Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Just told DH I will Divorce him over a fucking wedding Part two

716 replies

KeenHiker · 04/03/2024 09:52

https://www.mumsnet.com/talk/am_i_being_unreasonable/5018658-just-told-dh-i-will-divorce-him-over-a-fucking-wedding

I can’t believe the responses that I had.

Essentially I am going to that wedding so it won’t backfire on me and then as people have suggested reassess when everything has calmed down after Easter.

I am never going to look at MiL in the same light as she clearly thinks my daughter is an impediment to her own granddaughter.

Just told DH I will divorce him over a fucking wedding | Mumsnet

This is my first post. I think my head’s going to explode. BiL has shown no interest whatsoever in my daughters, not my eldest who isn’t my husband’...

https://www.mumsnet.com/talk/am_i_being_unreasonable/5018658-just-told-dh-i-will-divorce-him-over-a-fucking-wedding

OP posts:
Justkeeepswimming · 05/03/2024 09:11

Surprisedbuthappy · 05/03/2024 09:07

@Justkeeepswimming The point is that sending both girls to the school the couple can afford without help from the in-laws is not causing some kind of severe deprivation to the younger girl.

@Surprisedbuthappy

It separates her out from her cousins and paternal family, it takes away opportunities to focus on a broader range of subjects, to engage more fully with her interests earlier in a more supportive environment, it takes away important social contacts and opportunities, and more support to get into top universities….

The elder girl even if he pays for her to go to the private school doesn’t have the social standing and financial backup to make the most of it - the younger does, so why take it away from her, it’s bananas.

Surprisedbuthappy · 05/03/2024 09:10

Justkeeepswimming · 05/03/2024 09:08

@Surprisedbuthappy

He is not her father.

Then he shouldn't be claiming to treat her as his own! He should own who he is and who his family are and be upfront with OP.

Justkeeepswimming · 05/03/2024 09:08

Surprisedbuthappy · 05/03/2024 09:04

@InterIgnis Such clear displays of favouritism and othering is not treating her well and do not make him a good father figure.

@Surprisedbuthappy

He is not her father.

Surprisedbuthappy · 05/03/2024 09:07

@Justkeeepswimming The point is that sending both girls to the school the couple can afford without help from the in-laws is not causing some kind of severe deprivation to the younger girl.

InterIgnis · 05/03/2024 09:06

Surprisedbuthappy · 05/03/2024 09:04

@InterIgnis Such clear displays of favouritism and othering is not treating her well and do not make him a good father figure.

Op is the one that said it, take it up with her if you’ve got an issue with the descriptor 🤷🏻‍♀️

GasPanic · 05/03/2024 09:05

Surprisedbuthappy · 05/03/2024 08:27

This thread has been so enlightening! The moneyed people here have made it perfectly clear that money - and all the advantages that brings such as a private education - is either yours by absolute birthright, or it isn't.

Yet rich people often claim that poor people are poor because they don't work hard enough or because of some moral failing on their part.

They create a world of have-gots and have-nots and then blame the have-nots for not having.

I think all the "what class am I" type threads should be directed here. It's a real eye-opener!

Somewhat missing the point though in the gross generalisation made that your money is your money, to do with what you want.

You can give it to your family, your extended family, the cats home or save the whale. There are lots of good causes out there.

But it is your choice what to do with it, not the choice of other people to decide for you. No matter how good or equitable they think their decisions or causes might be.

Surprisedbuthappy · 05/03/2024 09:04

@InterIgnis Such clear displays of favouritism and othering is not treating her well and do not make him a good father figure.

Justkeeepswimming · 05/03/2024 09:02

@Surprisedbuthappy

The whole point here is that while DH has promised to love and provide for elder daughter…. That should not be to the detriment of his own daughter.

You cannot validate damaging a younger child to try and resolve the mental health of the elder. She is always going to have problems - she doesn’t have her nuclear family, her father has taken off, her paternal relatives are a disaster and her mother is evidently completely reliant on her husband and his insta-family on sorting out whatever mess she finds herself in.

Surprisedbuthappy · 05/03/2024 08:57

WillYouPutYourCoatOn · 05/03/2024 08:40

That's ridiculous hyperbole.

Asking to spend some one to one time with a five year old, because you haven't done so for over two years, is perfectly normal. "Oh, the poor eldest for simply existing" FFS Hmm

I have twins. DM is taking girl twin out for something on Wednesday. Just girl twin. I will give her a call later and tell her how awful she is for clearly resenting boy twin even exists, she obviously thinks he stands in the way of her and girl twin. How dare she want to spend time with one child. She must have both, on every occasion, no exceptions.

Still, OP with her threats of divorce is probably going to end up with this situation anyway. All it will do is stop the unrelated family having to deal with her entitlement and demanding they act a certain way, so they'll probably be up for that anyway.

I agree with PP, she saw this DH and his family as her ship coming in. But they saw it differently. And she can't tantrum her way into changing what they are in every right to do.

She needs to put the energy into building a relationship with "crying gran"... She just doesn't want to, because crying gran doesn't benefit her. She wants an instant extended family. And this one is supportive to each other, wealthy, she wants in. You can see why, she's had nothing paternally for years. They however, don't want that. They're happy to be inclusive to a point (a much higher point than the people who should be!) but OP doesn't acknowledge that at all. She just complains she wants more. Not her choice.

Your twins' situation has nothing to do with it. It's not a one-off occurrence of wanting to take the five-year old to an event without her sister just to spend some one-on-one time together, is it? It's an overall pattern of behaviour and attitudes from the whole family that demonstrates that the older girl is completely unimportant to them. She will pick up on that and it will be awful for her to grow up with that knowledge.

I do agree with you and others that the relationship with the in-laws can't be forced though. They cannot be forced to love her as one of their own, nor did they ever claim to. OP's husband did though.

Justkeeepswimming · 05/03/2024 08:53

@Surprisedbuthappy

Right now the elder daughter has self esteem issues with potential mental health complications because of her broken family dynamic, the failure of her father to provide both emotionally and financially, and the failure of her paternal relatives to interact well and her mother to support positive interactions with paternal relatives.

You are suggesting that to compensate for this and to make the older girl feel better about her circumstances in life that the younger girls paternal relationships (which are healthy and hugely beneficial) be damaged and that she should suffer financial and educational hardship - leading to her having low self esteem, potential mental health issues and a problematic relationship not only with paternal relatives but also her entire nuclear family who’ve created the mess.

So you suggest have one disturbed child, create another for free!!

To deny the younger her family and opportunities will create more problems for both girls and won’t deal with what is actually wrong for the elder - issues relative to her parents - NOT the DH and family.

As for your comments regarding people with money - there are many people who achieve well and have good careers who come from working class backgrounds. My grandparents were both working class - they achieved well in school and then decided to send their offspring to private education and so it continued. We don’t send our DC to private as the school nearest us rates higher than the local private schools so no point. In some areas it is more important than others. The whole point is, if the money is available via hard work or inheritance, why on earth wouldn’t you send your child, particularly if it is normalised in the family.

The DH contributes massively to the elder daughter’s life. But major costs should be paid by her actual parents. It’s unreasonable to leech off others to the extent you are suggesting.

InterIgnis · 05/03/2024 08:50

Surprisedbuthappy · 05/03/2024 08:03

He is treating treating her like a second-class citizen. He knew about the rubbish biological father when he married OP and made promises to care for her daughter as his own. Such obvious favouritism towards the younger girl as allowing his family to leave her out of family events like weddings, and paying for her sister to receive private education while she is denied it, will cause her massive self-esteem issues. It's a one-way ticket to years of therapy (at best) - possibly harmful ways of coping at worst. He simply wouldn't do that to a child he loved equally. A bunch of strangers on an anonymous internet forum are more concerned about her welfare than he is!

Oh, and if he's not the one offering to pay for the younger girl's education, then he should be saying to his parents (or whoever is) "that's very generous of you but I have two daughters and I can't expect you to pay for both, so both our girls will be going to X school". And OP should never have been excluded from the discussion as her opinion of where her child goes to school counts for more than her in-laws'.

He doesn’t need to say that, and what’s more he’s very obviously not going to.

what people think ‘should’ be happening here is meaningless, because that isn’t OP’s reality and isn’t going to become it. She married him knowing that his parents didn’t consider her daughter their grandchild, that he was fine with this, and that her daughter wasn’t going to directly benefit from her stepfather’s family money. She agreed to this, and now she has a problem because she’s having to confront it.

She is responsible for the wellbeing of two children, and trying to deny her youngest opportunities based on what is available to her eldest is doing a her a disservice (and one that could very easily damage her relationship with her youngest, which does also matter!). I say ‘trying to’ because what is also obvious here is that she would have a fight on her hands, one she would be unlikely to win. She can of course leave her husband, which would also probably mean her eldest ceases to have any relationship with a man OP acknowledges treats her well and is a father figure to her, whilst her youngest spends 50% of the time living the same privileged life OP may think divorcing him would prevent her from living.

InterIgnis · 05/03/2024 08:40

drumbeats · 05/03/2024 07:56

Because when you marry someone with very young children, they come as a package deal. If the dc were teenagers it might be different but dd1 was very very young. Both the OP and DH should have assessed this fully before committing.

His family is a different matter but he should have spoken to them and called them out constantly as said above. When you marry someone with small dc they come as a package deal.

That demonstrably isn’t the case though, and repeating it doesn’t magically make it so.

That said, this is the package OP and her DH agreed upon. She knew his parents didn’t view her daughter as their grandchild and that her DH was fine with this. She knew that while her DH would be kind to her daughter that he wouldn’t be financially providing for her in his will, and that she wouldn’t benefit directly from his family money.

WillYouPutYourCoatOn · 05/03/2024 08:40

Surprisedbuthappy · 05/03/2024 08:21

Nope, it's all being taken out a 10-year old child just for being there! She's accused of standing between the younger girl and her grandmother just for existing.

We all know that the girl's biological father is rubbish and he's the one who should be stepping up - but he isn't, he never has, and he's not the one who married OP making big promises he had no intention of keeping.

That's ridiculous hyperbole.

Asking to spend some one to one time with a five year old, because you haven't done so for over two years, is perfectly normal. "Oh, the poor eldest for simply existing" FFS Hmm

I have twins. DM is taking girl twin out for something on Wednesday. Just girl twin. I will give her a call later and tell her how awful she is for clearly resenting boy twin even exists, she obviously thinks he stands in the way of her and girl twin. How dare she want to spend time with one child. She must have both, on every occasion, no exceptions.

Still, OP with her threats of divorce is probably going to end up with this situation anyway. All it will do is stop the unrelated family having to deal with her entitlement and demanding they act a certain way, so they'll probably be up for that anyway.

I agree with PP, she saw this DH and his family as her ship coming in. But they saw it differently. And she can't tantrum her way into changing what they are in every right to do.

She needs to put the energy into building a relationship with "crying gran"... She just doesn't want to, because crying gran doesn't benefit her. She wants an instant extended family. And this one is supportive to each other, wealthy, she wants in. You can see why, she's had nothing paternally for years. They however, don't want that. They're happy to be inclusive to a point (a much higher point than the people who should be!) but OP doesn't acknowledge that at all. She just complains she wants more. Not her choice.

Surprisedbuthappy · 05/03/2024 08:27

This thread has been so enlightening! The moneyed people here have made it perfectly clear that money - and all the advantages that brings such as a private education - is either yours by absolute birthright, or it isn't.

Yet rich people often claim that poor people are poor because they don't work hard enough or because of some moral failing on their part.

They create a world of have-gots and have-nots and then blame the have-nots for not having.

I think all the "what class am I" type threads should be directed here. It's a real eye-opener!

Surprisedbuthappy · 05/03/2024 08:21

WillYouPutYourCoatOn · 05/03/2024 08:13

So he calls them out. And damages the relationship by telling them to act in a way they are no way obligated too.

Great, now both kids have no paternal family. What brilliant equality. What a win for youngest DD.

How about the actual parental family are called out? It's their responsibility. Their fault. It's all being taken out on the unrelated family of her new DH because they are simply there. OP keeps this up and they soon won't be. Well, they will for DH's child. So she can't stop them supporting her, no matter how much she wants to if they won't gift the same to her DD.

Nope, it's all being taken out a 10-year old child just for being there! She's accused of standing between the younger girl and her grandmother just for existing.

We all know that the girl's biological father is rubbish and he's the one who should be stepping up - but he isn't, he never has, and he's not the one who married OP making big promises he had no intention of keeping.

WillYouPutYourCoatOn · 05/03/2024 08:13

drumbeats · 05/03/2024 07:56

Because when you marry someone with very young children, they come as a package deal. If the dc were teenagers it might be different but dd1 was very very young. Both the OP and DH should have assessed this fully before committing.

His family is a different matter but he should have spoken to them and called them out constantly as said above. When you marry someone with small dc they come as a package deal.

So he calls them out. And damages the relationship by telling them to act in a way they are no way obligated too.

Great, now both kids have no paternal family. What brilliant equality. What a win for youngest DD.

How about the actual parental family are called out? It's their responsibility. Their fault. It's all being taken out on the unrelated family of her new DH because they are simply there. OP keeps this up and they soon won't be. Well, they will for DH's child. So she can't stop them supporting her, no matter how much she wants to if they won't gift the same to her DD.

Surprisedbuthappy · 05/03/2024 08:03

Justkeeepswimming · 04/03/2024 23:46

@Surprisedbuthappy

But he isn’t treating her like a second class citizen….

He’s saying he can’t contribute to funding a private school education for offspring that aren’t his own - possibly the funding is coming through from his family who made absolutely no promises to OP and do not see her elder daughter as ‘family’….

He’s stated he can’t force them to foster a familial relationship if they don’t want to. And he can’t…

The problem is the elder girl’s father is a waste of space, so are his family and OP and her family clearly don’t have much money either to contribute significantly towards the elder girl to match what the younger is getting.

Why is that the DH’s fault or his family’s?! Why must they sponsor her??

He is treating treating her like a second-class citizen. He knew about the rubbish biological father when he married OP and made promises to care for her daughter as his own. Such obvious favouritism towards the younger girl as allowing his family to leave her out of family events like weddings, and paying for her sister to receive private education while she is denied it, will cause her massive self-esteem issues. It's a one-way ticket to years of therapy (at best) - possibly harmful ways of coping at worst. He simply wouldn't do that to a child he loved equally. A bunch of strangers on an anonymous internet forum are more concerned about her welfare than he is!

Oh, and if he's not the one offering to pay for the younger girl's education, then he should be saying to his parents (or whoever is) "that's very generous of you but I have two daughters and I can't expect you to pay for both, so both our girls will be going to X school". And OP should never have been excluded from the discussion as her opinion of where her child goes to school counts for more than her in-laws'.

drumbeats · 05/03/2024 07:56

Justkeeepswimming · 04/03/2024 23:46

@Surprisedbuthappy

But he isn’t treating her like a second class citizen….

He’s saying he can’t contribute to funding a private school education for offspring that aren’t his own - possibly the funding is coming through from his family who made absolutely no promises to OP and do not see her elder daughter as ‘family’….

He’s stated he can’t force them to foster a familial relationship if they don’t want to. And he can’t…

The problem is the elder girl’s father is a waste of space, so are his family and OP and her family clearly don’t have much money either to contribute significantly towards the elder girl to match what the younger is getting.

Why is that the DH’s fault or his family’s?! Why must they sponsor her??

Because when you marry someone with very young children, they come as a package deal. If the dc were teenagers it might be different but dd1 was very very young. Both the OP and DH should have assessed this fully before committing.

His family is a different matter but he should have spoken to them and called them out constantly as said above. When you marry someone with small dc they come as a package deal.

Pamelapamela2024 · 05/03/2024 07:53

Justkeeepswimming · 04/03/2024 23:46

@Surprisedbuthappy

But he isn’t treating her like a second class citizen….

He’s saying he can’t contribute to funding a private school education for offspring that aren’t his own - possibly the funding is coming through from his family who made absolutely no promises to OP and do not see her elder daughter as ‘family’….

He’s stated he can’t force them to foster a familial relationship if they don’t want to. And he can’t…

The problem is the elder girl’s father is a waste of space, so are his family and OP and her family clearly don’t have much money either to contribute significantly towards the elder girl to match what the younger is getting.

Why is that the DH’s fault or his family’s?! Why must they sponsor her??

“sponsor her??”

what an awful thing to say. He is married to the OP and has a family with her which includes her young daughter which has spent the majority of her life growing up and being parented by him.

maybe you make distinctions like that in your family, ordering people into some sort of hierarchy but that is not the norm, nor should it be and not should it be excused or tolerated.

Pamelapamela2024 · 05/03/2024 07:50

Some of the responses on this thread are wild to me.

no wonder we are where we are in society.

OP I don’t think you’re wrong at all. i think when you marry someone you absolutely should expect them to treat your very young children like their own and they should expect, prepared and want to do the same. I would not be happy with the attitude that because he didn’t sire her, it gives him the option of making very big decisions around fairness and parity when it comes to two children who are fairly close in age.

I saw your previous post that said you asked your in-laws what they were saving for their biological GD so you could match the savings for your other DD, this seems like a lovely thing to do and a good compromise. The fact they wouldn’t tell you is awful and petty in the extreme. That’s not just not treating the girls differently; that’s actively trying to make sure one is disadvantaged for no reason at all when it is you who would be matching the savings.

my mum had a half brother and she refuses to call him that. He has always been and will always be her brother. I don’t buy into this attitude that the in laws should be excused from treating the two girls differently. Family set ups are different; your daughter is very young and should not be made to feel different or any less than “family” simply because she is not biologically related. How utterly awful.

id be seeing all of them, including my husband, in a very different light.

if others think that’s grabby or entitled then so be it. But I don’t think you are in the wrong here.

MCOut · 05/03/2024 02:36

I don’t think you sound entitled at all. I didn’t get the impression that you expect your eldest to receive an inheritance from your DH family. To be honest, I don’t think he should’ve told you any of this. MIL sounds absolutely awful. I’m not surprised you feel differently about an adult who has expressed resenting a child’s presence.

Regarding the wealth, disparity you also have equal decision-making power in where your youngest attends school. Fight that battle when the time comes. This will probably be unpopular but if you know your youngest will be very well provided for then, perhaps you can discuss leaving your assets entirely to your eldest.

Justkeeepswimming · 04/03/2024 23:46

@Surprisedbuthappy

But he isn’t treating her like a second class citizen….

He’s saying he can’t contribute to funding a private school education for offspring that aren’t his own - possibly the funding is coming through from his family who made absolutely no promises to OP and do not see her elder daughter as ‘family’….

He’s stated he can’t force them to foster a familial relationship if they don’t want to. And he can’t…

The problem is the elder girl’s father is a waste of space, so are his family and OP and her family clearly don’t have much money either to contribute significantly towards the elder girl to match what the younger is getting.

Why is that the DH’s fault or his family’s?! Why must they sponsor her??

WillYouPutYourCoatOn · 04/03/2024 23:20

Peaceandquietandacuppa · 04/03/2024 22:11

A big test would be asking him to officially adopt your eldest. Seeing as her father is not around. The answer will tell you a lot.

I think it's pretty clear he's not going to do that.

I think when he said he would raise her with OP, OP heard what she wanted to hear, as the child's actual father is completely absent, she attached immediately to the vision that her new partner is now dad, and will provide everything, no matter the circumstance, end of. "Instant dad."

I think DH meant it, as he would raise the child day to day, provide housing, care, food, social activities, clothes, all the basics. Everything the child needs to a nice level. He didn't mean hundreds of thousands of private school fees and inheritance from him/his family.

He's already providing all the necessities that her father doesn't. And OP just takes this as minimum entitlement, berating him for not doing more. She's decided "you're dad now" because it suits her not to have to make any effort with the actual paternal family, it's easier for her to pretend the paternal family don't exist because they show no effort and bring nothing to the table. But it's not right. She chose to procreate with the father, but she's got a "better" option now though, so fine by her to call this DDs new dad. She cut ties with the actual grandmother who "cries too much". But throws tantrums about a 96yr old step-great-grandmother (that's not even a thing! step-great-grandmother ffs) for wanting one picture at her grandsons wedding, with her blood grandchildren.

I wonder how much of DH's expected involvement was actually volunteered by DH, or if the dynamic was more OP telling him how wonderful it will be now he's doing everything for her child, and him just nodding along because it's what she wanted to hear, and gave him an easy life. Now it's crunch time, she's finding out that he was indeed just nodding along.

Her focus should be repairing a relationship with the real paternal family, not berating an unrelated family because they fit the model of what she wants better, but aren't acting how she wants them too.

Surprisedbuthappy · 04/03/2024 22:58

Justkeeepswimming · 04/03/2024 22:43

@2Hot2Handle

All blended families live in the same house together, some all of the time or the kids move back and forth between Mum and Dad’s houses…..

Usually the parents pay for their children and make decisions together regarding the child’s upbringing, with step parents taking an important but secondary role.

In this instance, the step parent is providing a home, paying for everyday costs, holidays etc, possibly birthday parties too….

And the mother is wanting more… or to deprive the younger girl to keep status quo.

Somebody said it’s grabby which I agree with - she must have thought her ship came in when he ‘took on’ her and DD1.

He only has one daughter that he’s responsible for, unless he adopts the first he is a step parent.

You know what, she probably did think that. And who could blame her when he promised to love and treat her daughter as his own? She must have thought he was going to give her daughter a nice life - not treat her like a second-class citizen in the family.

Katbum · 04/03/2024 22:49

InterIgnis · 04/03/2024 20:29

Yes. People do in fact do that. Each child would benefit from the opportunities available to them - that is fairness. Fairness is not denying one to compensate the other.

Edited

Exactly. If you had one child gifted at sport, are you going to let them not play sport if the other is not equally as good? Or one beautiful and one ugly daughter, beauty can’t be a model cos it’s not fair? I know a couple of families where the ex pays for private school for one (shared) child, and new dc don’t go because their own mum and dad can’t afford it. Not fair. But nor is life.

Swipe left for the next trending thread