🙄, had the spine for that), it's his now-wife that's made the difference. They are both from the same social class & he veered much more towards traditional middle class thinking but she has zero truck with it. She & I have very little in common but she gets family comes in all shapes, sizes, combinations & they are all important! It's a measure of her entirely.

Compare her to FIL parents who refused to even meet me & DS for YEARS cos I was divorced, grotty little wankers. Working class, divorced mum with child - I was positively satanic 🤣.

Thankfully FIL was entirely capable of change, it just took the right woman...doesn't it always...

TheCatOnMorrisseysHead · 04/03/2024 13:12

I commented on your last thread but I see things have moved on. You're a better woman than me, they'd have to drag me to that wedding.

Ellie1015 · 04/03/2024 13:06

The school would upset me more. Firstly he doesn't tell you what is happening for school choices and secondly why isn't it an option for eldest? Especially as only a couple of years both there at the same time.

Gran has no right to complain about not seeing youngest alone. Has she invited her anywhere alone? Why would you amd dh visit without eldest ever???

I would go to the wedding and be pleasent in group events but opinion of them all would have changed and i would be very low contact going forward.

ChampagneLassie · 04/03/2024 13:01

Caerulea · 04/03/2024 11:34

But this is all technical BS - an actual decision is made about how that child is treated & that's where the difference lies in being good or shitty, sorry 🤷🏼‍♀️

As an example -

My eldest DS is my husbands step son. DS now has a baby. DH is now a grandad & absolutely adores his grandson. Eldest is DH son & he loves him as such. He brought him up, loved him, advocated for him as his son.

FIL got remarried a few years ago. His new wife is step-mum technically but cos we're talking adults, she's not mum to DH & is referred to by her name. None of our 3 children are related to her by blood at all. She has no children of her own & is not remotely maternal. She's a strong, independent woman & I've got a lot of respect for her. She's improved the relationship between DH & FIL no end cos he was a bit selfish & distant prior. We see them a few times a year.

HOWEVER! Entirely of her own volition she now considers herself great grandma to a child who is not even blood to her husband. She looked fit to bust when she first met DGS, just smitten & immediately referred to herself as great grandma (which really took me by surprise). They've both stepped up to help eldest & his girlf out financially, we've just handed over a beautifully wrapped gift to DGS they sent him.

Sure, no one has to feel that way but that's the difference between good, ordinary, emotionally mature people & shitty elitist ones. The former just are that way, the latter choose to be.

OPs in-laws happen to be the latter & sadly for her, so does her husband.

this post made me cry a bit. They’re better grandparents than my actual parents who seem to have very little interest. You’re right it’s just the difference of being good people

user1469032438 · 04/03/2024 12:56

I can't believe some people. I am so cross on ypur behalf ypur poor daughter :(

I have a daughter whose father has no involvement and a new husband and baby. Dd is 7 and baby is 6 months. DH has been in DDs life since she was 2. I can't imagine my husband ever doing anything like this or his family. Him and his family do not differentiate at all. It's always just daughter/granddaughter/cousin etc. And if one gets they all get.

I think I am most cross at your husband tbh, regardless of what he says he clearly does treat them/view them differently. Your youngest would be going to private school over my dead body if eldest wasn't given the same opportunity.

It was my DDs birthday recently and BIL and SIL forgot. My MIL and FIL were livid!

That is how family should be. No child should be made to feel like a second class citizen in their own family.

I hope this doesn't come across as me shouting at you OP, you have dealt with everything very well and amicably.

Jeschara · 04/03/2024 12:54

Dutchairfryer · 04/03/2024 12:33

Why would he pay for his step child’s private education?

Have a word

Could you imagine the responses if someone posted here ‘AIBU to not want to pay for my step childs private school’ everyone would be in favour of not paying

Have a word with yourself as well, look at the circumstances,they are a family, the elder daughter see's him as her Father, if the youngest is going to be privately educated the elder hould have the same opportunity, they are both the Mothers children, he should have recognised this when he married her.

I would agree with you if the stepmother had no children of her own and the Father only saw the child at the weekend, but in this case they are a family with two children not just his one.

Nanny0gg · 04/03/2024 12:51

I would be putting my foot down over the private school

Unless you only have failing secondaries near you she'd go to the catchment school

Strictlymad · 04/03/2024 12:45

You are doing the right thing, hold your head high and know you aren’t stopping to their petty level. Go to the wedding enjoy a day dressing up with your lovely girls and know you are a good person