Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Just told DH I will Divorce him over a fucking wedding Part two

716 replies

KeenHiker · 04/03/2024 09:52

https://www.mumsnet.com/talk/am_i_being_unreasonable/5018658-just-told-dh-i-will-divorce-him-over-a-fucking-wedding

I can’t believe the responses that I had.

Essentially I am going to that wedding so it won’t backfire on me and then as people have suggested reassess when everything has calmed down after Easter.

I am never going to look at MiL in the same light as she clearly thinks my daughter is an impediment to her own granddaughter.

Just told DH I will divorce him over a fucking wedding | Mumsnet

This is my first post. I think my head’s going to explode. BiL has shown no interest whatsoever in my daughters, not my eldest who isn’t my husband’...

https://www.mumsnet.com/talk/am_i_being_unreasonable/5018658-just-told-dh-i-will-divorce-him-over-a-fucking-wedding

OP posts:
HollyKnight · 04/03/2024 18:22

People need to stop suggesting adoption as a solution. He doesn't want her to be his daughter. He doesn't see her as his daughter. All that was required of him was to treat her well, which the OP says he has up until this point. As far as he is concerned, he has one child, and that one child is who will inherit from him and his family. You can't expect his family to see her - and treat her - as more than he does.

Justkeeepswimming · 04/03/2024 18:18

NotThatWitty · 04/03/2024 15:04

He maintains that he loves her but can’t make others treat her the same.

He is correct here, he can't. However, it doesn't seem like he is treating your DDs the same either. Insisting that DD2 go to private school while DD1 will still be in state school. I'm assuming at this point DD1 will be around 15-16? She will be at an age where she will be both hormonal, but also old enough to understand the difference and feel it. This could potentially lead to resentment.

Your DH sounds like the type who insists he 'stepped up and brought DD1 up as his own', but who in reality hasn't, and then he will wonder why DD1 doesn't ask him to walk her down the aisle on her wedding day, and have a sulk about it.

@NotThatWitty

If they were full siblings and he had parental responsibility for the elder daughter then you might have a point….

But he is not her father and is not responsible for paying for her education.

If her mother wants her to have the same as her sister then maybe she and the father should work for it.

Surprisedbuthappy · 04/03/2024 18:18

@shenandoahvalley Thank you for the response! I do understand your way of seeing it now. I personally couldn't be the mother who agreed to such a mismatch in my own children's opportunities though. That's why I feel more sorry for the OP than the husband. If he had two biological children, he wouldn't seriously suggest just one of them goes to private school because they can't afford it for both, so it's simply not true that he treats the eldest as his own.

GrumpyPanda · 04/03/2024 18:15

Ponoka7 · 04/03/2024 15:46

Actually there's been a few threads were SM post about not wanting to do school runs, care or even extend to asking their family who are doing care/runs anyway and the replies are always in favour of it not being the SM's responsibility or that her family don't have to know her SC. There's a lot of projection on this site.

Completely different situation. All of these are threads where the birth mother is very much in the picture, has majority or 50:50 residency and yet both parents see fit to offload their parental responsibilities onto the SM, usually last minute and/or on the mum's time. (But God forbid the SM does any actual parenting, such ad reprimanding DSC for misbehaving in the SM's own home.)

Frisate · 04/03/2024 18:10

I am really sorry for what you and your daughter are going through OP. No one decided to grow up feeling left out and like the black sheep of the family. Take care of yourself and your daughter, she has her entire life ahead of her and you have the power to ensure that those people won’t leave her scared. You’re in control and you dictate what’s to come, I’m sure you’ll make the right decision. All the best to the both of you 🌺

shenandoahvalley · 04/03/2024 18:08

Surprisedbuthappy · 04/03/2024 17:54

Eh? So poor old husband gets to make the choice himself about youngest child's schooling and doesn't care what her mother thinks about it?

In the case of your two friends, do the children live with them full-time? Did they ever say they would treat the step children as their own?

The DH doesn't get to make the decision unilaterally, the youngest girl is both of theirs. But I wouldn't want to be the mother who denies one child a better (assuming it is better, of course) education just because the eldest can't have it. I'd probably tear myself apart trying to make up for it some other way with the eldest. Not a nice situation to be in.

For the friend whose SD left school at 16 because she was pg: he never undertook to parent the SD because she was old enough to have a say herself. She moved out shortly after the baby was born (as is happens, within a few weeks of when my friend's second DC was born). The SD and her now primary-school aged son live a 10 minute walk from the SD's half siblings (the youngest of whom is the same age as her own son). The contrast between the two families couldn't be more stark, though. It's a terrible situation, for everyone, and I dread what the future holds because the differences are only going to grow. The SD is now in her mid-20s, and yes she is somewhat resentful but she also knows none of this was planned, it's just the way the cookie crumbled. The worst part is that her son goes to the local (terrible) state primary; her half siblings (same age as her son and younger) go to the local, amazing, private feeder school. The consequences of this could be felt for decades and into the next generation.

For the other couple: on a day to day level, the dad treats them all the same. He has 3 kids in the house and does the same for all of them on a day to day level. The age gap means that now that the eldest is starting GCSEs in state school, the youngest (by the same mum + new step dad) are coming towards the end of primary in private. The eldest is smart and, tragically, could have really availed of the excellent opportunities the younger two benefit from. But, the mum has prostrated herself to foster a full and busy life for the eldest outside of school and separate from the younger ones. The SD picks up more than 50% of duties for his own DC to allow her to do this. The SD has been given (and dealt very maturely with) a lot of responsibility and freedom from a young age. She's lovely, really. I mean you never know what goes on behind closed doors, but to the outside observer she's just a lovely teenager. Her mother couldn't be more proud of her, and it shows.

SomeCatFromJapan · 04/03/2024 18:07

I honestly think I'd be tempted to divorce rather than subject my child to growing up feeling like an outcast and a second class citizen.

BruFord · 04/03/2024 18:01

InterIgnis · 04/03/2024 17:54

Then that’s on you 🤷🏻‍♀️ being in love and happy doesn’t negate the fact that it’s your responsibility to find out these things, especially if you’re also responsible for a child that will be impacted by your choices.

I imagine it’s easy to not think about these things if you don’t have assets, but when you do (or are marrying someone who does) they require consideration. I spoke about finances with my now husband, and our finances included family wealth on both sides - hence we spoke about it.

@InterIgnis Oh I agree, I was definitely young and daft when I met my DH! I hope that I’d have been more thoughtful if I’d had a child to consider.

That’s why the OP and her DH need to talk all this through now.

Surprisedbuthappy · 04/03/2024 18:01

TinyYellow · 04/03/2024 17:48

Yes, OP said her older daughter doesn’t know anything about the invitation so all this is passing her by and she’s fine. She has a mother that is clearly passionate about protecting her feelings so she’ll be more than fine.

OP has said herself that she doesn’t see a difference in how he treats her two children so she got exactly what she signed up for when she married and chose to have another child. She also said she knew there was money in the family and she made wrong assumptions about how that money would end up filtering down. So no, I definitely don’t feel bad for the OP. She sounds like she’s gone crazily over the top with her resentment towards her MIL who has done nothing wrong and the poor old lady who just wants a picture of her with her own descendants.

It's about way more than the wedding now and I'm absolutely sure all this isn't passing her by! She will be aware of the massive discrepancy in the way she's treated and the way her younger sister is treated - and that will get more and more obvious as time goes on.

I think it's very contradictory of OP to say she doesn't see a difference in how her husband treats the two girls, given the private school conversation! Quite clearly he doesn't see or treat eldest as his own!

I think MIL was quite cruel to complain that she never sees her granddaughter without her sister there - like the poor girl's mere presence is somehow detrimental to her relationship with her grandchild, so I disagree that MIL has done nothing wrong.

I think the photo with the old lady is a bit of a red herring and not something I'd be too focused on personally. There are far bigger issues going on here.

InterIgnis · 04/03/2024 17:54

BruFord · 04/03/2024 17:49

@InterIgnis It’s definitely a good idea to discuss family assets, but let’s be honest, when you’re in love and happy, you often don’t think about all that. I certainly didn’t when I met my DH!

The OP and her DH need to have a good talk about their family and see whether they can work things out. Clearly they’ve had mismatched expectations up to now.

Then that’s on you 🤷🏻‍♀️ being in love and happy doesn’t negate the fact that it’s your responsibility to find out these things, especially if you’re also responsible for a child that will be impacted by your choices.

I imagine it’s easy to not think about these things if you don’t have assets, but when you do (or are marrying someone who does) they require consideration. I spoke about finances with my now husband, and our finances included family wealth on both sides - hence we spoke about it.

Surprisedbuthappy · 04/03/2024 17:54

shenandoahvalley · 04/03/2024 17:46

This is the same man who, when his biological child came on the scene, had him and his wife draw up wills that left different things and amounts to each child, fully aware that his own DD was going to get more. (OP hasn't said that's what the timeline was, but seeing how old the youngest is and when the wills were drawn up, seems like a fair assumption).

I don't know that the DH has said OP should be fine with her youngest going to private school and the eldest not. She hasn't said. I suspect it won't matter to him decisively one way or the other (and this whole education thing is quite a quandry for OP). I have two friends in so-called blended families who have bio children in private schools, step-kids not. One has a very similar age gap, one has a much larger one so less of an issue. As parents, they both consider that they're working hard to provide for their children, and that their step-DC have two parents who can also choose to work hard to provide for their children (or not) as they please. How can you argue with that?

Nobody is denying that it would be wonderful if all children are treated equally, everywhere. That's just not life: not in nuclear families, not amongst full-cousins, not in blended families, in families in the same street/community/neighbourhood/city/country - anywhere. OP has decided to raise her two DDs at the fault lines of these divisions <shrug>. This is what happens.

Eh? So poor old husband gets to make the choice himself about youngest child's schooling and doesn't care what her mother thinks about it?

In the case of your two friends, do the children live with them full-time? Did they ever say they would treat the step children as their own?

shenandoahvalley · 04/03/2024 17:53

OpalShimmer · 04/03/2024 17:43

“Hey, I’m considering marrying your son, what inheritance would we due to receive?”

😂🤦🏻‍♀️

I agree with you.

More realistically:

"Hey, fiancé, seeing as we're getting married and we both know we want kids, we should probably have a conversation about money. Obviously I've twigged by now that your family is minted, and you know mine isn't and obviously you know about DD. How do you envisage things shaking down in the future as between DD and any future kids we might have together? Do we both think I'm going to continue working or will one of us be a SAHP? What if one of us gets seriously sick, who's going to look after DD and any future kids? What would happen to my and our kids if one of us dies early? What about if we break up? 50% of marriages end in divorce, after all, and you know I've been there once before. I can't handle going through all that again, I really want to be clear on what the future might hold. I don't care what your answers are to these questions, I just need to know so I can make informed decisions."

That's really not a million miles from the conversations I had with DH many moons ago. It's not that hard.

OhmygodDont · 04/03/2024 17:52

Her oldest was never going to inherit from her dh and thus never from his family.

Going out on a limb most people don’t suddenly decide to go to private school unless it’s new money so I’m going to assume the ops dh and his family members have been though private school so should be no surprise again that he would want his child too.

You’ve got two children with a five year age gap would it not also be easy to see that maybe some things even if they where biological full siblings be 1 on 1 to fit the age better. Again it’s not the little ones fault that the older siblings family are shit and nor should she be denied a good strong relationship with a family who clearly love her. They are not looking to ban the older the gps just want some one on one with the little. I don’t see the ultimate harm here.

10 isn’t a baby nor a teen but it’s old enough to be able to have some things explained.

BruFord · 04/03/2024 17:49

@InterIgnis It’s definitely a good idea to discuss family assets, but let’s be honest, when you’re in love and happy, you often don’t think about all that. I certainly didn’t when I met my DH!

The OP and her DH need to have a good talk about their family and see whether they can work things out. Clearly they’ve had mismatched expectations up to now.

TinyYellow · 04/03/2024 17:48

Surprisedbuthappy · 04/03/2024 17:32

You feel the worst for the husband - not the 10-year old child who was left out and is being made out to be a burden on her stepfather's entire family? Not the OP who married a man who claimed he'd treat her daughter like his own, but now says she should be absolutely fine with one of her daughters going to an expensive private school, while the other is denied that opportunity?

Yes, OP said her older daughter doesn’t know anything about the invitation so all this is passing her by and she’s fine. She has a mother that is clearly passionate about protecting her feelings so she’ll be more than fine.

OP has said herself that she doesn’t see a difference in how he treats her two children so she got exactly what she signed up for when she married and chose to have another child. She also said she knew there was money in the family and she made wrong assumptions about how that money would end up filtering down. So no, I definitely don’t feel bad for the OP. She sounds like she’s gone crazily over the top with her resentment towards her MIL who has done nothing wrong and the poor old lady who just wants a picture of her with her own descendants.

InterIgnis · 04/03/2024 17:47

OpalShimmer · 04/03/2024 17:43

“Hey, I’m considering marrying your son, what inheritance would we due to receive?”

😂🤦🏻‍♀️

I agree with you.

Or, “hey, husband to be - what role do your parents envisage taking in regards my child? If we have children, I’m concerned about them not being considered equal to one another, and one being at a comparable disadvantage”

shenandoahvalley · 04/03/2024 17:46

Surprisedbuthappy · 04/03/2024 17:32

You feel the worst for the husband - not the 10-year old child who was left out and is being made out to be a burden on her stepfather's entire family? Not the OP who married a man who claimed he'd treat her daughter like his own, but now says she should be absolutely fine with one of her daughters going to an expensive private school, while the other is denied that opportunity?

This is the same man who, when his biological child came on the scene, had him and his wife draw up wills that left different things and amounts to each child, fully aware that his own DD was going to get more. (OP hasn't said that's what the timeline was, but seeing how old the youngest is and when the wills were drawn up, seems like a fair assumption).

I don't know that the DH has said OP should be fine with her youngest going to private school and the eldest not. She hasn't said. I suspect it won't matter to him decisively one way or the other (and this whole education thing is quite a quandry for OP). I have two friends in so-called blended families who have bio children in private schools, step-kids not. One has a very similar age gap, one has a much larger one so less of an issue. As parents, they both consider that they're working hard to provide for their children, and that their step-DC have two parents who can also choose to work hard to provide for their children (or not) as they please. How can you argue with that?

Nobody is denying that it would be wonderful if all children are treated equally, everywhere. That's just not life: not in nuclear families, not amongst full-cousins, not in blended families, in families in the same street/community/neighbourhood/city/country - anywhere. OP has decided to raise her two DDs at the fault lines of these divisions <shrug>. This is what happens.

JuicyOrange01 · 04/03/2024 17:43

You know what OP looking at this entirely objectively with no emotions, I get all sides (other than not invited dd1 but the rest of her family wtf?). But I understood the differences between the in-laws in treatment of the dds.

HOWEVER

I then looked at my own dd and imagined her being treated like this and I immediately felt rage and out for blood!
Infact so much so rereading your thread imagining it was my DD little face watching her sister going out with grandma and going to private schools and watching the family fawn over her whilst she looked on, with no one but me to love/treat her, omg I was practically imagining myself signing those divorce papers.

Objectively no one’s wrong, but subjectively I’d be causing havoc.

sorry there’s no advice but I feel you.

OpalShimmer · 04/03/2024 17:43

BruFord · 04/03/2024 17:38

@OpalShimmer Can you imagine the conversation with your new in-laws?! 😂

Tbh, I would be surprised if a step-grandchild (not adopted) inherited significantly from those grandparents. As I said upthread, I didn’t inherit from my step-Mum and neither did my children.

“Hey, I’m considering marrying your son, what inheritance would we due to receive?”

😂🤦🏻‍♀️

I agree with you.

InterIgnis · 04/03/2024 17:40

OpalShimmer · 04/03/2024 17:36

Well your approach would be very different to one I’d take and that’s fine.

I would never ask in-laws about inheritance or ask DH to. I think that would come across as ‘grabby’.

Yet she did know that her eldest was not in line to inherit from either her in laws or her husband, and accepted that this would be the situation.

In my experience is normal to discuss expectations in regards to family assets, particularly if they’re substantial. It’s better to know where you stand than it is to assume incorrectly. I imagine this is especially true if it involves a child.

BruFord · 04/03/2024 17:38

@OpalShimmer Can you imagine the conversation with your new in-laws?! 😂

Tbh, I would be surprised if a step-grandchild (not adopted) inherited significantly from those grandparents. As I said upthread, I didn’t inherit from my step-Mum and neither did my children.

OpalShimmer · 04/03/2024 17:36

InterIgnis · 04/03/2024 17:30

I would have asked him, yes. She could have asked them what relationship they expected to have with her daughter (or again, you know, used her eyes on that one). It isn’t exactly hard to anticipate that these are issues that are likely to arise in blended families, particularly when it comes to significant differences in wealth.

tbf it appears she did ask him, and she did accept that her eldest wasn’t considered their grandchild, the same as she accepted that her husband wasn’t going to include her in his will. OP did in fact know that they were not considered to be equal.

Edited

Well your approach would be very different to one I’d take and that’s fine.

I would never ask in-laws about inheritance or ask DH to. I think that would come across as ‘grabby’.

Surprisedbuthappy · 04/03/2024 17:32

TinyYellow · 04/03/2024 17:22

I feel worst for the husband in the this story. It can’t be nice being stuck between your at home family and your biological family and all he’s getting is grief for just trying to do his best by everyone.

It was ridiculous to ever think that he shouldn’t go to his own brothers wedding, even though OP is in the right to stick up for her own dd. The husband went back to his family and got his step daughter an invitation and his wife an apology and it’s still not good enough.

This great great grandma, does the originally excluded daughter even have a relationship with her? If not, why would she want a child she barely knows in a photo of her with all her own grandchildren? Again, it’s ridiculous to think OP’s oldest daughter should be included in this.

At least the OP has recognised her own naivety is what has caused the current problem with inheritance. This is the stuff people need to think through properly before they have children with different Dad’s.

You feel the worst for the husband - not the 10-year old child who was left out and is being made out to be a burden on her stepfather's entire family? Not the OP who married a man who claimed he'd treat her daughter like his own, but now says she should be absolutely fine with one of her daughters going to an expensive private school, while the other is denied that opportunity?

InterIgnis · 04/03/2024 17:30

OpalShimmer · 04/03/2024 17:25

So you would have gone to DH’s parents and asked about inheritance for example?

I didn’t comment on what she has to accept, you did.

It’s important for eldest DD to know that her Mum stands up for what she believes in.

*Edit - typed DH instead of DD.

Edited

I would have asked him, yes. She could have asked them what relationship they expected to have with her daughter (or again, you know, used her eyes on that one). It isn’t exactly hard to anticipate that these are issues that are likely to arise in blended families, particularly when it comes to significant differences in wealth.

tbf it appears she did ask him, and she did accept that her eldest wasn’t considered their grandchild, the same as she accepted that her husband wasn’t going to include her in his will. OP did in fact know that they were not considered to be equal.

WimpoleHat · 04/03/2024 17:29

I think what makes this situation so awfully difficult is how close the girls are in age. I don’t believe in there being “one right way” for these things to be dealt with; all families differ. “Blood” matters far more to some people than others. These things can generally be navigated with a bit of decency on all sides. But the problem here is that these girls are being brought up in a nuclear family unit - but seemingly without the support of the extended family for that. And that’s awfully hard - because, much as OP might wish her in-laws to see her older DD as “one of them”, they pretty obviously don’t. An older child (or a child with her “own” paternal family) could cope with that a lot more easily - but it’s a heck of a thing for a child of 10 to come to terms with. But what to do for the best? If OP leaves her DH it doesn’t improve the situation for her older DD in any way and probably means that she loses that father figure. But it can’t be easy to stay and feel that your own child is somehow lesser or rejected. Very tricky situation all round.

Swipe left for the next trending thread