Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Just told DH I will Divorce him over a fucking wedding Part two

716 replies

KeenHiker · 04/03/2024 09:52

https://www.mumsnet.com/talk/am_i_being_unreasonable/5018658-just-told-dh-i-will-divorce-him-over-a-fucking-wedding

I can’t believe the responses that I had.

Essentially I am going to that wedding so it won’t backfire on me and then as people have suggested reassess when everything has calmed down after Easter.

I am never going to look at MiL in the same light as she clearly thinks my daughter is an impediment to her own granddaughter.

Just told DH I will divorce him over a fucking wedding | Mumsnet

This is my first post. I think my head’s going to explode. BiL has shown no interest whatsoever in my daughters, not my eldest who isn’t my husband’...

https://www.mumsnet.com/talk/am_i_being_unreasonable/5018658-just-told-dh-i-will-divorce-him-over-a-fucking-wedding

OP posts:
OpalShimmer · 04/03/2024 17:25

InterIgnis · 04/03/2024 17:21

Or she could have asked the relevant questions, or observed what was already apparent to her, given that they never attempted to take on the roles OP seems to think they should be filling.

Of course she can, but she also has to accept that regardless of whether she’s with her husband or not, he and his family aren’t going to start considering her daughters to be equal. Whether she likes it or not the unequal dynamic exists and isn’t going to go away.

So you would have gone to DH’s parents and asked about inheritance for example?

I didn’t comment on what she has to accept, you did.

It’s important for eldest DD to know that her Mum stands up for what she believes in.

*Edit - typed DH instead of DD.

TinyYellow · 04/03/2024 17:22

I feel worst for the husband in the this story. It can’t be nice being stuck between your at home family and your biological family and all he’s getting is grief for just trying to do his best by everyone.

It was ridiculous to ever think that he shouldn’t go to his own brothers wedding, even though OP is in the right to stick up for her own dd. The husband went back to his family and got his step daughter an invitation and his wife an apology and it’s still not good enough.

This great great grandma, does the originally excluded daughter even have a relationship with her? If not, why would she want a child she barely knows in a photo of her with all her own grandchildren? Again, it’s ridiculous to think OP’s oldest daughter should be included in this.

At least the OP has recognised her own naivety is what has caused the current problem with inheritance. This is the stuff people need to think through properly before they have children with different Dad’s.

BruFord · 04/03/2024 17:21

Devilshands · 04/03/2024 16:27

It’s not what OP wants though that matters for adoption. I’m sure OP would leap at the chance tbh…

BUT ’DH’ has to want to do it…and judging by his approach, words and actions so far, he has no interest in seeing the older daughter as his own. He talks a good talk but hasn’t walked the walk (his phrasing after the initial argument/ position on schooling all tell us this). So adoption wouldn’t work. Even if he did willingly do it (doubtful IMO) it wouldn’t change his families attitudes either which is just as big an issue. It also wouldn’t automatically entitle the daughter to ‘any extras’ (school support/inheritance etc).

It’s really sad for OP and her elder daughter but there’s no fix here. It’s too broken, I think.

@Devilshands Sadly you may be right. The OP and her DH appear to have very different expectations of his role as a step-parent. I hope they can work it out, but they may not be able to. 🙁

InterIgnis · 04/03/2024 17:21

OpalShimmer · 04/03/2024 17:16

Like I said, should have got a crystal ball!

Of course as a parent you can stand up for what you believe in. Doesn’t mean everyone else will or has to agree.

Or she could have asked the relevant questions, or observed what was already apparent to her, given that they never attempted to take on the roles OP seems to think they should be filling.

Of course she can, but she also has to accept that regardless of whether she’s with her husband or not, he and his family aren’t going to start considering her daughters to be equal. Whether she likes it or not the unequal dynamic exists and isn’t going to go away.

Glenthebattleostrich · 04/03/2024 17:19

Bloody hell OP, I'd definitely be limiting your contact with his family, after all they aren't blood and apparently that means more than anything to them. In a few years time, if you are still with your husband (and after the schooling comment amongst others I'm not sure I would be), your MIL will need help and support. It certainly wouldn't be coming from me.

They are toxic to your eldest and this could make a huge rift between sisters.

Would your husband consider adopting your eldest (provided he actually becomes her dad, not just carries on treating her differently)?

OpalShimmer · 04/03/2024 17:16

InterIgnis · 04/03/2024 17:13

Presumably it’s for emphasis.

The onus was on OP, as the one responsible for her child, to find out. It isn’t anyone else’s fault that she didn’t. Now she has to deal with the reality of the situation she’s in, and she’s not going to get what she wants whether she stands up for what she believes in or not. She isn’t going to make her eldest equal to her youngest in their eyes.

Like I said, should have got a crystal ball!

Of course as a parent you can stand up for what you believe in. Doesn’t mean everyone else will or has to agree.

Surprisedbuthappy · 04/03/2024 17:16

@GasPanic I meant it's only recently become apparent on the thread - at least to me! I'm sure the OP was aware of it all along. I'm just talking about my own lightbulb moment of understanding why there are so many posters on here who are fine with the exclusion of a child from family events, such as a wedding. It's because the child must be reminded of their place.

InterIgnis · 04/03/2024 17:15

Thedance · 04/03/2024 16:57

There is more to it than that. So you need to read the first thread or at least OPs posts. Also the elder child does not have contact with her dad at all or his family. So to all intents and purposes the OPs husband is her father and his family is her family. But they are not treating her as though she is.

They’re treating her like an in law, which she is. It sounds like this has always been the case as well. It isn’t their fault that she doesn’t have a relationship with her paternal family, and they don’t have to step in as surrogates.

InterIgnis · 04/03/2024 17:13

OpalShimmer · 04/03/2024 17:07

Firstly, why the capitals? Can you not write like everyone else or are your responses more important?

Secondly, “If you didn’t know, that’s your doing”, if she didn’t know, then she didn’t know. What was she meant to do? Pull a crystal ball out of her pocket?!

OP, ignore this over-use of capitals MNer. Keep standing up for what you believe in…

Presumably it’s for emphasis.

The onus was on OP, as the one responsible for her child, to find out. It isn’t anyone else’s fault that she didn’t. Now she has to deal with the reality of the situation she’s in, and she’s not going to get what she wants whether she stands up for what she believes in or not. She isn’t going to make her eldest equal to her youngest in their eyes.

GasPanic · 04/03/2024 17:10

Surprisedbuthappy · 04/03/2024 16:55

Yes, but the extent of the money discrepancy has only really come into it recently. Initially it was about an invitation to a wedding (or lack of one). I hadn't realised that the reason people might be so cruel to a 10-year old child is to deliberately keep them at a distance so as to protect their own financial interests. It doesn't make it any less cruel, but it makes more sense to me now. It's just rich people doing rich people things.

Really has it only come into it recently ? I think it has more likely been there all along. People don't change opinions on this sort of stuff quickly. It's the wedding invitation that has really made the OP think about these things and the spiraling consequences such as education and inheritance (which are actually much bigger deals than the lack of wedding invitation) when they hadn't really thought about them before.

And no, I don't believe keeping the step child away from the wedding is "to protect their own financial interests". Because whether they invite them to the wedding or not has absolutely zero impact on what they chose to do with their money in the future. I don't believe it was organised to protect their family wealth because it was never under threat from taking that action anyway. It was just probably an accident because all the step children were considered the same and they didn't think initially about the impact of leaving the child out.

Giving cash directly to their grand daughter and bypassing their son, that could be realistically described as "protecting the family wealth". Not not inviting someone to a wedding.

Rich people protect their money because they have some. Poor people don't because they don't have any to protect.

OpalShimmer · 04/03/2024 17:07

shenandoahvalley · 04/03/2024 14:12

I commented a couple of times on the first thread.

Your DH and in-laws are telling you LOUD AND CLEAR who and what they are. It's astonishing to me that you didn't figure this out before you brought your eldest into this situation. That strikes me as extremely irresponsible, and not good parenting. The inheritance around your flat/his house would have rung alarm bells with me; surely you would have talked through things like money and inheritance and education and the family home??

They're allowed to have a different view on step-children from you, of course they are. But YOU CHOSE to marry into this family. YOU did this. If you didn't know, that's YOUR doing. You can bitch and moan about them all you like but that doesn't change anything - and you're certainly not going to change them.

Firstly, why the capitals? Can you not write like everyone else or are your responses more important?

Secondly, “If you didn’t know, that’s your doing”, if she didn’t know, then she didn’t know. What was she meant to do? Pull a crystal ball out of her pocket?!

OP, ignore this over-use of capitals MNer. Keep standing up for what you believe in…

PhoenixStarbeamer · 04/03/2024 17:03

I don't think you can get mad that they're treating her like his step daughter and not his daughter. You can't expect a whole family to want to have a step child in the family photo with the great grandmother. That's a precious keepsake. Or expect them to want a step child to be flower girl. Or to save for a step child. They've invited her now, deep breath and move on. You being awkward will cause more of a divide.

Caerulea · 04/03/2024 17:02

Surprisedbuthappy · 04/03/2024 16:55

Yes, but the extent of the money discrepancy has only really come into it recently. Initially it was about an invitation to a wedding (or lack of one). I hadn't realised that the reason people might be so cruel to a 10-year old child is to deliberately keep them at a distance so as to protect their own financial interests. It doesn't make it any less cruel, but it makes more sense to me now. It's just rich people doing rich people things.

Saved me the effort of writing that out, thank you

Cornishclio · 04/03/2024 17:02

I was in the camp of you being unreasonable after SIL backtracked and invited your eldest. Now I am not so sure as treating both girls differently financially with private school for one and not the other and your MIL asking for time alone with just one seems very unkind to your eldest and quite unnecessary. You cannot make extended family feel the same way about a child who has no biological link to them but they seem to be going out of their way to show how they perceive her and at 10 she will notice this, I think they sound horrible and not sure about your DH either.

Thedance · 04/03/2024 16:57

SecondUsername4me · 04/03/2024 10:24

I'm a bit confused as am late to this - am I right in thinking the SIL (bride) invited you, dh and your shared child to her wedding, but didn't invite your child? And then when dh raised it with her she apologised, extended an invite and said she hadn't realised that your dd would have been with you and not her dad that weekend?

There is more to it than that. So you need to read the first thread or at least OPs posts. Also the elder child does not have contact with her dad at all or his family. So to all intents and purposes the OPs husband is her father and his family is her family. But they are not treating her as though she is.

Surprisedbuthappy · 04/03/2024 16:55

GasPanic · 04/03/2024 16:41

Well if there wasn't any money then there wouldn't be a problem in the first place.

Both children would be treated equally going forwards. Neither would have any significant inheritance in the future and neither would be going to private school.

It can only arise if one side has money and the other doesn't.

Yes, but the extent of the money discrepancy has only really come into it recently. Initially it was about an invitation to a wedding (or lack of one). I hadn't realised that the reason people might be so cruel to a 10-year old child is to deliberately keep them at a distance so as to protect their own financial interests. It doesn't make it any less cruel, but it makes more sense to me now. It's just rich people doing rich people things.

Whiskyinajar · 04/03/2024 16:53

My brother remarried and took on a four year old child. That child has been part of our family from day 1, he's now in his teens with a little sister. My Mum and Das have never differentiated. Both are their grandchildren and I am auntie to both. I would never exclude the older child, he's one of us and can count on us to have his best interests at heart in everything.

We celebrate his birthdays, Xmas and I even gave him £20 on his sisters birthday recently. He likes gaming and all teens enjoy a bit of in app purchasing. He comes along to all family celebrations.and my Mum adores her grandson.

ohthejoys21 · 04/03/2024 16:48

superplumb · 04/03/2024 16:00

I believe if you marry someone you become part of that child's life as do the family. If they can't manage that they can sod off. I'd leave. I'd take all my kids and leave. What a weird bloody family. Protect your daughter, she needs you too. Make a choice and choose her.

I wouldn't expect the dh's parents to feel the same for the step child as they do for their own but would expect them to make as best an effort as they can so the older dd feels no different.

I would however find it unreasonable to expect them to leave her any inheritance.

GasPanic · 04/03/2024 16:41

Caerulea · 04/03/2024 15:56

Nailed it. It absolutely is a class thing & mumsnet is largely the last place this kind of thing would be admitted..

Well if there wasn't any money then there wouldn't be a problem in the first place.

Both children would be treated equally going forwards. Neither would have any significant inheritance in the future and neither would be going to private school.

It can only arise if one side has money and the other doesn't.

Bananasandtoast · 04/03/2024 16:40

In defence of MIL... There are so many threads where the advice to a SM is to accept that every weekend their DH will be off with his older kids as they need time to bond without younger half siblings around. Very important.
Is it so very difficult to imagine that MIL might want time to focus on her own DGC?
I like to have one to one time with my own kids sometimes as each is absolutely an "impediment" in his own way as their ages/stages/needs are often in conflict. Do you never do this with your girls?

InterIgnis · 04/03/2024 16:38

WaitingForMojo · 04/03/2024 15:35

Those of you accusing the op of depriving her youngest of her rightful inheritance/ privileges in life, what would you want in dd2’s shoes? Because i wouldn’t want a huge inheritance that my sister didn’t have. In fact, as an adult i would try to split it without her ever knowing she hadn’t inherited, if that were possible.

Creating an unequal dynamic and permanently playing these girls off against each other could create lifelong resentment that isn’t a good thing for either child. Being the golden child isn’t great either. I really don’t think it’s a case of depriving dd2 of anything.

I don’t think my dc would want to be flower girl at a wedding that their sibling had been left out of, either. That would taint it for them, not the mum’s behaviour.

I wouldn’t want to be denied opportunities in the name of ‘making things fair’, no. If my parent had decided to do that, I would not be thanking them, and it’s unlikely that our relationship would be a positive one. There have been countless threads on here about this being done, and the damage that has been caused in the name of ‘not doing damage’.

An unequal dynamic already exists. Pretending it doesn’t won’t change that. You don’t avoid resentment by denying someone opportunities open to them.

OP may not approve of her youngest going to private school, and if she and her husband continue to disagree it could end up in the hands of a judge.

Nevermind31 · 04/03/2024 16:34

My question to OH would be…. If we separated, would you be happy for DD2 to be treated like this by my new OH’s family/ your new OH’s family?

LocalHobo · 04/03/2024 16:29

Her sense of entitlement to other people’s money to pay for her elder child or to totally screw over the younger girl is hideous.
Surely the husband just needs to adopt the elder DD? Then she will be fully integrated with his family. We have heard her bio-father (sorry) is uninvolved.
If I were the PIL and adoption had not been mentioned I may well think my son had a reason for this omission.
Either they're family or they aren't and so far, they aren't.

Devilshands · 04/03/2024 16:27

BruFord · 04/03/2024 16:20

Also, why would OP wanted the husband to adopt the daughter - who he’s been very clear he doesn’t see as his own?

@Devilshands My impression from the OP’s posts has suggested that she does want her DH to treat the two girls exactly the same and be their Dad in every sense as her eldest’s bio Dad is completely uninvolved. Adoption would place them on an equal legal footing as he’d then have PR for both DD’s and send a clear message to his family and her DD.

That’s why some posters (myself included) are suggesting adoption. Did you get a different impression from the OP’s posts? Genuine, non-goady question.

Obviously if she doesn’t want him to have PR, that’s fine.

It’s not what OP wants though that matters for adoption. I’m sure OP would leap at the chance tbh…

BUT ’DH’ has to want to do it…and judging by his approach, words and actions so far, he has no interest in seeing the older daughter as his own. He talks a good talk but hasn’t walked the walk (his phrasing after the initial argument/ position on schooling all tell us this). So adoption wouldn’t work. Even if he did willingly do it (doubtful IMO) it wouldn’t change his families attitudes either which is just as big an issue. It also wouldn’t automatically entitle the daughter to ‘any extras’ (school support/inheritance etc).

It’s really sad for OP and her elder daughter but there’s no fix here. It’s too broken, I think.

BruFord · 04/03/2024 16:20

Also, why would OP wanted the husband to adopt the daughter - who he’s been very clear he doesn’t see as his own?

@Devilshands My impression from the OP’s posts has suggested that she does want her DH to treat the two girls exactly the same and be their Dad in every sense as her eldest’s bio Dad is completely uninvolved. Adoption would place them on an equal legal footing as he’d then have PR for both DD’s and send a clear message to his family and her DD.

That’s why some posters (myself included) are suggesting adoption. Did you get a different impression from the OP’s posts? Genuine, non-goady question.

Obviously if she doesn’t want him to have PR, that’s fine.

Swipe left for the next trending thread