Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Just told DH I will Divorce him over a fucking wedding Part two

716 replies

KeenHiker · 04/03/2024 09:52

https://www.mumsnet.com/talk/am_i_being_unreasonable/5018658-just-told-dh-i-will-divorce-him-over-a-fucking-wedding

I can’t believe the responses that I had.

Essentially I am going to that wedding so it won’t backfire on me and then as people have suggested reassess when everything has calmed down after Easter.

I am never going to look at MiL in the same light as she clearly thinks my daughter is an impediment to her own granddaughter.

Just told DH I will divorce him over a fucking wedding | Mumsnet

This is my first post. I think my head’s going to explode. BiL has shown no interest whatsoever in my daughters, not my eldest who isn’t my husband’...

https://www.mumsnet.com/talk/am_i_being_unreasonable/5018658-just-told-dh-i-will-divorce-him-over-a-fucking-wedding

OP posts:
AllThePotatoesAreSinging · 05/03/2024 11:56

KeenHiker · 05/03/2024 10:26

Right I thought I was done but to answer your question. We have our own accounts and a joint account for expenses which is 50:50 from both of us BUT twice a year he puts in a sum of money into the joint account.

He has a bit of a sideline with a school friend and a cousin where they actually get their hands dirty, which also makes money!

For those of you who think that I am naive he is a very generous man and on the very odd time that I have had a cash flow problem he had given without question and hasn’t asked for it back.

In terms of financing the eldest he has done it without question or complaint.

He would pay fees for his own child not his parents, I have no idea if my eldest would be jealous, interested or even question it. I don’t know what she will be like in 6 years time.

I do not believe that he would however, pay for two sets of school fees and I couldn’t pay for eldest without a massive compromise.

If possible at all I would make the massive compromise and pay for your daughter yourself. Either way he is going to pay for private school for your youngest. It’s the only way you can equalise it without risking resentment between sisters, between the eldest and you and between your eldest and your husband. You and your husband is another thing though.

I don’t think I’d be able to forgive him for creating this obvious division and I’d just have to see how long I could live with him afterwards.

Surprisedbuthappy · 05/03/2024 11:50

GasPanic · 05/03/2024 11:39

Have you considered the fact that it is also easy for people on here to suggest to other people what to do when it is not costing them tens or potentially hundreds of thousands of pounds ?!

Maybe if it was they might think differently...

I can't speak for everyone, but if I were in the position to spend hundreds of thousands of pounds on a child in my care, and who had been in my care since a toddler, then I would! I do mean genuinely in the position to spend that money and not if I could just about scrape it together but with great sacrifices. I obviously do not know this man's financial position so I'm not saying he should do that!

What I definitely wouldn't do is spend all that money on one child only out of two in my care if I couldn't do it for both.

Edited to add: Yes, even if one of those children was my biological child and the other was not but had been living in my home as my child from a very young age!

Cantquitebelievewhatitscometo · 05/03/2024 11:50

And the OP concedes that she could cover school fees for her eldest , for whom she is responsible, but that would mean compromises, yet OP is upset that people who are not related to her child will not make compromises.

There’s a big disconnect in OPs train of thought there.

InterIgnis · 05/03/2024 11:45

Tryingmybestadhd · 05/03/2024 11:13

Why do you think toxic relationships are needed ? Why does the youngest earn from having someone who clearly doesn’t like their sibling ? Why are these nasty people needed in her life ?

Because not treating a child that isn’t their granddaughter like a granddaughter isn’t ’toxic’. It isn’t their fault that she has no relationship with her paternal family, and it’s not on them to step into those roles.

Op knew how they considered her before she married her husband, and she knew her husband had no problem with it. These ‘nasty people’ are the youngest daughter’s family, that love and are loved by her. She shouldn’t have to miss out on her paternal family because her older sister doesn’t have one.

GasPanic · 05/03/2024 11:39

LadyBird1973 · 05/03/2024 11:19

OP, it's easy to be kind and nice when it doesn't cost you anything, and this is what I think about your husband.
In a household with two children living there full time and with no other parent in the mix, I truly think it's appalling to pay for private education for one and not both.
If your husband cannot understand why it would feel so bad for you to see your two children being treated so differently re schooling, whole hide reside in the same home, then he's not the man you thought you were marrying.

I think that if he promised to treat your dd as if she were his, then he's misled you.
You need a serious conversation where you tell him how his feelings/behaviour are hurting you. If he loves you he will want to put that right. If he doesn't, then you've got some choices to make.

I'm really sorry, this totally sucks. It's awful to have everything you thought you knew about people, ripped away x

Have you considered the fact that it is also easy for people on here to suggest to other people what to do when it is not costing them tens or potentially hundreds of thousands of pounds ?!

Maybe if it was they might think differently...

Tryingmybestadhd · 05/03/2024 11:25

Surprisedbuthappy · 05/03/2024 11:24

No, I don't think that at all - read my previous posts! I was being sarcastic.

Sorry just seen that 😉

Surprisedbuthappy · 05/03/2024 11:24

Tryingmybestadhd · 05/03/2024 11:23

Birthright ? lol sorry this is not a jane Austin novel , this so real life . You think a child should be brought up with toxic people because of the possibility she may have some money at a stage ? I teach my kids different to that ! No amount if money could make me expose children to someone who would damage sibling relationships.

No, I don't think that at all - read my previous posts! I was being sarcastic.

Tryingmybestadhd · 05/03/2024 11:23

Surprisedbuthappy · 05/03/2024 11:19

Because these people have money! And that's youngest's birthright and to deny her any possible advantage that money could buy would be the absolute most heinous crime of all.

Birthright ? lol sorry this is not a jane Austin novel , this so real life . You think a child should be brought up with toxic people because of the possibility she may have some money at a stage ? I teach my kids different to that ! No amount if money could make me expose children to someone who would damage sibling relationships.

Surprisedbuthappy · 05/03/2024 11:19

Tryingmybestadhd · 05/03/2024 11:13

Why do you think toxic relationships are needed ? Why does the youngest earn from having someone who clearly doesn’t like their sibling ? Why are these nasty people needed in her life ?

Because these people have money! And that's youngest's birthright and to deny her any possible advantage that money could buy would be the absolute most heinous crime of all.

LadyBird1973 · 05/03/2024 11:19

OP, it's easy to be kind and nice when it doesn't cost you anything, and this is what I think about your husband.
In a household with two children living there full time and with no other parent in the mix, I truly think it's appalling to pay for private education for one and not both.
If your husband cannot understand why it would feel so bad for you to see your two children being treated so differently re schooling, whole hide reside in the same home, then he's not the man you thought you were marrying.

I think that if he promised to treat your dd as if she were his, then he's misled you.
You need a serious conversation where you tell him how his feelings/behaviour are hurting you. If he loves you he will want to put that right. If he doesn't, then you've got some choices to make.

I'm really sorry, this totally sucks. It's awful to have everything you thought you knew about people, ripped away x

Tryingmybestadhd · 05/03/2024 11:13

WillYouPutYourCoatOn · 05/03/2024 08:13

So he calls them out. And damages the relationship by telling them to act in a way they are no way obligated too.

Great, now both kids have no paternal family. What brilliant equality. What a win for youngest DD.

How about the actual parental family are called out? It's their responsibility. Their fault. It's all being taken out on the unrelated family of her new DH because they are simply there. OP keeps this up and they soon won't be. Well, they will for DH's child. So she can't stop them supporting her, no matter how much she wants to if they won't gift the same to her DD.

Why do you think toxic relationships are needed ? Why does the youngest earn from having someone who clearly doesn’t like their sibling ? Why are these nasty people needed in her life ?

Tryingmybestadhd · 05/03/2024 11:09

EWAB · 05/03/2024 11:04

My MiL was I thought, the nicest, kindest, most hospitable woman you could ever met. She was warm and generous.

The saddest, saddest I have ever been and I am embarrassed about this as both my parents died too early, was doing some chores and deciding to pop in to see the in-laws.

We turned into the road and they were on the sliver of garden in front of their town house. BiL was up a ladder with FiL footing it with MiL watching niece play on pavement.

We parked about 6 houses away and niece saw us and came running with MiL, and when MiL saw that only my youngest child was in the car a look of unbridled joy spread across her face. She then remembered that my eldest from an earlier relationship was away on a school journey. She shrieked to FiL about”the boy not being there as he was on a trip.” Niece shouted “Yes!”.
They got him out and openly said that niece could finally play with him without eldest.
These ‘lovely’ people left their money not to their sons but divided everything between their grandchildren to ensure my eldest didn’t benefit from their money what, potentially half a century later? Their prerogative of course.
When I wake up before the alarm and then go back to sleep I wake up hearing her Cork accent referring to my precious son as “the boy.”

That’s awful 😞

Tryingmybestadhd · 05/03/2024 11:07

Pamelapamela2024 · 05/03/2024 07:50

Some of the responses on this thread are wild to me.

no wonder we are where we are in society.

OP I don’t think you’re wrong at all. i think when you marry someone you absolutely should expect them to treat your very young children like their own and they should expect, prepared and want to do the same. I would not be happy with the attitude that because he didn’t sire her, it gives him the option of making very big decisions around fairness and parity when it comes to two children who are fairly close in age.

I saw your previous post that said you asked your in-laws what they were saving for their biological GD so you could match the savings for your other DD, this seems like a lovely thing to do and a good compromise. The fact they wouldn’t tell you is awful and petty in the extreme. That’s not just not treating the girls differently; that’s actively trying to make sure one is disadvantaged for no reason at all when it is you who would be matching the savings.

my mum had a half brother and she refuses to call him that. He has always been and will always be her brother. I don’t buy into this attitude that the in laws should be excused from treating the two girls differently. Family set ups are different; your daughter is very young and should not be made to feel different or any less than “family” simply because she is not biologically related. How utterly awful.

id be seeing all of them, including my husband, in a very different light.

if others think that’s grabby or entitled then so be it. But I don’t think you are in the wrong here.

100% this

EWAB · 05/03/2024 11:04

My MiL was I thought, the nicest, kindest, most hospitable woman you could ever met. She was warm and generous.

The saddest, saddest I have ever been and I am embarrassed about this as both my parents died too early, was doing some chores and deciding to pop in to see the in-laws.

We turned into the road and they were on the sliver of garden in front of their town house. BiL was up a ladder with FiL footing it with MiL watching niece play on pavement.

We parked about 6 houses away and niece saw us and came running with MiL, and when MiL saw that only my youngest child was in the car a look of unbridled joy spread across her face. She then remembered that my eldest from an earlier relationship was away on a school journey. She shrieked to FiL about”the boy not being there as he was on a trip.” Niece shouted “Yes!”.
They got him out and openly said that niece could finally play with him without eldest.
These ‘lovely’ people left their money not to their sons but divided everything between their grandchildren to ensure my eldest didn’t benefit from their money what, potentially half a century later? Their prerogative of course.
When I wake up before the alarm and then go back to sleep I wake up hearing her Cork accent referring to my precious son as “the boy.”

Surprisedbuthappy · 05/03/2024 11:02

OK, I'm confused now, OP. You seem to be defending your husband by saying he's a very generous man and you haven't been naive. What actually is the situation here? Did he make out before you married and had another child that he would treat your eldest like a daughter of his own or did he not? Do you believe that by sending one child to private school and not the other, he is demonstrating that he loves them both equally? What exactly are you angry about? If you're fine with the unequal schooling opportunities but angry about the photo with great granny then I don't understand your priorities, but OK.

For what it's worth, I think your husband is an a-hole and his parents are horrid people (well, his mother, I don't think you've mentioned much about your FIL). However, as I've come to realise, having money apparently makes it OK to act that way towards an innocent child as long as the money stays in the bloodline. I was angry with him this whole time, but if you're now going to defend him then I don't know what it is you want from this!

KeenHiker · 05/03/2024 10:26

Right I thought I was done but to answer your question. We have our own accounts and a joint account for expenses which is 50:50 from both of us BUT twice a year he puts in a sum of money into the joint account.

He has a bit of a sideline with a school friend and a cousin where they actually get their hands dirty, which also makes money!

For those of you who think that I am naive he is a very generous man and on the very odd time that I have had a cash flow problem he had given without question and hasn’t asked for it back.

In terms of financing the eldest he has done it without question or complaint.

He would pay fees for his own child not his parents, I have no idea if my eldest would be jealous, interested or even question it. I don’t know what she will be like in 6 years time.

I do not believe that he would however, pay for two sets of school fees and I couldn’t pay for eldest without a massive compromise.

OP posts:
OchonAgusOchonOh · 05/03/2024 10:07

KeenHiker · 05/03/2024 09:30

I am sitting in a cafe having taken my kids to school.

I am no nearer a resolution as evidenced here there is a lot to weigh up.

I don’t want to come on to defend myself in any way but to challenge what some people have posted.

I was privately educated until 11. I have a career and I am financially independent but not at a point where I could solely pay for a private education without compromising on essentials.

Adoption was never discussed and I don’t believe this would have affected my in-laws’ attitude.

I have never ever expected my in-laws to leave an inheritance to my daughter and the inheritance that my husband referred to recently does not come directly from his parents.

What I did expect that the inevitable disparity in their finances because I do accept that they have different fathers, would play out some decades in the future when they were mature and quite possibly my eldest would not necessarily have been privy to the youngest’s affairs.

I haven’t stopped facilitating a relationship with my eldest daughter’s family because they do nothing for me but because my daughter would become very distressed seeing her grandmother becoming distressed. My daughter’s father can no longer live independently because of choices he has made.

As a result of this thread I might try to speak with his sister to see if she would be willing to see my daughter independently of her mother.

Some posters are blaming me for all of this but as another poster said I didn’t possess a crystal ball.

I still don’t know what to do but my daughter doesn’t know any of this and the relationship she has with DH is a positive one.

I am upset that MiL sees her as an impediment to her own granddaughter and upset that she isn’t regarded as family for a photo with a 96 year old woman, incidentally a very minor part of the wedding and prompted by a cousin not the old lady herself.

I am shocked as the in-laws all of them, are always nice and polite showing no signs of this attitude.

The SiL, while I accept that she reached out, hasn’t really apologised and I don’t think feels that they have done anything wrong. Her own sister’s stepchild, completely unknown to me seems more independent than mine and is being brought up in a different setup.

I don’t think I can add anything else.

Can I ask a couple of questions?

How are your finances organised with your dh? Is it all joint or are they separate? What about if you used your salary to pay dd1's private school fees while your dh covered the rest of your family expenses? Your dh's reaction to that suggestion will be telling but it does depend on your finances overall as to whether it is feasible.

Does he plan to pay for the private school out of his income or is it his family who would pay? That would obviously make a difference and I could see how your dd1 could be more accepting and less hurt by his family paying than him paying as she will presumably be well aware of the fact she is not family to them.

I think I would still go to the wedding as that way you are not burning bridges before you make decisions. The photo is easy to avoid given dd2 and dh are in the wedding party so I wouldn't get too het up about that.

GasPanic · 05/03/2024 09:53

I do not envy your position and you have my sympathy.

I don't think there is an ideal solution. I don't think pressurising your husband about his family or pressurising your husbands family is going to lead anywhere good. I just think it will end up with you looking pushy and entitled.

I don't think divorcing your husband is a good solution, but reminding him of/clarifying his commitment to you regards the older child is.

I think you just have to do your best to compensate to your older daughter and prepare her for inequalities that might arise in the future and to foster the best relationships you possibly can with her fathers family as well as her stepfathers.

It might be worth reminding yourself that siblings are never raised entirely equally, no matter how hard parents might try, and no matter how much parents believe they have succeeded, because ultimately they are independent people.

InterIgnis · 05/03/2024 09:51

You knew they didn’t, and didn’t intend to, see her as a granddaughter. Well, this is what that looks like. This isn’t something that’s been hidden from you, and nor is your husband thinking this to not be a problem. Maybe you thought that given enough time this would change, or that once married you’d be able to kick up enough of a fuss that they’d back down and you’d get your way. If so, you badly misjudged. The situation is what it is, and regardless of whether you’re with your husband or not (and he may be the one to decide he’s had enough and leave. That option is open to him as well) the familial and financial disparities between your daughters exist. They will always exist. Whatever happens, you’re going to need to come to terms with that.

Your MIL isn’t wrong to want to spend time with her granddaughter without your eldest being present. The same applies to your BIL. Presenting them as a package deal didn’t change the way they consider her, and nor will it. You can’t make them agree with you, no matter how much you think they should.

Surprisedbuthappy · 05/03/2024 09:36

@KeenHiker Talk to your husband, OP. As plenty of people have said, you can't expect too much from your in-laws. You can expect him to either live up to promises he made you or be clear and honest about why he can't/won't. And then you make your choice. Good luck, I feel for you and your daughter.

KeenHiker · 05/03/2024 09:30

I am sitting in a cafe having taken my kids to school.

I am no nearer a resolution as evidenced here there is a lot to weigh up.

I don’t want to come on to defend myself in any way but to challenge what some people have posted.

I was privately educated until 11. I have a career and I am financially independent but not at a point where I could solely pay for a private education without compromising on essentials.

Adoption was never discussed and I don’t believe this would have affected my in-laws’ attitude.

I have never ever expected my in-laws to leave an inheritance to my daughter and the inheritance that my husband referred to recently does not come directly from his parents.

What I did expect that the inevitable disparity in their finances because I do accept that they have different fathers, would play out some decades in the future when they were mature and quite possibly my eldest would not necessarily have been privy to the youngest’s affairs.

I haven’t stopped facilitating a relationship with my eldest daughter’s family because they do nothing for me but because my daughter would become very distressed seeing her grandmother becoming distressed. My daughter’s father can no longer live independently because of choices he has made.

As a result of this thread I might try to speak with his sister to see if she would be willing to see my daughter independently of her mother.

Some posters are blaming me for all of this but as another poster said I didn’t possess a crystal ball.

I still don’t know what to do but my daughter doesn’t know any of this and the relationship she has with DH is a positive one.

I am upset that MiL sees her as an impediment to her own granddaughter and upset that she isn’t regarded as family for a photo with a 96 year old woman, incidentally a very minor part of the wedding and prompted by a cousin not the old lady herself.

I am shocked as the in-laws all of them, are always nice and polite showing no signs of this attitude.

The SiL, while I accept that she reached out, hasn’t really apologised and I don’t think feels that they have done anything wrong. Her own sister’s stepchild, completely unknown to me seems more independent than mine and is being brought up in a different setup.

I don’t think I can add anything else.

OP posts:
Surprisedbuthappy · 05/03/2024 09:29

InterIgnis · 05/03/2024 09:21

It would be denying her an opportunity that she could/would greatly benefit from. It also fails to recognise that she is an individual distinct from her sister, and that her opportunities shouldn’t be curtailed because her sister hasn’t the same ones available.

It also means her sister being associated with things she can’t have, that she would otherwise be able to if not for said sister. Her sister becomes the charity case prioritized by mummy, in contrast to daddy who wants to, and will fight to, provide for her what he can afford to. For all the talk of ‘protecting sibling relationships’ this factor is being willfully overlooked as inconsequential.

If they both had the same two biological parents, but the parents could only afford to send one of them to private school, would you make the same arguments? If not, why not?

In OP's case, that is exactly the position she is being railroaded into by her husband.

InterIgnis · 05/03/2024 09:21

Surprisedbuthappy · 05/03/2024 09:07

@Justkeeepswimming The point is that sending both girls to the school the couple can afford without help from the in-laws is not causing some kind of severe deprivation to the younger girl.

It would be denying her an opportunity that she could/would greatly benefit from. It also fails to recognise that she is an individual distinct from her sister, and that her opportunities shouldn’t be curtailed because her sister hasn’t the same ones available.

It also means her sister being associated with things she can’t have, that she would otherwise be able to if not for said sister. Her sister becomes the charity case prioritized by mummy, in contrast to daddy who wants to, and will fight to, provide for her what he can afford to. For all the talk of ‘protecting sibling relationships’ this factor is being willfully overlooked as inconsequential.

Surprisedbuthappy · 05/03/2024 09:16

@Justkeeepswimming

This wedding business has just brought the difference in treatment and opportunity for the girls to the fore, and it will become more apparent now as they age and have different opportunities due to their different fathers.

Well yes. On that we do agree.! 👏🏻

Justkeeepswimming · 05/03/2024 09:14

Surprisedbuthappy · 05/03/2024 09:10

Then he shouldn't be claiming to treat her as his own! He should own who he is and who his family are and be upfront with OP.

He has been @Surprisedbuthappy they’ve had wills for 5 years - he made it clear the elder girl would not be inheriting from him or his family.

That is the difference.

This wedding business has just brought the difference in treatment and opportunity for the girls to the fore, and it will become more apparent now as they age and have different opportunities due to their different fathers.